Member Reviews

Brightly Burning is an exciting retelling of Jane Eyre, set in the future. This is a charming and delightful retelling with all of the tension and romance of the original, propelled by a new setting. Fans of Jane Eyre, romance, and science fiction will devour this unique recreation of one of the most beloved classics.

Was this review helpful?

Absolutely MAGICAL. Styled as "Jane Eyre in Space" and it is exactly that. Just as clever, just as heartfelt, just as romantic, with a stellar cast of characters and inventive world building. Just enough science fiction to make this an utterly delightful space romance. Donne creates a logical set up in which groups of refugees from earth have spent generations living in space ships in orbit after a massive ice age, and now the ships are beginning to fail. Amidst that is one Stella Ainsley, engineer who would much rather be a teacher, who gets a job on the reclusive ship, Rochester, which orbits the moon all by itself.

Donne follows all the plot beats of Jane Eyre, but spins them all in a freshly romantic way that will please fans of the original classic, and those who have never read the book and are just looking for a sci fi romance.

Was this review helpful?

Strong but flawed, Stella Ainsley is the perfect heroine to bring this high-stakes outerspace Jane Eyre retelling to life. Donne does an excellent job weaving a compelling cast with fresh twists on a familiar classic. I haven't read a retelling this clever since CINDER, and will definitely be recommending this to everyone looking for books set in space.

Was this review helpful?

I received a digital review copy of this book from Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. My review is susceptible to changes in the final copy of this work.
Before reading Brightly Burning, I had no previous experience with books set in space. Also, I had no clue if I would like books set in space. Turns out, books set in space are fun, so much opportunity for fantastic world-building (ahem, space building) that I had not discovered before.
Brightly Burning tells the story of Stella Ainsley, a seventeen-year-old who lives on a big spaceship the Stalwart. She is eager to get off this particular ship and takes up a job as a governess at a fancy private ship the Rochester. Captain of the Rochester is Hugo Fairfax, with his nineteen years slightly older than Stella. He has a reputation that precedes him and is known for being drunk often and having severe mood swings. Almost immediately after Stella enters the Rochester, mysterious things start to happen and she gets more and more curious to find out what is going on. Fun to know is that the book is a modern retelling of Jane Eyre.
As we have previously established, this book made me realize that I adore books set in space. The world building was pretty cool and it really made me wonder how impressive the big spaceships like the Stalwart and the Empire must be, and I imagine the Rochester to be a really classy yet mysterious one. Stella was a lovely and well-developed character. Hugo was a character to my liking as well. Yet, his personage felt slightly less well established than Stella’s. The other supporting characters were interesting too, with Jessa and Xiao being my favorites. After the first few pages, I was dying to know how the story would continue and actually read the whole thing on my phone because I was too impatient to wait for it to download on my iPad as well.
There were two things I was less enthusiastic about. The first being part of Hugo’s character. In the book, he is often drunk, which makes him rude toward everybody around him. I guess this element is part of the book being a retelling of Jane Eyre, but I did not really like this. It just seems like this was not really necessary, and it could potentially be a harmful element for younger readers, furthermore, it did not really come to a conclusion. I felt that his alcoholism had just disappeared towards the end of the book? Secondly, the epilogue was a bit extensive. It was good, but just a little too much information to all be placed in the epilogue. This caused that I felt some elements in the epilogue felt a little bit rushed because they ‘needed’ closure.
All taken together I really enjoyed this book, and that made me really happy. I would rate it 3,5 out of 5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

I cannot say enough good things about this book! I really adored it! This is a futuristic retelling of Jane Eyre that takes place on a space ship. The book follows Jane Eyre pretty closely and even though I knew what was coming next, it still had me feeling all sorts of feelings! I thought the explanations of living life in space was well done. Sometimes, with books set in space I get too bogged down with all the technical terms that are used. However, with this book, I was able to read through it quickly which was a good thing since I couldn't get enough. Stella was a fantastic “Jane”. I thought she was a really well done character. This book is perfect for anyone who loves sci-fi and Jane Austin retellings.

Was this review helpful?

To start this off, I hate fake curse words. The word frex was used instead of the eff word which was annoying and made zero since. It means the same dang thing!!! Also romance was weird. For one, Hugo was drunk nearly the whole book or had a drink in his hand. AA anyone? Then he wasn't really there most of the time, and no real conversations went down between the two. Honestly, one of the characters named Jon would have been a much better fit.

I thought some of the side characters were great such as Jon and Jessa! George was cool at the beginning, but then he faded away. This was still one of the better YA space books I have read, because I didn't feel bored at all while reading it. I just needed better chemistry with the romance! 

Stella was a good character—she did always put people above herself, so she was pretty likable. There were some interesting reveals that I guessed one for sure, but one I didn't. Overall, this was a fun and quick read!

Was this review helpful?

I was unable to review since it wasn't in kindle format - I'm so sorry!

Was this review helpful?