Member Reviews
I was so anxious to read this story by Jodi Picoult and am so thankful to the publisher and Netgalley for the opportunity to read in exchange for my review. Thank you!
I thought the way that Jodi Picoult took on this controversial topic was brilliant. This story will really make you think about the pro-choice/pro-life option that we have. I will say that I was sort of confused in my reading by going back an hour each chapter because we usually go forward, but I was able to keep up easily.
When Wren and her Aunt Bex go to the Women's Clinic to get some birth control pills for Wren, they never could have imagined how their day would turn out. While they are in the clinic, a father whose daughter had gone to the clinic for an abortion comes in and shoots some of the people in the clinic while taking the others hostage. Wren frantically sends a message to her father, Hugh, who is a hostage negotiator. When Hugh finds out that his sister and daughter are in the clinic, he knows that it is a conflict of interest for him to be on the negotiation, but he keeps it a secret as long as he can in order to be able to try to help and get them out alive.
As the negotiation goes on, some are shot and others are injured. Hugh finally tells that his daughter and sister are in the clinic and is almost pulled off the case until the mad man calls his cell phone and lets him know that he found out that Wren is his daughter. Hugh is determined now to get everyone, especially Wren and Bex, out alive.
I respected Jodi Picoult for the way that she wrote this story and the amount of research that had to be done on the topic for both sides. I enjoyed reading this one and look forward to many more from Jodi in the near future!
Oh my god you guys, I actually read this book months ago and I’m still thinking about it today. As soon as I received a copy I dropped everything and started it and it totally blew me away. It has her trademark hard hitting subject matter and deeply moving storyline and she rips her storylines straight from the headlines like no ones else does. If you read one book I recommended this year I urge you to make it this one, I feel like we can all learn something profound from this book.
The structure of this was amazing, it’s told in reverse order which always sounds super confusing but if it’s done well then it’s a little bit of magic and if anyone has the magic touch it’s Picoult. I don’t know how else to describe her writing other than to say it’s beautiful and even poetic at times and she’s writing about this god awful tragedy and still hope and beauty shines through.
Abortion is arguably one of the hottest of hot button topics of all time and I so admire how Picoult examines the issue from every single angle you can think of, and also from some you would never think of yourself. She forces you to consider your own personal values and morals while doing so sensitively and with so much respect. I don’t usually expect straight up fiction novels to be twisty but she also manages to throw a knock down punch (or two) that made me gasp in disbelief. This book was total perfection in my eyes and I cannot wait to see where she takes me next.
Spark of Light in three words: Profound, Emotional and Incredible.
Whew - Where to even start! Another beautifully written, well researched book, by Jodi Picoult.
I thought Small Great Things was thought provoking? This book was even more so. Definitely touched on just about every emotion and feeling I have. Sadness, curiousity, anger. At times, in this book, you have to stop reading and just take a breath. Well written, as usual, and a great story of fiction, with lots of factual information to back it up. Jodi's commentary at the end, was a great personal touch, even though I can almost guarantee it'll cost her some readers. Just because we can't agree to disagree in this world. I have already recommended this book to all my friends who are avid readers like me, and even those who aren't.
I received this book free of change from NetGalley in exchange for my honest review.
Jodi Picoult is never one to shy away from controversial topics. This book is no exception. It tackles the tough subject of abortion.
The story is told in reverse and works backwards in time. You find out that George has comes into an abortion clinic and started shooting the place and people up. The story follows the stories of several different women who are in the clinic as well as the doctor who chose to work at the clinic and the police officer, who is the hostage negotiator and the father of one of the patients in the clinic.
At first, I had a hard time keeping several of the woman straight but as the story wove on it was easier and you found out that not everyone in the clinic was there for an abortion. Some were there for other female health issues. I wish I could say more abot the book but, spoilers!
In true Jodi Picoult fashion, there is a twist at the end of the book. I never see them coming.
I can't wait to see her in person in Oct and get a hard copy of this book for my collection.
One of the things that I love about Jodi Picoult books is her ability to tell a story that not only tugs at your heart, but also makes you think deeply about issues. This book is no different, however, I felt in the end that it leaned just a little too far supporting one side of the abortion issue than the other. Usually the author is a master of letting the reader come to their own conclusions, instead of taking a more political stance. That and the reverse storyline, made the book just a tad less enjoyable for me than her usual books. With that said, I will definitely be eagerly awaiting her next novel, as her writing style is still beautiful and the stories well told.
I am a huge fan of Jodi Picoult and tried all summer to get this book. I was SO happy when I got it. Thank you! As usual, it was terrific. The topic of the book is abortion. Picoult takes you through every scenario that touches on the subject. I found myself agreeing with every one of them. Picoult "forces" you to consider every aspect of abortion and the centers that perform them. I LOVED this book!
Quite a hefty topic in this book so be prepared to take a break every so often just to lighten up. I have read quite a few Jodi Picoult books and unfortunately this was not one of my favorites. It will still have a place on my library shelves although I don't see occupying it for long. This book is sure to be devoured by loyal Picoult fans.
On the whole this book brought many sides of an important issue to light. The beginning and ending chapters were the best. I didn't care for the reverse order of time the middle was written in although I understand why the author did it. The passages which correspond to the title are points to be pondered
Thank you. Netgalley for the advanced copy.
I love Jodi Picoult. I really do. I would say this is the second novel I didn't fall in love with. Humpback Whale... not a fan. This one... it didn't pull me like the rest.
Not sure if it was the style, how each chapter was an hour previous? It wasn't the subject matter. Just something was off. The ending was rushed and halted.
Maybe I need to re-read it again. Or sometimes you are in a mood when you read a book. Was I disappointed. A little. But hey, not all can be perfect, right?
I received an advanced copy of this book through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. This book had me on the edge of my seat the whole time! It was definitely a book that kept you thinking! I would definitely recommend this book to fellow readers. Thank you!
This book was well written. The author did a good job of describing the location and the characters to the point I could imagine it all. However, I didn't care for the backwards timeline. I felt it was hard to pinpoint what I should know and what hasn't happened yet. The subject was controversial but is ok. I was able to see the story from everyone's point of view and it makes you think. Plus some of the facts about abortion in the book I didn't know and helped broaden my own opinion.
As always Jodi Picoult out does herself with another book that makes you question how you would handle a similar situation. The subjects of her books are always on the controversial side, hopefully causing the reader to consider long held beliefs.
I was thrilled to receive this ARC as I’m a big fan of Jodi Picoult. I’ve had this on my list for month when I saw she would have a new release this fall. The author always takes on touchy subjects with sensitivity and tact. It pains me to say I struggled through this one (took me 6 days). I’m not a fan of reverse storytelling and it detracted so much for me.
So here’s the deal. I absolutely adore Jodi Picoult and will read anything she puts out. In all fairness, I always have unusually high expectations for her stories. Maybe that’s unrealistic because this book disappointed me. It started off well enough with an intriguing storyline. But then it became very disjointed, hard to follow, not compelling. I mean, it took me nine days to finish which is an unheard of amount of time with me for a book by a favorite author. And honestly, I probably would have abandoned it if it were by most other writers. But I stuck with it, hoping the pendulum would swing back. Sadly, it didn’t. It’s hard for me to pinpoint exactly what it is that threw me off. I will say, though, that the time reversal aspect of the storyline was a huge downside for me. By the time I got to the end, well actually the beginning, there was no element of intrigue. No suspense, no plot twist to bring it all home. Sure, there was one little moment. But that’s not enough to save the story in this case. My review is not meant to dissuade anyone from reading this one, as it won’t keep me from eagerly anticipating her next one. It just is what it is.
First of all, I'd like to start off that I have never read any of Jodi Picoult's books. I didn't pick any of her book due to the hypes. I don't like to be influenced by other people's opinions. I received this copy about a month ago from Net Galley but I didn't jump into it due to the fact I was reading books by their published dates. However, the cover of this book kept beckoning me. Finally, picked it and started reading it Friday and finished the next morning.
I appreciate the fact that Ms. Picoult did her research on one of the most controversial and sensitive subject of all time. She did this from all different perspectives of all of her characters in this book.
However, I was irated that the book went into reversed timeline which made it more disconnected with the characters and the topics the author was conveying. Just annoying to the point where I vowed to DNF any book with reversed timeline in the future.
I would give this book 3 3/4 stars for this book, for good research, perspective, beautiful cover (the reason of the colors is in this book) and plot. Negative: reversed timeline, disconnection, storyline too general which will not stay with me long after I read this book.
I received this ARC from Net Galley and Random Publishing House/Ballaline in exchange for my unbiased and honest review.
Generally I either love or hate Picoult's novels, this one fell squarely in the middle, which is unusual.
Initially it felt the story was comprised solely for shock value, and I disliked the reverse timeline. However as the story progressed, I liked it more and more. With the author's note at the end, it felt complete. (Or as close as one can get regarding a subject as divisive as abortion.)
A teenaged girl asks her beloved aunt to take her to the local reproductive clinic to obtain birth control. While they're seated in the waiting room, a gunman enters the clinic and opens fire. What follows is a compelling narrative following each of the hostages, along with the gunman, his family, and the hostage negotiator and his family, tracking back through the past to see what brought each one to where they were on this day.
Taking place over the course of less than 12 hours, A Spark of Light is an incredibly intense, well rounded exploration of a deeply emotional and complicated issue. There were a few times I felt the author was redundant and unnecessarily graphic, which I've encountered previously in her writing. Fans of Picoult will enjoy this reading experience, as well as readers looking for a fast paced novel.
This is another home run for Picoult, who is an amazing storyteller. This is a creatively told story of a women's clinic, in Mississippi, in fact the only clinic in Mississippi that performs abortions. It is told on one particular day, backwards. That's right... the story starts at almost the end of the day and goes back an hour at a time, to tell the story of what took place on this day. This was done AMAZINGLY well, because you do not know what you do not know, until you know it, as the day goes backwards. On one side of the clinic, there is a fence, and behind it are the anti-abortion group, that does their best to change the minds of any women who enter the clinic to have an abortion. They do this through both kindness and insult. In addition to individuals from this group, the story centers on a number of amazing characters. There is George Goddard, a born again Christian, who is responsible for turning the day upside down, for all the individuals who are at the center, or near it, on this particular day. His daughter, apparently, previously visited the clinic, and he has now returned with anger and a gun, to teach them all a lesson for what they have "done" to his daughter. There is Wren McElroy, a 15 year old girl who is raised by her Dad, and is visiting on this particular day with her Aunt Bex. Olive, an older women who is there to go over some medical information with the nurse practitioner, who she has regularly seen for her gynecological needs. Hugh McElroy, the hostage negotiator who arrives on the scene, after the announcement over the police radio of an active shooter on site at the clinic, who also happens to be Wren's Dad. Janine Deguerre, who is at the clinic to have her initial appointment at the clinic, to be able to get an abortion. However, Janine has a secret, as well, that will change how everyone at the clinic sees her. Joy Perry, who had her abortion performed at the clinic, on this monumental day, and gives kindness, even where others think it may not be due. Izzy Walsh a nurse who comes to the clinic after her late shift at the hospital, she is pregnant with her first child and not 100% sure what to do about this. Her boyfriend Parker does not know she is pregnant. Dr. Louie Ward - an amazing doctor who performs abortions, who is also a devout christian. He is devoted to the care of women, and as such, does not want women to have to take abortions into their own hands, where they jeopardize or lose their own lives, like his mother did when he was a child. Rachel, a part time angel, who guides the women through the chaos of the anti-abortion protestors, from the parking lot into the clinic. Vonita, the brave and kind clinic owner, who works tirelessly to run the clinic and keep it open, even after it was burned down, in previous years, and Beth, a 12 year old girl who finds herself handcuffed to a hospital bed, after she was brought in post hemorrhage, and a brush with death due to tremendous blood loss, after giving herself an abortion, when she was unable to get one at the clinic. Soon after, she finds herself under arrest for the death of her unborn child.
The story is expertly woven in and around all of these characters, and you learn how each individual is connected on this day. The story starts where most stories end, and builds on the lives of these individuals, until you understand all of them well, and the reasons why they are all together or connected on this particular day. Having read this, I feel I know more about the human psyche, particularly in the area of abortion and reproductive health and what drives each person to do what they need to on this one day in their lives. The characters are so sharp, they practically leap off the page.
I cannot say enough good things about this novel. I love all of Jodi Picoult's books, and am amazed by each new book she writes.... how could they possibly be better than the last book she wrote? But they are... and this is likely the best book yet.
This book feels...well, like every other Jodi Picoult book. Which is a good in some ways. It is well researched and very readable. So readable I tore few it in just a couple of days. But at the same time feels overly familiar and formulaic. And what I imagine were meant to be twists or surprises in the plot were pretty predictable for the most part. I also didn't love the reverse timeline. Overall, though, it's a solid book, and probably one of the better Picoult books I've read in recent years. Every time I read one of her new books I say it will be the last time. And yet I keep coming back, I think I've read just about everything she's ever written.
Jodi Picolt is one of my favorite authors and I was looking forward to reading her newest book. I was disappointed in the style of this book. The story went backwards starting with the devastating event at the beginning and then going back to describe the lives of the characters. The book is very well written and characterized what is going on in our country now which is scary and could take away women ‘s rights. Picolt made her point and it is a significant one. I just wish that it had moved forward rather than backwards.
I could hardly finish this book. I finally skipped to the epilogue after the “10:00” chapter.
1. I did not like the backwards storytelling. The first couple chapters were good, but I grew weary of going back one hour earlier over and over again while each character shared their memories.
2. It was hard to keep all the women in the clinic straight—which ones were there for what.
3. Picoult’s pro-choice agenda triggered a “here we go” eye roll....that soon led to my “get off your soapbox and tell the story!” reaction. She is free to voice her theories but I don’t have to agree. I do not support any part of this political agenda. People need to stay out of womens’ business and their choices. Stop using this to support or take down political candidates.
4. There were loose ends everywhere when the story ended. It seems Picoult was sidetracked by the political agenda and forgot that she left several characters hanging.
Advanced reader copy courtesy of the publishers at NetGalley for review.