Member Reviews
Emma & Cass disappeared from their home 3 years ago. Cass knocks on the door and has a story to tell about what happened to them The same FBI agent and psychologist who investigated now are there to hear the story Cass has to tell of what had happened to them and why she is home alone.
This story starts long before they disappear with many twists and turns to it. They are raised by a narcissistic mother with a father too weak to fight for them when the parents divorce. A half brother who loves them but too young to really be of help. A step-father and step-brother who add to the problems at home.
A hard situation to grown up in and then to deal with what happened when the girls disappear adds to it.
This is the first book I've read from this author, so I had no idea what to expect. I was intrigued by the description and requested an ARC from the publisher through Netgalley.
When I chose this book, I had no idea that parts of the book were set in Maine. As a Mainer, that was interesting to me since they referenced places I know and I could kind of picture what the island might have looked like or where it would be. At times I thought I had figured out what was going on, and I was sort of on the right track, but ended up staying up late to finish. (I love books that keep me up late, even though I regret it the next morning when I have to get up for work!) I thought the book skipped around quite a bit from present, to past, and to different characters and it was a bit distracting, but seemed to fit well with the story. It added another layer to the psychological aspect of the book. I thought the connection of the forensic psychologist who wrote her thesis about narcissistic personality disorder, who then is assigned to this case and recognizes the disorder in the mother was a bit of a strange "coincidence" with a disease that was talked about as being pretty rare, but it was done fairly well. I liked the writing and although there was a lot going on with the story, I really liked it. I will definitely be checking out the author's other books
This book is what I call a “Going to be late for workbook” as it’s impossible to put down. You want to read just a little bit longer - just a few more pages.
Cass and her sister disappear for three years when they are young teens and we follow the multi-layered tale from most of the family members point of view, including Cass’s and her sister Emma.
With parents, step-parents and step-siblings, this book is a hotchpotch of conflict and psychological warfare. Just how dysfunctional this family really gets clearer as you read on and I absolutely love a story where you cannot predict the ending.
Very well written. I’d be surprised if it doesn’t win an award.
I’ve never heard of Wendy Walker until now but I will be looking out for her future books.
Fatima
Breakaway Reviewers received a copy of the book to review
I devoured this story at an absolutely break-neck pace. Each bread crumb that Wendy Walker dropped, I gladly picked up. This is a wickedly fun mystery that had me guessing from the very beginning, but I never quite hit the nail on the head. The idea of an unreliable narrator is turned up to 11 and these vivid and real characters will undoubtedly throw you for a loop.
I'd recommend this to any of my friends, no matter what they generally read.
I received an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest and unbiased review.
In the dark of night, two sisters disappeared. Only one returned…
I wanted to like this book so much. The blurb was so intriguing and made it sound so much better than it actually was. I had a difficult time getting into the book. At a certain point, I wanted to know how it ended, but I no longer wanted to read it. Not a single character was relatable, or even likable.
The mother was a narcissistic sociopath; the father a coward. Emma, the ‘favorite’, learned everything she knew from her mother. And Cass was stuck, trying to survive the insanity of her home life, without losing her own sanity.
While Cass’s story is compelling; full of secrets, kidnappings, and an island full of craziness, she never actually tells anyone the whole story. Just spins out half truths, lies, and distractions. Cass has questions of her own, and she wants answers. She has no problem using everyone around her to get what she wants.
Most of the book is told through psychological analysis and flashbacks. There’s little action until towards the end, and even then it wasn’t much. Emma’s fate wasn’t overly shocking; after all, she was turning out to be just like her mother.
Publication: August 8, 2017
St. Martin’s Press
This book had me from the start, intruiging set up, lovely writing style but it went in a different direction than I originally thought it would and just ran out of legs and lost my interest towards the end.
The story is based around two sisters, Cass and Emma as they go missing from the family home on the same night. Three years later and Cass turns up back at the home but without Emma.
The FBI are brought in to investigate and we are introduced to forensic Psychiatrist Dr Abby Winter. She originally investigated the case when the girls went missing and was convinced that the mother might have played a role in their disappearance or had been in some way responsible. Having recently published a paper on narcissistic parents, Abby was convinced that their mother was a pathological narcissist.
Cass, now 18 tells them stories of kidnapping, a mysterious island where they were held and how she escaped without Emma.
Abby doesn't believe she is telling the whole truth and as she delves deeper finds a totally disfunctional family. A narcissistic mother who turned her love for the children on and off while they were growing up and neglected them for large parts. Left their father and remarried a rich and powerful man who had had a son from a previous relationship, both of who seemed to have an unnatural interest in Emma.
I loved this book up until about half way through. The set up was great. It was all very mysterious and of course we all want to know what happened to the girls that night and why Cass has escaped without Emma. I was particularly looking forward to the relationship between Cass and Abby as I was expecting her to have many sittings with her to prise out the truth.
Unfortunately this isn't what happened. Instead we have a study of a dysfunctional family, with the disappearance of the girls a vehicle to tell the story instead of being the story. I remember reading Wendy Walkers pervious novel - All Is Not Forgotten and thinking the same thing. It wasn't the book I expected when I stared reading it, turning into more of a character study rather than the mystery being the central theme of the book but, whilst it worked brilliantly with that book, here it doesn't work half as well and ultimately falls down.
I found the characterisation much less sophisticated and developed here. Nearly all the characters here are dislikeable and not that interesting, the mother probably the most interesting of the lot.
The book also, despite being only 320 pages, feels a little word heavy. The detail gone into the petty squabbles and one upman ship became a chore to read at times and just didn't hold the attention.
It's such a shame for me as I really like this authors writing style. She had me from the first page and I was totally engrossed in the setup for the read ahead. But as the characters and story developed I found myself becoming more and more detatched. The more it went on the less there was to like about it or the characters. Practically everyone in the family is totally dislikeable and spend their time playing mind games with each other trying to humiliate each other. It just becomes tiresome in the extreme.
Thanks to NetGalley, St Martins Press and Wendy Walker for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Loved this novel! Ms. Walker is a truly talented writer who develops character and builds suspense. A masterful page-turner.
Reading this novel was an intense experience, to say the least.
I, too, was raised by a narcissistic mother. I've read a lot about the matter, I've gone on therapy many times and discussed it. My growing up had many, many similarities to the one described on these pages, which made this reading unbelievably personal. Through this story I felt like I was both on therapy, learning more and more about myself and the years that helped form the person I grew up to be, with all the screams it left inside me (and what beautiful, powerful, heartbreaking metaphor this was. I am forever using it from now on) and being somehow vindicated, liberated. I'm not alone, it's happened to others, it's on a book.
It's a sensation that is tainted with guilty, because I surely didn't want anyone else to have lived what I lived. I'd prefer if it were an isolated case for sure, but it's not. And to grow up in such a toxic environment leaves scars so deep it's unbearably hard to move on and even harder not to repeat the pattern, to break the cycle. I'd like to think I did, but I am not sure. The old joke of fearing to turn into one's mother is a lot more terrifying when said mother is a narcissist.
With all that I could certainly understand Cass's thought process, her feelings, her aims. However, some aspects of her motivations did not convince me and that's why, despite having connected with this book as much as it is possible without actually having written it, I'll only give it 4 stars and not 5. I have to be completely honest and fair and not let my endearment with the story tarnish my objectivity when rating. There are aspects of the story that did not make perfect sense and/or are unconvincing, at least to me but I could easily overcome them all not only because the story is so dear to my heart but also because of how well written it is. Each sentence is fabricated with mastery and every character greatly constructed. I love the novel as a whole and recommend it immensely.
I'd like to profoundly thank NetGalley and the publisher for giving me the opportunity to read an ARC of this, which I am sure is going to be one of the most talked books this year, in exchange for my honest review.
"It was like watching a tornado. Beautiful. Terrifying."
I've seen a lot of mixed reviews for this novel, and truthfully, I can understand all of them. What you need to understand is that this novel is truly psychological in every sense. If you have no interest in the human mind and the way people think, what shapes people to think the way they do and even act the way they do, then you will not like this novel. This is not overly suspenseful, it's not on the edge of your seat thrilling, but it is thrilling. It's thrilling because we get to see inside the mind of a young woman who has been so damaged by her family and her ordeal that one would expect her mind to deceive her, yet her intellect and insights are truly captivating.
This novel is about two teenage girls that disappear into the night, Cassandra and Emma Tanner. After three years of being missing, Cassandra returns home, but where is Emma? This story is told from two different points of view, the main being from Cassandra herself, and the other from Dr. Abigail Winter, Forensic Psychologist for the FBI. Upon Cassandra's return, her message is clear, "Find Emma!". Cassandra... Cass... begins to tell her story to her mother and the FBI; she explains how her and Emma left, why they left, and where they went. Dr. Winter is not sure what to make of Cass' story... somewhere in there lies the truth.
As the FBI scramble to find Emma we begin to learn what lead up to the disappearance of Cass and Emma. We learn that the girl's mother, Judy Martin is a classic narcissist. As such Judy had not been an ideal caregiver to her young daughters. When married to their father, Owen Tanner, she had told him, allegedly, that she had done her part by giving birth. We learn that once Judy had an affair with a man from the country club, Jonathan Martin, and left their father, that this sparked a series of events. A chain reaction if you will. Their father was devastated, his pain became a parasite feeding on him, and nothing could bring back the parts of him that had been eaten away. Judy and Jonathan were married and with that came Hunter, Jonathan's son. It's not long before we see how dysfunctional this brought together by marriage family becomes. As Cass begins to fill us in on all the family history, I found myself fascinated. I couldn't help but think of those shows on Investigation Discovery where someone in the family has been murdered and we learn all the facts that lead up to that murder... what literally drive people over the brink into madness. This is one messed up family, twisted really.
This is the first novel I've read by Wendy Walker, and I have to say, I'm impressed, she really knows how to do her homework. This novel focuses on narcissistic personality disorder more than anything; I felt Wendy did an excellent job of really making the reader understand what this is and how it affects not only the person with the disorder, but those in direct contact. The characters, each and every one of them, I found to be well developed and fit into the storyline just as they needed to be. Considering I received an uncorrected copy of this novel, I found the grammatical errors to be very minimal, which is definitely a plus since that can often be distracting. All in all, conceptually this novel came together very well, and I enjoyed it.
3 stars--I liked the book.
The writing in this book isn't very good (I was surprised it wasn't Walker's first book, actually). It's simplistic, and dialogue is especially awkward. But I don't read suspense novels for the writing--I read them for a good, gripping story.
And this was gripping! I stayed up late last night to finish, because I had to know what happened. Though I had a quibble or two about the story (specifically, why didn't the taxi drive or anyone on the train say they'd seen Cass with a baby when she was heading home?), overall I was caught up in the suspense and had a good time reading.
I received this review copy from the publisher on NetGalley. Thanks for the opportunity to read and review; I appreciate it!
EMMA IN THE NIGHT by Wendy Walker. A interesting and suspenseful psychological thriller. Learned much about the Narcissistic Personality disorder and very glad never to have met such a person. That one person has so much control, and so little empathy towards others, it is amazing that the Cass wasn't more damaged psychologically or Abby, for that matter.
Thank you to the publisher, author, and NetGalley for the opportunity to preview the book.
'Emma in the Night' is fun and twisty and kept me guessing. It is well written and expertly paced with an interesting plot line. I wasn't sure what to make of Cass: was she lying about what happened? Was some of it the truth? Why would she lie? If she was lying, where had she been all this time? And where was Emma? This book kept me reading long into the night, wanting to read just one more page to find out what happened.
An enjoyable and worthwhile read. Recommended.
It would be a lie if I said I enjoyed this book. It’s dark. It’s interesting. I have no idea if pathological narcissism actually exists or if it’s a device of the author’s. She acknowledges a person who helped her with this mental disorder, so I have to take a leap of faith and think it’s real. I do know that the family in this story is dysfunctional to the tenth power! They’re awful! Not one character who is really likable. Cass is understandable, at some level, but certainly not likable.
So, if you really like the dark, psychological stories with an unreliable narrator, this will be right in your wheel house. If you love reading about rare, difficult to diagnose mental disorders, you will be fascinated. The writing is superb, the pacing and flow is perfect. It’s very well done with just a tiny plot hole at the end. That plot hole may have been intentional. Maybe. In real life few issues are tied up in neat little bows, so that gave the story a certain air of authenticity that was, to me, absent in the rest of the story. I find it hard to believe that a family this messed up would go unnoticed until after a tragedy occurs. However, the news reminds me every day that these things happen. I guess I would rather not read the same tragic stories for entertainment. If you disagree, pick up a copy and…
Enjoy!
2shay
Another excellent book by Wendy Walker. I really liked how it was told from both Cass and Abby's point of view. Really good and interesting story.
Thank you for the ARC of this novel. I thoroughly enjoyed this book. This is my favorite genre psychological suspense. While the novel started out strong, i was not a fan of the the latter half. Will not disclose why, other than the plot line....as i dont want to give anything away
thank you
I was given this book as an Advanced Reader's Copy with the understanding that I would read it and review it.
I wrestled for a while to determine what rating to give this book-- 3 or 4 stars. Ultimately, I decided on 3 stars because the book didn't grip me as much as I had hoped.
The premise for the story is interesting--- a young woman shows up at the door of her childhood home years after she and her sister disappeared under suspicious circumstances. The narrative switches between Cass, the young woman, and Dr. Anna Winter, the forensic psychologist with the FBI who notices troubling signs in Cass's family dynamic that reflect Dr. Winter's own dysfunctional upbringing. Cass' mother, whom Cass refers to as Mrs. Martin throughout the book, is a classic example of a person with Narcissistic Personality Disorder. Perhaps because I am a clinical social worker myself, I found the depiction of Mrs. Martin to be a bit heavy-handed at times and a bit of a distraction from the narrative.
As with almost all books nowadays, there is a few twists in the story, but I was able to figure out most of them beforehand, but that may be because I'm on the lookout for twists and "gotcha" moments (because I read so much). In any event, this wasn't a bad book. It was readable, and I think it will do very well if it develops some of the hoopla of similar novels in summers past.
Very early on in this story you knew that things were not exactly as they seemed. Two young girls went missing - were they abducted, did they run away, are they still alive. The investigation is still not quite closed but its been three years now. Of a sudden the younger girl returns. She just turns up at the door to her mother's house with a very long, perfectly logical explanation as to what has happened to her and her elder sister. Now it is the turn of the investigators to find the elder sister from the clues given by Cass the younger girl.
Abby and Leo are the investigators for this from three years ago and they take over again. Abby has her own suspicions but without proof it is not easy to pin point anything. Cass's explanations are explicit, very detailed with just enough clues to keep the investigative process going rapidly. The background at home is very complicated - parents separated and mother married again. There are step children involved and the mother is not your average lady on the street.
The story was full of suspense. It was a psychological battle between a mother with narcissist tendencies who was manipulative, deceitful and self centred. Nothing else mattered to her other than herself. The story was twisted and took a great deal of step by step story telling to unravel it.
Goodreads review on 28/6/2017.. Amazon is not permitting a review as yet. Review on my blog 8/8/2017.
Thank you to the publishers and Netgalley for an advance copy in return for my honest review.
I love psychological thrillers. The dark side of people thrills me, and a psychopaths ability to hide in full view fascinates me.
This book explores the Narcissist Personality in that teenage sisters Cass and Emma mother suffers from Narcissist Personality Disorder (NPD) giving them a difficult home life.
I suppose I was expecting a story along the lines of Mommy Dearest or even Flowers in the Attic. I really wanted the book to take off in the direction of the psychologically disturbed mother tormenting her teenage daughters to the point of no return. This does happen but the story for me just didn’t ‘take off’, and reach the dark side where I was expecting it to be.
Cass and Emma disappear into the night. Three years later Cass returns with a disturbing story of being incarcerated on an island, teenage pregnancy and a sister left behind.
This book just did not engage me though. I really could not put my finger on it but the conversations just went on and I found I really didn’t care about the characters, Mrs Martin was certainly narcissist but she just wasn’t dark enough for me. In fact I found that I disliked her and Cass intensely and maybe would have preferred if Mrs Martin and Cass had got more of their comeuppance at the end.