Member Reviews

Thanks so much to the publisher and to NetGalley for giving me access to this book. Interesting book - Well written, and interesting characters. I will be recommending this book. Thanks again for letting have a chance to read it.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this coming-of-age story of a kid in the early 1990s - I felt so nostalgic! Events are both heartbreaking and inspiring, and I was eager to see how it would all end. What initially felt like your typical type of story ended up exploring race issues in a way I hadn't read before in a very touching, real way. Highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

An exploration of growing up white in a predominantly black school/neighbourhood, and realizing some of the privileges that your classmates will never have. This does not offer easy answers/solutions to the cultural biases found in the story, but it definitely sparks a conversation.

Was this review helpful?

This book started out a little slow to me. It was written in the style of a teenage boy with a lot of slang. Half way through it did pick up a bit, enough to want to finish it.

Was this review helpful?

A middling, wandering novel with no real point or intended audience. I got the sense that Graham-Felsen aspired to writing a newer "Catcher in the Rye" but failed spectacularly. The characters are flat and lifeless, there is no real plot, and I definitely wasn't invested in Dave enough to care about his coming-of-age.

The one thing that Graham-Felsen does well is capturing the language of a pre-teen urban kid in the 90s. Weird talent, but reading the thoughts of a try-hard, confused white boy desperately trying to fit in by using slang and basketball references was pretty entertaining.

Was this review helpful?

David Greenfield, a white pre-teen, finds his way through the trials of being a minority in a predominantly African-American school in Boston in the 90s. This is his coming of age story. I am divided about the book. It deals with important issues, such as racism, but I didn’t feel the story did enough with the topic. Much of the time the main character is upset about being one of two white kids in his class, and the bullying he experiences. He begs his Harvard educated parents to transfer him to the private school his brother goes to, but they have chosen to eschew the privilege it represents. I find it hard to sympathize with David. He complains about his lot in life and takes his privilege for granted. The question is, does he mature and recognize his own privilege? This book would work as a good conversation starter about discrimination and privilege, but I didn’t feel it made much of a statement.

Was this review helpful?

So many of the books I've read or even the experiences I've heard about are stories of a black person (or someone from another marginalized category) living in a white world. This novel was written about the opposite situation. 12-year-old David Greenfield sticks out like a sore thumb at Martin Luther King Middle School. With his blonde hair and blue eyes, he is one of only two white students in the school. This story takes place in the early 90's, around the same time as the Rodney King trial and the riots that shook the country. The message is timely and it has you look at white privilege in a new way. Throughout the book, I couldn't help but think that it was a direct contrast to Angie Thomas' The Hate U Give. Overall, a good read. *ARC provided by the publisher in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I received an ARC of this book from NetGalley in exchange for my unbiased opinion.

David Greenfeld, or Green as he prefers to be called, is starting 6th grade at Martin Luther King Middle School in 1992 Boston. He is one of only 2 white students in his class and feels completely out of place. Eventually, he becomes friends with Marlon, and they bond over their love of the Celtics. Gradually, however, Green's eyes open to “the force” - the way the world treats him and Marlon differently just because of the color of their skin.

Green and Mar dealt with so many mature issues during their times at school and in the neighborhood, that it was almost startling when they began to behave like kids while hanging out – doing trick basketball plays, watching Celtics games from a fort as a good luck charm, making up their own words for commercials on videotaped games. In those scenes, it hits hard that these boys aren't even teenagers yet.

This is definitely not the book to pick up if you are looking for a light read. Green asks the difficult questions, questions that to this day don't have a good answer. Questions remain unanswered in the book, too, not wrapping everything up into a nice bow so that you can feel good at the end of the story. This book could open up a lot of dialogue among those who have read it.

Was this review helpful?

3-3.5 stars overall. Special thanks to Netgalley for allowing me to review this book in exchange for an honest review. Overall I think this was a good story addressing racial issues that arise in society. The main character, Green, is one of 2 Caucasian students in an all African American school. I'm conflicted with this review because I was left wanting more. Don't get me wrong it was a read that kept my attention, but I wanted more from the story and on his friend Marlon's life with more closure to their relationship.

Was this review helpful?

Green by Sam Graham-Felsen is about a white boy growing up in Boston in the 1990s in a school where he is the minority. The book is aimed at young adults but can be enjoyed by adult readers too, as the book tackles a multitude of issues, including race, racism, religion, sexuality, violence, mental illness, family, friendship, and class, just to name a few. As seen through the eyes of a twelve-year old boy, these issues are shown to have real consequences.

I enjoyed reading Green. It falls outside my reading comfort zone. I don't usually read young adult novels centered on puberty-induced hormonal boys. I found Graham-Felsen's writing to be authentic and really put me in David's shoes, a character growing up in a totally different time and with totally different concerns than I did.

I did have a few issues with the book, the major one being that I felt the plot meandered towards the end. It just kind of ended and I was left without a sense of closure. I don't expect books to wrap up neatly, but I didn't feel like we had closure on many of the story-lines introduced in the book. I did think it ended at the natural ending point. It just didn't leave me with that jittery just-finished-a-book feeling.

Recommended for readers who want to experience 1990s Boston and who are looking for something that doesn't shy away from hard issues.

Was this review helpful?

First and lasting thought. There's way too much ghetto slang for dis aged, kountry, kracker, shorty. So, imma bounce mah kicks outta tha scene cuz dis shorty jess ain't feelin' it.

That's not to say the book is without merit. It was aight.

What I liked
The characters were well developed. There is an equal mix of different races, gender, social status, and religions among this small group who are friends (acquaintances). I liked that the author wrote a story targeted for middle-school aged BOYS.

The story takes the reader through the lives of this group of 6th graders, the forming of new friendships, coming of age.

What I DON'T like – and it's a deal breaker for me -
The ghetto slang can be forgiven because the target reader is a middle-school aged boy.

BUT

There's too much emphasis on negativity. Too much violence committed AGAINST this little white boy BY the BLACK kids in the story. Too much constant fear expressed by the white boy. Too much RACISM BY the BLACK kids AGAINST the white kid(s).
Muggings, hi-jacking, robbery, fights, knives pulled, drug selling (although none of the 6th graders were the ones selling drugs).

** Racism goes both ways **.

If my son was still in this targeted age group – I would NOT allow him to read this book.

Why would I ever expose my child to that? Why would I ever let my child think “Oh, that's normal” or “It's OK, that's just the constant fear of black kids that white kids have to expect and live with”. ?Why?

The answer is – I wouldn't.

The things that happen in this book are NOT OK. It is hate and racism BY the black kids AGAINST the white kids. There's too much of that racial hatred in society – and it's NOT coming from white society.

Although the book was well written – I can NOT recommend the book because I would never let my own child read it. I'm sure it's “real” in any big city, maybe in your part of the world – but it's not in my small, very rural part of the world. I don't live in a big city, never seen a ghetto – so I would never introduce that type of life/hate/racism to my child.

I received this ebook free in exchange for my honest review.
I gave it 3 stars because I love the book cover art, along with the things I listed above that I liked about the book.

Was this review helpful?

OK coming of age story about a young man David who is bullied at school and had other things he is dealing with. Being a minority in his school also adds to his anxiety. Enter Marlon who stands up for Dave in school one day. They become friends and we read about things they encounter for this friendship as well as individualy. The book had good promise but fell short just a tad for me. Overall, an ok read. Thanks to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for the ARC fof this book in return for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Not at all the book I was expecting from Sam Graham-Felsen, journalist and former blog director of Barack Obama’s 2008 presidential campaign. But an enjoyable and insightful read nonetheless.

“A coming-of-age novel about race, privilege, and the struggle to rise in America … propelled by an exuberant, unforgettable narrator.”

Graham-Felsen’s debut is an original take on both teenage angst and race relations/inequality. Laugh out loud funny with cringeworthy moments. Honest, thought provoking and sad. Lots of feels :)

Was this review helpful?

Content Warnings: bullying, violence

In 1992, Dave Greenfield is one of the only white students at Boston’s Martin Luther King Middle School. He thinks he’s been given the worst hand in life possible- girls ignore him, guys pick on him, and his parents won’t let him transfer to a private school. His only option is to test into the best public school in the city, but that’s unlikely given his lack of interest in academics.

Dave finds an unexpected friend in Mar Wellings when he shocks everyone and stands up for him in the cafeteria. Mar is a loner from the public housing project in Dave’s gentrifying neighborhood. He’s awkward, gawky, and nerdy- all characteristics that challenge Dave’s stereotypical views about black culture. Before they know it, they’ve formed a strong bond and are letting each other into their private lives that they keep shielded from everyone else at school. As Dave gets closer to Mar, he realizes just how many breaks he’s gotten in life that Mar hasn’t because of the colors of their skin.

I was a bit hesitant going into this book. While the premise really grabbed me, I was nervous about it being a stereotypical book where no actual realizations were made about white privilege. I was pleasantly surprised when Green proved me wrong and wound up being a fresh take on the typical coming-of-age novel, packing a punch with humor, charm, and powerful revelations about race in America.

Graham-Felsen created a lovable, complex narrator in Dave as he stumbles through the confusion and uncertainty of adolescence. We watch him stumble between his world at home with his “hippie,” academic parents and his self-proclaimed “ghetto” school. His friendship with Mar is truly powerful and unique, and added a lot to the novel.

Green is a solid debut that tackles racism and adolescence in a charming way.

3.5 Stars

Was this review helpful?

I will be surrounded by dudes like this for the rest of my life. White boys and white girls who grew up behind whitewashed fences, who grew up with no idea, for the rest of my life. The force preordained it: Not only will I be surrounded by them, I will become one of them, the thing I hate and can’t escape. Not a white boy or a whitey or a white b*tch, but a white person.

If you’re looking for a way to start your new year out right, Green is absolutely the way to go. Prepare yourself to be transported by a distinctive voice and a story line that screams with authenticity. More than authentic—it was one that mirrored what middle school was like for me in the 90s: the same cliques, the same typecasts, the same social rules. This novel transported me back to those days, back to those vibrations in the air, to that slang on our tongues, to those priorities in our pre-teen minds and to those questions that plagued our thoughts night and day about the world around us and our place in it.

Picture it (in my Estelle Getty voice): Boston, 1992.

David Greenfeld is one of the only white sixth graders at Martin Luther King Middle School—the “ghetto” school—with no friends, no cool points, and no chance at getting a girl. His Harvard-educated, politically correct, granola parents don’t understand his pleas to be removed from the school, and there seems to be no end to the social torture in sight. Until. He meets Marlon Wellings, an ultra-smart, Boston Celtics-obsessed, black kid from the projects across the street whose street smarts start to rub off on Dave and who’s life in the hood and drive to get out of it spark questions in Dave’s mind he’s never contemplated before.

In Green, Sam Graham-Felsen gives us a fresh look at the merging of two cultures, literally painting it is a physical intersection of neighborhoods as well as of cultural mores and rules. I couldn’t help but remember another book I’ve reviewed recently that was also a coming-of-age story with a jumping off point from the ’92 L.A. riots—and all the while, I marveled at how much better this story was told, at how much more the voice and experiences rang true. Graham-Felsen brought these characters to life on the page. He gave them hopes and made them my hopes. He made them fall, and I felt the blow myself. And he made them fail, as we all do in life sometimes. It is in those moments that this novel’s heart is most evident and that its impact slammed into me the hardest.

Through Dave and Marlon, Graham-Felsen explores the color line through the eyes of adolescents still finding themselves amidst the chaos of race relations. What really set this novel apart for me is that he gave us the perspective of the white side of the fence, while still being true to both stories, to both cultures.

In school the next day, Ms. Ansley shows us another installment of this long, made-for-TV movie we’ve been watching called Roots. When she introduced it, she said we needed to know our history, especially after what happened in L.A…I hear people shifting in their chairs. The violence is one thing: We all know the wounds are just makeup, the whip’s just a prop, the loud crack’s only a sound effect. But the n-word is different. Even if it’s just acting, it’s still the real n-word. I’ve heard it ten thousand times…but always with the soft ending. Hearing it with the hard er …makes my face muscles clench up even thinking about it. All that evil, all that power, packed into two tiny syllables.

Then, we have ‘the force.’

As their school year progresses and confrontations are had, as Dave’s belief in religion is explored and his cross into cultures and upbringings other than his own changes his outlook on his surroundings, he begins to ponder the idea of ‘the force,’ his interpretation of race relations around him. He sees it everywhere. It peppers his every interaction with the world around him, and jolts him out of adolescence and into a more adult mindset:

It seemed like the smoke of those riots spread all across the continent, all the way to Boston, like they were looking for their own Reginald Denny, because as far as I could tell they stepped for no other reason than the fact that I was white. But as I ran away…I began to wonder if maybe I was looking at them the wrong way, the same way I must have stared at the TV screen when those dudes bundled Denny—a shook and boggled look that said, You are predators—and maybe that made them want to treat me like prey. All summer, I tried to deny the force, but I felt it every time I got checked on my way past the Shaw Homes...And I felt ashamed of that…and yeah, I’ve been feeling ashamed that the force has been with me, pretty much nonstop…

Green was an entertaining read and one that provoked thought. There were moments when I laughed out loud and, yes, even a moment when I cried. There’s something for everyone within these pages, because we all know at least one of these characters, from the granola do-gooders to that kid from the wrong side of the tracks. Here’s your chance now to get glimpse into their world. I wouldn’t be saying enough to say that I highly recommend this book for readers of all sizes, colors and creeds who are ready to open their minds and their outlooks. I even recommend it for all ages, because the cultural boundaries explored within Green are real and not to be ignored. The tragedies of everyday life surrounding us are real and not to be downplayed. And the line between the haves and the have nots, the clueless and the culturally aware, the predators and the prey is real and should never, ever be doubted. 4.5 stars. *****

Was this review helpful?

Published by Random House on January 2, 2018

David Greenfeld, blond and blue-eyed, is starting middle school in Boston, one of only two white kids in his class. His teacher wants her advanced class to move on to Boston Latin for seventh grade, but David sucks at standardized testing and isn’t holding out hope of escaping MLK. To their credit, David’s hippy parents believe in public schools and refuse to send him to a private school. As a consequence, David needs to find a way to deal with his lack of acceptance.

David tries to be cool, in the way that white kids emulate black kids because black kids have style and white kids are nerdish. He speaks the vernacular (you feel me?), but he doesn’t have the right gear (his sneakers are old because his parents won’t buy shoes that are made in sweatshops), he isn’t athletic, and he doesn’t rock the kind of attitude that earns the respect of his peers. His white friend Kev is a baller and fits in easily, but Kev isn’t much of a friend. Eventually David is befriended by a nerdish black kid named Mar, nerdish in ways that are similar to David’s, although their different religious backgrounds are another reason for David to feel that he doesn’t fit in.

One of the novel’s themes involves the various aspects of racism. David and Kev and Mar are all studying to take a test that might get them admitted to Latin School, which might get them admitted to Harvard. But a city council member clues them into the reality that most of them won’t get into Harvard, and even if they do, society’s white power structure will impose obstacles to advancement that white students won’t need to overcome. Mar and David are both subjected to neighborhood bullying and both are subjected to racial slurs. This is a fair and nuanced view of society in which racism goes both ways, and race is often secondary to common interests, like a fan’s love of a particular team. And while the themes of race and class are serious, the broader theme is that kids are kids. Their confusion and anxiety as they try to get a handle on life transcends race and lends itself to easy laughter.

Green would be a coming-of-age novel except that David is too young to come of age. Still, he endures the pain of growing up and earns the kind of wisdom and maturity that characterize coming-of-age novels. The plot isn’t particularly eventful but the story has an authentic feel and it’s easy to relate to David’s unrelenting angst.

RECOMMENDED

Was this review helpful?

I thought the cover art was fantastic and the "novel of race and privilege" premise was interesting, so I gave Green a chance. It is absolutely a lesson in empathy and Mar's story was a bit thought-provoking. From the beginning, though, I couldn't get over the dialect of the main character, David. The excessive use of "shook" and other terms just wasn't believable from this character, written in this way, and it annoyed me. I continually wished the book wasn't written in his voice but instead was narrated with quotes from him inserted, if it would even be believable or less annoying that way. I also kept waiting for the big twist and the point. It never came, but reading the adventures of Dave and Mar was at least amusing.

*This review is based on a free digital advance copy provided by the publisher. The opinions expressed are my own.

Was this review helpful?

GREEN by Sam Graham-Felsen has been described as an "original voice" and that it is. Unfortunately, it may be so original that I am not sure if students will relate or not. To them it will likely seem written for younger students since the protagonist, Dave Greenfeld, is in sixth grade. He is certainly immature and uses strange slang and ethnic expressions, even for someone living in 1992 Boston. Both his immaturity and language were obstacles to building any empathy for a character who seems overly clueless (although White, trying to fit in at his almost all Black school by spending money his parents don’t have on a “stylish” outfit only ostracizes him further). The book improves when another loner, Marlon Wellings from the nearby projects, eventually befriends Green/Dave and they bond over basketball and their attempts to get into a better school. On balance and despite its exploration of inter-racial friendship, it felt as though GREEN reinforced stereotypes instead of battling and exposing them. Maybe that "original voice" and the associated humor ("it's not easy being green") are an acquired taste with wider appeal than I suspect? This title was chosen as an Indie Next Selection and received starred reviews from Booklist and Publishers Weekly.

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful book. The author has put tremendous thought behind showing us the way the world works. I genuinely believe that people never grow up. They just become older. They learn to hide better, and to show only what they want to. Here the author shows us how early people begin to get shaped. How their thoughts and ideas and thier weaknesses make them who they are.

Was this review helpful?

This book is challenging to review. The perspective was one I didn't really identify with....a 12-year-old white boy from Boston who is navigating life in a middle school where he is one of the only white kids. The slang, the obsession with Celtics basketball, none of it was something I really enjoyed reading about. And yet....the author had something to say about race relations, and maybe it was best he said it from a perspective with which he identifies. I guess it was reasonably well done -- just wasn't a book that I was destined to enjoy.

I was given an advance copy by NetGalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?