This is a book with many touching moments, yet it does not work for me as a whole. It might be the style problem - it reads like a long sermon, while the subject of “being all in” in the Church to me is an emotional, not rational one. Maybe it is me, but in cases like this (why stay/become Catholic when the Church does not seem like a very attractive choice) I very much resonate with the human stories.
But there are many pearls hidden here - for example, the chapter on loving your enemy is both very touching and full of good, understandable teaching!

I just finished reading this and already I think I need to read it again. The author has a lovely style of writing and the stories from her personal life really add to the feeling that it's a friend talking to you. To use the author's phrases I am a 'cradle Catholic' and most definitely a 'work in progress'. While the author gives plenty to think about, she helpfully gives references for where to find more information. A well constructed and well written book.

Well-written and personal. Great for old and young, and new Catholics.