I love the Victorian era setting. It may even be my new favorite in historical fiction. The author did an awesome job with her worldbuilding. I was thoroughly transported to this industrial community with progress and dirt commingling everywhere. I can smell the smoke, inhale the dust, got blinded with the flashes of the camera’s bulb, and gagged at the various forms of stench and morbidity. I didn’t know that hanging was such a fascinating topic. I learned so much about it through reading this morbid and fun mystery.

Needless to say, I was hooked right from the start. This novel surprised me at just how good it is. I was kind of hesitant at first when I realized it’s the third book in a series, but the author’s skillfull writing made sure I’m all caught up. I personally did not like all the exposition—sometimes it can be glaring and repetitive for me, but I do know it can help with other’s reading experience. The plot twists are still so satisfying and totally unexpected.

I really loved Sarah’s team. They don’t plan ahead with their adventures. I’m always worried something bad would happen and unfortunately I’m often right. I admire their courage and passion despite the risks they are facing. Even though they sometimes use questionable means in their investigative process, their hearts are in the right place. I am now thinking of reading the first two books just to know more about how their unique friendship formed. I would highly recommend this book to anyone who loves historical crime/mystery fiction. Truly unputdownable!

I’m frustrated by this book and, indeed, this whole series. The book had promise - a great premise, fairly evocative of time and place, and a truly interesting and exciting mystery. But the execution, as with the first two books, is just disappointing. While the mystery (both the individual mystery and the series-spanning mystery about Sarah’s family) is great, the interplay between the characters continues to be tedious. The book and series is full of tiresome people making stupid choices. Although the book was not especially long, it took me forever to read, mostly because I had to psych myself into picking it back up. Usually reading is my first choice of activity, but with this book, I was easily distracted by almost anything else. Even when I was enjoying the book - and I really did enjoy the parts specifically about the interesting and well-plotted murder - I was nervous, knowing that eventually I’d get back to the whining and angst of Sarah, Mick and Hugh’s personal lives. I really can’t recommend this book or series.

The Hangman's Secret is a well-paced novel, written with great care regarding all details of life in the Victorian London. While reading, you feel as if you are actually on London streets by the end of the 19th century. The plot is interesting and the suspense is there until the end of the novel. The main characters, Sarah Baine and Hugh Staunton, having worked earlier on Jack the Ripper case, this time solve the mystery murder of a publican-cum-executioner. Language is modern, sometimes too modern as for my liking. When you forget the setting of the novel, you might think the story is about modern London. One thing which might be a little discouraging a reader is the fact that Sarah too often refers to the previous case that is unknown if you have never read The Ripper's Shadow, which is the case with me. All in all, a recommendable Victorian mystery.

You can find this review and all of my others over at www.readbookrepeat.wordpress.com

This book is due to be published on the 18th of January 2019

Sarah, Hugh and Mick are awakened early one morning from rapping on their windows. They race to get ready, grab their photography equipment and head out for another day. They photograph crime scenes for the Daily World newspaper, and have also been known to help solve a couple of crimes themselves. Once they get to the crime scene at the pub The Hangman's Daughter, they are sickened by what they find. Harry the hangman has been murdered, hung in such a way that his head has come clean off and it seems that there are no clues as to who was responsible. As they investigate further, Sarah and Co. fall down the rabbit hole of secrets upon secrets when they learn that the murder may have to do with a hanging of a woman named Amelia Carlisle, The Baby Butcher, and what transpired at her hanging. Though thanks to the Secrets Act the other people present aren't at liberty to tell anyone what happened that day, letalone reporters for the Daily World. Sarah and Co. must find out what really happened that day in order to solve the mystery of the hangman's botched hanging and time is running out, fast. Who hung the hangman? Did it have anything to do with the baby butcher's hanging? And will Sarah and Barrett's relationship stand the test of this mystery?

Once again, I didn't realise that this was part of a series when I requested it, though this is book three in said series, and I haven't read the previous two books, it really does not impact the story at all. If anything, I've only missed the relationship evolution between Sarah, Hugh, Mick and Barrett, which I can live with, it honestly didn't impact the story at all or make it hard to understand what was going on.

I loved the Victorian setting that this book is written in, there's something about stories written in the world of the 1800s that just gives a certain charm to the novel. I found myself many times thinking about how murder mysteries these days often give the characters so many more abilities when it comes to proving the truth. Such as with revelations, when that moment happens where whodunit? is answered. When that pivotal part came about in this story, I found myself almost wishing it was written as a modern mystery because that would mean that the characters could record what was being said on the handy mobile phone that everyone has. Alas, it was not to be, as come on now, we're in the 1800s here, and I must admit, it does add that extra bit of suspense and anxiety, to me anyway, worrying that the culprit will get away, that there won't be sufficient proof to put them away. I believe this falls under one of those charms I was talking about earlier. Rowland has such a way with the written word. I felt completely immersed into the world of London in the 1880's, I felt like I could taste the coal dust on my tongue, that I could see the smog and the pollution that the characters had to walk through. Rowland also has a beautiful way of illustrating what life was like for a woman in that time through the small things. *Gasp* a woman reporter?! A woman asking questions?! OH THE SHOCK HORROR! I love it.

The characters were well written. Sarah Bain is a fantastic character and I thoroughly enjoyed reading about her jaunt to catch a killer. Hugh is so likable, I absolutely love that Rowland has included Hugh in the story as she has, a gay man in 1880's London, and it's no secret, the poor man has had his secret laid bare for all to see and scrutinise. He deals with it swimmingly, and I feel like he's almost my favourite character because of his strength and the way he is portrayed. Mick...I honestly found Mick to be increasingly annoying as the book progressed. I get that things were different back then and that men had to become men at such a young age, but something about him being 14, trying to win the heart of a 19 year old actress, and declaring that he doesn't need to go to school while speaking with poor English, just absolutely grates on me. I just really didn't like him at all. I felt no empathy towards him and just wanted to smack him upside the head and tell him to get to school and learn how to speak properly. Honestly though, that's just me, either you like a character or you don't, and in this instance, I really didn't like him one bit. Barrett was a great character, he loves Sarah so much, he will do anything for her, and while he wishes that she would quit the paper and marry him so he could care for her, he does not push the subject and understands her love for independence. The romance between them was tastefully done and didn't overshadow the main plot of the story at all. It was a lovely addition. Sir Gerald's character was such a mean, ask no questions man but I found myself strangely liking him.

The mystery itself was amazing!! I honestly had NO IDEA whodunit, none whatsoever. I had my inklings and suspects, as there is good reason for a few characters to have murdered the hangman, not until the characters found out did it all become glaringly clear. The way the mystery was written was fantastic, the twists and turns were done phenomenally, I loved the sub-mystery of Sarah's Father as well as the inclusion of the baby butcher's mystery. It was all so wonderful and I felt myself becoming elated along with the characters when they discovered something new, another step towards finding out what had happened.

all in all this was a wonderful mystery and was a seriously satisfying read. I'm interested to read the previous two books in this series and see how they stack up.

The Hangman’s Secret by Laura Joh Rowland
BLURB~
“From award-winning author Laura Joh Rowland, a story about the darkness that lurks within and the deadly secrets that beg to be revealed.
Intrepid photographer Sarah Bain and her motley crew of friends are back to hunt criminals in the dark, seedy underbelly of Victorian London, but little do they know, the darkness may lurk closer than they first divined.
Photographer Sarah Bain and her friends Lord Hugh Staunton and sometime street urchin Mick O’Reilly are private detectives with a new gig―photographing crime scenes for London’s Daily World newspaper. The Daily World is the latest business venture of their sole client, Sir Gerald Mariner, a fabulously wealthy and powerful banker. 
One cold, snowy January morning, Sarah, Hugh, and Mick are summoned to the goriest crime scene they’ve ever encountered. A pub owner named Harry Warbrick has been found hanged and decapitated amid evidence of foul play. His murder becomes a sensation because he was England’s top hangman and he’s met the same fate that he inflicted on hundreds of criminals.Sir Gerald announces that the Daily World―meaning Sarah and her friends―will investigate and solve Harry Warbrick’s murder before the police do. The contest pits Sarah against the man she loves, Police Constable Barrett. She and her friends discover a connection between Harry Warbrick’s murder and the most notorious criminal he ever executed―Amelia Carlisle, the “Baby-Butcher,” who murdered hundreds of infants placed in her care. 
REVIEW~
This book is the third in the Victorian Mysteries series but can certainly be read as a standalone. It is told from the perspective of our protagonist, Sarah Bain. A scrappy and independent gal, which was uncommon in such times. I really liked her character.
I must say I found this to be an intriguing premise for a novel. The author’s writing style has quality. She is efficient at providing background information that helps readers that haven’t read the first two books, to understand what is going on. The characters play well off one another and each has their individual roles in the story. Each also has their own troubles, which enliven and enrich the tale.
The characters were fascinating and likeable. An unlikely group of friends who are amateur sleuths, each having their own backstories that add more to the tale. There is suspense, mystery, romance-all set in 18990s London. Each of the characters add to the story and make it an enjoyable read. It is a page turner that had me guessing till the very end, and what an ending it was! I had no clue who the killer was, although I had suspicions throughout the story. There are many to be suspicious of. SO many suspects., but each is ruled out. Just as Sarah gets closer to solving the mystery, she finds herself in more imminent danger.
The book was paced quite well. A steady stream of action and introduction of characters helped the narrative to flow easily. This was an enjoyable read. An intense mystery, though it was a light read for me. It was engaging and entertaining. I plan to read the first two in the series so that I can get to know the characters better since they are all so interesting.
The only criticism I have, is the verbalizations between the characters didn’t seem to fit well given the time period. The conversations and verbiage used seemed more modern. This, I feel, was an oversight that could not be ignored given the fact that otherwise, everything seemed so authentic. SO, I am giving it a 4/5 stars.
All in all, it is a book that I enjoyed and enough so that I will surely read more of her work. I would also recommend this book despite my one misgiving.
I was given this book by the publisher via Netgalley in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This review, or portions thereof, will be posted (when able) on Amazon, B&N, Goodreads, Kobo, IG, FB, Pinterest, Litsy, and my own blog.
Unfortunately, I am unable to provide links to all sites as I am using my phone.
On various sites I am:
Pinterest~ Pinterest.com/katskraps
Barnes & Noble~ Karyl-Ahn-white_7
Litsy~ Karylahn or Karyl White

3.5 stars
I am fascinated by the Victorian Era, and this series has been on my wish list since it began so I jumped at the chance to read this third installment, THE HANGMAN’S SECRET. With its plucky protagonist, heaps of atmosphere, and an intriguing mystery, the book did not disappoint.

Sarah, a professional photographer, and her friends Lord Hugh Stanton and Mick O’Reilly have formed an investigative team of sorts, having had success with prior cases (books one and two). They are hired by Gerald Mariner to take photos of crime scenes for his newspaper. When they are called to the particularly grisly scene of pub owner and hangman Harry Warbrick’s death, a competition soon erupts between the investigators and the police to see who can solve the case first. This is particularly hard for Sarah as her love interest is part of the police force. The investigation leads to a cover up at the prison involving the hanging of notorious baby killer Amelia Carlisle. Time is against them as more people connected to the hanging die.

I enjoyed every twisty turn in THE HANGMAN’S SECRET. The pace is a bit slow in the beginning but quickly picks up, as does the tension in the tale. Rowland successfully weaves historical figures and places into the story, giving it some gravitas. The characters are a little outlandish, but here is where the fun lies. They are so eccentric, one cannot help but root for them. In addition to the main murder mystery, there is an ongoing subplot about Sarah’s father and her romance with Constable Barrett that fills out the book.

THE HANGMAN’S SECRET is darker than a traditional cozy mystery, but I think any mystery reader, especially fans of historical mysteries, will enjoy time spent with Sarah and crew.

I received a copy of this title from Crooked Lane Books through NetGalley and voluntarily shared my thoughts here.

An early morning knock on the door summons photographer Sarah Bain and her associates, Lord Hugh Staunton and former street urchin, Mick O'Reilly to yet another crime scene. The three had formed a detective agency based on the success of their first two investigations. However, their employment by Sir Gerald Mariner at the London Daily World has kept them busy. This crime scene is particularly gruesome. The most well-known hangman in England, Harry Warbrick, has been hanged in his pub and in the process, decapitated. The police are ready to declare it a suicide, but our detectives think it has to be murder, and Sir Gerald agrees. Always on the lookout to increase the circulation of his tabloid, Sir Gerald kicks off a contest between the Daily World and the police. The competition can only cause conflict with Sarah's love interest, PC Barrett...again. It appears that the murder is connected to the recent hanging of a notorious criminal; Amelia Carlisle, who murdered many infants placed in her care. No one who witnessed the hanging will talk about it, pleading the Official Secrets Act.

Once again, Laura Joh Rowland takes us into the seamier side of Victorian London, among the highest and lowest members of society. There are a plethora of characters, both old and new, but Rowland characterizes them all so well, I was able to keep them all sorted. Underpinning the main storyline is Sarah's search for her missing father, who may have murdered a child, and her fraught relationship with PC Barrett. In my opinion, the romantic link takes up too much time in The Hangman's Secret and detracts somewhat. The secrets she is forever keeping from Barrett don't augur well for the future, even with a possible resolution in the book. I also found the vocabulary used not in keeping with the time and place and the general tone a little too modern. For example, I have never heard the word "candy" used by my British friends and relations. They all use "sweet." Those problems do not detract from the excellence of the plotting and characterization, however.

Thanks to NetGalley and Crooked Lane for an advance digital copy. The opinions are my own.

3,5 Stars

All in all, I enjoyed the book. Would I pick up other novels in this series? I don't think I'd seek them out, but I'd definitely pick them up for a lighter read. :)

Fans of historical mysteries set in the Victorian period should give it a try.

___________
I'd like to thank to the publisher for giving me the opportunity to read this book in exchange for my honest review

I did not read the first two books of this series but the story was easy to follow with plenty of references to the events and outcomes of the previous books.

The Hangman's Secret was an easy and quick read for me that flowed well and kept my interest throughout. The mystery/crime-solving element of the story was straight-forward and linear but the secondary mystery, which will probably be explored in the next novel, had a surprising twist I didn’t see coming.

I just didn't feel really connected to the story because I didn't find Sarah relatable, or very likable to be honest, and it’s an issue when you don't care for the character who is narrating the story.

The Hangman's Secret by Laura Joh Rowland is #3 in her Victorian mystery series but reads very well as a standalone. This novel follows photographer Sarah Bain and her two cohorts Sir Hugh and Mick who are tasked with photographing crime scenes for the London Daily Mail. The story starts with the hanging death of hangman Harry Warbrink. The trio are on the hunt for the perpetrator of this faked suicide. They are in a race with the police department to solve this crime. And then, as they say, the plot thickens. This novel is a joy to read and maintains the tension until the very end. There is a love story, lies, murders, mayhem, deception, all-in-all, a very entertaining read. Highly recommended for anyone who enjoys a good old-fashioned suspenseful yarn. Thank you to Crooked Lane Books, the author and NetGalley for the e-ARC in exchange for an honest review.

I received a complimentary ARC copy The Hangman’s Secret (#Victorian #Mystery No.3) by Laura Joh Rowland from NetGalley & Crooked Lane Books in order to read and give an honest review.

Another fantastic book in Laura Joh Rowland’s Victorian Mystery series featuring photographer and private detective Sarah Bain. Rowland, a master at writing fast-paced, suspenseful whodunits again keeps readers on the edge of their seat with this newest entry. I have been fortunate enough to read and review her first two books in the series, the first The Ripper’s Shadow and the second A Mortal Likeness, all three fantastic mysteries I would recommend.
This time around as the story opens we see Sarah Bain has landed on her feet from the previous book A Mortal Likeness. She is working as a photographer for Sir Gerald Mariner, photographing crime scenes for his London newspaper the Daily World. Sarah, Hugh, and Mick are living and working together, her relationship with Constable Barrett is going well, life seems perfect...until a call to photograph the corpse of the decapitated body of a well-known hangman, Harry Warbrick. After initially considered suicide when Sir Gerald gets wind that it was under suspicious terms, he decides to launch a contest, a race to see whether they can beat the police and solve the crime. The contest puts Sarah in a precarious position, she will have to hide what she finds from her police officer lover after they had just survived the events of the last book, "A Mortal Likeness". Sarah is convinced that Warbrick's murder is somehow a result of something that occurred at the execution of Amelia Carlisle, the “Baby-Butcher,” who'd killed hundreds of infants in her care. While investigating Sarah is plagued by political cover-ups, run-ins with dangerous people and an old animosity rears it’s ugly head when a former nemesis, Inspector Reid, is back and as threatening as ever.

The case tests Sarah like none other, her life, reputation, relationship, friendships, and job are all in jeopardy and my heart breaks for her throughout the book. Just when you think it can’t get any worse Rowland throws another twist that will keep you on an emotional roller-coaster. I won't reveal anymore but if you are a fan of clever, fast-paced, mysteries this is definitely a must read.

Historical mysteries, especially Victorian ones set in London, are a favorite of mine. When Laura Joh Rowland turned her immense writing skills from her Japanese series to Victorian London, I knew I was going to have another great series to add to my ever growing TBR pile. This is the third in the series and it's great. Set in a time when women are just starting to make their mark in business, Sarah Bain is a woman very much in a man's world and it can be a very ugly world. Sarah is a photographer, a vocation that, in and of itself, wouldn't be all that scandalous. Unless one is a woman who is in partnership (as private inquiry agents) with a disgraced member of the aristocracy and a teenaged former street urchin along with doing photography. Not the kind of pretty pictures and portraits that anybody would like to have adorning the walls of their Victorian homes. No, Sarah is what is now known as a crime scene photographer. With crime scenes like Jack the Ripper. She and her partners were independent until one of their cases, a kidnapping, brought them into the world of Sir Gerald Mariner, a very wealthy man - banker, shipper and newspaper owner. As the owner of a newspaper, he employs Sarah, Hugh and Mick to be his crime scene photographers 24/7. It's not a job for the weak or faint of heart. But this trio is up to the task and has already solved two very big cases. Will they be able to solve this one as well?
Sir Gerald decides to make this case a contest between Sarah and her partners and the police. That gets more than a bit sticky. The victim is a hangman who makes most of his living running a pub called the Ropemaker's Daughter, a polite way of describing a hanging. Somebody wanted to give Mr. Warbrick a taste of his own medicine by hanging him. Too bad he didn't have Mr. Warbrick's skill with the rope. It was a ten foot drop, he was a heavy man and it did not end well, as in neat and tidy. The drop was too long and it was 'off with his head' - oh dear, very messy indeed.
The investigating begins and Sarah has to deal with not only the case at hand but an added twist - the police constable on the case is her lover and her feelings for him are very complicated. It becomes even more complicated when they make a connection between Warbrick and one of the people he hanged - Amelia Carlisle, the baby butcher. Something happened during her hanging that invoked the Official Secrets Act. The hangman may have let some secret slip.....did somebody want to silence him permanently?
If asked, I would say that I am considered to be a cozy reader - put a cat on the cover and that's a book for my mystery reading. It surprises my friends when I can become so engrossed in a mystery like this that I may forget to eat or sleep. It's because writing on the level of this series, with a very well described historical setting, a very satisfying mystery and great characters is just my cup of tea. The main reason is that it isn't gratuitous. It's well crafted in every way. If you have not read the previous two entries to this series, no worries, it stands alone. But I will warn you, if you enjoy this mystery as much as I did, be ready to binge read the other two. I'm already waiting eagerly for the fourth book.

Photographer Sarah Bain and her friends Lord Hugh Staunton, a disgraced member of the upper class, and sometime street urchin Mick O'Reilly are private detectives with a new gig - photographing crime scenes for London's Daily World newspaper.

A pub owner named Harry Warbrick has been found hanged and decapitated amid evidence of foul play. His murder becomes a sensation because he was England's top hangman and he's met the same fate that he inflicted on hundreds of criminals.

Sir Gerald Mariner, a fabulously wealthy and powerful banker and owner of the Daily World decides to turn the discovery of the murderer into a contest between the Metropolitan Police and the intrepid members of the newspaper team.

Rowland’s The Hangman’s Secret is a face paced Victorian murder mystery that kept me entertained and on the edge of my seat from the beginning. I couldn’t put this unpredictable novel down until the murderer was found.

Victorian Mystery at its best!

Superb continuation of the trials and challenges of denizens of the former detective agency who now work for Sir Gerald Mariner, photographing crime scenes for his London newspaper the Daily World.
Called to a pub to photograph a decapitated body that turns out to be a leading hangman, Harry Warbrick, events open up that will lead the trio through a maze of cover ups, hampered by the Official Secrets Act, along with a threatening visit to Newgate Prison.
Something had happened during the execution of Amelia Carlisle, the “Baby-Butcher,” who'd killed hundreds of infants placed in her care. Something that seems to link the murder of Warbrick to Amelia's death. Warbrick had divulged cryptically, "‘Two minutes and fifty seconds.’ [Sarah was] becoming more certain that something of consequence happened during Amelia Carlisle’s last two minutes and fifty seconds alive."
I teetered on the abyss several times with Sarah, I was devastated for Mick O’Reilly, and Lord Hugh Stanton continues to be, well, Hugh!
Inspector Reid is present as malevolent as ever, threatening Sarah and her search for her father. Constable Barrett finds himself caught between his loyalty to his chosen career and loyalty to Sarah. Sarah continues to be self contained, even as she opens up fractionally to Barrett. Even so, as a habitual secret keeper this is tough going for her and comes near to jeopardizing her's and Barrett's growing relationship.
A power house of feelings, of dank and dark places, and all of us, reader and characters, always on the edge of fearful surprises.
Once again a rapid and diverting read!

A NetGalley ARC

There is something fascinating about the Victorian Age and mysteries set in that time period. The values and accepted behavior are so different from today. I love the fact that Sarah Bain is a photographer during a time when women are beginning to have more freedom. The two males are as interesting as Sarah. Lord Hugh Staunton is gay in a time when it is a crime and Mick is a street kid who they have taken under their wing. Add in Sarah's love interest Barrett, a police man and you have a great mix of characters to carry the story. The plot here has multiple paths and watching how it plays out made it hard to put down. This is book three and can stand alone but I did wish I had read the first two so I would know exactly what happened when those past cases are mentioned.

I received a free copy of the book in return for an honest review.

There was a time when Laura Joh Rowland was known for her books set in seventeenth-century Japan with Sano Ichiro as the hero. The Ichiro books were great, and I looked forward to each new one which she published. Lately, however she has turned her attention to late Victorian England, and we readers are lucky for it. Rowland is a master, and she has written a corker of a book.

Photographer Sarah Bain and her friends Lord Hugh Staunton and Mick Reilly, who was formerly a street urchin, have formed a private detective agency and also work for the proprietor of a newspaper. At the beginning of the book they are called out to photograph a suicide by hanging, and if that weren’t gruesome enough, the corpse is decapitated. I don’t like spoilers, so I am not going to give any, but trust me, the book takes off from there. I couldn’t put it down.

This is a wonderful, clever mystery; very atmospheric and full of interesting characters. Do yourself a favor and pick it up, I cannot imagine anyone being disappointed.

This book just wasn't for me. I had a hard time getting through it because I was getting bored. I know some would love it but it just didn't keep me interested.

I haven't read thriller/mystery book in a while and The Hangman's Secret made me want to read more! I really enjoyed the story and I loved the characters. I loved how strong Sarah Bain is, especially for a woman of her time. This book makes me want to read more of Laura Joh Rowland's books as well! x

A fun read, but not very 'Victorian'. I enjoyed reading it, but was a little taken aback by the descriptions of Victorian London, Ely and Leeds, and the people. Also in Britain we open a box of chocolates and eat a chocolate - not a candy, that's an Americanism. If you know very little about Britain - and/or the Victorian era then it will be just a ripping yarn, but don't look to it for historical accuracy.

This was a decent cozy mystery set in Victorian London. I liked the characters and the book was a quick read. One plus is that you don't necessarily need to read the other 2 novels in the series to understand the what was happening in this book.