Member Reviews
This is a very interesting read and an interesting take on why we, myself included, are so fascinated, for want of a better word, in genocide, mass destruction and the obliteration or near obliteration of races of people through our history. It challenges us to ask ourselves why we pay and travel long distances so we can visit locations where millions we imprisoned, tortured and even killed. What is it that draws us there? Is it a guilty conscience that encourages us to visit, to pray, to pay our respects? Is it because the facts are almost surreal, dream like, nightmarish? Did this really happen? How could people have allowed this to happen? How could just a few orchestrate such atrocities? This book will really open your eyes. It will make you question what you know and what you've previously believed. It is a really good read, unlike anything your read before.
So sad, but very important book. I have not seen this book advertised and I’m surprised because Ive never seen anything like it anywhere so I feel like it’s not getting the credit it deserves. Peoples stories should be told so that they are never forgotten.
I did not like the style of the writing in this book. I felt like I was reading a book for my college class. This is way too wordy. Honestly, it was boring.
The only redemptive aspect of this book was that it introduced me to a few places that I had never heard about Chelmno and Belzec. I also had never heard about the Auschwitz Album.
Unfortunately, I have never been to any of these locations. I have met Eva Mozes Kor and been to her museum. I have also read many books about the Holocaust.
So while I do appreciate this book for introducing me to these locations and the album, I just couldn't enjoy this book because I felt so disconnected from the writing.
This book looks at how tourism is shaping the way we remember the holocaust and how although there can be issues with it in terms of making sure people respect the sites and the memories attached to them it is vitally important ensuring we continue to remember and learn from the past.
The Holocaust brings about a range of emotions that will vary from person to person. One however remains constant - horror.
While the atrocities of the camps and the stories of those who went through are told through interpreters and sometimes survivors of the camps, the photographs will forever remain witness to the lives lost. As tourists travel to these places today, photographs are taken and thoughts recorded in diaries or letters.
This book was thought provoking and well written. I enjoyed reading through it, and gaining a deeper understanding of the history of the camps, those who perished, and those who survived. I would recommend this book to anyone who wants to learn more - not only from a historical standpoint, but from the viewpoint of what we see and experience today when visiting these sites.
A really touching and thought provoking collection. Very sobering to look through this. Highly recommend.
I enjoy reading and learning about the holocaust and WWII. This book holds a great deal of helpful information about the history of auschwitz. The author provides a decent amount of discussion regarding the tourism trade surrounding this historical death camp. This discussion brings up very good questions regarding the attitude behind this tourism trade.
While I enjoyed the pictures included in this book I did not enjoy the writing style. I found it very clinical and similar to reading a textbook.
I thank you for the opportunity to read and review this book.
I've read a lot of books and stories about Auschwitz, WWII, and the Holocaust and while I find what happened to be horrible I find the history behind it to be fascinating so I keep finding myself being drawn back into them. So the title and the description of this book had me hooked as soon as I laid eyes on it. While most books I've read have been fictional stories or stories about Hitler not about Auschwitz strictly this one was more factual. I found it interesting to get the history behind the building itself not just the murders that took place inside. I found parts of this book were a little boring and it seemed almost clinical in its telling. I liked the idea behind it however the way it was told didn't hook me as a reader. If you are interested in the Holocaust then this is one that I think you would enjoy. It was interesting to read about how Germany went to try to get as far away from the tragedy that was the Holocaust as possible but also remembering all of the lives lost in that terrible time
I have read many books related to the Holocaust and am so glad to add this one to my library. It is not my favorite and at times it was a dry reading.
this is such an emotional and important subject, but the book was almost like a term paper, dry and hard to read.
A very interesting examination of the nature of remembrance, and the ethics of modern-day interpretations of the Holocaust. Do the memories that we have ingrained dictate how others portray and depict their own experiences? Or are there certain absolutes that are a line in the sand when it comes to memorialising genocide? A fascinating read.
Speechless. This book is excellently done. It needs to be a part of the curriculum of every higher education history class in the US if not the entire world. Seriously. Postcards from Auschwitz is a relevant, thought provoking book. We need more history books like this so our future generations can stop the horror of genocide from happening. I read and reviewed this voluntarily and feel privileged to have done so.
*thank you to Netgalley and NYU Press for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review*
2 stars.
Firstly, I really like to read books on the holocaust, but this one just wasn't for me. It wasn't as interesting as I thought. I managed to get through it all and there are points that are interesting, it just wasn't enough of them. The writing style is really good, and I also liked that photos were used. To actually see what the author was talking about. I hope other readers enjoy this more than I did.
A thorough and sobering exploration of the role of tourism in remembering the Holocaust. Reynolds has a clear, measured writing style which makes the book accessible to casual readers (historical overviews of each place mentioned as well as the Holocaust and its aftermath are helpful), but at the same time he doesn't shy away from noting academic discussions about tourism and memory. His own observations and photos of sites allow those who haven't visited them to relate to the spaces. He also discusses visitor behavior and the emotional responses elicited by Holocaust-related sites, from the naive boredom of teenagers on a field trip, to the grief of victims' relatives, to an elderly survivor's grateful joy of life. I was struck by how many of the points Reynolds raises in this book could relate to a number of tourist sites, museums, or even how we simply choose to commemorate past events.