Member Reviews

A clever, well written mystery novel.

When an at risk Black kid rises above his circumstances to become a gifted student at a prestigious university it seems like his troubles are over. Then, under hypnosis in a group therapy session, he admits to having just murdered a young woman. His White girlfriend. And, just like that, it seems like it's all over...

Until P.I. John Francis Cuddy takes on the case. Cuddy owes a big favor to a friend of the boy's family and that favor gets called in. Things aren't adding up but the young guy doesn't want Cuddy's help so he's forced to do things the hard way.

So Like Sleep is the third book in the John Cuddy Mystery series. You do not need to have read any of the other books in the series to enjoy So Like Sleep, it does fine as a standalone novel, there are a few casual references to previous incidents sprinkled throughout the book but it doesn't hurt the overall experience

The subject matter is slightly dated. I imagine that when it first came out (in the mid '80s) the whole idea of hypnosis and murder confessions was hugely controversial. These days it comes across more as a plot device but the writing is good enough to make up for it.

This book (and series) is perfect for fans of Ross Macdonald. John Cuddy is somewhat like Lew Archer with violent tendencies.

There is strong language, racial slurs, and violence.

Was this review helpful?

I have been a fan of Jeremiah Healy since I read his first book. After reading, So Like Sleep, I realized how much I have missed him. I am thrilled that is books are being re-released.

So Like Sleep is later in the series, but the narrative is clear to give new readers the comfort of a stand alone. The story finds John Cuddy investigating an "open and shut" murder as a favor. He uncovers inconsistencies that eventually lead to the truth.

It is worth reading and re-reading!

Was this review helpful?