Member Reviews
What a fantastic story!!! You will not want to put this book down!! I would definitely recommend it as the book of the summer & for reading clubs.
I had hoped to enjoy this book more based on other reviews but I couldn't get engaged. It was an okay story, the writing was quite well done. But the plot dragged and the story line didn't move as quickly as I would have liked given the subject matter.
Children for Sale. A simple photograph of the sign and the children in question is the catalyst for Ellis Reed's career. In the midst of the Depression, he takes the photo and develops it in the newsroom where he works. When Lily, the newsroom secretary, finds the picture and shows it to the head of the paper, a story spirals out of Ellis' control and only he has the ability to make things right. With the help of his growing friendship with Lily, he sets out to remedy the problems he has caused by a simple photo.
This historical fiction novel is based on an actual photograph from the Depression era, showing several children sitting outside with their own "Children for Sale" sign and the author paid a great deal of attention to the historic details. Ellis' and Lily's roles in the newsroom, especially Lily's desire for something more than a secretary spoke deeply into the mindset of the time, and their stories flowed well, juxtaposed to the children's stories.
I would highly recommend it to fans of historical fiction, as I think this time period is often missed between the typical WW1 and WW2 stories.
Lou Jacobs's Reviews > Sold on a Monday
Sold on a Monday by Kristina McMorris
Sold on a Monday
by Kristina McMorris (Goodreads Author)
M 50x66
Lou Jacobs's review Jun 04, 2018 · edit
it was amazing
Read from June 01 to 04, 2018
A beautifully written historical fiction masterpiece. Told in the backdrop of the Great American Depression along with Prohibition. Where people had to scrape together dollars to put food on the table. Both poignant and hard hitting .. it explores the multiple complexities of both the human condition and unexpected motivations. With heartfelt prose the dilemma of our main protagonists are explored. Ellis Reed, a young aspiring writer, determined to make his mark in the newspaper world ... with the unintentional gift to capture significant moments with candid photographs. And, Lily Parker, a young single mother, challenged with the pressure of society raising a child out of wedlock, and yet determined to break into the world of reporting. She finds herself accepting a job as a secretary for the Chief of the newspaper with the hope of eventually "getting a chance" . Ellis out on a normal and mundane story assignment .... comes across a scene that disturbs him which he must capture for himself on film. Two boys on a old farm porch with a wooden sign nearby ... declaring Children For Sale. He captures the image without any real intent to create a story. Lily on her own notices his photo drying in the developer room .... she is so moved that she places the photo on the Chief's desk .... and the subsequent events cascade in rapid order. The notoriety of the photo is instantaneous and pulls at the heart strings of America. Events spiral out of control resulting the "separation" of the children from their mother. Ellis and Lily need to team up in unexpected ways and overcome multiple obstacles in an attempt to right the situation. Beautifully written page turner that will remain in your mind and heart long after it is finished. Thanks to NetGalley for allowing me to read this magnificent Advance Proof in exchange for an honest review. This novel will be read by book groups all over the world ... the word will spread quickly!
This is an excellent book with a great backstory. The author was inspired to write the story about Ruby and Calvin after finding an old photograph showing children offered for sale. Their story unfolds against the backdrop of the Great Depression and gives historical context to the struggles of working women, the desperation of average men and women and inner workings of newspapers at that time.
Ellis is a young reporter looking for that one great story. He accidentally stumbles upon it when a photograph he took of two impoverished children with a For Sale sign hanging over them is selected by the newspaper’s editor for publication. Lily Palmer is the editor’s secretary who has barely hidden desires to be a reporter and is living a bit of a secret life. She and Ellis are thrown together when the publication of the picture and story has unexpected consequences. I didn’t expect the twists and turns as their adventure moves along very quickly.
I usually avoid books that I think will make me cry but I am so happy I read this one. The author has the ability to draw you into the world she is writing, and you become invested in the outcome for characters who all seem to be slightly damaged by their circumstances. I highly recommend this book and plan to read others by this author.
I was hoping this would be more focused on the great depression and hoping it would keep my attention, but it didn't hold my attention like I thought it would. Not a terrible story, just not for me though.
This book has all the feels...I cannot imagine what it would have been like to live during and after the Great Depression and not have any other choice than to sell my children. This book is heartbreaking, inspirational and gives you hope. Loved it! Great choice for a book group.
I really had no idea what this book was about when I requested it. I had just seen it all over Facebook and was curious. I started it yesterday and finished it today. And it was excellent. This book is so different from anything else that you will read. At times it's sad but it is also very uplifting to see the lengths people will go to to right a wrong. Despite what may happen to them in the process.
Interesting historical context for an easy-read.
Lily Palmer and Ellis Reed are two young, aspiring newspaper employees who want to be feature writers. Their lives become involved over the publication of a depression era picture that posts two children for sale. The foundation for the story is based in fact, and the supporting secondary themes are interesting to follow.
The problem is that some of those themes head down a road and disappear. For example, Ellis has occasions to meet with members of the Irish mob. The most important meeting, though, the one that should prove to be dramatic and help to resolve a major conflict of the story, simply doesn't happen.
Motherhood, though not stated specifically as a theme, is actually prevalent as five of the women present very prominent characteristics of nurturing, assertive, wise behaviors. The one exception is Sylvia, the female character who is emotionally erratic, a questionable character at best.
The crux of the book is the personal integrity issue that Ellis seeks to settle once his social interest article appears in papers across the country, awakening people to the plight of the nation's hardest hit citizens. The adventures in pursuit of his resolution is an easy, interesting read that includes several historical references centered during the depression, things like prohibition, the woman's role in the workplace, mobs and the mafia, etc.
All told, Sold on a Monday has a solid foundation and some stong story lines. I was a little disappointed in the Sylvia character and the depiction of life for the two children after they were sold.
I enjoyed reading the book and recommend it to others.
I was fortunate to have access to a pre-release version of this well-written historical novel. Set in the depression era, the author delves into some of the very real challenges families, especially single parents, faced during the depression. With grandparents who lived through that time as young parents, I have an appreciation for the struggles people faced even to find enough to eat, much less earn enough money to feed and house a family. The addition of a young, single mother embarrassed by the presence of a child born out of wedlock evokes a sense of the morality of that time, not to mention the difficulties women faced.
The early chapters seemed a bit slow, but I realize the author was necessarily setting the stage for the rest of the book. I particularly liked the inclusion of mob involvement as I heard about those elements from my family members who lived through that time. All in all, it was a great read that was hard to put down. This would be a good book club choice.
I read a lot of thrillers these days, so diving into a story set during the Great Depression held great appeal. I especially enjoy historical fiction that really drops you into its place in a history.
Unfortunately, Sold on a Monday isn't one of those books. The setting was clear enough, but it wasn't very well fleshed out. I know very little about the time period, but I didn't learn anything new, either.
Don't get me wrong. There is a lot to love about this book. The subject matter is compelling, the characters are well developed, and the story is keeps you interested from start to finish.
Ellis is the reporter who takes the picture that gets everything started. He sees two boys on a porch, standing below a sign that says, "Two children for sale."
With such a beginning, it is no surprise that this story pulls at the heartstrings, but it's not a one note plot that turns into a cliche. The story deals with losses of many kinds, each unique and tender.
The romantic aspect of the book, however, feels flat. It's fairly clear from the outset what the outcome will be, but I found myself really pleased to have been right.
If you're seeking serious historical fiction, this book isn't for you; but if you are seeking a really easy, emotionally charged story, Sold on Monday is a great choice.
The central theme of Sold on a Monday, a novel by Kristina McMorris, is the power of the press; so appropriate in this era of “fake news”. Secondary to the theme of honesty in journalism is one of the strength and power of a Mother's love.
Set in Philadelphia during the Great Depression McMorris captures the essence of the era –- fear for one's livelihood, model T cars, gangsters, speakeasies, appropriate behaviour of unmarried women. She also did a great job of capturing the stress and pressure apparent in the news room of a daily newspaper.
What a captivating story. It is set in the early thirties when the ravages of the Depression were taking hold of the country. Ellis is a struggling newspaper writer trying to find his big break. When he takes a calculated risk to create "alternate facts," unintended consequences result.
The author is masterful in putting the reader back in time. The characters are well-developed and the story itself was spell-binding. I am very interested in reading more of Ms. McMorris's work.
Thanks to NetGalley for the opportunity to read and review.
This is a well-written historical novel that will keep you guessing until the very end. McMorris's characters are very believable, and I cared about what happens to them. She does an excellent job of revealing bits and pieces of the backstory of the two main characters, as well as throwing in plot twists to keep up the suspense. It's not necessarily an enjoyable read, as the historical setting is the years of the Great Depression, with injustice, poverty, and difficult times for many. The author's treatment of forgiveness, honesty, and other such issues makes it a memorable and challenging read.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Sourcebook Landmark through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
This was a wonderful read! I was hooked by the cover and the whole premise of the story of the publication of a picture with two children and a sign "Children for Sale" and the reporter that captures the shot and the consequences of that picture.
Ellis Reed is a struggling reporting on the brink of losing his job, until he drives by a farmhouse and captures the shot of two little children for sale. He never intends to publish this picture, but it turns out it is just the break he needs. Lillian Palmer is the secretary at the publishing firm and gives the picture to the boss. The picture leads them on an adventure to right the wrong that Ellis finds he has created for this poor family.
This is a heartbreaking story during the Depression when families were struggling to survive, so much so that they would go to such lengths as to sell their children. This story is a tale of ambition, love, and the lessons that result from our actions.
This book is a page-turner. The subject matter is very interesting and based on a part of American History that seems to get swept under the carpet.
I enjoyed this book - it took me awhile to really get into it, but as it progressed, I became interested in the characters and the story. It all starts with a photo and a news article. The photo that is ultimately published is actually a staged photo and thus begins a winding tale of the repercussions and unintended consequences of submitting a half truth to be published in a newspaper. The photo of a mother presumably advertising her children for sale goes "viral" - as much as it can spread during the 1940's and two newspaper employees are caught up in the saga that unfolds as a result. The end has a surprising twist that I was un-prepared for, but was happy with the ending - even though it definitely ends suddenly and what felt like a bit too soon. I would have been okay with a bit more! Overall, I very much liked Lily and Ellis and willingly followed along as they worked to rectify the damage that had occurred once the deceptive photo was published.
This historical novel is a very poignant telling of some tragic family sacrifices during the Great Depression.
It’s also a very poignant telling of how a falsified photo with all good intentions can have devastating and unintended consequences. And in that regard, the story could be current today with all the photoshopping and posting of photos on the internet that serve an agenda, but which do not serve the truth.
This story is set in Philadelphia with forays into NYC and New Jersey in 1931. I loved the verbal portraits of the times and the struggles of the people during the Depression. I loved the pictures she painted of their hard scrabble lives and bare existence, but without being maudlin nor hopeless.
Each character had his or her own challenges which were beautifully shown as relating to the time period.
The “rescue scene” was a bit too fantastic for my blood (sort of like chase scenes in other books), but that is my only criticism. This was a well crafted and meaningful story based on several different true accounts from the time period. The action moved in a straight forward manner. The characters were good, kind, hard-working people. I immediately felt immersed in the story and could easily identify with the characters.
This is my first novel by Kristina McMorris, but it sure won’t be my last.
Many thanks to Netgalley and Sourcebooks Landmark for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
This review will be posted to GoodReads immediately and to both Amazon and the Anniston Calhoun County Library's website following publication.
I received a copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
To me the line that sums it all up is: IT STARTED WITH A PICTURE. That is exactly where it started and ended. The between parts are the story that will capture you and draw you in and not let you go. This is a touching, heart wrenching story that also has so much more. The time period being 1931 during the Great Depression when people did what they had to to survive. Even where children were concerned. They were given away, left at police stations, hospitals, orphanages, even sold. Yes sold.
“A thousand words will not leave so deep an impression as one deed.” -Henrique Ibsen
“Photography is the art of observation. It has little to do with the things you see and everything to do with the way you see them.” -Elliott Erwitt.
“There is nothing to fear except the persistent refusal to find out the truth. -Dorothy Thompson
“There is not a trick, there is not a swindle, there is not a vice which does not live by secrecy.” -Joseph Pulitzer
This is one of the most heartbreaking books I have read in so long. The era is perfect and the fact that it is based on a real picture in a newspaper of children actually being sold, just tears at the heartstrings even more. It will pull you in from the first. From the Prologue to the very last word. Even the Author’s notes are to be read. The whole book.
Ellis, a new reporter takes a picture of two children and a sign that says “2 children for sale”. Ellis could not believe anyone would sell their children. But during such a hard time. When people didn’t have much at all, it happened more that we now would or could conceive. That picture started a string of events that would make Ellis a great reporter. Get him known and eventually a much better job.
Lily worked at the paper as a secretary and was pulled into the story that Ellis wrote about the two children. The picture touched her as a woman and as a mother. She had a child and was keeping it secret from many because in those days that was just not done. She was working and trying to save so her child and her could have a better life. She only sees him on weekends because of her job. Her deep desire is to be able to write for the paper also but her boss does not understand that. It was just not the job for a woman. She was the secretary not a reporter. Yet!
Geraldine is a mother to two sweet children who love her and she loves them so much. But she is sick so it was not hard to see why she might have done what she did.
This book touches on sickness both physical and mental. One mother who thinks she is dying and one who lost a child and needs mental help so bad.
The things that happen in this story are so true to the time period you feel like you are there. You will cringe at times when things happen. You will definitely cry a lot when it comes to children, and even mothers. It’s a very emotional story that will pull you right in from the start. Even after it ended I thought about the children. My thoughts were one what happened to them, to their mom, to them after they grew up. Would they be ok. I have to think they would be fine knowing they were loved so much and that some things were just out of their mother’s hands. She did the only thing she could.
It’s just a book that will pull you in so many directions and leave you breathless, thoughtful and hopeful.
You have to read the author’s note at the end. It’s well written and full of info that is so good also. Read it all. You won’t regret it. This is a wonderful book with many different characters to like or dislike. To cheer for and cry for. A big 5+ stars from me. I feel fortunate to have been given this book to read. Thank you again NetGalley...
I would like to thank NetGalley and the Publisher, Sourcebooks, for a copy of this book for an honest review.
"Sometimes we have to make sacrifices for the ones we love."
When I read this quote from the book, Sold on a Monday, by Kristina McMorris, it seemed to convey to me the essence of this story which started with a picture of two children sitting on a porch in a rural area of Laurel Township, Pennsylvania with a sign reading, "2 children for Sale." Ellis Reed, a photographer for the Philadelphia Examiner newspaper, took the picture and wrote a story about Geraldine Dillard having to sell her children out of desperation in 1931. The story was a catalyst for promotion to a New York newspaper for Ellis Reed when it made headlines across the nation and changed the lives of the children. Ellis and his friend, Lily, spend the rest of the novel trying to right the irreversible wrongs caused by the article in the paper.
Kristina McMorris has written a book based on an actual newspaper photo that appeared in a Chicago newspaper in 1948 which shook the nation. It is a story of ambition, love, family and the far reaching effects of our actions. The characters are drawn in such a way that you find yourself caring about what happens to them. There is a strong sense of place in the novel and you can feel yourself in the streets of Philadelphia and the surrounding area trying to help find where the children are and who has them. There are lots of historical references to the Italian and Irish mob, prohibition, speakeasies and the affects of corruption on the characters.
I found this book to be a fascinating read and look forward to reading more of McMorris' novels. I would highly recommend this book to those who love historical novels that tug at your heartstrings.