Member Reviews

This was a great read! Poor villager Amani becomes a stand in for the hated Vathek princess. During that time she learns about palace life and falls in love with the prince.

It was a quick read, and kept this reader engaged. I can't wait for the follow-up. I will be recommending this book to my students.

Thank you for the advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

Mirage is a character driven sci-fi fantasy. I really liked the premise but I didn't end up loving the book. Partly I think because it seemed like fantasy with or without magic and then all of a sudden there are droids and technology. The science fiction felt like a last addition and I didn't really feel like it added anything to the story.

The relationship between Maram and Amani was the most interesting point of the book. I struggled with everything else. I wanted Amani to do more and be more and stop being manipulated so easily. I wanted a bit fast pace. I kept picking it up and putting it down. So mostly I wanted to feel more urgency about Amani's situation and what she's going to do about it.

Was this review helpful?

**I received a copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review***

OMG!!! I LOVED this book!!!! Seriously, I can't get enough of it and I can't wait for the next one! Somaiya Daud has created such unique, interesting, and engaging characters that I can't wait to see what happens next.

Originally I went into reading this book with pretty mediocre expectations, I've never really been to into the sci-fi/fantasy genre before. I should say, I've read science-fiction and I've read fantasy before, but I've never read a book that blended the two together so well!

I love that the author created a world and characters that made me feel so much. I always wanted to know what happened to our heroine, but at the same time I didn't want the story to end. I wanted to vanquish the villain, but at the same time wanted to know more of why there were like they were. The characters had such depth, that you couldn't help but feel for each and every one of them.

I seriously have recommended this book to pretty much everyone that I know. If you want to really get into the story, I'd also recommend the audio book as well!

Was this review helpful?

I enjoyed the story. Unfortunately, the galactic world building was hard to follow with all the planets, moons and cultures.

Was this review helpful?

This is a fantasy sci-fi with planet travel, drones, and technological advances, which was a really cool combination. I loved the mythology, the heritage, and tradition that this story wove. It is a story much like a lot we have seen before, a girl put in an impossible position and making the most of it, taking comfort and making friends however she can.

Mirage is a simply beautiful novel. Daud paints a vivid tale of a girl torn from her family to serve her conquering oppressors, but it has so much more than that; Mirage is about hope and resilience, about myth and religion and tradition, about power and duty and sacrifice. Above all else, it is the simple beauty of the writing that elevates this book to one of my favourites of the year.

Was this review helpful?

Really compelling story set in a Middle Eastern-inspired interplanetary world... the setting is sci-fi light, kind of like Star Wars. Strong characters, interesting conflicts, and I loved the worldbuilding!

Was this review helpful?

wow I really liked this. There were so many elements that I am obsessed with. The best thing was hands down the amazing and complex relationship between Amani and Maram. Despite looking identical, they are as different as two people can be. But the bond that they form was so powerful.
Maram is definitely becoming one of my fave characters. She has been forced to wear a mask of cruelty her whole life. Being hated by all her people and ignored by her family, she has had no one and it made her hard.
The only thing I didn't like about this book was the romance. It was really unnecessary and far too insta-lovey for my taste.
I really can't wait to read the next book and see what happened with Amani and Maram because this ending destroyed me.

Was this review helpful?

Mirage is the first book in a series by the same name by Somaiya Daud. Mirage is a young adult fantasy/ sci fi series about a world that is actually the moon of another planet, called Andal. I loved the set up. Immediately it had a star wars type vibe, but the comparison does not go very far. Because Mirage is a masterpiece all of its’ own. Somaiya Daud did such a fantastic job weaving this story! I am seriously still mesmerized by it.

As I said before, Mirage is set on a moon world, called Cadiz. Here we meet Amani, who is kidnapped and taken to the planet Andal, where she is forced to train to become the princess’ Body Double. I was completely swept up in this story, and a large part of that was due to the intricate world building. Cadiz is heavily Moroccan inspired and Somaiya Daud really did a fantastic job creating this vast world. She immediately sucked me in and held me captive for the entire novel. By the end, I was practically begging for more!

There is also a really interesting romance developing in Mirage between Amani and Idris caught me right from he very start. (Idris the the princess’ betrothed. scandalous!) It was a bit rushed and a bit predictable but I loved it nonetheless. Mirage is a character building journey for Amani. I loved watching her develop into the young lady she was at the end of the book. And I know she is going to be even more kick butt in the next installment. The rebellious under current is a very strong theme brewing throughout. I cannot wait to see where this duology takes us and I cannot wait to see how it concludes. Honestly, I loved Mirage so much that I am kind of bummed it is only going to be a duology. I am not ready to say goodbye to these characters and this world yet.

Was this review helpful?

I liked the idea of a Middle Eastern-inspired fantasy sci-fi, but I found it pretty meh. The romance was very insta-lovey, and I found the eventual friendship between Amani and the princess to be super predictable. I also thought nothing really happened until the end? Every time she did something that could have been dangerous it turned out basically fine. I also wanted to hear more about the rebel leader who may have been a goddess reincarnated, but we didn't really get much of her.

Was this review helpful?

Beautifully written debut novel with a distinctive Moroccan flavor, filled with lush prose and solid world building. The characters are wonderfully fleshed out, and the relationship between the two main characters is especially interesting to see grow. The romance that develops isn't a surprise, you can see it coming, but it's sweet and swoonworthy and who really cares if we know what going to happen if it's done well? The ending will tug at your heartstrings, and I'm looking forward to the next book so I can see what happens!

Was this review helpful?

Such a fun read! I don't read a lot of sci-fi but I really enjoyed reading this one! With Middle Eastern influences I was excited to see this world, and am so happy I did!

Was this review helpful?

I probably enjoyed this book more than I normally would have because it has a lot of cultural elements borrowed from Moroccan culture so it reminded me of when I lived there. Beyond that, I liked that it was different than other YA fiction, in that the main character isn’t being forced to marry a prince or overthrown some regime. The main conflict is based around Amani being forced to become the body double of the cruel Princess Maram, whose people have conquered Amani’s. The relationship between Amani and Maram changes over time despite a violent beginning and somehow you almost end up feeling sorry for the Princess.

Was this review helpful?

This was FANTASTIC! I automatically preordered the book! It has such great characters and a beautifully lush setting. The romance and politics in this book are flawlessly done! I can’t wait for book 2!

Was this review helpful?

I appreciate scif-fi where world building isn't the be all and end all of the plot. Apart from some referenced technology, this plot could happen just about anywhere and any time. While most of the events of the plot are entirely expected, the character development takes some interesting directions. Worth a read, for sure.

Was this review helpful?

<b>The World building was incredible and atmospheric</b>. It’s Moroccan inspired (ownvoices too), which was cool to see, even though I probably didn’t catch a lot of how the culture and history translated into the book. However, here is a really great Review that talks a bit about how the book was drawn from recent Moroccan history, if you’re interested. Because of the mentioned history, the book has a focus on oppression and translates into a sci-fi setting, which was really well done. The world felt vivid and interesting, mainly due to the focus on native poetry and legends, which made the world come alive and added an extra layer of depth! Like I mentioned, we also get a huge insight on the Kushaila people and their culture through the main character. That also included the Vathek oppression, who have colonized almost all of the galaxy, while erasing native culture and history wherever they go. The book perfectly talks about this topic in-depth, especially about the complex history and consequences that the occupation has caused. I don’t really have words for how well done it was, but let me just say that this book is important. Furthermore, I wanted to mention that Mirage felt more like fantasy at times (at least when it comes to the overall atmosphere), which isn’t bad as I love Fantasy. In truth the book is light sci-fi. That’s perfect for beginners, who might be overwhelmed by more heavy sci-fi.

<b>I have only complaint when it comes to the world building</b>. Why are there people who look exactly like someone else? Maram obviously knew there was someone who looked like her and searched for Amani, yet it’s never explained why they look-alike. It hopefully will be explained in the sequel, but I didn’t think it was a good choice to keep the reader completely in the dark. Since Maram didn’t seem to be too surprised about having a double, it seemed weird why she never explained how she knew this, because obviously she had to know, since she actively searched for Amani. My personal theory? Probably something with clones, that would be cool and it’s sci-fi so who knows?

<b>Amani was such a great protagonist to have.</b> For starters, I immediately loved the relationship she had with her family and friends, it was great to see it, before everything went to hell and she was kidnapped. Amani – rightfully – starts out as scared and lonely. She is dragged away by those who oppressed her people to serve as a body double to the princess who is so hated by the Kushaila people that she fears to go outside. The beginning is very hard to read, because there’s a lot of abuse and violence that Amani has to endure when she is forced to learn how to best become like Maram. It was heartbreaking to watch what they did to her and how they stripped her of things belonging to her culture and identity. However, Amani endures. She grows stronger and more confident, she becomes exactly why they wanted her to be and she excels at it. Still, Amani is also very kind and feels for her people. It was great to see her love for her own culture and people, that prompted her to take risks and try to help as much as she could in her unique position. I’m definitely looking forward to seeing where her journey leads her, as in the end things are going down and … Amani makes mistakes (even though I never thought she was guilty, this girl did the best she could and acted incredibly selfless), but there is also hope. You’ll see what I mean when you get to the end.

<b>I hated Maram a lot in the beginning, but she was a well crafted antagonist.</b> Obviously I’m not willing to forget how she treated Amani in the beginning, it was horrible and definitely not okay. The strength of Maram as an antagonist is that you can actually understand her actions, even if you don’t agree with them. She isn’t evil just because, she has motivations and a background story, which is something that takes a villan to the next level. Yes I hated her, but through Amani’s observations, we also saw that Maram’s life had forged her into this person as well. We saw how her heritage of both Vathek and Kushaila made her an outsider on both sides, made her feel alone wherever she went. How do you best protect yourself against that? By being cruel, mean, cold and never letting anyone get close, so they don’t betray you. It doesn’t make Maram a good person, but you could kind of understand where she was coming from and why she decided to reject her Kushaila heritage. She responded with rage and hatred to protect herself. Throughout the course of the book we also see Amani and Maram’s relationship growing from hatred to something more positive which I really didn’t expect as Maram was so horrible in the beginning. But I think that every good book should have a dynamic between the protagonist and antagonist that gets explored and that’s exactly what happens here. Amani can help her discover more of her rejected heritage and after a while Maram even opens up, prompting Amani to consider that there is hope for her becoming a better queen as her father. Still, their relationship is messy and if you’ve read the book you know why.

<b>I liked the romance and love interest.</b> The romance is between Amani and Maram’s fiance and it’s a forbidden romance, which is one of my favorite romance tropes, so I was thrilled! Idris was a very kind person and certainly had his charm, so it was very easy to like him and root for his relationship with Amani. He was the only person she could be truly open with and he actually understood her situation, as he is Kushaila, but has no real memory of the culture and language anymore. Instead he is just as caged as Amani is, forced to play a role after his entire family was murdered to set an example. However, she also can help him understand more about his people and reads the language for him as he cannot barely read Kushaila at all. My heart really reached out for him and I totally understood what drew Amani and him together. They had great chemistry and fit together very well. Furthermore, their relationship is built on so much respect, it was really nice to see that and to have no love triangle! I enjoyed all the scenes they had together and the end broke my heart.

<b>The only thing I had issues with is the plot & pacing in the middle.</b> That’s kind of what made me drop 1 star, because the more I thought about it, the more it bothered me. But let’s start out with the good stuff. I loved the beginning and end of the story. Both were very fast paced and full of suspense and tension. I was on the edge of my seat the entire time and really felt with the characters. Especially the ending is perfect as it’s so bittersweet. A lot of things went wrong, but there is also hope. However, the middle didn’t convince me as much. It took me a while to know why exactly and I think it has to do with (1) how the pacing was a bit too slow in comparison to ending and beginning and (2) that the premise of the body double was a bit underused, causing lower stakes and conflict. Don’t get me wrong, I loved the focus on family, tradition and characters! I wasn’t bored or unengaged, so the slower pacing didn’t bother me, but it wasn’t ideal either. Especially how the premise was used didn’t live up to my expectations. Of course we see Amani in her role as the body double. But whole things were at stake for her, the tension and conflict weren’t as high as they could have been. The problem being that I didn’t really worry for Amani as much as I hoped to. It also felt like the plotline in the middle was a bit linear, without many downs. That was nice to read, but the conflict could have been higher at times. That’s the only thing I can say without delving into spoilers.

<spoiler><b>Okay let’s talk about what I mean a bit more in-depth</b>

** Until the end when Maram was set to be assassinated and Amani went in her place, nothing ever happened to her. There was no attack on her life, so I never really feared for her.

** Likewise, I didn’t buy it that there was no threat at all at Amani’s life during all the events that she attended as Maram. It’s made very clear that Maram fears for her life, but I honestly didn’t get why after a while, as nothing remotely threatening happened.

** There is always a risk, but this potential for higher tension and stakes was underused. I would have found it more realistic, if the rebels had only tried to make an attempt on her life, so it turned out that Maram’s fears were justified. But, since we were always told about the risk but never really shown it, I couldn’t completely buy it. Therefore, this aspect disappointed me a bot.

** Furthermore, I wanted at least one person – except from the one who found out – to see some difference in Amani and suspect something was up. I felt like Amani was almost too perfect in her imitation, so there was no big conflict about someone discovering her. The stakes would have been higher if she had wavered more and maybe even failed once, with a huge conflict about disposing of the one who found out or something like that.</spoiler>

<b>IN CONCLUSION:</b> <i>Mirage</i> is a <b>great Moroccan inspired sci-fi story</b>, which talks about very important topics, such as oppression, family and culture. This is definitely a book that you don’t want to miss out on. It has a great heroine, a complex villain and a great swoon worthy romance. My only issues was with the plot pacing in the middle, but apart from that the story really gripped me. I can only highly recommend it!

Was this review helpful?

Lately I have been reading so many books with very cool and creative worlds, and Mirage was no exception. Probably one of the most unique things about this book is that it is a science fiction book with a Middle Eastern inspiration. Desert landscapes are common in science fiction but one that was so grounded in the setting and culture of the people of the desert and Middle East is not something I think I have read before. It was definitely cool and I really enjoyed being able to experience the culture. Especially because it's a book which has it's own history and mythology and you know I love that. And the author did a really good job of showing the reader the world instead of telling them. In fact, she may have done too good a job. I felt like I wanted to learn so much more about the science fiction aspect of the book and we didn't get that.

The other thing that I liked about this book was the characters, especially the female characters. Amani was a really good main character. She is the kind of female character that I love in that she is not your typical kickass femme fatale. She's vulnerable and a reluctant hero who is forced into a terrible position and has to show a lot of inner strength to make it through. She's easy to get behind in that way because you are in her head and can completely sympathize. But there were other really interesting and complex characters. One of the ones I liked best was Maram, the princess who Amani becomes the body double for. Maram could have easily become a total cliche bad girl, but she was super complex and had really great development throughout the book. I wish her father Mathias had a little more development and screen time because he was really interesting and could have gone very dark but he wasn't around much.

If you read this book then you may have noticed that I didn't mention Idris as a character that I liked, and believe me there is a reason for that. It's not that I didn't like Idris, who by the way is the love interest. He was a fine character. I just really hated the romance here. This is probably no surprise to most of you, I don't like a lot of romance. But here it was really tough because the romance was so much a part of this book and I really wish it wasn't. This had all the hallmarks of romances I don't enjoy. The character fell hard and fell fast after what was definitely insta-love. And she made so many of her decisions based on her feelings for this guy. I felt like the romance kind of took over the plot of the book in portions, which is something a lot of people love but I am not one of those people.

Which, brings me to the portion of the book I wish was different, the plot. There was a lot of promise to this book when it came to the plot but it just didn't deliver for me. There was a good amount of political intrigue here. I love books that combine fish out of water stories along with court politics and that's what this book had. For me, it was at it's best when it was focusing on the rebellion and the relationship between the rulers and the people they ruler. There were some really good scenes where it explored these aspects of the story. But I wish there were more of them. It got there in the end and I think the next book in the series is going in a really great direction, but in this one it just felt like it had a little bit of first book syndrome.

I liked this book but I feel like I'm a bit of a black sheep here. Maybe it was the hype monster, maybe it was first book syndrome, or maybe this just wasn't my kind of read. However, it did have some great things like a really good world and complex characters.

Was this review helpful?

ARC provided via Netgalley.

I was intrigued by the blurb right off the bat. The fact that the cultral background is not your stereotypical Eauropean foundation thrilled me to no end. I love when authors used other cultures for their characters and story foundations because it gives readers a different look into a culture many are ignorant about. That is mostly what got me through the book.

I also loved the character twist. The heorine, is not your sterotypical Disney princess. She's more of an anti-princess in a way. Amani is a female character I grew to like. This book won't be for everyone because of the fantasy element and the overused concept of a special female character who is also a princess, but I see this being a good read for 8th-9th graders in a way. Not necessarily your older teen crowd.

I highly approve, overall, and can't wait for the next in the series.

Was this review helpful?

This book was a solid 3 stars for me, I didn't dislike it but it also isn't really a book I would recommend to someone with similar tastes as mine. I think it would be enjoyable to younger YA readers who enjoy a shorter, straight forward story without a lot of additional world building and character development.

Things I liked:
Amani's devotion to her family - an admiral quality in any YA protagonist and this was clearly her driving force for most of the story.
The world - while I would have liked more world building, I was still very intrigued by the political system the author developed and the tense relations between Vathek and Cadiz.
The relationship between Amani and Maram - this was really my favorite thing about the book and felt like the core of the story. I would hope to see more of this in the next book and I was way more into their burgeoning friendship than the romance.

Things I didn't like:
The romance - It was boring. There was no mystery here, it was obvious right away that Amani would fall for Idris and the fact that he returned her feelings almost immediately and was ready to marry her by the end of the book had me rolling my eyes. I actually feel like the romance could have been completely removed from the story and it wouldn't have been missed.
The pacing and plot - Things just moved way too fast for me and I felt like there was overall very little development of the characters. This is something I frequently have a problem with in YA fiction due to the low word count. World building and character development gets sacrificed for plot and I don't form the right attachments to characters. However, I know plenty of people who prefer the shorter, faster paced narratives and don't need a lot of extras. I think those are the readers who are going to really enjoy this book.

Was this review helpful?

Amira lives in a time when her home and the surrounding areas are under the control of a cruel regime, in which many people have been killed and countless others are oppressed. One night at her coming of age party, Amira is roughly torn from her family because she looks just like the princess. She is taken to the palace and treated cruelly by Princess Maram and her advisor Nadine, and over time Amira is transformed into a body double of Maram. Maram is hated across the kingdom for her cruelty and she is constantly in danger of being assassinated, so Amira is forced to attend high risk events as the princess. When Amira meets and gets to know Idris, Maram's fiance, they begin to fall in love. Will Amira have the strength to do the right thing, even if it means losing her family, Idris, and even her life?
I loved this book, especially since it's a unique sci-fi romance with elements of fantasy woven in. The story takes place in space on moons and planets, and each one has a different environment and diverse people. The political intrigue was interesting, especially when Amira decides to become a spy for the resistance. The circumstances Amira had to endure were heartbreaking, especially being separated from her family and her forbidden relationship with Idris. Their relationship was sweet and smoldering, and I can't wait to find out what happens next. I highly recommend this book and am eagerly anticipating the sequel.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from the publisher through NetGalley. A positive review was not required, and all opinions expressed are entirely my own.

Was this review helpful?

As a debut author, I didn't know quote what to expect from Somaiya Daud, but she ultimately brought us the diverse, feminist YA fantasy we've been waiting for. Yes, Mirage has some problems such as a ton of tropes, but in the end it's a fantastic story that has definitely become one of my favorites of the year.

Daud has a wonderful, almost poetic writing style which lends very well to the world building of the book. Her words truly made the world come to life, and I could certainly see some of the Moroccan inspired aspects. Also, I will admit that I did not read the synopsis before starting Mirage (something I often do) so I was sort of surprised by the Sci-Fi aspects of the story, but I think Daud did a great job at incorporating them in. Sadly, though, I did not like the characters as much as I'd hoped I would. Maram was hands down my favorite, and I think Daud did a fantastic job in bringing her character to life and making her an intersting, complex villain, but I thought that Amani was just ok, and Idris was the worst. Mostly I hated the romance between Amani and Idris--it was completely unequally and really ruined the characters for me. I will say though that the cliffhanger at the end of the book had me completely and utterly shook, and, for that reason, I am very much looking forward to the next installment in this series.

Overall I give Mirage 4 out of 5 starts for being an interesting read with one of my new favorite villains, and I recommend it to anyone looking for a fun YA read.

Was this review helpful?