This wasn't really something that I usually would enjoy, I'm sure some people would like it but it just wasn't for me

This novel was hard to get into and that made it seem to take forever to finish. The characters were fantastic though

While The Year of Lightning had straddled the line between science fiction and fantasy, The Black Tempest moves over to fantasy, directing the plot towards a world where there are people that can manipulate time at will, and an eternal kingdom that protects the timeline. Though most of the story still takes place in Emmett's Bluff, a significant part of the plot comes from that kingdom. Asha and Thorn, princess and prince of the Everwatch, are transported to this current time, and are fighting a villain named the Black Tempest, who is coming to this world. This review will be a bit spoilery, because there is really no other way for me to discuss it, so be warned and proceed at your own risk

Now, normally I would like the expansion of the canon universe, but in this case every addition of an element to the canon felt like it was there only to solve plot problems. Let me start with the whole concept of Chronauri - while it seems like the Year of Lightning is now setting up the origin story for the twins and their powers, there are a lot of things that don't fit right in with the theme of the book. It was about time travel, the ability to go back and forth in time, and yet a key element - time paradox - was used only once in the plot. I really tried to keep up with every new information and bit of confusing canon being constructed on the fly, but honestly, after the mid-way mark I stopped trying to make sense of it. This book took me 5 long days to finish, and that was not because of any lack of time (pun intended); rather, I kept getting distracted and was wishing for it to be over the whole time.

The whole mystery of the identity of the Black Tempest and the Frost Hammer was overdone, too. I could guess the Black Tempest because duh, it was obvious, and I have read too many mystery novels to not suss that out (and it was a good arc), but the Frost Hammer was more frustrating. Partly because there is a red herring thrown in, but mostly because when it was revealed, it was done so without any indication whatsoever in the story previously. It was a shocker precisely because that character was literally on the sidelines, and had shown no relevance to the plot. Also, it seemed to raise questions on that person's existence for all this time in Emmett's Bluff. And then there is an addition of another kind of manipulator at which point I was like so done with the messy world-building.

What makes me truly sad that this was nowhere close to the continuity of the original. For a plot filled with action, the pace dragged on tortuously. There were no real stakes because Malcolm and Valentine always were just instinctively growing into their powers and dropping miracles like Beyonce's new album. Over on the science part, Clive and John were crafting up new tech like nobody's business - which raised the question of how? I get that those goggles were helpful but it takes months to understand and develop machines? Not days, especially when it comes from a technologically advanced time? Are you telling me all the parts in those tech were available in Emmett's Bluff just like that? It was like a sequel had to be written and this was thrown in just to further their story. Even at the end of this book, in Marvel Cinematic Universe fashion, there is an after-epilogue-ish scene that is supposedly setting up the plot for the next book.

Basically, I was disappointed in this sequel and rushed through pages to finish it. Never have I resented a book's length more than when it was for this. For all the magic, action and wonder in this plot, it still fell short for me.

My review will post on April 19th & the link won't work until then.


I wasn’t expecting The Black Tempest. Admittedly, I should have been A Year of Lightning snuck up on me too, yet I was still shocked when I was drawn into a story I couldn’t put down.

The action in The Black Tempest is non-stop. So much so that before I was even 40% in I ordered print editions of both books in the Time Shift Trilogy for my son. (The middle child doesn’t love eBooks ;( what’s wrong with that kid?) Between the action, that was sometimes too fast for my old brain, the solid friendships, and the age-old fight of good and evil this book is sure to please!

While A Year of Lightning was firmly in the middle-grade category, The Black Tempest is a solid YA read. The romantic relationships have moved to the next level, there is some searing smooching, and there’s some alcohol use by one of the teens that’s not necessarily appropriate for younger readers. Most in high-school will have seen/experienced more but for the MG, probably not. (Yes, I know I live in my own little bubble of conservativism.)

While you don’t need to read A Year of Lightning to enjoy The Black Tempest, you won’t want to miss the first book in this enthralling series! I actually can’t wait for the finale. Except, there are some events that are alluded to and I’m already dreading the heartbreak for this family that’s already overcome so much.

All in all, I recommend The Black Tempest to all, but especially to high-school boys and reluctant readers. Remember, I even BOUGHT copies with my own money AFTER reading it!

wasn't really my thing but was ok. it had a good premise, i just found it to move a bit slow.