Member Reviews
Wonderful. I really enjoy Mr. Anderson's voice, as well as the parallels he makes in his stories. His books are raw and immersive, throwing you in without preamble, trusting you to figure out the world.
This was an interesting idea but I was suuuuper bored. Practically no character development left me with no connection to the characters.
M.T. Anderson wrote Feed, which is not to be confused with Mira Grant's Feed, but which is widely admired and which appears to have predicted the world of social media, though it was published in 2002. I still haven't read it, but all those recommendations were what pointed me at his new novella, Landscape with Invisible Hand.
I got an ARC from Netgalley a while ago, but the format wasn't cooperating with my Kindle, so I ended up reading it when it came out, especially after I saw Librarian Sam reading it she told me how great it was. I checked it out and started reading, and it is great--incredibly well written and perfectly portrayed. But my GOD, what a downer.
In Feed, Anderson anticipated the overwhelming role of social media in society; Landscape is about poverty, economics, and social stratification. Basically, an alien race called the vuvv have introduced themselves to Earth, offered cultural and economic exchange, and some have come to live here. Their advanced technology changes everything.
In fact, it almost eliminates the need for a workforce. Adam is a high school student and aspiring artist; his parents can't find work and everyone in his town is living hand to mouth. Adam and his girlfriend sign up to be a vuvv reality show, where their dates are televised and translated. Of course, the vuvv's understanding of human culture is based mostly on old TV, so the only way to "authentically" date is to go bowling or for moonlit walks. And if, at some point, they decide to break up, they might be in breach of contract.
This is a dark story, and it's very much about helplessness, and what you're left with when you not only have nothing, but see avenues closed off to you one by one. When your health and your finances and your relationships are all collapsing, and there are no resources, and, and, and. It reminds me of another recent read, Hand to Mouth: Living in Bootstrap America, by Linda Tirado, which is basically an account of being working-class poor in the US. There are specific points I would argue with that author, but her clear explanations of the logic of poverty just makes me outraged at everyone who fails to see that virtually every person is trying their hardest, and many of them are being screwed by the system.
Capitalism is rough, and a lousy social system. The vuvv treatment of humanity is exactly--precisely--how we treat the poor. The dystopia is that we're all living in the world that we've built for each other, but when we emerge from behind the veil of ignorance, we discover that we've all drawn the short straw that we expected someone else to get.
Well written and engrossing, I can't say it was a pleasure to read. But it was worth it, and I actually liked the ending. I couldn't have imagined an ending, happy or sad, that would satisfy me while I was reading it, but in the end it was what I needed. I definitely need to read more MT Anderson, though maybe not all at once.
Solid satire that really draws you in. The parallels are clear and intense.
Unfortunately, I couldn't read this novel because of the formatting of it on my kindle. For some reason it was messed up and impossible to read after downloading from Netgalley.
I did not like this book. Perhaps other people will. I won't post a negative review online. Thank you and good luck with it.
If a more bleak view of the future is you bag, Anderson is the author for you. There is no need to wrap up the book neatly with the promise of a better future. The humans in this book live in a generally desperate situation. Yet their desperation doesn't cause them to band together and start a rebellion. If anything they become more isolated and self-serving. And all of the issues that plague societies - uneven distribution of wealth, the collapse of the nuclear family, etc - are magnified. The plot is not entirely linear, framed instead around paintings, so it's a little strange and isn't likely to have a broad mainstream following. But if you're cool with something a little different this may be the book for you.
Wry and clear-eyed, Anderson imagines a future where an alien civilization has invaded and controls our society. Since their first contact was in the 1950's and they have no idea that humans have moved on at all from that era, there is plenty of room for misunderstanding and misinterpretation. Then again, how much HAVE we moved on? Inequalities abound, health care is inaccessible, unemployment and underemployment are epidemic. It feels uncannily like the present. Except there are these aliens....
I enjoyed this book as much for what it says about art as for what it says about humanity . Art and real artists come out on top. At least, that's my interpretation. A great, quick, funny read.
A thought provoking novel seen through the eyes of Adam who attends high school.
The story begins after aliens (VUVV) have landed on Earth which later causes the collapse of human economy and only the wealthiest of humans can compete.
This was my first time reading M.T. Anderson (I know, I know...) and I really enjoyed it. It was a quick and enjoyable read. I pretty much immediately felt drawn into this world and sped through the book. The vuvv land on earth and humanity essentially allows them to remain because of the promise of new technology and medical advances that will cure all diseases. Little do they realize that this technology will leave millions out of a job, and the life-changing medicine promised comes at a steep price. It was interesting to see a non-hostile takeover of planet earth and the repercussions of it. I appreciated Anderson's ability to balance the hardships faced by the human characters after the vuvv invasion with Adam's sense of humor. Really enjoyed this book and would definitely recommend to YA audiences.
This science fiction story takes a dark satirical look at a future in which an ostensibly benevolent alien race,the vuvv, has come to earth as colonizers (literally living up in the sky above the rest of the people), promising advanced technology and lives free of work. There are a small percentage of those on Earth who, investing in vuvv technology, manage to become rich, but most humans are in a permanent state of poverty and despair; the human economy could not stand up against what was provided by the vuvv.
Possibly a dark look at communism, or colonialism, or even capitalism (there is a lot of discussion of “the invisible hand” of the market determining worth and value), or at a world divided between the 1% of the vastly wealthy and the rest of us, there is much to contemplate in this book. The colonizers see only what they want to see, and ignore the suffering in their wake. They impose the culture they prefer (the U.S. in the 1950’s) on the populace and aren’t willing to accept anything else or examine the effects of their colonization. The 1% think only of their own pleasure and superiority. The rest of the world becomes so desperate they will contemplate just about anything to rise above the sinkhole of their lives.
We learn about all of this through the main character, Adam, a high school student who is an aspiring artist. Each chapter is headed by the title of a painting he is doing of the action he describes.
Adam is quite sick from a gastrointestinal disease resulting from untreated tap water; as part of the vuvv’s austerity measures, municipal water is no longer purified. Possibly this is a metaphor for the way everyones lives have turned to shit. Nevertheless, and while growing increasingly septic, he enters a vuvv-sponsored art contest in a last-ditch attempt to make money for his family.
The outcome of the contest suggests to Adam the real way to survive in vuvv society, taking yet another jab at our current social, political, and cultural milieu.
Evaluation: I love this author and I appreciate the points he was trying to make. But ultimately this story fell flat for me. While it raises a lot of interesting issues, the overtly allegorical quality of the story kept it too “unreal” and prevented me from engaging much with the characters.
A fast paced YA dystopian novella. Satire. Commentary.
Thought-provoking. Definitely worth a read and then thinking about, discussing.
"Feed" was the last M.T. Anderson book I read, and that was probably over a decade ago. Needless to say, I was beyond thrilled when I saw that he had some new material coming out in the fall. That said, it can also be a bit nerve racking when an author has been out of your life for so long. I mean, I loved "Feed" and Anderson's writing style is one of my favorites, but what if after so long, it just didn't have the same effect? I mean I've changed, he's probably changed, so many variables! Well, I shouldn't have worried, because "Landscape with Invisible Hand" definitely reminded my why I love Anderson's work so much. This is a slim book, just cresting over a 100 pages, but my goodness does it pack a powerful punch. The desolation and deterioration of not only Adam and Chloe's relationship but Earth as a whole and its inhabitants is heartbreaking and, quite honestly, an interesting commentary on our country's current state. Additionally, with such sparse language, Anderson does an exceptional job of not only captivating his reader but he's also able to do so in a weirdly brutal and beautiful way. I think my favorite aspect of this book, though, is just how much discussion power it has for teens. I can seriously picture them talking for hours over this book and for that as well as all of the other reasons I mentioned, this is an absolute necessity in all YA library collections. Seriously. I'm probably going to re-read it right now . . . and maybe again after that . . .
YA Books Central review link: http://www.yabookscentral.com/yafiction/21772-landscape-with-invisible-hand
Aliens have invaded Earth and promise to share their technology. Of course most people are very excited about the idea that Earth will have advanced technology, but they don't realize the cost. Adam watches as his parents lose their jobs to this technology. Then his father leaves the family. His mother rents the house out to another displaced family. Adam hooks up with Chloe, the daughter of the family and together they put together a pay by the minute recording of their romance. They do this to survive. Only their loves fizzles in the process. Adam needs to find another way to help his family survive the alien's colonization.
What worked: This is a sharp, funny at times, satire on what would happen if an advance race invaded Earth. Only in this case it's colonizing our planet. There's a huge cost to receiving the so-called advanced technology. A cost that leaves people out of work and money almost useless. I thought it was very intriguing how Andersen shows how an alien race can take over a world and at the same time show their disdain for the inhabitants of the world. **Show kind of familiar?
Adam witnesses the after effect of the invasion and wants to help his mother and younger sister out. The whole idea of recording a romance using old 1950s culture and slang(aliens first encounter Earth in the 1940s), is creative, but what at first was an easy way to get money, grows old fast. We see this world through Adam's eyes. I wanted to see more of Chloe and how she really felt about all of this. At times she seemed almost too unlikable on how she viewed Adam. He has Merrick's disease, a terrible stomach disease based on having to drink unpurified water(the aliens don't need that). Her comments about this felt almost too petty.
I loved the glimpses into the Vuvv. There's lots of rich details-the condos in the sky; snobbery against the Earth inhabitants; and their love of anything in the 50s. Also I felt there was so much parallelism of this world with our own history of occupying countries and imposing our will on those people.
I also loved the humor woven throughout the novel. Adam's final realization on how he can beat the aliens seems almost genius. Let's just say he does take lemons and make them into lemonade.
Dark at times, humorous tale of life under the colonization of aliens. Biting humor that gives readers a new hero to cheer for.
On another note, I was very surprised when I saw the starred reviews (from Booklist, Horn Book, Kirkus, Publishers Weekly and School Library Journal) that LANDSCAPE WITH INVISIBLE HAND by M. T. Anderson had received. I would agree that it is very well-written by National Book Award winner Anderson, but his vision of a dystopian future was depressing to read, especially given all of the all too real recent news about hurricanes, a major earthquake, identity theft, and immigration restrictions for refugees and dreamers. Anderson's work involves a future Earth controlled by an alien species, the vuvv. Humans such as the main character, Adam, struggle to provide for their families due to a scarcity of jobs. Healthcare, too, is an issue with high costs and limited availability, plus a polluted environment contributing to disease like Adam's frequent bouts of diarrhea and gastro-discomfort. Also, social media is used for entertainment with sometimes little regard for factual presentations. Yes, I guess one should acknowledge Anderson's satirical points, but even though LANDSCAPE WITH INVISIBLE HAND is more of a novella (about 150 pages), it is still quite a sad, bleak, and disturbing read.
I can appreciate a book, even when I don't 100% enjoy a book. Take the humor and alien invasion of Smekday, plus combine it with a bit of reality TV satire a la Beauty Queens, and then throw in a bit too much diarrhea for my personal tastes, and you get this odd, short, ya sf novel.
An interesting commentary on poverty and where our society is going. The haves and the have nots. After having read the groundbreaking book Feed many years ago, this is another fine work by MT Anderson. His language is captivating and playful at times ("chic sheath" stands out.). I'm not sure yet what audience I will talk this up to, but I will!
<a target= _blank href="https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-LAlKz8L2T5k/VZMv28K2ETI/AAAAAAAAFf4/W15ebQqAQ547jnAQf7DN7pXl0N5BTdmywCPcBGAYYCw/s1600/summer%2Breading.png" imageanchor="1" ><img hspace=10 align=right border="0" src="https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-LAlKz8L2T5k/VZMv28K2ETI/AAAAAAAAFf4/W15ebQqAQ547jnAQf7DN7pXl0N5BTdmywCPcBGAYYCw/s320/summer%2Breading.png" width="320" height="235" data-original-width="834" data-original-height="613" /></a><font face="Georgia"> <h3>Welcome to another session of Turning Pages!</h3><p>M.T. Anderson is the king of the intellectual young adult novel. His work is arguably not written <i>for</i> young adults, but rather simply marketed toward them, because his characters are teens and tweens whose behavior is not circumscribed by the "usual" teen boundaries which get books challenged and called out by concerned parents. A lot of times, teens might not truly even quite <i>understand</i> M.T. Anderson's novels... but there's definitely still something about them that makes them fascinating, worth rereading, arguing with friends about, and dissecting in English class.</p>
<p>This is another classically Anderson book - a short, stabby little satire, with a dark futures, existentialist narrative that might upset some - but which will amuse and provoke others to further consideration and insight.</p>
<p><i><b>Synopsis</b></i>: Adam Costello's carefully ordered world began to unravel when the vuvv landed on Earth. Not that the vuvv are killers or anything, no. They've just brought <i>progress</i> - all at once, igniting a new kind of class war. Now, there's no need to work, because the vuvv do all the jobs; no need to research and strive, becaue the vuvv have brought the cure of all illnesses. At the expense of human jobs, Earth's ecology, and myriad nations' sovereignties, the Earth has been made a client planet. Now there's no competition, because the vuvv have the least expensive everything. Farmers are undersold, goods are commercially produced elsewhere, and all the new tech and medicine is behind a steadily rising paywall. For those who made relationships with the vuvv early on, there are riches untold. For the "have nots," there's nothing, literally and truly nothing. People are bored, bitter, and starving. All that seems left is for humans to try and be and do what the vuvv see and enjoy - the 1950's in terms of art, music, and film. Entertaining the uber-rich and the vuvv, humanity scrambles to be funny, romantic, sexy, and pleasing. It is both lowering and amusing that adult humans, with advanced degrees, can think of nothing else to do to survive but to pander. </p>
<a target= _blank href="https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-u-0bUAP6tVo/WZIwPeGBSoI/AAAAAAAAHbQ/YvkZ1Qx_k7ckOYLNZF4aHJfAHGC8ZcglgCLcBGAs/s1600/33281801.jpg" imageanchor="1" ><img hspace=10 align=left border="0" src="https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-u-0bUAP6tVo/WZIwPeGBSoI/AAAAAAAAHbQ/YvkZ1Qx_k7ckOYLNZF4aHJfAHGC8ZcglgCLcBGAs/s400/33281801.jpg" width="236" height="400" data-original-width="280" data-original-height="475" /></a><p>Adam doesn't fit into the new world order really well. This is not because he has not tried, and tried hard, with an entertainment vlog scheme hatched up by he and his lust neighbor, Chloe. For a while, they made decent money off their scheme. But lust doesn't last for long. Adam's crush wants to Be Somebody, and Adam, whose father has stolen their means of travel and disappeared into the night, is kind of a nobody. His mother is unemployed, his baby sister is grimly selling her stuffed animals, and Adam is desperately ill, from a gastrointestinal disease which he got from the unfiltered water that his family is forced to drink. With municipal utilities no longer under the control of anyone with a human digestive system, Adam is hardly anyone to inspire lust - especially not without health insurance or medication. Between bouts of horrible fevers, diarrhea, and flatulence, Adam tries to determine what is of value to the human world anymore, now that the vuvv determine value. What Adam really cares about is his art, and while he once made computer landscapes of fantastical beauty as the places to which he'd like to escape, now he processes all he sees and feels through the medium of paint. He paints what he sees - not a brave new world, or castles in the air, but the detritus of a dying civilization, and the oddly tacked on ephemera of the vuvv society. What the vuvv want to see in art are still life and kitsch, bright colors and castles in the sky. While most people will do anything to survive in this brave new world, the artist in Adam realizes that he can't give them what they want, and that, in a larger parallel, that maybe none of humanity can give the vuvv what they want.</p>
<p> Maybe it would be better if everyone stopped trying.</p>
<p><i><b>Observations</b></i>: This novella-length satire is, in some part, about art and humanity. It is also about, in part, the way the United States relates to the rest of the world, and its colonialist attitudes. This is a novel about how everything is monetized, and only those who are workers or somehow "valuable" to what Important People need and want - entertainers, worker bees, soldier drones - are worth anything in Western society. This is also a book about family, and individuals, and what we do to survive. It is both sparsely written and terse, and voluminously artistically rendered. It is both bleak and grim, and sneakily, snarkily funny.</p>
<p>I noticed that there really was only <i>one</i> America in this novel, and that Adam didn't seem to know anything about how the vuvv interacted with anywhere which wasn't America. The were issues where people complained that immigrants were stealing jobs, and knocking apart bodegas, but the vuvv seem to see humanity as just... humanity, a group of cattle worth corralling. Ironic, that humans still blamed humans for what was going on, and yet... isn't that what we do? Isn't that what we always <i>will</i> do? Or, do we have it in us to try something else?</p>
<p><i><b>Conclusion</b></i>: Adam and his frequent, explosive gastrointestinal disorder is going to gross out and confuse a lot of readers, young and old, but this is one of those short pieces of literature which we'll see later as a classic of economic thought and worth sticking with and returning to again. While it would be a challenge to teach, it would be a worthwhile challenge, and I look forward to hearing how it is received.</p>
<br>
<hr width=55%><p>I received my copy of this book courtesy of the publisher. After September 12th, you can find <a href="http://www.indiebound.org/aff/readersrant7?product=9780763687892" target=_blank><i>LANDSCAPE WITH INVISIBLE HAND</i></a> by M.T. Anderson at an online e-tailer, or at a real life, independent bookstore near you!</p>
</font>
*THIS REVIEW WILL RUN AUGUST 22, 2017 https://writingya.blogspot.com/2017/08/turning-pages-reads-landscape-with.html
An alien race has landed on earth. With their astute bargaining skills and advanced technologies, they have created a huge divide between the rich and poor. Adam and his family are dirt poor, struggling to earn enough money to feed themselves. When Adam and his girlfriend Chloe decide to record their experiences, the Vuvv watch fascinated, enamored with true love. Adam and Chloe begin to despise one another and when their relationship falls apart, the Vuvv demand their money back - after all, they were selling true love and true love lasts forever. Desperate, Adam enters an art contest, hoping to win enough to save his family.
This was a very bizarre book, but in a really good way. I think it will be a big hit with middle schoolers and perhaps even teenagers. Overall, a hit!
Interesting premise told in a very concise way. Doesn't have broad appeal, but I could see giving it to a very specific reader. Maybe one who enjoys titles like "1984" or other out-of-the-box books. I liked that it was a unique read, but I'm still working out whether I enjoyed it or not.