Member Reviews

Camellia is a belle in the world of Orleans where belles are revered because they control beauty and beauty is coveted. In Orleans people are born gray and only a belle can turn them beautiful.

Camellia wants to be the favorite and be chosen by the queen, so she can live in the palace and be recognized as the most talented belle of all time.

Once she makes it to the palace she sees that court life is not all that it is made to seem. There are dark secrets buried. She finds out her powers are far stronger than she could have ever imagined. The queen asks Camellia to help a sick princess by using her powers in an unconventional way and she must come to a decision. Save the lives of her and her belle sisters or risk her own life and help the princess.

This book is getting so much buzz in the bookstagram community. The cover is absolutely gorgeous and there's a PINK MAP YOU GUYS! I absolutely love books with maps in them.

The description of the book was extremely promising. I absolutely love that it was a take on a court in a "new Orleans" world. With a plot written around society's obsession with beauty, a bit realistic since beauty makes the world go round today. It gives you a small dose of reality in a beautiful, fictional world. The author has the ability to weave a story that is completely unique and has excellent world building skills. Definitely pick this one up!

Was this review helpful?

I was really apprehensive about this YA book. I am not a reader of princesses, high court, royalty, or any of that jazz. So to say I was amazed and surprised would be an understatement. This book slowly weaves its magic around a set of sister’s called the Belles. Belles are raised to understand that their one and only purpose is to create beauty for the people of their kingdom. One Belle is traditionally chosen to be the “Favorite” of the royal family. To adhere to all beautifying needs. I do not want to give any spoilers. But if your job is to provide the ultimate beauty service to a spoiled princess who is never satisfied and definitely a bit mad. Things are going to get CRAZY!!!!!!!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley, and the first thing that needs saying is that there is nothing beautiful about these Belles.
A strangely disturbing read, that led me to expect one thing but delivered a very dark and disturbing tale.

Was this review helpful?

This book was gorgeous. From the descriptions to the writing to the characters, I loved all of it. Camille was a great main character, she was determined to do the right thing no matter what and I really admired her. It took a bit for me to get into it with most of it being description at first, but after the first few chapters I found myself immersed in this world that the author had created. I wasn't expecting such a richly imaged world but this was exactly that. I think that someone who isn't even a fan of fantasy like myself would enjoy this and I would recommend it to anyone. I am looking forward to a sequel and anything else that this author will write in the future.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley for an ARC of this book.

Wow. First of all check out that cover! Yeah for a female POC, MC!!!! Gorgeous.

If you're not a fan of LOTS of descriptions (see my husband) than this book is not for you. I thought it was amazing though because the whole POINT of this book was how incredibly superficial all of these people are, and how the idea of "beauty" is constantly changing. Lots of interesting social commentary about our society now reflected in this fantasy.

At first I did not like Camellia but she was definitely a product of both nature and nurture and she grew throughout the book so that was good. Edel was amazing! <spoiler> I am super stoked by the ending and hope we get to see WAY more of her in the sequel </spoiler> Sophia was insane! I kept wondering why they didn't just kill her....seriously...do that same stop her heart thingy that had been used before and get rid of the crazy lady.

Anyways, very engaging read and I will certainly be waiting for the sequel!

Was this review helpful?

This was 100% a case of "it's not you, it's me" with this book. This is absolutely a beautiful book (inside and out) - I'm just not really a visual reader so the imagery was a little lost on me and there's SO MUCH of it that I was just kinda reading without really comprehending things (I don't picture anything when I read, I'm a monster, I know). I had a hard time connecting to the characters as well because it felt like a lot of telling, not showing. We're told a lot at the beginning that Camilla is rebellious and like, I can see that from her debut, you don't have to keep telling me over and over how she never follows the rules (this was mostly brought up when she was talking to a guy she meets who she's not supposed to talk to). We're also told a lot about how close the Belles are, but they're apart for most of the book which was disappointing (understandable, but disappointing). The way this ends opens things up for the sequel that I would definitely be interested in, so I'll probably check that it out when it's released. Like I said, this is just a "it's not you, it's me" thing. I wasn't in the right mood or mindset for this, but I definitely still recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

Wow! Something fresh and unexpected for the YA scene!

Was this review helpful?

This was actually a pleasantly surprising good book. I don't really care for the fantasy genre, but the subject and setting were intriguing. It took a few chapters to get me engaged and I felt that some of the characters needed more development, but because this is going to be series that will likely happen in the next book. Toward the end, there so many plot twists and turns that I couldn't put it done. I look forward to the next one.

Was this review helpful?

This was my most hyped read for 2018 so far. I dropped all other reading to read it when I was approved. Sadly, so far, it was my most disappointed reading so far as well. I knew going into it that this book had flaws. I had read reviews about it and knew it was in there. But much like others, I hoped it wouldn't be that bad. And it wasn't at first. It was the book I was waiting for, that felt like utter magic and covered in sugar. As someone who tends to vary in their femme side on a daily basis, this book made me pick up makeup again and try to express it when that side appeared. And I was thankful for that. It reminded that side of me that it can shine. And the story itself felt like magic and original when a lot of stories prefer gritty, it was glitter.

But that started to change as the closer the book came to the end. Flaws started showing up. Camille hadn't really gotten past the one dimension of herself. And she continues being the same naive character to the end, despite going through ordeals that should make her grow. She stays flat, saying she'll do something but puts it off for five more chapters only when there is no choice. Most of the ending could have been prevented if she had just spoken up when she decided to. She instead kept saying Sophia couldn't rule at the end of each chapter and doing nothing to actually stop it. It became painful to even read at times, leaving me frustrating and feeling like I read the same chapter again and again just with slight differences.

The things that became my biggest issue however was three factors: the fatphobia, the bury-your-gays trope being played heavily, and the evil bi person. I nearly didn't finish the book because I was so upset. The fatphobic mentions weren't in most of the book. But as Camille is brought to court, it's shown heavily in court that fat is ugly, that fat people (Claudine) shouldn't eat, that they aren't beautiful, and that they're bad people. Claudine is mostly used as a point to pick at due to the fact she was over weight. Sophia and her other ladies "tease" her about it (it's more then teasing later on). Because of it, she was ugly and ends up dying at the hand of others making her more "pleasing" to look at. But more on that later. As for the evilness, I point to Prince Alfred, a horrible person who happens to be fat. It ends up being his most distinctive feature whenever he's described. He tries to rape Camille and the only describing words I can remember her saying about him is "greasy" and "fat". I can't even remember if they gave him a hair color. But it did say that.

As for the bury-your-gays, we come back to Claudine. We find out she's in love with her attendant, another girl. She's hiding it because the girl is of a poor class. But it's found out despite that and Claudine ends up dead. But first we go through the horrible scene were she's promised to disgusting Alfred to marry. Not another woman, which she clearly would prefer. We know Sophia is being cruel on purpose, but this rubbed me the wrong way. As someone who's gay, the very idea makes me sick and is part of my worst nightmares. Nothing about this is okay. Yes Claudine had other suitors that were men, but she showed no actual attraction to them. She seemed to be doing it simply to please Sophia. Claudine is then tortured to death while Camille and Amber make her 'more beautiful' to please Alfred. Because he doesn't like fat women. I had to stop here for a while, furious. Because it's 2018 and I had hoped that this trend would have stopped and it hasn't. It's one of most disgusting tropes in popular media and leaves actual gay people hurt, including myself. Because I desperately wanted this book to succeed. Because we need a black girl being the most beautiful and working actual black girl magic. We needed stories like this, but this book doesn't hold up, hurting in turn others. Claudine was used only as a plot device to push Camille past her limit and to fight back. That's it. Her death isn't mourned nor is she shown respect in the book. She's simply a throw away for the story of another straight character.

Finally I talk about the last issue, the evil bi queen. Aka Sophia. Though Sophia is only mentioned to have been with one girl, it was similar to Claudine's story, a girl she loved but came from the wrong position. So she had her killed. She in turn poisons her sister to take throne, has Claudine killed, has Bree killed, tortures Belles, and become the villain of this story. This is the second most used gay trope. Bi people, and bi women in particular are often made the villain in stories and in life. To me, I feel it's unfair and throws a stereotype that often leaves people who are bi hurt and accused of being so. This will only add more fuel to it, the intention or not.

I know the author tried, but in hoping to bring together someone beautiful, she hurt too many others in doing it. Sadly, I don't recommend it, even if I'll ache for this book and what it could have been. The writing and descriptions were lovely, it made me long for this world in a way. But the plot is full of pain and the characters fell flat, either as stereotypes or lack of emotion or character. I give this book a 2.5, the world saving the story enough that I give it a 3. But not without a heavy heart and some pain in doing so.

Was this review helpful?

This book is definitely a page turner. I could not put it down! There were so many surprising twists and turns in the book and it was refreshing to read something different. The author keeps the reader engaged and wanting more.

Was this review helpful?

This was such an unusual and gripping book! I loved the opening descriptions and the lush feel to Orleans. Right off the bat, the Belles intrigued me, and reading about Camellia transforming the small (terrified) girl was fascinating. The dark undertones also immediately caught my attention -- and I couldn't put it down for the last quarter! I would call this 4 1/2 stars (missing from 'perfect for me' because of a distance I felt throughout from Camellia...not necessarily a bad thing, but something I noticed). I will definitely pick up the second one.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this book on futuristic beauty and what it takes to maintain the ideals. There is an evil princess, great dressmaker, and a sorority of beautiful girls trying to stay alive. I loved it.

Was this review helpful?

The villains were just so obvious. I found the concept a little confusing and the characterizations inconsistent. It also didn't feel like a complete story - yes, it's the first in a series but not enough happened for it to stand on its own.

I do think this would be easy to booktalk though!

Was this review helpful?

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/1916280274?book_show_action=false&from_review_page=1

Was this review helpful?

Orléans is populated with people born gray and ugly but obsessed with beauty and excess. The Belles carry the blood of the Goddess of Beauty and, alone, are born colorful and beautiful. They have the power to restore temporary beauty to the rest of the population. Camellia Beauregard and her five sisters are this generation's Belles. At the age of 16, they are sent to the Queen's palace to compete for the title of favorite Belle. But Camellia finds that the high price of maintaining beauty as the Queen's favorite is rife with ugly politics and dirty secrets. Caught between the wishes of a docile queen and a vindictive princess, Camellia finds herself with an impossible choice.

Dhonielle Clayton has created a lush, detailed world in THE BELLES. The theme of outward beauty being desirable at any cost is woven thickly through the story. Once I settled into this fantasy world, I was swept up in the riveting plot that speeds up as it goes along. I was super excited to get an early look at this book and look forward to the next one!

Was this review helpful?

I received an e-arc of this from Netgalley.

See, I liked this. I read this during jury duty, and it was a really fast and enjoyable read.
It sputters before it starts, and I found myself a bit peeved, feeling like the story didn't really start till 21% in.
I will say that this world and magic system are intoxicating, scents as heady as the flowers and perfumes referenced in the prose. Once it got going, I found myself enjoying it enough that I wasn't trying to guess all the plot points (a horrible flaw of mine), and felt that a couple were really deserving of the word "twist".
I like this take on vanity in a young adult fantasy book, and I think if the trilogy continues with showing the ugly truth behind buying beauty, it will be a series that can boast an immensely powerful message for those who read it.
A character named Bree really stole my heart, and it was a perfect portrayal of the "sweet handmaiden who wants to help too much".
If there's a trope in this book that brought it down though, it's the "girl has insta-love with the Very Obvious Bad Guy" formula. I was pulled out a tiny bit at the scenes with the two of them, feeling like it was very misplaced in this story that was weaving together so nicely otherwise.
I absolutely adored Remy, he was a delight.
Overall, I'm trying not to go into much depth because even with a spoiler warning, people who haven't read might click.
I really did like this, quirks aside. and I look forward to grabbing and reading a finished copy! This is a lovely debut.

Was this review helpful?

So…I’m that person.

You know the person who gets completely swayed by a book cover? Yup. Me.

It was the cover art for The Belles that caught my attention originally. I quickly dismissed it, thinking it was a romance. (Nothing wrong with romance novels. It’s just that sometimes I’m more in the mood for the kind of screaming that comes with pain and terror.)

But despite my dismissal, I kept being drawn back to the cover. It was so striking.

And, finally, I read the plot summary and oh my god, I was in.

Now, quick other book reference: The Belle reminding me a bit of Glitter. It has that kind of lush, completely over-the-top ostentatiousness about its setting. Sometimes when reading the book, you’re just overwhelmed by its absolute gorgeousness.

But, never fear, the author very quickly lets you in on the fact that there are some pretty ugly secrets behind all this beauty.

More than once, just when I let myself me lulled into that same old YA dystopia complacency, the author would pull the rug out from under me with something I simply didn’t see coming. And as for the origin of the Belles themselves? I knew something was up, but didn’t expect that!

As I’ve read a little of the buzz now about the book, people keep talking about the fact that the author is African American and you’ve got that lovely brown-skinned girl on the cover. I do want to tell you that the book isn’t about race. At all. In fact, the author has created a world where you choose your own skin – and you can change it every month if you want. You simply choose based on your idea of beauty and the skin in the book ranges from the palest of whites to the deepest of browns. Race just isn’t a thing in this book. Beauty is. Pain is. And betrayal, and romance, and heartbreak, and fear.

I loved this book. There’s certainly room to make this a series and I truly hope the author does!

Was this review helpful?

I was intrigued by the concept of this novel and all that it might implicate. I got a little over 100 pages through it, but unfortunately, the story dragged for me, without gripping or intriguing me further enough to keep going for 300+ more pages. It just wasn't my cup of tea.
_______________________ I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher via NetGalley for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

It is very rare these days to find a book with such an original premise as this. I absolutely loved the whole idea of the plot and the charcters within it - it completely drew me in, until I coukd not put it down.
What a rare beast! I cannot wait for more from this author.

Was this review helpful?

In a market crowded with gritty dystopias, this Rococo fantasy about beauty and pain and power really stands out. Everything in Camille’s world is beautiful, but we soon learn that beauty comes with a frightening price—jewels have sharp edges, and silk is strong enough to bind. The physical transformations that Camille performs for the nobility cost people in pain and suffering, and endanger her own life if she does too many. Camille herself is ambitious, powerful, creative, and rebellious, and my heart ached for her. To tell you how the betrayals and revelations unfold is to spoil you for the reading, but believe me when I say that this is a stunning story and a fascinating world and I can’t wait for book two, whenever that may be.

Was this review helpful?