Miraculous Mysteries is a compilation of mainly locked room and puzzle mysteries presented in roughly historical order beginning with Arthur Conan Doyle and ending with Margery Allingham. It is, at best, a mixed bag.

I don’t care much for the late 19th and early 20th century locked room mysteries. Most depend on secret passages, hidden rooms, and diabolical mechanisms to mislead the reader and this collection is no exception. The early story, The Thing Invisible by William Hope Hodgson, has a diabolical ancient dagger in a family chapel which activates and kills enemies of the family. There are poisonous harps, malevolent chandeliers, pistols set with ingenious timers, etc. The Arthur Conan Doyle story has a five car train vanishing between two rural train stations. The solution is so fantastic that Doyle must have needed some pin money when he wrote it. (Plus Holmes, not yet returned from his “death” at Reichenbach Falls, would have solved it in two minutes with his logical approach).

As Dr. Tancred states in Too Clever By Half by G. D. H. and Margaret Cole, “My dear fellow, do let me give you a word of advice. If ever you make up your mind to commit a murder, don’t make the mistake of trying to be clever. Push the chap over a precipice or shoot him from behind a hedge, or something of that sort, and get away from the scene of the crime as fast as you can. Don’t do anything else. Above all, don’t start laying false clues, or trying to build up an unbreakable alibi. I assure you, many more murderers have been hanged through being too clever than through not being so clever as Scotland Yard.”

There are some real gems in this collection and they are by the best of the Golden Age authors. One of the best is Sayers’ The Haunted Policemen if for nothing more than the charming opening scene where Lord Peter Wimsey views his son and heir for the first time. The mystery is good, too, Michael Innes, tongue in cheek, has Appleby end a short story with a pun that is so bad it is wonderful. The Villa Marie Celeste finds Allingham’s charmer Albert Campion solve the disappearance of a sweet young couple from their kitchen. The ending is more than satisfactory.

So, enjoy this collection for the absurd mechanical puzzles and the “less is more” true mysteries. I think the sleigh of hand is much better than the elaborate illusions.