Member Reviews

I have always loved the story of Anne of Green Gables and I have loved most of the adaptations I have seen of the story and this graphic novel is no different. I loved that the story followed fairly closely to the original and the colors from the art was beautiful. The only thing that I didn't care for was the art itself, it just wasn't for me.
Overall, I would probably purchase this for my kids to read when they are older.

Was this review helpful?

I wanted to love this reimagined Anne! I have an almost 12 year old daughter who hasn't met Anne yet, and I so hoped this would be a great way to introduce my reluctant reader to a favorite from my youth.

And when I first saw the illustrations, I was pleased. So quaint! So much color!

But once I saw the faces and read the dialog, so much whimsy seemed lost. In fact, it seemed so abridged, there were times I felt part of the story was completely missing. It just didn't seem to do justice to my beloved Anne. Maybe it's better for someone who is a new Anne reader and hasn't experienced the perfectness of LMM's original Anne. I just don't think I need her to be reimagined.

Was this review helpful?

The adaptation for this story is so good!!!
I really enjoyed reading this book! The illustrations are so good!
I haven't read the original story but I got a good idea what it was about, is perfect forbids and for everyone who likes visual content in a story.

Was this review helpful?

The classic story of Anne of Green Gables is brought to life in this stylistic and heartfelt graphic novel. The story is as charming as ever, and the graphic illustrations bring a soft warmth to the familiar characters. This is a good introduction to the series for reluctant readers; they will be intrigued enough to go back and read the source.

Was this review helpful?

I had the opportunity to read this on NetGalley, but that didn't influence my opinion in any way.

I've been a fan of Anne since I was a child. I loved the made for tv miniseries with Meagan Follows. I read all the books, all the way up through Rilla.

Now, this is not a 'word for word' rendition of the book. This is a graphic novel imbued with the spirit of Anne even if it doesn't have every experience and every word. There are a couple small changes to the included experiences, but, nothing too earth-shattering. The illustrations should be appealing to younger readers who might find the Anne novels to old-fashioned to even attempt. I welcome anything that might make young readers give Anne a chance. I would probably even read a sequel if Marsden decides to make one.. lol

It's cute enough where someone who didn't know what it was about would even be tempted to read it.

Was this review helpful?

I hadn't re-read this for a few years, so to connect with this story again via this graphic novel was a treat. It is a great story that never grows old and the illustrations just add another dimension to the story as a whole..

Was this review helpful?

I am a huge fan of the original series. The kind of loyalty I feel to the series made me dislike the Netflix versions trailer on the spot. I hesitated before downloading this version from NetGalley but I decided to give it a shot due to the good reviews on Goodreads. 

This book is the comic strip version of the first book where anne arrives at green gables. I liked bits of it but felt some more panels could have focused on other parts of the story, providing more detail than it did. I can imagine it would be extremely hard to condense such a well-loved piece of literature into a shorter version and the author and illustrators have done a good job in that sense. The only reason I do not rate it higher than I did is because of the length of time I have lived in that world and have a very fixed idea in my mind about the images , some of which could not be shaken. But for someone with an open mind, you should definitely try this book out!( Some of the illustrations are very good). Anne is an orphan mistakenly brought to the home of the Cuthbert siblings. Both Matthew and Marilla are good people with different approaches to life. This whirlwind of words who has landed on their doorstep lights up, adds colour and a whole lot of zing to the life of town and their inhabitants.

Was this review helpful?

This beautiful adaptation not only does justice to the original, but does so in a way that feels unique. The illustrations are wonderful, and I didn't feel like the story was lost, eve though it was short. In fact, I would have loved for this book to be longer!

Was this review helpful?

This graphic novel edition is nice. It sticks relatively well to the source. It captures Anne pretty well. Much of the art is simple, especially faces. What I really loved were the landscape pieces showing forests and flowering trees. Some stunning work there, I actually thought it was wasted space at first, but I actually found that it slowed down the rapid fire story from moving forward too quickly.

Was this review helpful?

This graphic novel retelling of the classic children's book is one of the best I have come across. It is honest to the original and the lovely artwork makes up for a delightful reread. Loved it. Recommend reading it. Thank you Netgalley for the opportunity, as always.

Was this review helpful?

This was a sweet and simple graphic novelization of Anne of Green Gables. It holds true to the original, but it is too abridged for me to truly love it. Instead, it just makes me want to reread the L.M. Montgomery's wonderful original.

Was this review helpful?

A lovely adaptation of a favorite literary classic, perfect for reluctant readers and those who might find dense amounts of text hard to get through or intimidating. Lovely art and of course lovely content, true to the original.

Was this review helpful?

Mariah Marsden has taken the beloved Anne of Green Gables story, turning it into a charming graphic novel adaptation that captures the spirit of Anne Shirley. L.M. Montgomery’s Anne of Green Gables along with the books that follow hold a special place in my heart, so I was thrilled to see such a beautifully done graphic novel come along.

I see a whole new generation coming to love this orphan girl who changes the world around her for the better. The presentation of the story is well done though it is difficult to convey all of the emotions of the characters within the novel in a graphic format. However, the illustrations give vivid life to the personalities of the characters as well as the place and time of the story. Everything about the book is on the mark. Kudos to Mariah Marsden and Brenna Thummler for taking on such a massive task..

Was this review helpful?

Anne of Green Gables: A Graphic Novel by Mariah Marsden and illustrated by Brenna Thummler. As a lifelong fan of all things Anne of Green Gables I could not wait to experience this graphic novel. It lovingly reproduces all the charm of the original story with the added benefit of these beautiful, lush and breathtaking illustrations. All of your favorites are here, Anne, Marilla, Mathew, Diana, Gilbert and of course the town gossip, Mrs. Lynde. this book is a true gift for fans and a charming treasure for new readers to discover. It is a brilliant blend of beloved classic and modern form. Do yourself a favor and get this stunning, amusing and heartwarming read. I am posting an honest review after reading an ARC copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

This book is amazing! Now I understand what all the fuss is about. I kept hearing about "Anne of Green Gables" and that it is an amazing classic book, but because I was in a reading slump, I wasn't that interested. Until I saw this graphic novel on NetGalley..and because I discovered recently that if I start reading graphic novels or short stories, the reading slump is going far away from me.
So this is how I started reading "Anne of Green Gables", the graphic novel.

At the beginning of the story we meet Marilla and Matthew Cuthbert, an old couple of sister and brother. They were living in Avonlea, in a place caled "Green Gables". They also had an old lady neighbor called Rachel Lynde who was spying on them every time.
One day, Matthew went to bring an orphan boy home, because they needed help. But instead, a ginger-haired girl with freckles and green eyes awaited him. He had no choice but taking her instead. All the way home she kept talking about this and that, and Matthew listened to her.
The first reaction Marilla had was to be dissapointed that a girl came an not a boy as they planed.
She decided to keep her that night but to bring her back the next day. But when she saw how special and different the girl was, she choose to keep her. A lot of things are happening. Anne is making a best friend, she makes a lot of mistakes (but learns from them), she saves a life and she is very strong.

When I finished the last line of the book I smiled. Although it was a short 230 pages story, I only think that it was a beautiful journey. Now I really want to read the classic version of this book, because I really loved Anne. I found some things about her that I resonate with. And it was a line that made me understand why we usually name objects or plants:
Marilla: "Where's the sense in naming a gerandium?"
Anne: "Well, you wouldn't want to be called 'woman' all the time, would you?"
I mean, seriously! The girl is amazing! Plus, I kept hearing about the line "I'm so glad I live in a world where there are Octobers!" Now I understand: Anne said that. I am so in love with this book right now and I keep thinking about it. It will be stuck in my mind for a very long time and I really missed this kind of bondage. That's why I'm going to buy the classic "a.s.a.p.". Full 5 stars! I truly recommend this.

Was this review helpful?

It's been many years since I read Anne of Green Gables. As a Canadian girl, this was part of our "required reading."

This is a great graphic novel adaptation. Marsden stays faithful to the original story. It is also very brief because a lot is said through the illustrations rather than words.

I loved Anne (with an 'e')! She's funny, sarcastic, and dramatic. She kept me laughing through the whole book.

I liked the bright illustrations in the story. They would be very appealing to young children. Anne reminded me a lot of the girl who plays her on the most recent TV series, so she looks like the contemporary image of Anne.

This graphic novel would be great for fans of the original novel and new readers! I highly recommend it.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

A beautiful rendition of a classic story.

Was this review helpful?

I received an electronic ARC of this novel from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

The book Anne of Green Gables is probably more dear to my heart than any other book ever. And this graphic novel has definitely done the story justice! It is just as sweet and wonderful as the original text.

The parts the writer chose to adapt for the graphic novel were perfect - they shortened the story but didn't leave out anything important or make it lose the tone or importance the book has. And the art style of this matches well too! It's so colorful - full of reds and greens - and whimsical and happy. It definitely evoked the right emotions in me!

I read the whole thing in one sitting, and was smiling the whole time. It was just so wonderful!

Was this review helpful?