Member Reviews

I was so excited to pick up Behind the Song but found myself disappointed with most of the short stories. I was expecting this anthology to not only have essays and short stories inspired by certain songs but that the theme in the stories itself would be music too and because that wasn't the case, I felt very underwhelmed by this overall.

I found a lot of the short stories to be super absurd and weird. I wasn't expecting to get such a range of different stories without any connecting point. I thought that music would always be IN the story as well but it wasn't. So there's really no way to determine if you're gonna enjoy this anthology.
Overall I enjoyed the essays way more than the short stories. Because the essays focused on music, be it a musician writing about the song writing process or an author writing about how a certain song inspired them, the music was always part of the essay as well. This is exactly what I was looking for and what I had hoped this anthology would be. My favourite was by far “The Opposite of Ordinary” by Beth Kephart. The way she described how a song made her feel and how it inspired her, was very special but also relatable.
A short story that I really enjoyed was “The Ride” by Suzanne Young. It was clearly inspired by a song but it was also IN the story, even though it wasn't a big part of it. But Young was able to write short story that reflected what I had wanted lots more of the stories to be. It was inspiring and uplifting and made a connection to music.

Overall I would say if you are a fan of anthologies that feature a lot of different stories, you will find that in this book. If you're looking for an anthology that talks about the power of music and how much it can influence people, you should looks elsewhere.
A video review will be up on my YouTube channel on August 25th.

Was this review helpful?

I am all about music, YA, and anthologies so BEHIND THE SONG was sure to be a hit for me. This incredible anthology hit it out of the park and I am thrilled to share it with you all today.

A few reasons I loved Behind the Song (and I think you will, too):
Each author is at their complete best. I've read or interacted with most of the authors (though not the musicians) so I have a sense of their personality. Their stories were so their own that I couldn't help but smile. I especially appreciated Ellen Hopkins' story (I haven't read her stuff before) and EC Myers (who writes an amazing speculative fiction piece that is so deep I felt like I needed to decompress after I read it).
The personal essays. Jonathan Maberry gets REAL in his and it was fun to see G. Love and Donn T write about their songs and experiences with music.
A good mix of stories. From the non-fiction to the fantasy to the cute contemporary (OMG Tiffany Schmidt's story), this anthology has a mix of everything.
It's KM Walton's story that really surprised me. I haven't read anything by her previously but her story (which is the last story) really stood out. I may have shed a tear (or ten).

Highly recommend this anthology!

Was this review helpful?