Member Reviews

Illegal is the tale of two brothers who are trying to escape their home and reunite with their sister who is now in England. The boys gone on a dangerous journey over desert and seas. This is a great graphic novel for middle grades and up. Fans of Alan Gratz's Refugee will enjoy this book as well.

Was this review helpful?

Illegal by Eoin Colfer and Andrew Donkin brings the refugee story front and center and paints a clear picture of the human experience. As the setting bounces back and forth in time for the story of two brothers trying to make their way to their older sister in Europe, the story will cause your own hopefulness and despair to bounce back and forth as well. Make the time to experience this powerful graphic novel. It will set the stage for a discussion with older middle-grade readers and beyond.

Was this review helpful?

Offers a powerful perspective to the immigration narrative.
Beautifully illustrated.
I'm eager to share this story with students.

Was this review helpful?

This graphic novel tells the timely story -- illegal immigration. Eoin Colfer brings the characters to life and makes me think and care more about my global world connections. Perfect choice for middle school and high school curriculum regarding current events in immigration.

Was this review helpful?

Wonderful and important story to share in this climate. I really appreciated the additional content at the end of the book.

Was this review helpful?

I think the more stories of immigrant and migrant children we can collect, the better. I haven’t seen one in graphic novel form before. This would be perfect for reluctant readers!

Was this review helpful?

Unsurprisingly, this is a solid, deeply personal graphic novel that I think will connect to many readers.

Was this review helpful?

Colfer's Illegal portrays the dangers faced and bravery shown by immigrants leaving Northern Africa for Europe in a highly engaging graphic novel format. Students will take the journey vicariously with the brothers and root for them the whole way.

Was this review helpful?

I was very interested in reading this book when I heard about it. I didn't know it would make me cry. This gives a moving and realistic portrait of the struggle of modern immigrants. It reminds the reader how much many people are willing to risk and sacrifice for a chance at a better life.

Was this review helpful?

Topical and well-illustrated, this is an interesting new work from Eoin Colfer. This will definitely appeal to teens wanting to know more about the topic.

Was this review helpful?

Illegal is a deeply moving graphic novel that tracks Ebo as he attempts to migrate from his village in Ghana to a new life in Europe. Each stage of his journey; from the trip across to the Sahara desert to the harrowing sea journey are wonderfully illustrated. Although Ebo’s story is fictional it’s followed by the real-life story of a young woman named Helen.
Illegal is aimed at MG and YA but I think adults would love it too.

Was this review helpful?

Powerful, poignant, and bittersweet.
A stark reminder that for many immigrants the journey to their new home is an agonizing undertaking -- they are often fleeing from their home country due to war, persecution, poverty, etc.

Thanks to NetGalley for an eARC copy of this graphic novel.

Was this review helpful?

I think this is one of the best graphic novels I’ve ever read. Be prepared. It is a rollercoaster of emotions. I’ve never once geared up from a graphic novel but this one had tears streaming down my face.

I was engaged the entire time, pulled in and spurred to emotions by the narration and illustrations. This has some of the best storytelling I have seen in this format. Usually I have a sense of disconnect when I read graphic novels because of the information the authors leave out that would normally be in a book. I didn’t feel that with this one.

I’d also like to note that it is a different immigrant story than the one I have grown used to. This one features a young boy trying to make it from Ghana to Europe. This allowed a fresh look into these characters life’s and gave me a different, new perspective when it comes to the immigration situation.

I feel like this book is important. These things are really happening and they shouldn’t. There should be more humane ways to handle these kinds of situations, of helping people get to where they need to be.

Was this review helpful?

Illegal is relevant and honest. It tells the story, based on real refugee accounts, of a boy in Africa trying to get to Europe. The adversity he faces is unbelievable, packed in a small raft leaking water while unable to swim, traveling through the desert on foot with no water, yet is what refugees throughout the world are facing. Refugee stories are hard to accept and understand, especially for young adults.

This graphic novel will appeal to students interested in the topic and also to reluctant readers. It will be an aid for educators teaching about refugees and immigration because of it's visual nature and relatable characters. The amazing visuals and perfect amount of text make this a perfect selection for even 5th and 6th grade reluctant readers. Even though it is fiction, it is rooted in nonfiction, which will appeal to teachers and parents who are still not open to graphic novels as good literature. The subject matter is deep and somewhat mature in nature so it should be noted as a YA book, rather than an elementary selection.

Was this review helpful?

This is fictional story made from pieces of what refugees truly experience as they make their way from Africa to Europe. People who attempt the journey make their way across Africa, through the Sahara until they reach Tripoli. They save their money and pay for a ride across the desert. Once they reach the port city, they must find passage on a boat or ship to cross over to Europe. If they make it across the Mediterranean, they are taken to refugee centers and must find a way to make a living and meet up with family members who have made the journey before them.

For this account, readers follow a boy named Ebo as he tries to find his brother Kwame and join him in the journey to Europe to reunite with their sister Sisi. They encounter many difficulties including illness, dishonest human traffickers, flash floods, and leaky boats - to name a few. Throughout their ordeal, Ebo never gives up hope, just like many of the real refugees. The back matter includes an account (put into comic book form) of a refugee named Helen.

This is a useful book for classes studying immigration, refugee situations, current events, or humanitarian organizations. The format makes the story very accessible and helps students visualize the conditions refugees endure to reach their goal.

Was this review helpful?

Ebo’s brother Kwame is missing. But Ebo knows where he’s gone: he’s gone to find their sister. Life in Libya is hard, so Ebo and Kwame’s sister, Hannah, left and promised to send back money once she was installed in Europe with a new job and more money. But since she left, Ebo and Kwame have heard nothing from her. So when Ebo wakes up one morning and Kwame is gone, Ebo knows he must go after him. What follows is the harrowing, heartbreaking story of Ebo’s journey through dangerous cities, deserts, and the ocean.

Wow. Look, I cry a lot, and am no stranger to crying whilst reading. But this book made me sob. Like, uncontrollable tears running down my face. The refugee story is often a sad and intense one, and Ebo’s is certainly no exception. And then, when you think about Ebo’s story in the context of it being a real thing happening to real people in this world that we all share, and the US is actively turning away people in similar if not the same situation, well, its depressing. But importantly so. One must also consider the fact that thousands of children, thousands of people are dying, and no one seems to care. It’s a deeply sad book that will cause lots of introspection, but for me, that’s a good thing. This is an issue that needs more attention.

The stunning artwork added to the impact. Seeing Ebo’s expressions - the heartbreak, loss, and hope playing out across his face – made what was already an intense, powerful story all the more affecting. I loved pretty everything about this book, and I hope you take the time to read it. 5 stars.

Thanks to Baker & Taylor, Netgalley and Sourcebooks for the free paper and electronic advance copies, which I received in exchange for an honest review. Illegal is available for purchase now!

Was this review helpful?

The only thing that keeps this from being five stars is that the back and forth storytelling was off putting. I understand it was there to build up the tension, but since we know, from the first page, who makes it onto the boat, I was not worried about people or I knew who was not going to live to see the boat. If the story were told in a straight line, I do not think I can find a flaw. The last line in the author's note that "everyone of them is a person" was perfectly placed and exemplified the point.
4.5 stars. Thanks to Net Galley for the ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This haunting story is both timely and unfortunately timeless in that the refugee crisis has been going on like this for so long. It gives so much context to what we often see as a single news story of a single moment in a much larger and longer journey. The art matches the story perfectly, the luminous eyes and frenetic lines convey so much.

Was this review helpful?

ILLEGAL by Eoin Colfer and Andrew Donkin with illustrations by Giovanni Rigano is an extremely informative and moving graphic novel. I am definitely recommending it to our Geography teachers, although it should have wide appeal to anyone interested in this crisis. This is a very quick but impactful read which will build empathy and prompt discussion. Following up with a role-playing and/or simulation involving refugees like the one from World Relief Seattle or using lesson plans from Teaching Tolerance would be very memorable. The Refugee Project has a series of amazing interactive maps built on data from the UNHCR which could also be used. And, PBS POV in conjunction with its lesson plan for the documentary 4.1 Miles, suggests checking out The Refugee Center for volunteer opportunities. Our high school students have worked successfully with Chicago’s RefugeeOne. The list could go on and I hope that ILLEGAL's publisher, Sourcebooks Landmark, will add more to the UK based groups that appear in the text. Colfer, Donkin and Rigano's graphic novel received starred reviews from Booklist, Kirkus, Publishers Weekly and VOYA. Perhaps the authors and illustrator will collaborate further on telling the story of life in the camps or as a resettled immigrant?

Links in review:
https://worldreliefseattle.org/refugee-simulation-project AND
https://www.tolerance.org/learning-plan/immigration-and-the-american-dream-refugees-undocumented-immigrants-american AND
http://www.therefugeeproject.org/#/2017 AND
https://therefugeecenter.org/in-your-city/?address%5B0%5D=60093&per_page=8&lat=42.105579&lng=-87.746807&form=1&post%5B0%5D=local-resources&tax%5Bresource-category%5D%5B0%5D&distance=40&units=imperial AND
http://www.pbs.org/pov/4point1miles/lesson-plan/ AND
http://www.refugeeone.org/

Was this review helpful?

With the current popularity of graphic novels, Illegal offers a unique look t the plight that many have taken to freedom. I loved the alternating tense as a way to learn how Kwame and Ebo came to be on the inflatable boat heading to Italy. The graphic novel format adds to the storytelling with the vivid pictures - I just loved that it was so descriptively drawn that you could empathize with the emotions that the characters felt! I think this book will offer a great detailed look into a timely matter than many children may have only heard their parents talk about or have overheard it on the news; it is then made even more relatable by age appropriate characters as we see their thoughts and actions. This was another great hit by Eoin Colfer! Thank you, NetGalley for the ARC!

Was this review helpful?