Member Reviews

This book follows 4 friends Pato, Arbo, Marcos, and Gladys. They are at a family members quincera when shots fire and from then their lives have changed.

The beginning of the book was equally sad for me. These 4 kids watched their family members be killed in front of them and they couldn't help without getting killed themselves. So they decide to go on the run. They meet up with a man that Pato knows and he helps them get supplies together to cross the border and go to the States.

I was really proud of these four characters and how strong they were despite what they were going through. They did butt heads but no matter what they stayed there for each other. There was a death but I won't say. The book sometimes did D R A G but overall it was a good read. The author did a lot of research on the gangs in Mexico and how people are always trying to cross to the border.

Was this review helpful?

This was a brilliant read. As soon as I started reading this book I just knew I was going to love it. Highly recommended

Was this review helpful?

The book was a book that at first I was like it’s going to be that book that kills me. The cover and the book title to me screamed sadness. But it’s a book everyone must read. The story of four immigrants fleeing Mexico for a better life. Everyone has to read this book to understand what people go thru just for a better life in the United States.

Was this review helpful?

The border by Steve Schafer.
Crack. Crack. Crack.
Not fireworks—gunshots. The music stops. And Pato, Arbo, Marcos, and Gladys are powerless as the lives they once knew are taken from them.
A really good read. Likeable story and characters. 4*.

Was this review helpful?

Very interesting and eye opening book about the realities of border crossing. When picking this up I didn't realize this wasn't an own voices story. While it was well researched I would have preferred to read something from someone who had more real life experience.

Was this review helpful?

The Border is a book that deals with the topic of illegal immigration given the circumstances of a tragedy that happens to 4 Mexican teenagers during a birthday party. Pato, Arbo, Marcos, and Gladys have to cross the border after losing their families forcing them to deal with violence, death, pain, and trauma as they make their make across the border. Each of the main characters have their own strengths which they use in certain points in the book. While, it was hard to picture them since they aren't described vividly enough for me to place them. It is told in first person from Pato's perspective, he was a well rounded character who had to deal with a lot in a short amount of time. His determination and strength is what drives the story. His cousin, Arbo is the comic relief of the group while Marcos and Gladys are siblings. Marcos was a complex character, a lot of times I couldn't tell what he was thinking and Gladys was a character that was strong and independent Although, I wish that she had been developed more instead of just being the sister and Pato's love interest. She was seen as the caretaker of the group and used to make the guys feel better.
With that being said, She shouldn't have been resorted to being the saving grace of the guys when she's able to hold her own. It just sends a bad message to kill off the only girl in the group because that just means that she was just used as a plot-device to motivate the guys.

Was this review helpful?

When Steve Schafer approached me about reading and reviewing his new book, I was intrigued. ‘The Border’ examines illegal immigration from a different perspective–the reasons why people are forced to leave their homes and travel to a new country, where they have nothing and know no one. Honestly, I haven’t read a lot of books regarding this subject. Last year, I read ‘Something In Between’ by Melissa de la Cruz which examined the life of a girl living in the United States who finds out that she is here illegally. Clearly, the issue of legal and illegal immigration is a big one currently in the U.S., with many different opinions flying about. With no prior knowledge on the specifics of illegal immigration, I felt that this book created a compassionate, thought-provoking story. It’s easy to look at statistics or read news articles, but to read the experience first hand emotionally connects readers to the issues and puts names to those stats. While fictional, this book depicts the struggles that many people face, and doesn’t shy away from the horror and desperation of the situations.
The book starts off pretty quickly, there isn’t a whole lot of exposition which I liked. All of the characters were distinctly their own, and handled the shock and information that was thrown at them in different ways. Told from Pato’s point of view, readers get to see how real people are affected from disasters that, as a nation, we rarely hear of. Often illegal immigrants are painted as monsters, but this novel showcases the humanity behind that stereotype.
I liked the connection between how all of the teens knew each other. Marcos and Gladys were siblings, and Pato and Arbo were cousins. At the start of their trek through the desert, it seems uneventful and too easy for the four of them to actually cross the U.S./Mexico border, which Pato does acknowledge. Their trip is never glamorized, or romanticized in any way, which I appreciated as a reader. It feels like a genuine account of what many immigrants experience.
I felt as though Gladys and Pato’s relationship moved a bit fast, in terms of how soon they professed their love to one another. However, being close to death in an endless desert is definitely not your average teen love situation, so the circumstances would obviously be a lot different. Pato mentions once that he sees Gladys brother, Marcos in her personality and defiance, and although that is never stated outright again, I liked how Gladys was portrayed as decently strong and independent, and she held her own with the boys.
I found the writing style easy to read. Format wise there were a few weird enters etc., but as this is an eARC I totally understand that it won’t look like that in the final copies! There are a few words and very short phrases in Spanish sporadically throughout the book, paying homage to the actual language that is being spoken even though the book is written in English which is really nice. It should be easy for non-spanish speakers to catch on to the meanings. I’ve taken years of Spanish in school, so although I’m nowhere near fluent, I was able to easily understand what was said.
Overall, I thought this was a good book and I would recommend it. Books like this one force readers to become emotionally connected to current issues. It’s easy to say ‘stop all illegal immigrations’, many people do, but the issue isn’t as black and white as some make it seem. All angles of issues need to be considered, and this novel creates a great platform to do so.

Was this review helpful?

Sourcebooks Fire and NetGalley provided me with an electronic copy of The Border. I voluntarily chose to review this book and my opinion is freely given.

Four teens must embark on a treacherous journey after a horrific event turns their worlds upside down. Can fear, determination, and strength of character save them or will the teens succumb to the elements?

Having read American Dirt prior to my reading of The Border, I could not help but make comparisons to the aforementioned novel. The Border is not nearly as realistic, nor did I feel as invested in the characters. Considering all that the teens went through, even before their arduous journey, I wanted to feel a connection to the characters. The gangs, especially the retribution and skewed sense of justice, are treated with kid gloves for the most part. Being that The Border is a YA novel, I did appreciate the glossing over of certain facts. That being said, the author was more concerned with exposing his characters to certain aspects of the landscape and the dangers that the teens face, than making sure that the events could actually happen in that manner. Overall, I never quite felt the danger or the fear, so I would be hesitant to recommend The Border to other readers.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to love this book so much, but I ended up not being able to connect with the writing style or the characters. I really didn't like the treatment of the main female character, and the writing just wasn't engaging and I got annoyed. I realize I may have just picked this at the wrong moment. The topic and themes are important, particularly with the state of American politics and the treatment of immigrants, so I won't rate this book lowly, because I still think it should be read, The so it was a DNF for me. and unfortunately I won't be rating it on my blog since I didn't enjoy it.

Was this review helpful?

As usual, Pato, 16, his mother and father always seem to arrive late for get togethers, and cousin Carmen's quinceañera is no different. On their way into the house to join the happy, noisy celebration, Pato notices a suspicious car parked nearby, noticeable because it is completely painted black, even the bumpers. He briefly debates with himself about saying something, after all, there are two men in the car carefully watching the house, but in the end, he decides it is probably nothing. Soon after arriving, Carmen's older brother, Arbo, Pato's cousin and best friend, head out to their favorite spot in the desert behind the house with Marcos, 17, a ace soccer player, and his sister Gladys, 15. But the celebratory noise is suddenly interrupted - not by fireworks, but by the sound of gunshots - lots of them.

Back at Arbo's house, they discover that everyone has been shot dead execution style. To make matters worse, Marcos kills one of the shooters, whose brother recognizes him and threatens to kill all four of them. Realizing they have to get away, even before they can process what has just happened, Pato remembers an older man that he and Arbo had helped once as part of a school project. Pato, Arbo, Marcos, and Gladys head out to Señor Ortiz's house on the outskirts of town.

Señor Ortiz agrees to let them stay for a while and even goes into town to see if he can hear any news about the shooting. Returning, he tells them that the shooting was done as a warning by members of a drug cartel called La Frontera who control every aspect of life in their Mexican town. The school photos of all four teens have been posted everywhere, offering a very big reward for them. The teens decide that the only thing they can do is try to cross the desert and slip over the border into the United States. But this is a trip that proves easier said than done.

The Border, though timely, is a difficult book to read. It isn't enough that these teens have just lost their families to gun violence, but they are also trying to survive on a hot, unrelenting desert which is a struggle for anyone, but even worse if you are completely unprepared the way Pato, Arbo, Marcos, and Gladys are.

The story is told completely from Pato's point of view, and I think this is a story that would have lent itself better to multiple viewpoints. I would have like to know what is going on for the other three teens. But despite that, each person's personality comes across distinctly, and there is even some humor to be found, as well as an attraction between Pato and Gladys, giving the unbelievable horror of their stories more of a human face.

With everything that has been going on in this country regarding the border and immigrants from Mexico, and Central America, this is a very relevant story. While this country builds walls to keep desperate people out, or puts them into cages, and deprives them of any shred of human dignity, it is easy to see why people are willing to risk everything to escape local violence and abuse.

The Border is a book for older, mature teens, even though Pato, Arbo, and Gladys are only 15-years-old. It is a very realistic novel and there is, as I've said, violence and some mild sex, as well as profanity. But it is really an eye-opening experience for those who do decide to read it.

This book is recommended for readers age 14+
This book was an EARC received from NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately, I have not been able to read and review this book.

After losing and replacing my broken Kindle and getting a new phone I was unable to download the title again for review as it was no longer available on Netgalley.

I’m really sorry about this and hope that it won’t affect you allowing me to read and review your titles in the future.

Thank you so much for giving me this opportunity.
Natalie.

Was this review helpful?

*DNF*

Copy kindly received via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

The plot for this one is a great idea, and I wanted to keep reading, but unfortunately the writing style was a bit bland for my taste and I couldn't bring myself to keep going.

The Border is the kind of the book which will showcase the horrors of the lives some people live, and I think many people will find it interesting and enjoy it, it just wasn't for me.

Was this review helpful?

The Border is a hard hitting, gritty read that grabs your attention by starting with a hugely distressing multiple shooting and doesn't let up interest wise until the very last page.

I loved reading it, it brought so many emotions...

Was this review helpful?

This book was incredible. I really enjoyed reading this. The characters were amazing, the story kept me on my toes. It was such a great insight into the lives of illegal migrants and the struggles they go through. This book really stuck with me.

Was this review helpful?

The Border is the debut novel of author Steve Schafer.

Four Mexican teenagers witness the cold blooded murder of their families, by a band of Narcos, whilst attending a 16th Birthday celebration. They flee into the darkened night with the sounds of death threats ringing in their ears.

Schafer has lived, worked, volunteered and travelled throughout most of latin America, including northern Mexico and it is clear he has extensively researched his topic.

The story is narrated in the first person by 16 year old Pato. But we also get a good sense of the other three main characters, Arbo, Marco and Gladys.
When they realise their only means of escape is across the Sonoran Desert into the USA the teens are naive and unprepared. Desperate situations call for desperate measures.

It’s easy to feel empathy for these four teens. Good kids who have been placed in a life or death situation. Throughout the story they bicker, they get along, they dream and occasionally the leadership role shifts but most of all they are scared; just like normal teens.

This is a timely and relevant story with the immigration debate currently storming in America.
The Border is a highly emotional and thought provoking read with palpable suspense and page turning action.

Highly recommended!

Was this review helpful?

A great Young Adult read! A family party in Mexico is the devastating target of a gang shooting...and four teens' lives are changed forever! Having snuck out of the party briefly, Marcos, Gladys, Arbo and Pato return to find their families murdered and, as the only survivors and witnesses, a price on their heads. They cannot stay in Mexico if they are to stay alive; the only option is to cross the border into America - but the desert stands between them.
From their comfortable family lives, the four teens suddenly find themselves thrust into a battle of wills and a fierce fight for survival; against the murderous gangs that took their families from them, against the people they meet who would hand them over for the monetary rewards, against the dangers of the desert - and even against each other.
I really enjoyed this book, and what an education into a drug running, gangland lifestyle that despite this being a work of fiction, that truly exists.

Was this review helpful?

I really had a hard time getting into this book. It did not keep my attention. I found myself really bored reading this book. I do not think it was a bad book but it was just not something that kept my interest.

Was this review helpful?

3.5/5

I wanted to like this book more than I did and I am not exactly sure I can pinpoint what exactly didn't work for me.

The characters were realistic and their stories were raw, interesting and heartbreaking. I had to walk away from and come back to this book several times honestly in order to get through it. Working with students in poverty, from undocumented families and who have had traumatic events in their lives - this is real for far too many.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you so much to Netgalley for giving me a copy of this book. 

As I think back on this book and remember the story and the characters my overall feeling is one of ambivalence. The first chapter is really well written, it's vivid, it hurts to read and you automatically get attached to the characters. From there though the story starts to get slow, although the characters weren't terrible. I liked the subplot with Pato and Arbo's fathers, it gave insight into how life can be very gray at times. 

On the one hand this story is really heartbreaking and realistic and I really appreciated that.  On the other hand I disliked that the story only had one female character and her sole purpose was just there to be inspiration for the main character. *Spoiler* She even ends up dying and there's literately no point to her death other than to move the main character to finish the story, and this really pissed me off. *End Spoiler* As far as the Bechdel test goes this book completely fails, and really it's 2018 why is this still happening? 

In all I thought that it wasn't a terrible book, I thought that it followed an important story, but it could have been written better. I gave it three stars.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted very much to like this, but I couldn't finish it.

Was this review helpful?