Member Reviews

Very informative! A well-detailed account of the ship I really had little knowledge of, except for the speech in the movie Jaws. Read Kindle version but I bet this would make a wonderful coffee table book

Was this review helpful?

What an outstanding job the authors did not only to research the history of the Indianapolis, but to research the lives of the men, themselves, and their families. This made the whole accounting much more human than just a clinical dissection of naval history.

It was beautifully written and there were really nice illustrations.

Once the book is published, I plan to buy a hardcopy and read/peruse it slowly, underlining, book marking and digesting it more thoroughly. I received this as an ARC from NetGalley and the publisher, Simon and Schuster.

Was this review helpful?

I requested and received a free review copy via NetGalley!

I really loved this book as it is about history, WWII. The writing is as if you are in the story, and so well defined.

The description of the ship, the sailors, their stories, of how it talks about Pearl Harbor, and then the sinking
of the Indianapolis. The writing is detailed and vivid, you feel the fear and terror that the sailors felt. Some of our service members so young that join to be a part of our U.S. Navy.

The Indianapolis sinking remains the Navy's second greatest loss of life in World War II. Out of a crew of 1,195, only 317 survived.

This is like one of my favorite books I read in a long time. I love history, and being married to a sailor, and listening to them go up and down the ship stairwells and all brought back memories for me. My sailor was on the U.S.S. Sierra that was a destroyer tender part of the WWII also.

Definitely pick a copy of this book, you will not be dissapointed.

Was this review helpful?

Lynn Vincent has done an incredible job of bringing not only the details of the events leading up to but also, during and after the tragic sinking of the USS Indianapolis. From the devastating kamikaze attack several months prior to the tragic sinking to the fight to clear Captain McVay's name, the facts are laid out in a riveting way with periods of pure horror at what the survivors endured during their 4 1/2 days in the deadly waters of the Pacific. I've always been inspired by the survivors of the Indianapolis who never gave up even when faced with certain death which certainly puts our ordinary everyday stresses in perspective. A must read for history/military history fans!

Was this review helpful?

Coming from these two authors, I knew this was going to be a good book. And it was. I don't usually do Military history. But something about this story pulled at me.

A true account of what happened to the ship and crew of the USS Indianapolis. After delivering precious cargo that would effectively end the war with Japan, she has limped on a course to complete the repairs that were not finished before they were pulled for a special top-secret mission. But they never made it. Torpedoed by the enemy and sank. 

A story of bravery, of teen-aged boys stepping up when needed. Of the fight to survive for those left alive in the dark water surrounded by deadly oil slicks and sharks. I am not going to lie, it was hard to read some of this but then these young men sacrificed their lives and as we learn more about each one we become invested in their survival.

A story of how a crew and an enemy came forward to save their Captain from an unjust court-martial.

Any military fans will love this in-depth look at our military history. I know I will never forget this one.

Netgalley/ Simon and Schuster  July 10, 2018

Was this review helpful?

A truly excellent book. Well-told, well-researched, comprehensive, and satisfying. I've read several books about the Indianapolis (all of them wonderful, really) and its sinking by torpedo at the end of the war, after which the survivors drifted in the ocean for four days before anyone happened upon them. But I'd forgotten or never known that the ship and crew had just finished delivering The Bombs that brought about the Japanese surrender, and I didn't know either about the nice occupatio of how the man who captained a navy sub, named for the Indianapolis, helped bring about the exoneration of Captain McVay. The ending passages, about the shipwreck's discovery, were perfect.

I imagine I'll be giving this one to my stepdad. Highly recommended.

Was this review helpful?

Reads like fiction: big time admiralty SNAFU allowing an important USN ship, cargo, and crew to be torpedoed and sunk without support so that too many died then and there and those who were alive weren't rescued for nearly a week. Then came the cover up, wrongful accusations, driving the captain to opt out of life. But it's not fiction, it's a well researched documentation of a very shameful event near the end of WW2. The survivors suffered badly without water in the remorseless South Pacific Ocean waiting for rescue and continued to suffer even afterwards. Extremely well written and meticulously researched, it brings it all to life and reality. A rewarding read.
I requested and received a free review copy via NetGalley. Thank you!

Was this review helpful?

WOW. Military history is usually not one of my first choices when I choose to read non-fiction, but I didn’t know anything about the USS Indianapolis and thought this would be a great opportunity to learn about it. I felt like this book was so much more than an education on history. It reads like a beautifully written novel, made only more compelling by the fact that everything actually happened. The authors did a fantastic job humanizing this history by interweaving the stories of the men on board, as well as their spouses back in the states, with major historical events associated with the ship. There were points were I wanted to laugh, cry, and cheer. If all history books were written like this I would never hesitate to dive in.

Was this review helpful?

Lynn Vincent and Sara Vladic have crafted an amazing read in "Indianapolis", with great insight into mission details, the actions and personalities of the crew. They write the "facts" but have the ability to wrap the facts with humanity that makes the story move. Captain Charles McVay is a case in point where even the good guys look bad, often for a long time. I enjoyed it and learned some more stuff.

Was this review helpful?

My review has been posted to Goodreads.

Review has also been tweeted as usual.

Thank you! :c)

Was this review helpful?

WOW does not even begin to tell how awesome this book is!!! I have read many WWII stories and this one surpasses them all. Lynn and Sara’s research was absolutely phenomenal and their story telling takes this disaster to a new level. One of the best written, most riveting books I have ever read. If I wasn’t reading it, I was thinking about it, or telling my husband what I had just read, and most times, I would tear up when relating the events. This story pulls you into every emotion you can imagine, I broke down crying with emotional tears several times, they were not sad tears, they were tears brought on by the actions of the rescuers, the survivors, or the showing of devotion they had for their captain. You feel love, caring, fear, heartache, loss, death, life, sacrifice, anger, and most of all, hope. Amid a horrible situation, heroes rose above the rest, the humanity effort by the rescuers was unbelievable.
I will remember this book for years to come and will re-read it at least once a year. It is that awesome!! There could not have been a better way to honor the men that gave their lives, to admire and respect the ones who survived but were changed forever and to remember the ones that agreed to finally tell their stories before that era is gone. Justice was finally served due to one tenacious young man and a bunch of survivors.
I now have two favorite books of my lifetime, this one and The Boys in the Boat by Daniel James Brown.
Phenomenal is the best word I can use to describe this book, it should be required reading in all high schools.
I received a complimentary copy of this book from Simon and Schuster through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own. This one gets 5*****’s, if I could, it would get 10**********, this is one of the best books I have ever read!!!

Was this review helpful?

Excellent history book. Well written. Very informative. I learned a lot. WW2 always fascinated me. I highly recommend this book.

Was this review helpful?

This is an amazing and staggering story about brave sailors and Marines facing impossible odds following the sinking of the USS Indianapolis in WW2. A highly readable and throughly researched book that tells a non-fiction story with some elements of reconstructed first person narrative. Well worth a read and will leave you with your heart in your throat for the entire book.

Was this review helpful?

What an incredible, compelling, and absorbing read. My interest in the Indianapolis began with that scene in Jaws where the crusty Quint reveals he was on board the vessel that delivered the bomb, the USS Indianapolis. It was a chilling story. The best part of this book are the survivors' stories. I had no idea what transpired during those 5 days afloat in the Pacific. It was also sad to read the stories of some of the survivors after the sinking, but heartwarming to read others' tales as well. This book is a comprehensive study of the Indianapolis' story in its entirety. I remember when it was found last year and this book is an excellent testament to the ship and her crew.

Was this review helpful?

If there were 10 stars, this book would receive them. This book was engrossing and exciting. It kept me reading late into the night. I was not familiar with the story and am so glad the authors do it justice. They represent the men of the Indianapolis respectfully and tell their stories with careful attention to detail without sounding like textbook. Even though we know what happened, it was an enthralling read. It was clearly a labor of love for the authors.

I received a digital copy through NetGalley for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Lynn Vincent and Sara Vladic’s collaborative history of the nation’s worst naval catastrophe is well constructed and researched. The result is an astounding record of submarine warfare against American warships and how a ship’s commander can be made culpable for over 800 deaths, a wrong only rectified after 50 years of bitter dispute.

The USS Indianapolis was a heavy cruiser launched in 1932 and through the years, before her sinking on July 30, 1945, she amassed a distinguished record of service. Eight battle stars had been awarded to her crew. She was instrumental in America’s victory at Iwo Jima and delivered the parts for the atomic bomb that demolished Hiroshima. But with the torpedoing that killed almost 900 of her 1,195 crewmen, her story became more about the sinking and the survivors of 4 days of brutal suffering from exhaustion, dehydration, saltwater virulence, drowning, and shark attacks.

The drama was painfully extended fby the court-martialing of the ship’s commander, Captain Charles B. McKay III. Naval officers far from the scene were more interested in covering their own rear ends than in finding the real cause of the sinking. They piled on McKay and he was shamefully convicted of failing to zigzag his ship despite testimony from numerous experts that it wouldn’t have made of difference in getting torpedoed. It was a pitifully weak conviction. He suffered with that indignity until 1968 when he shot himself in despair. Congress eventually exonerated him in 2000, long after his death. The surviving crewmembers never waivered in their support for their commander.

The book extensively covers the sinking, the survival, the trial, and the painful aftermath using straightforward language and thorough research. The trial proceedings deserve special mention for their accuracy and interest.

Both authors had accumulated an immense amount of research materials; Vincent in her role as a veteran investigative reporter and Vladic as an acclaimed filmmaker with a particular interest in the Indianapolis disaster. It’s an amazing collaboration of material that combines the explicit facts with riveting personal accounts. One cannot read the story without both being disgusted with naval authority failings and sorrowful at the suffering of the victims and the ship’s commander. It’s an amazing accounting that I won’t soon forget.

Was this review helpful?

The story of the sinking of the Indianapolis has been told repeatedly over the years, but this appears to be the definitive account.
The Indianapolis delivered the uranium for Fat Man and Little Boy, making it possible to assemble the bombs that would end WWII. Job done, she set out on her next voyage...and never arrived.
Unfortunately nobody noticed.
Her distress messages didn't get out with all the necessary information. 1195 men found themselves sinking in the ocean after a Japanese submarine torpedoed their ship. Many died as a result of the sinking, trapped in the ship wreckage, leaving hundreds swimming, struggling to get to rafts and flotation devices. There they waited for days, coated in bunker fuel oil, suffering from their injuries, hungry and thirsty. The sharks took them one by one.
They were found by chance when a seaplane on patrol noticed the oil slick and looked for the source. Once found, the rescue took place in piecemeal fashion, and the Navy covered things up. Three out of every four crewmen on the Indianapolis died.
Captain McVay survived, and the Navy decided to make him the scapegoat for the sinking. For decades he was a pariah to all except his surviving crew, who still honored him at reunions. McVay ultimately committed suicide. He didn't live to see his ultimate vindication, generated by a high school kid working on a history project for school. The youth contacted survivors, assembled memorabilia and oral accounts, and pushed an effort to change the way the Indianapolis sinking was viewed in history.
History can be fixed. It just needs to happen while the people who lived it are still around.

Was this review helpful?

Indianapolis is an outstanding telling of the ship that was entrusted with the responsibility of carrying the atomic weapons that led to the end of World War II in Japan... and then was sunk shortly afterwards. It is the story of how the men survived five days in in shark-infested waters while the Navy bumbled about, not even knowing that the ship was missing until some of the survivors were spotted by a passing plane. It is the story of how the captain of the vessel was unjustly blamed for everything that happened -- and finally was absolved of guilt for the incident, decades after his death from suicide.

At times, this book reads almost like a fiction book. The stories of the sailors being surrounded by sharks, going crazy, and struggling to survive, are exciting and horrifying because they are true. You care for the people in this story as you get to know them, and I admit that I cried at the end when the ship's captain finally received justice.

This is a beautifully written story that would be great for history buffs, people that are interested in World War II, and people that like to see good finally triumph over corruption and miscarriages of justice.

I will be reviewing this book from another angle and will publish to my blog on June 11th.

Was this review helpful?

Phenomenal, engrossing, riveting, devastating---all of these (and more) apply to Vincent's book about the USS Indianapolis. Following the ship from just a little while before it was attacked by a Japanese sub and ending as recently as last year, Vincent has arranged an amazingly coherent narrative that gives intricate insight into mission details, the actions and personalities of the crew, and pointed answers, almost in a paint-by-numbers fashion, as to just how the sinking of this ship blossomed into such an untold catastrophe.

It would be easy to focus for the most part on the men's struggles at sea (as that is the most publicized part); I mean, isn't that right? As the book is quick to point out, a great majority of today's awareness of the ship comes from the film Jaws, and I'll raise my hand to that effect, as I'm definitely one among that particular crowd. Vincent seems to be quite aware of the fascination of this part of the story, and gives it proper due without giving in to the temptation of sensationalizing the ordeal. Many pages will be turned over to reveal heart-wrenching deaths, survival against the odds, and humbling conclusions that further cement these men (and their loved ones) as champions beyond comprehension.

The final third of the book outlines the court-martial trial of the captain of the Indianapolis and subsequent attempts to reinstate him, despite the verdict and the shaky, shady events that preceded it. Modern proponents and allies of the survivors are highlighted as they take up the mantle, working in tandem with what's left of the crew to secure the ship's legacy, writhing in the agony of a stubborn bureaucracy, and celebrating in the ecstasy of legal victory.

You'll close the book and likely have a somber moment (or several) in remembrance for the crew and what they had to endure for over half a century. A lesser book might have either been too clinical or weighed too heavily on the survival at sea (as mentioned earlier); Vincent wonderfully reveals the story in its entirety, showing what adversity can cause us to become, for better or for worse, warts and all.

A most supreme recommendation from me. You'll be floored.

Many thanks to NetGalley, as well as to Simon & Schuster for the advance read.

Was this review helpful?

Wow! Lynn Vincent and Sara Vladic have crafted an amazing read in "Indianapolis" that puts you in the middle of a seemingly unbelievable tale of war, loss, brotherhood, victory, faith and determination as they unpack the story of the USS Indianapolis. From the time at sea through the secret journey to deliver components for Little Man to the heart-pounding torpedo attack and sinking of the ship through the survivors time adrift waiting for rescue days later, a clear visual picture is drawn of the surroundings as well as the people involved in this heroic tale. As fascinating as the story was leading up to the rescue, what happened in the months, years and decades since is also an amazing tale unto its own. The dogged determination of survivors and their families to right the record about what happened combined with the involvement of the final USS Indianapolis submarine commander make for a compelling read. Sara Vladic became enthralled with this story as a teenager and she has made it a key part of her life to capture and share the story of this crew - that passion was evident within the pages. Lynn Vincent and Sara Vladic pull from myriad sources to tell a story that keeps you interested from the first page until the end (and even the end pages are an interesting read, too) - this book is a great example of a well crafted narrative nonfiction that I find to be some of the best writing around. In the days since reading it, I have already recommended it to at least 3 people and keep coming back to the story in conversation with others.

I received an ARC through NetGalley and Simon & Schuster to read in exchange for my honest review. This book is released July 10th. I look forward to buying my own copy of this in hardback for my personal library.

Was this review helpful?