Member Reviews

I heard good things about this book and decided to request it on NetGalley. Unfortunately I abandoned it after 16 per cent read. I firmly believe that there are readers for all books, and I was just not the reader for this particular book. The novel begins with an elder man in NYC who has decided he's gotten to the age (75) that he wants to determine when he dies, he's seen too many friends, patients, family die in all manner and he'd rather choose the time and place. In addition, there were many references to how things used to be in NYC, and semi-famous people long since dead. Not getting all these references got in the way of my enjoyment.

Many thanks to the publisher and NetGalley for providing me with a copy.

Was this review helpful?

Millard Salter - a Consulting Psychiatrist who “provides mental health services for the physically ill in hospitals” has decided to commit suicide on his 75th birthday. In his own terms, his is a “rational suicide”, a “curated death”. He simply doesn’t want to end his days in the same painful, feeble, isolated way of so many others. This book is the story of this last day.

The story is told completely from his perspective - we see events, characters, and the past, solely through his eyes. Poignant memories, surprising interactions, and a panoply of characters fill the pages. Reading the memories of the old Jewish neighborhood in the Bronx felt like a love letter to me. We are deftly moved from childhood memories to current events to recent memories, from minor irritations at work (a baby lynx has gone missing at the hospital) to major irritations at the graveyard (his burial plot has been usurped!). This is no painful Proustian obsession - quite a bit actually happens on this day - I was surprised to reach the end and realize that only a day had passed.

The writing is excellent - clear and incisive and full of brilliant lines. Millard says of his recently deceased wife Isabelle: “she possessed a knack for distilling people”. I would say the same is true of the author. Character after character, line after line, just nailed it. Thinking about his son, Lysander, Millard finds himself “pondering whether a man who hadn’t yet amounted to a bucket of warm glue might not generate an artistic or literary masterwork at the age of 43…”. I really had to read that line a few times. Great use of fun words too (I’m always pleased when someone can use tatterdemalion persuasively in a sentence.

One note - the descriptive blurbs on Amazon are completely misleading. This book has nothing in common with “A Man Called Ove” aside from the two main characters sharing initial thoughts of suicide. Ove is a curmudgeon (a bad-tempered or surly person according to dictionary.com), but Millard is not. He is neither bad-tempered nor surly - he does have many opinions that don’t always adhere to the accepted norms of the society but I find it interesting that non conformity automatically stamps with him with curmudgeonhood! Millard has many opinions that are clearly his own - well thought out and adhering to no particular ideology. I found it insightful and refreshing.

I really loved this book - Millard’s voice is one I will remember for a long time.

Was this review helpful?

I found this book tedious to read, skimmed some and really didn't care how it ended. I did enjoy the part with the cabdriver Konnie and some of his interactions with the medical staff.

Was this review helpful?

I found most of this book difficult to follow, I had to keep going backwards and repeating reading a part because I was lost in conversation or the storyline - was it current or the past.
There were some parts that I truly enjoyed and I clung to every word.
The last visit to the public library, last dental checkup, and deciding the best method made me ponder and reflect. I enjoyed Konnie the cab driver.

Go through an emotional and thought provoking day alongside Millard.

Was this review helpful?

Maybe it was the mood I was in, but I felt the book dragged and found myself skimming parts.

Millard is a successful psychiatrist who has decided to end his life on his birthday. Everything is planned out to the minute, but things like work and family keep getting in the way. I found I didn't care if he did or didn't carry it out and though I finished it, I didn't care about that, either. Ok, on to the next book, no need to reflect on this one.

I do thank NetGalley for the chance to read it in exchange for an honest opinion and wish I had something nice to say about the book. It wasn't a waste of time, but it was not a worthwhile use of my time to read it.

Was this review helpful?