Member Reviews

I loved Emma Hooper's debut novel, 'Etta and Otto and Russell and James', and 'Our Homesick Songs' is equally lovely. Set in Newfoundland, in 1992, it is the story of a young boy, Finn who tries to find a way to entice back the fish that have disappeared, so his life can return to normal. It's a captivating tale about a dying community and one boy's attempt to save his family.

Was this review helpful?

I can't put my finger on exactly what it was about Our Homesick Songs that I loved so much, there's a real lyrical, melodic sense to the book, as someone who grew up on the coast of Ireland, in a way I could imagine this being a story told by one of the old fishermen that used to sit down by the pier, it's quite a slow paced book and took a little time to get into the story but once you do it's wholesome and gives a very true depiction of life on the coast, I know all too well the hardships that coastal towns and those that go out to sea face, and this book depicted it in a perfectly poetic but raw way.

There's a touch of the magical throughout the book with the interwoven folk tales and songs and you'll fall in love with Finn and Cora as they forge their way in Big Running with the aim of rescuing the town amidst the devastating backdrop of the Canadian Fishing crisis of 1992...

Try and read this without shedding a tear or two....

Was this review helpful?

I should have known from my experience with Etta and Otto that Hooper’s style is too twee for me, but I was lured in by the accordion on the cover! I did like the existence of the library boat and Cora redecorating the rooms of a derelict house to match her latest travel book.

Was this review helpful?

This is an absolutely delightful tale of a young boy who thinks up a plan to save his family and community. Newfoundland 1992. The fish on which the small community depends have been overfished and have disappeared – in fact in that year the Canadian government stopped all cod fishing off the Newfoundland coast. No longer able to make a living, one by one the local families are forced to move away. 10 year old Finn’s parents take it in turns to go away to work, doing a month each, then coming home to take care of Finn and his sister. Such a disrupted and disruptive life can’t continue – it’s up to Finn to find a way to get the fish back. It’s beautifully gentle story, moving, lyrical, perhaps a little sentimental at times, but a thoroughly absorbing read which I very much enjoyed, an evocative and atmospheric novel about family, love and forgiveness.

Was this review helpful?

What is it about this book that I loved so much? I am always drawn to stories set in a northern wilderness, especially on an island, and it ticked that box. Difficult lives, for sure, and it is a sad story in some ways - the people’s livelihoods taken away by overfishing and their very homes under threat, leading to the parents working away from home on rotation with all the stress that involves. The two children touched me most, both trying to save their family in their own ways. I was drawn to brave, resilient, determined Cora. My heart belongs to Finn, though, so earnest in his strategies to call the fish back and save the day.

Gorgeous descriptions of landscape, especially the hazardous wintry ocean, plenty of wry humour, despite the serious themes, pithy dialogue, to say the least, I liked everything about this book and the ending was a joy. I particularly enjoyed Cora’s surreal installations in the empty houses, Finn’s sound and light extravaganza and the vision of Sophie clanking around with her medals up her jumper.

A solid 4-star read, with an extra star for Finn himself.

Was this review helpful?

A gentle, moving story about the demise of a Newfoundland fishing community and the stresses the loss of their traditional livelihood had on families who had made their living for generations by fishing there.

Our Homesick Songs alternates between two years, 1974 and 1992/3. The latter is significant because 1992 was the year in which the Canadian government suspended cod fishing off the Newfoundland coast. The big factory ships had decimated stocks, as they also did in Scotland, and they needed time to recover. Aidan Connor and Martha Murphy fell in love in 1974. In 1992, their relationship was strained by the necessity of working away from home in alternate months from each other. Their children, Finn and Cora, reacted in different ways to the problems facing their community and their parents, with both trying to find their own way to help the family and their community to survive.

Old folk songs and folk memories are interwoven into the story hence the title of the book. Whilst addressing serious issues, it’s a warming tale of relationships and of the power of music to create a bond between people. I really enjoyed it.

With thanks to NetGalley and Penguin Books UK for a free review copy.

Was this review helpful?