Member Reviews

This book is very detailed, comprehensive and engaging, but for me I found it a little boring. as a YA book, I think it might be a little heavy. Too much text book, not enough to engage the younger readers. I did enjoy it, but found MY attention span wandering, so I think the target audience would too.

Was this review helpful?

Winifred Conkling is emerging as a definitive chronicler of women's history. Passenger on the Pearl told the story of Emily Edmondson, who escaped slavery and dedicated her life to education young African-American women; Radioactive! gave long-overdue props to Irène Curie & Lise Meitner, whose work on radioactivity was often overlooked in a male-dominated field; now, Votes for Women gives us a comprehensive history of the fight for American suffrage, long before women finally won the right to vote in 1920. For readers who may only be familiar with Susan B. Anthony, this volume is indispensable, introducing readers to Elizabeth Cady Stanton; Susan B. Anthony's counterpart and founder of the suffrage movement, and Alice Paul, who took her cue from the more action-oriented British suffrage movement, and went to jail for the cause, where she and fellow protestors suffered deplorable conditions and were force-fed. We meet Victoria Woodhull, the first female Presidential candidate, and revisit Sojourner Truth's famous speech, "Ain't I A Woman?" Most importantly, we learn about the beginnings of intersectional feminism; when abolitionists and suffragists found common ground - and then diverged under political fire.

This is a comprehensive book, complete with photos, primary sources, and writing that never turns away from the more difficult moments in the battle for the vote: from racism to violence, it's all here. It's a good book for your nonfiction collections and women's history collections for middle school and high school, with extensive primary source references, a timeline of American women's suffrage, a bibliography, notes, and an index. Booktalk this with the graphic novel, Sally Heathcote: Suffragette by Mary M. and Bryan Talbot, which features a fictional character from the British movement, and is a great hook to get teens interested. A Mighty Girl has a strong list of additional reading, filtered by age, on suffrage.

Was this review helpful?

Votes for Women! is a very well-researched account of the American Women's Suffrage Movement. While technically aimed at the middle grade audience, this is dense text. There are some fascinating facts throughout the book, and I think it would be great to pull passages to use in the classroom. I just wish that this was slightly more engaging for the younger audience.

Was this review helpful?

I have read extensively about the campaign in Britain to secure votes for women but know little about the equivalent in the USA. Winifred Conkling's book has filled huge swathes in the gaps of knowledge. Excellent!

Was this review helpful?

An excellently drawn and wonderfully told tale for students and readers alike.

Was this review helpful?

Votes For Women is an extremely well written and extensively researched book. The author included not only the issues of suffrage, but other topics such as the temperance movement and the exclusion of voting rights for women with the passing of the Fifteenth Amendment. There’s a myriad of background information as well as personal obstacles that many faced along the way. You will not find this type of information in history textbooks. This book would be an added bonus when teaching about the suffrage movement in a much more comprehensive manner and will enlighten the minds of students everywhere.

Was this review helpful?

Every woman should read this one - the details of what it took to get the rights we sometimes take for granted! So interesting and ... inspiring really!

Was this review helpful?