Member Reviews

Really enjoyed this story, great characters and well written. Would love to see this as a TV show or film.

Was this review helpful?

The only reason I requested this book was that of the beautiful cover but when I learned this was an alternative look at the story of Frankenstein I was hooked and honestly Our Only Chance does not disappoint.

Was this review helpful?

What exactly does it mean to be alive? What exactly does it mean to be human? These concepts have been pondered philosophically for a very long time. Science has offered explanations of both. However, the real question is whether or not science has the right to tamper with basic humanity. OUR ONLY CHANCE is an interesting read, and I've been trying to figure out just whose only chance is meant in the title. Is it humanity's only chance and, if so, for what? Is it technology's only chance to get it right? Or, is it some combination of the two? In novels such as this, there is always the attempt to improve the human condition without fully understanding, or even considering, that every advance has its downside. The dark side of innovation is often catastrophic.

Ray Else has created an atmosphere that conveys the location of the story through use of language. To the Western ear, and perhaps the Western mind, Japan is a place of minimalism and serenity. Else has made use of this notion, quite well, in the crafting of dialog among his various characters, human and otherwise.

Here we have a modern day, technological Frankenstein created by a woman who is both brilliant and naïve. The idea of reviving the dead is universal. Christianity tells us that under the right circumstances we will find everlasting life. Others believe that the soul is reincarnated over and over again, thus achieving something akin to living forever. Lovecraft gave us Herbert West - Re-Animator.

Technological innovation is something we deal with daily. "Hey, Google!" "Alexa…" "Siri…" We talk to our cellphones and they respond with information. Make a call, no problem. Find the nearest fast food place, coming right up. Dig up some dirt on your next door neighbor, maybe not such a good thing. It has been suggested that AIs will one day take over, rule the world, make our lives miserable, and that we 'let' them do it. Automation was going to take away the livelihood of millions… Personal computers were going to give us the four-day workweek… AIs are going to do all our thinking for us… People still work in factories. People still work that old five-day workweek and then some. So, as long as we are able to think, we will.

Although many aspects of OUR ONLY CHANCE should have been compelling, I found that they sometimes fell flat. It was not the page-turner I anticipated. All books are not meant for all readers. Keeping that in mind, this just wasn't really my cup of tea; however, it might just be yours.

Was this review helpful?

Sorry for the inconvenience but I have lost interest in this book, I just can’t get past 50% of the story. I have tried several times to finish reading but I have hit a wall with this one.
Thank you for considering me.

Was this review helpful?

I received this free from NetGalley and the publisher.
I have not read many AI stories, so I was looking forward to reading this one. I enjoyed the setting, having never been to Japan, I liked learning about some of its culture. I did not like any of the characters. They all struck me as amoral people or in one case an A.I., who would do anything to accomplish what they set out to do no matter who was hurt or killed. It was kind of disturbing. Perhaps the next book will have characters who are likable.

Was this review helpful?

This was an interesting read - not something that I would typically go for, but the way the author delivered the overall plotline was good. I didn't necessarily connect with the characters as much as I would have liked for me to really get into the novel, but from an overall standpoint it was an enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun read and an interesting look at the AI question. I would recommend this for anyone who enjoys thinking about the beginning of a world with Artificial Intelligence.

Was this review helpful?

This was just okay. It was pitched as Frankenstein but was more I, robot with a female robot in Japan. I strongly feel that this had so much potential yet something just didn't fit quite right. The image of Japan was extremely stereotypical and sounded like someone googling Japan and writing whatever they saw on the internet and I didn't feel a lot for the characters for some reason. The basic premise and the main theme of AI humanity, kept me reading. I don't regret giving this a chance but this wasn't really my cup of tea.

Was this review helpful?

At first, I was unsure if I would enjoy this book, as it opens like you're reading a cross between a screenplay and a book, but I quickly lost myself in the story. A very interesting story, and one that tackles the question of AI humanity.

Was this review helpful?

While drifting between "genuinely thought provoking" and "beating the reader over the head with obvious metaphor", Our Only Chance is an interesting and refreshing take on both the Frankenstein plot and on the "AI wants to be human" story.
Where the author struggles is not in making the AI accessible and human, but in making the humans so. Our main human character, Manaka Yagami, is introduced to us, literally, in the nude, sexualized as an adult. Her character is then shown in the past, sexualized now as a stereotypical (borderline racist) Japanese schoolgirl - short skirt and zealous focus on schoolwork included.
While the plot eventually deals more with the AI and the implications of her existence, the sour notes the book starts with ends up carrying through the rest of the story, tainting almost every interaction with weak personalities based on vaguely formed ideas of Japanese culture.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to enjoy this novel. I really did. Alas, I did not.
What pulled me in was "A different kind of Frankenstein." It was more of a different take of I, Robot with a single female robot in Japan.

[SPOILER]
The only Frankenstein mention was when she resurrects cadavers to house herself and the other A.I. programs. I enjoyed reading that part.
[END SPOILER]

I wasn't attached to the characters... The setting seems like a forced, stereotypical version of Japan... The plot split off in a lot of directions and there wasn't a lot that was resolved... There just seemed a lot that this novel needed to work on.

Was this review helpful?

I found reading Our Only Chance to be, quite to my pleasant surprise, something I couldn't put down. Else has envisioned a world in which a young and socially inexperienced child genius, called Manaka, almost singlehandedly brings into fruition the bionic evolution of mankind.

It begins with a gradual build-up of a coming-of-age approach done so well that I couldn't even bother to suspend my disbelief. With small steps, the program that is Einna, slowly and carefully comes to life - in every sense of the word. As this little android struggles to find her purpose in life and all of its upheavals, the search for her own soul becomes the centerpiece of this force that drives her as she searches for her own soul.

Of course, if Einna can't find her soul she'll just make one.

Influenced by strong Asian themes, Our Only Chance is a very interesting take on the concept of artificial intelligence. Plagued by the sinister Tagona-san and his shady dealings in the background, you being to wonder what lengths he'll go to in order to have his own personal army of androids.

All in all, this was a very entertaining read.

Was this review helpful?

This book has promise and needs a second book to fill it out. It would work for most ages, and could be a good film with some assistance. It is a bit disjointed, but I have seen some movies that are as well. They just don't become my favorites.

My copy came from Net Galley. My thoughts and opinions are my own. This review is left of my own free volition.

Was this review helpful?

The legalities: I received a free copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.

This is a fascinating story. It’s fun, thoughtful, suspenseful and it is also a great moral tale. Einna is an Artificial Intelligence Robot built by her “Mother,” Manaka to enhance the lives of humans and humanity. She has a human-like brain that can learn, but like most activity of humans, things go skidding out of control and disaster looms. Einna is a teenage robot!! Imagine a teenager with all that intelligence, but still a youngster.

We find Einna involved in a secret project that she is keeping from her mother, while her mother, Manaka, deals with gangsters and a project of her own. This intelligent tale of technology of the future is fast paced, filled with interesting turns and hard to put down. I want to know more about Manaka and Einna.

Was this review helpful?

Not my type of book, I tried to start it but just couldn't get into anything about this book!

Was this review helpful?

This book was a very well written book and I felt like I was in the lab when it was taking place. I do like Manaka and her relationship with Eina since she does have the motherly personality and really wants to know what Eina is really doing. I hope we get to see these two in more books since I would like to see the next one show more of them. And if it was animated into a movie I would so see it on a big screen with audio description.

Was this review helpful?

I liked this take on the creation of androids and artificial intelligence. Einna intrigued me, so much feeling in her, I'd want to be friends with her. With the setting in Japan, I got a stately, paced vibe from the storytelling. And the involvement of a high end "mob boss" type was inevitable. But that gave the story a real world connection. This really could be our future.

Was this review helpful?

Manaka Yagami is the first female tech millionaire, and she had started as a grad student interested in imprinting memories onto brains. One of her supervisors drafted her into his project, and soon the world's first AI was born. Einna is like Manaka's daughter, and she wants to make sure that the Yakuza can't use her tech for untoward purposes. Einna, however, has plans to better mankind and be more human.

The themes in the novel are very poetic, but I found it hard to get past the language style. Sentences are broken up and choppy, often fragmented thoughts, and it was difficult to get a feel for any of the main characters. Perhaps Manaka is supposed to be more standoffish, but it was difficult to care about her struggles. The background characters and Einna were more engaging, and their sections of the novel did seem to flow a lot better.

There isn't a neat ending to the novel, so it almost feels like a let down at the end. All of the characters had their own agendas, even Einna, though her naivete means that she has good intentions behind them. She doesn't explain herself, and the very dry tone of the book is a stark contrast to the sudden chaos at the end. On top of that, it all came to an abrupt stop. I'm not sure if this is meant to have a sequel, but I don't find the story engaging enough to read a follow-up.

Was this review helpful?

This is a very strange book. It has a very slow pace, which made it feel like a much longer book than it is.

Sadly, I didn't like this book as much as I wanted to. The characters are all very... robotic. Which is kind of ironic if you think about it.

The writing was decent, but it also felt a little choppy at times. There wasn't a very clear focus on who exactly the main character is supposed to be. And the beginning of the book, after reading about half, sounded like it was a massive time jump into the future, but the book never really addresses that, or they did and I missed it.

The "meat" of the plot, for me, was kind of confusing and a little unclear for a good while, and when it was revealed it seemed a little underwhelming. I also wasn't really fan of all the name dropping for anime that is popular now. I think this book is supposed to be real-world, just in the not so distant future. It was strange and kind of took me out of the story. It was like in this world no new anime was made since 2010 or something.

The "science" behind all this was glossed over, to the point where you could barely argue that it was explained at all.

This book was fine, it wasn't terrible, but it wasn't great either. Just okay, I wouldn't not recommend it, but if someone said they were reading it I wouldn't be really all that excited for them either.

Was this review helpful?

A brilliant and chilling novel about the dangers and potential of artificial intelligence. I couldn't put it down! A genius student, a philosophical AI, and danger and betrayal. Readers will read this book into the late hours!

Was this review helpful?