Member Reviews

I love this peek at a great new book. I love Melissa de la Cruz's books and this will continue the pattern. I can't wait to continue and read the whole thing!

Was this review helpful?

I liked the excerpt enough to read the finished book but I was ultimately disappointed with all the liberties the author took with historical fact. When she did include historical facts, it was done in a dry encyclopedia entry manner. I will not be reading the sequel. Instead I am reading Ron Chernow's excellent biography about Hamilton.

Was this review helpful?

Anything Melissa De La Cruz writes is great!! I really love this book!!

Was this review helpful?

I'm interested at this point and will probably pick this book up from my digital library at some point!

Was this review helpful?

Alex and Eliza is a historical fiction novel about a love story for the ages. As much as I love history, I don’t pick up historical fiction very often and reading this book makes me want to. It is a wonderfully written young adult novel that makes America’s history more relatable. Some historical texts tend to be dry and don’t lend themselves to casual reading. My belief is that this novel (and others like it) might spark an interest in history that will lead teens, or really anyone, to seek out further information.

As this is a work of fiction, the author takes liberties with the plot and adds a fair amount of drama. Historically, there is not a lot known about the courtship between Alexander Hamilton and Elizabeth Schuyler. As you may be aware from history lessons, or your obsession with Hamilton the musical, the two fell in love quite hard and fast. It was nice to see the author’s take on their first meeting, interactions, and ultimate wedding.

This love story reads true and will warm your heart, even if you are aware of the future turmoil in their lives. I enjoyed getting to know Alexander and Eliza so much over the course of this book. The author also does a fantastic job of introducing and developing the supporting characters in this love story. They don’t feel like flat portrayals, but dimensional people that you love (or hate, as the case may be).

For those readers familiar with Hamilton, you will not find that this is the young adult novelization version of the musical. I’ve heard many readers dismaying that fact and it is unfair to the author to make those comparisons. They are two different mediums that each share their love and admiration for the powerhouse that was Alexander Hamilton. The musical follows and chronicles much of Hamilton’s life, whereas this book is a love story. It tells the tale of two souls who found their match, despite all the odds and fell in love.

While the dialogue at times can be cumbersome and strange, it is likely because the reader is used to the modern way of speaking. If you were to read letters that were composed during that era, you likely would notice they have a much more formal, or flowery, way of speaking. Although I found some of the lines to be a bit over the top, overall I felt that they were authentic to the time period in which the book takes place. It would have been unfortunate if the story had been written as if these historical characters were speaking in modern times.

I highly enjoyed this read and would recommend it to anyone who enjoys history. I believe that it is a very accessible book and would lend itself well to those who are hesitant to delve into historical fiction. It does a wonderful job of blending the love story with purposeful doses of actual historical events. Whether you are a fan of the musical, historical fiction, American history or something else – I urge you to give this book a chance.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fabulous book that I think many of the YA audience could use to read rather than simply try to watch the play Hamilton. I loved the portrayal of the sisters bond in this book.

Was this review helpful?

If you are a Hamilton fan, then Alex and Eliza is a must read! De la Cruz takes you on a historical ride with one of our founding fathers, Alexander Hamilton and the love of his life, Eliza Schuyler. It starts off with us meeting the Schuyler sisters, Eliza being the one I can relate to. The one sister that is beautiful on the outside as well as the inside and who wants to help colonists during the revolution. Then comes the fateful night the will start a beautiful relationship. This is a must read and one of my favorite authors.

Was this review helpful?

Alex and Eliza, a fictionalized version of the romance between Alexander Hamilton, an aide for General Washington and America's first treasury secretary and Eliza Schuyler, a socially connected young woman, includes some historically accurate information and much imagined. Alex meets Eliza and incurs her wrath, when he delivers news to the family that her father is to be court martialed. He can't forget her fiery nature and two years later pursues her in Morristown, NJ, where she has come to inoculate soldiers against smallpox. Although he comes from humble beginnings, he ultimately earns her love and rescues her from a disastrous engagement. The story ends with the wedding of the two, who become a political power couple in the early days of a new nation. Although many of the characters are real, much of the action, including Eliza's engagement to Henry Livingston and Hamilton uncovering Benedict Arnold's treason, are fictional embellishments to add pizzazz to the story. Told from Eliza's perspective, the story sheds some light on the civic minded woman who aided her husband with his political writings throughout his career. This is an entertaining read for those who enjoy "history light."

Was this review helpful?

Not my type of book, I tried to start it but just couldn't get into anything about this book!

Was this review helpful?

This book was INCREDIBLE and just what this reader needed! I am a huge Hamilton fan and this story made me love Eliza and Hamilton even more! I couldn't get enough and will be recommending to all of my friends.

Was this review helpful?

This book was such an interesting take on Alex and Eliza's story, and the Hamilton references were always fun to see, but I couldn't, really, get into it properly? Enjoyable read, would read again though

Was this review helpful?

I want more of this book! Being a Hamilton fan, I NEED the rest.

Was this review helpful?

This sneak peak gives the first few chapters of Alex and Eliza, just enough to set the scene. We get to the know their backgrounds and see their first interactions with each other.

I enjoyed the bit we got to read and look forward to getting the full book so I can see where it goes from there.

Was this review helpful?

I didn't read or review because it was only a sneak peek. I will wait until I have a full copy of the book.

Was this review helpful?

Sweet, entertaining & pretty accurate. Some leniency of course but I wonder if readers know Hamilton acknowledged a affair later on.,,

Was this review helpful?

I am not quite sure what Should think about this story so far.
I liked what I read, that is definitely not the problem. I just don't know, if I liked it enough to continue on with the story.
I think I will give this book chance at some point, but not immediately.

Was this review helpful?

I fell in love with Alexander Hamilton at 18 years old when I studied him in my freshman American Political History class. His story, from his beginnings in the Caribbean to his death at the hands of Aaron Burr, fascinated me. BUT, what we didn't cover in my college class was his relationship with Eliza. My fascination with Elizabeth Schuyler and her sisters came from Lin Manuel-Miranda and Hamilton: The Musical. This sneak peek of Alex and Eliza: A Love Story, only made me more interested and excited to learn more about this dynamic relationship and the tumultuous love story of one of America's founding fathers. Well done!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley, Penguin Young Readers Group, and Melissa de la Cruz for the chance to read and review this ARC Sneak Peek;

I was really hoping to love this sneak peek a lot more than I ended up liking it. I felt like it was strangely pushed and put together, and that Eliza's character could use a little more research and settling. It was hard to tell if this book was based more in actual research to the time, or more on the coattails of Hamilton which is so big across the nation right now. I felt like Eliza was very one way and then another (especially if we look at her choosing demure clothes and then jumping into dressing up, even before saying no two pages later).

I truly felt from the beginning that the voices of the two sisters who weren't Eliza blended and blurred too much. They were constantly compared against Eliza more like they were the same person in two bodies rather than two different sisters of a threesome (which anyone with multiple sisters knows that even if you have two who act alike, even twins, there are going to be really big differences in what they do and who they are, too).

This all together from the beginning made it hard for me to do more the skim the sneak peek, and I won't likely be picking up the book.

Was this review helpful?

I had a very hard time getting through this sample, and I usually love De la Cruz's work. I'm also a fan of historical fiction. But for some reason this was very slow for me, and hard to get through. I didn't enjoy it and it felt like a chore to read. I'm quite surprised.

Was this review helpful?