Member Reviews

I went into this adaptation with high hopes after reading other Manga Classic adaptation and unfortunately I was let down. While the art was well done I feel like the intricacies of the story and deceptions were hard to keep track of in manga format and did not translate well into a great reader experience.

Was this review helpful?

❗This is a spoiler-free ARC review from NetGalley❗

I tried to read The Count of Monte Cristo when I was younger and could not get through it. That book was huge! But, most Manga I can read in one sitting. So when I saw this version on NetGalley. I wanted to read it immediately. It did not disappoint.

A lot of thought and care was taken in creating this Manga. They kept true to the time period dress and setting. The language was more digestible and interesting. I couldn't put it down! A very simple rundown of the plot is a good man who was betrayed and now wants revenge. I will be picking this up and reading time and time again.

Was this review helpful?

To start out, The Count of Monte Cristo is one of my favorite books of all time. This adaption to manga must have been a massive undertaking and I would just like to take the time to commend the art and the artist, With abridging something and plot heavy and long as the source material some risks are always taken, Personally i think the manga does a good job maintaining the main spirit and essence of the story. I think this is something that would be a pretty good jumping off point in getting someone who may not be interested in reading into literature.

Was this review helpful?

The art is nice and I am always happy to explore a classic in a new form. My one complaint is with formatting when I downloaded the book and opened it it starts immediately at the end of the book which took me a second to figure out that I needed to scroll to the "end" to actually start the book.

Was this review helpful?

An old story, a style of our time
I first discovered this story in musical form, falling in love with the songs, the characters, and the plot. Now I got to experience way more details and elements of Dumas’ heritage, falling for this story once again. Although I do not count myself as a fan of manga (not anymore), I was highly intrigued by the opportunity to read this adaptation. The Count of Monte Christo is known to be a very long, detailed book, so I took the advantage of discovering it in a shorter, condensed version. Nevertheless, I had my pleasure with the many twists and characters the manga could, despite its decreased length, convey.

Reading through the notes on the production of this manga at the end of this book, one gets to know about some of the changes made to Alexandre Dumas’ novel. Still, I believe that this manga has caught the essence of the story and the main characters quite well. Although I seldomly appreciate this art style nowadays, I was intrigued by the Count’s detailed expressions and his handsomeness, as well. But he is not the only figure of the book that comes to life on these pages. Although condensed, the manga does not fail to convey many side stories, motivations, and faults of minor characters.

Experiencing the story in this way allowed me to discover the genius that is Alexandre Dumas without suffering through hundred and hundred of pages. I loved every twist and turn of his story that I read and saw in this manga. I was pleased by how the plot turned out and how one could, respectively, recognize many details in one single frame. Surprisingly, this manga is not only for lovers of this artisan genre, but also for admirers of the writing of classical authors like Dumas.

In conclusion
I fell in love with this story due to its highly simplified adaptation as a musical, but now discovered more and more details. Enjoying the many shades of the characters and the depth of the story itself was fully possible within this condensed version that did not omit the most shocking, surprising twists. I will surely pursue some more of these amazing adaptations that are the Manga Classics.

Was this review helpful?

I always wanted to read some of the classic stories such as Les Miserables and The Count of Monte Christo - thinking that I would most likely really enjoy the stories but might not enjoy the classic writing style as much (and then having to commit to a heavy tome to get through it). When I saw there was a Manga adaptation I thought this must be the answer to my prayers - And. It. Is.

The adaptation is done so beautifully. Granted - I cannot really compare it with the original story since I have not read it but both Les Miserables and The Count of Monte Christo were so incredibly enjoyable that I am definitely considering giving the original books a try! I really think that there might be a lot of others that might give a classic a try if it is in Manga format! I am curious to read other peoples reviews who have read the original book to understand how it compares. I feel like with a Manga on so little pages (compared to the original) they must have left major events and background information out. I am not sure how much one would enjoy this Manga after reading the real deal. But I do think it might be the perfect entrance point into the story.

The art is beautiful and I would consider it to be enjoyable for manga enthusiasts as much as people who are new to the manga style and more of the typical western reader.

Thank you to NetGalley for providing me with an advance copy of the book in exchange for this honest review.

Was this review helpful?

One thing I love about Manga Classics is they introduce me to classics that I’ve never read and give me enough of the story that I feel like I’ve got a handle on the basics. They also give me a better idea of whether I want to go ahead and read the novel or not. Then there’s the fact that they’re manga, a format I love more with each one I read.

I’ve picked up the general story of The Count of Monte Cristo over the years but couldn’t even tell you how. I haven’t read the book or watched the movie.

I think in this case it would have been helpful if I did know more about the story before I read the manga. There are so many characters that there’s a character relationship guide at the end of the story. Even with this, I was a bit lost at times. While I got the gist of the story, I’m sure I missed a lot. I am interested enough to try to tackle the book at some point.

I love manga illustrations. The characters are always expressive and I’m just a tad obsessed with doe eyes. This story is illustrated beautifully. I particularly liked the detail of the clothing and the backgrounds.

I’m definitely going to be reading more Manga Classics.

Thank you to NetGalley and UDON Entertainment for the opportunity to read this book.

Was this review helpful?

Full disclosure, I have never read the original, not seen any of the movie adaptations or plays that exist. I understand that quite a lot was cut out from this version.

That said, I quite enjoyed it. There was no way I was going to make it through the full book for my book club, revenge stories are not my thing at all, but with this reading I think I can follow the discussion and even contribute some to the discussion. The story arcs and character development appeared to me to be conveyed in a meaningful way. There were no obvious gaps in the storytelling, although after learning that the original tells how the hero searches out the treasure, I do wish more of that part had been included here.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publishers for the ARC

Was this review helpful?

"I have been heaven's substitute to reward the good. Now the god of vengeance yields to me his power to punish the wicked!"

Edmond Dantès, later the Count of Monte Cristo, is a morally grey character bent on repaying those who had shown him kindness in the past, while exacting his revenge on those who wronged him.

One of the original revenge stories that inspired so many after it. This manga adaptation was fun to read as it smartly streamlined the story, retaining the most important plot points. There are of course many things that were left out from the original book, but you'll get the gist of the story from reading this manga—and maybe even decide to venture out and read the classic novel.

But being streamlined has its limitations at certain times: character reactions can be so sudden they can cause whiplash, a lot of events happen off-page, and then those that do occur on-page run the risk of being rushed through. Nevertheless, the Manga Classics version is a great alternative if you feel like experiencing this highly addictive story in a matter of hours.

For the most part, the language used felt appropriate for when the original story was written, but there was an odd mix ranging from the archaic (example: “I thank thee”) to the colloquial terms of nowadays (example: "Hoping she would still be single"). While not a deal breaker, it is noticeable and has the potential to pull you out of the story momentarily.

The art was very well-done! Crisp lines and every character was distinguishable from the next.

There's a reason why this story has stood the test of time and has inspired so many revenge stories; it's so complex and unravels in such a satisfying way. I would definitely recommend the Manga Classic version of The Count of Monte Cristo to longtime fans, as well as to those new to the story.

Was this review helpful?

This manga adaptation of a French classic succeeded in bringing the plot of this tale to life with illustrations. The art style is dynamic and perfect for this book. Perfect for fans of revenge tales, this manga brings this story to a wider audience

Was this review helpful?

A wonderful adaptation of the classic: The Count of Monte Cristo with wonderful illustrations by Manga Classics. They adapted the story plot in such a way that it is very easy to follow and understand. But the book takes the reader through an emotional rollercoaster which went missing in manga adaption.

Was this review helpful?

This manga comic strip confused me in how to read it. But, this comic of Alexa Dre Dumas has a lot of characters with so much in-depth stories. A story of revenge at all cost that may cost the revenge person to ruin unless they wake up. But, when watching the film there is so much missing from it, and my goodness is this much more action pack and interesting. You have to read it properly to get the first of all the characters. Well worth it,

Was this review helpful?

i really enjoyed getting to experience The count of monte christo in manga form! i had not read It before so this was exciting! i can't wait to read the other mange adaptations that i have now!

Was this review helpful?

I wish I could read classics without the fear of not understanding them, for many classics are written in such a way that common readers find them hard to read.

This project, right here, is the perfect way to make just about ANYONE to be able to know their stories. Classics but make it with pictures? YES.

So I think this was genius and gave me a chance to try to read a new classic in a differente way. And the art is stunning.

Was this review helpful?

The Count of Monte Cristo has been on my tbr for so long already, but I've always been to intimidated by it to actually read it, so the Manga Classic version was my way to get into the story. And it did an amazing job by that! The character design of Edmund has been so incredible, it was simply amazing to see how he developped within the story but still kept his design so one could notice him! It was just so amazing and I really want to read the original story now!
As always, Manga Classics just did a great job by converting the story into a manga and making the story more accessible for everybody, it is simply amazing.
Thank you for providing a review copy!

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed trying a Manga version of one of my favorite books. Though the Kindle version made it a bit harder to physically read I love the adapter's artistic capability in bringing the classic to life visually. I would recommend this version for those who enjoy Manga or are trying to get younger reader into classics. I received this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

This was my first time reading a Manga Classics book. It is a faithful telling of the original Alexander Dumas' The Count of Monte Cristo. I greatly appreciate how it explains why some trimming of the storyline occurred and how they chose to counter it as best as they could. The illustrations are gorgeous! The story is well told and makes me want to read the original.

The only reason for a four-star rating is that this would be easier to read in print or with a table of contents digitally, so that you can clearly follow it in the order designed for manga.

Was this review helpful?

I love how it's straightforward and easy to read through with the help of beautiful illustrations drawn by the artist.

Was this review helpful?

The Count of Monte Cristo manga was a very good adaption of the book. I never read the original but this made me really want to read the original book. It was very easy to read and I loved the art that was in the manga. I really liked the art and it was a nice adaption to the original.

Was this review helpful?

Actually this was a pretty fun read. The Count of Monte Cristo is one of my favorite books and this manga was great, I'm really looking forward to see more titles of this collection. The illustrations were beautiful and I think that it was a pretty good adaptation.

Was this review helpful?