Member Reviews

Enjoyable read. Complicated and very broad topic but well researched and interesting/engaging overall.

Was this review helpful?

I was not able to finish this book. For me, it did not pull me in. I am certain that others will find it interesting.

Was this review helpful?

My apologies - because this book was not available as a mobi file, I did not have the chance to read it before it was archived.. Thank you for the opportunity - I'm sorry I missed it, because I enjoy the author's work, and I'll look for it on Amazon.

Was this review helpful?

At the moment I will only give a rating to the book and I hope it is possible for me to write down my reviews on Amazon. Barnes and Noble and Goodreads. I am very grateful to you because your publications are great, especially in the topics that interest me most. Thanks and blessings.

Was this review helpful?

A nonfiction book intended for a general audience about human DNA and what it tells us about our history and current existence. It's extremely up to date – I believe Rutherford even manages to cite studies from 2017 a few times – but also goes all the way back to the beginning, covering Darwin and Mendel and similar pioneers. It's nice that Rutherford doesn't spare his own field any criticism; he goes fairly thoroughly into the story of Francis Galton (the inventor of eugenics) and the problems with other scientists who have tried to use DNA to bolster their racist beliefs. He also does not have a lot of patience for 23andMe or similar 'analyze your heritage through DNA!' companies, arguing that they're too imprecise to give real answers.

The book is split in roughly half, with the first part covering human history (the evolution of Homo sapiens; how we mixed with closely related species like the Neanderthals and Denisovans; the movement of groups of people across the world, particularly Europe and Britain; and the evolution of traits like red hair and milk drinking), and the second half covering DNA in the modern world (does race exist genetically?; do genes predispose some people to becoming violent criminals?; how easy – or hard – is it to identify genetic diseases?; and the story of the Human Genome Project).

I found the writing to be dense and hard to get through, though I couldn't say exactly why; Rutherford certainly drops in plenty of jokes and references to the Simpsons or Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. He's at his best when he's telling a specific story rather than a general point of scientific principle. His descriptions of the attempt to use historical DNA to uncover mysteries like the identities of Richard III (successful!) or Jack the Ripper (hugely failed!) were very well-done, as was the chapter on why race doesn't work as a genetic concept. I think a lot of people are familiar with that general point, but he really digs into why with specific examples and many details and it was a fascinating read. But reading the rest, I often found my attention drifting, and had to yank it back to the page again and again. Unfortunately this problem seems to be worst in the opening chapter, making it hard to get into the book.

Overall, there's plenty of worthwhile information here, but the writing itself didn't work for me.

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show/2199037355#

Was this review helpful?

see online review

Was this review helpful?

Unfortunately I hadn't realized that this title was not available for Kindle when I requested it. I had some problems loading it and ultimately gave up....will have to read the print edition when available from my library!

Was this review helpful?

I am afraid that I will have to try the paperback. I found this too scientific to read as an ebook. If I read the print, it might help. The author mentions Anne of Green Gables, so I will definitely try to read it again!

I received the free ebook from Net Galley in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I was really drawn in by this book. I loved the ideas of the stories in our genes. Now I am wondering if I do want to find out my DNA.

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful well written accounting of science that will expand your beliefs and inform. I found this book captivating and well researched. The subject of DNA , history of our genes and new information not taught in schools will inspire the reader to learn further information as they read. This is a must read for all interested in science and our human history.

Was this review helpful?

A Brief History of Everyone Who Ever Lived : The Stories in Our Genes by Adam Rutherford was an interesting if somewhat long and rambling read. ( The book could have been edited better.). It examines genetics, DNA, and a history of Homo sapiens through the lens of popular science and anecdotal writing. Rutherford is a broadcaster and science writer and studied genetics at University College, London. In this book, he examines recent discoveries about our genomes and clarifies what they have enabled scientists to tell us from those discoveries, and what they have not. I learned a lot from this book and will be more discerning when seeing fallacious headlines in the news about what science has and has not discovered from mapping the human genome. If you have ever been interested in getting your DNA tested, this book will help you discern somewhat what is hype and what is not ( although you need to do your own research about the strengths and weaknesses of the various companies out there) . Thank you Orion and NetGalley for the Advanced Reading Copy of this book and for allowing me to review it.

Was this review helpful?

Really enjoyable! I would recommend this for any science book club, but also for anyone who is looking for read alikes to Mukherjee's The Gene or The Emperor of All Maladies. I might even recommend this for someone who enjoyed Neil deGrasse Tyson's Astrophysics for People in a Hurry.

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed this book. The writer paints a picture that I feel was excellent and look forward to telling my friends and family about this book

Was this review helpful?

What I read of this book was absolutely enticing. Written in a way that makes one desire to soak up the knowledge. Unfortunately, I found it a little daunting to read so much from my computer, since I was unable to download this on to my tablet for some reason. Because of this, I will definitely be purchasing the book itself, and will update my reviews on other sites when I am completely finished.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Netgalley for providing me a review copy of this book.
I love books that can present and explain scientific ideas clearly, especially when the idea in question is Human Evolution. It's a topic we usually run out of time for at the end of the year in biology, but its a fascinating topic.
There are so many misconceptions that about regarding what genetics can and can't tell us, and A Brief History does an excellent job addressing those misconceptions. This is a book I will get for my classroom (HS Biology), and refer to it when we start genetics each year.

Was this review helpful?

I received an advanced ready copy of this title from NetGalley: Lots of really interesting information about genetics, but I had to give this title a 3 because it was ultimately way too much of a good thing. The author tends to get lost in the details and to go off on tangents that stray far of the path of the topic of this book. This makes it a difficult sale to a mainstream reading audience who may not be interested in the minutiae of the topic. With some strong editing to keep the writing focused and more succinct, I feel the book would be a much more enjoyable read for the everyday reader.

Was this review helpful?

I was unable to read the title due to it not being accessible on my device.

Was this review helpful?

"This is a story about you". It's hard to think of a first sentence more likely to engage a reader and beguile them into a 400-page dissertation on DNA and evolution. It gets right to the point and demands attention.

Soon after, Adam Rutherford sums up human evolution as "one big million-year clusterf*ck", and you know that this is not going to be just any science book. And so it proves. <i>A Brief History of Everyone Who Ever Lived</i> is erudite and entertaining, informative and occasionally cerebral.

The book starts with the rise of hominids and the migrations of homo sapiens out of Africa, showing how DNA recovered from fossil finds enabled these migratory pathways to be better understood. For example, DNA has shown that India was settled from both the south and the north, but that both North and South America were settled from the north. Our DNA also shows that homo sapiens and neanderthals interbred.

Rutherford tackles the paradox of "family tree" thinking, which ultimately leads to a point where the number of putative ancestors exceeds the number of people on earth at the time. Oddly, this means that, around the time of Richard II, everybody in Europe was an ancestor of everybody with European descent today. We are apparently all descended from royalty and we all have Viking ancestry.

I found his account of the Hapsburg's inbreeding and the DNA identification of Richard III's remains really interesting, but Rutherford's most potent writing is on race, and he is abundantly clear that there is no genetic basis for the concept of "race". The genetic triggers for skin pigmentation are the same in African and Indian people, yet we perceive these people as being of different "races". The same goes for other characteristics that are used to label a person as being of a certain race. There is no gene for race, and only a tiny number of our 22,000 genes account for the physical differences that we typically use to distinguish between races. We are overwhelmingly more similar than different, wherever we are from.

While I did struggle with some of the concepts in this book, Rutherford's clear explanations and waspish humour kept me engaged throughout what was a fascinating read.

Was this review helpful?

A brilliant introduction to how the developments in genetics in the last two decades have helped to unravel the mystery of our origins. This engaging, riveting book not only introduces us to how our ancestors spread throughout the planet but also reveals surprising truths about our own history, and debunks various myths about race.

Was this review helpful?

This author is absolutely brilliant, he conveys information about this complicated topic in clear language with use of fantastic metaphors and in a manner that I a person with little scientific background can understand. Science and sometimes be funny and it is conveyed here as well. There is so much going on and the author acknowledges at the pace at which science is being challenged, changed and made with every new discovery and technological stride that there will be things that may not even necessarily be true at the time of the publication of the book, but it makes for such a fascinating read.

Was this review helpful?