The plot of The Trial of Prisoner 043 by Terry Jastrow grabbed me from the start. Former President George Bush was on a golf outing at St. Andrews when commandoes kidnapped him off the 17th green. He was smuggled to The Haig where, in reality, the International Criminal Court (ICC) is located, a court that has the jurisdiction to prosecute individuals for the international crimes of genocide, crimes against humanity, and war crimes. The U.S. is one of few western countries that do not participate in the court, but most of its allies do. The court agreed that they had jurisdiction and agreed to hear the prosecution’s case. Of course, the U.S. and Bush’s lawyers challenged the jurisdiction of the court to try this past President of the U.S. When those legal maneuvers failed, a commando assault on the ICC Detention Centre where Bush was being held was beaten back. Then the case of The Prosecutor v. George W. Bush proceeded. There was no jury and the case was heard in front of a panel of three judges.

Essentially, this book replayed all the evidence for and against the Iraq War. The author was able to use real quotes from all of the principals who were involved in the war effort, as well as those who opposed it. He even included Hans Blix, head of the UN Iraq weapons inspection team, who conducted 731 inspections between 11/02 and 3/03 when the war began. No doubt, this book was very well researched. I’ve actually heard this scenario debated and wished for by my leftist friends while the righties I know seem to automatically dismiss the idea, much like Bush’s attorneys tried to do.
Jastrow created believable figures in the respective teams of attorneys and the panel of judges. Jastrow wrote that his characters understood that the very legitimacy of the court was going to be on trial, along with the attorneys and Bush. As a political junkie, I thought his portrayal of Bush was spot on. The prosecution hammered away at Bush’s allegedly nonsensical pivot from seeking to find and kill bin Laden for 9/11 to pursuing the war in Iraq. Lead prosecuting attorney Michael McBride said, “This is the story of how George Bush is personally responsible for creating the pretext for, and then waging, the Iraq War – and the devastating results of his war.” Certainly, the author does a pretty good job of presenting Bush’s side of the argument.


You get the idea, and I won’t reveal the conclusion. Jastrow has done a remarkable job, and if the topic interests you, this is a must read.

Terry Jastrow's The Trial of Prisoner 043 postulates a very unlikely scenario - that former US president George W. Bush, golfing in St. Andrews, Scotland, would be abducted by paramilitary commandos and taken to the International Criminal Court in The Hague, to be tried for war crimes in Iraq.

That being said, the trial itself is engrossing, not so much as a piece of fiction, but as an analysis of the background to the US decision in 2003 to wage war against Saddam Hussein. The issue of weapons of mass destruction - and the failure to find any - are addressed, as are the unintended consequences.

The conclusion seemed to me something of a cop-out but I enjoyed the discussion that preceded it.

An interesting premise. George W Bush is attending a golf tournament in Scotland, when he is abducted by, and held for a war crimes trial, by the ICC. If one is willing to suspend disbelief that this could actually happen, and that the United States would stand blindly by and allow the trial to continue, the story could be interesting. However, it is wholly unrealistic.
Bush, rather than having the best legal team the US Government could put together, instead decides to let some old friends represent him. And the ICC legal team is made up of obviously prejudiced people. The lead prosecuting attorney quite unstable.
But, I continued on....amongst the chaff, there were many interesting points raised, in Bush's defense, as well as against him. I was looking forward to how the trial would end up.
That was until the end.......it completely and utterly ruins the book. I won't spoil it for anyone who decides to read it, but you might as well as had space aliens and unicorns at the end.
WHOLLY DISSATISFYING AND A WASTE OF TIME!