Member Reviews
*ARC received from NetGalley in return for an honest review*
This book was one that I quickly found out that I couldn't finish. What finally made me drop it to continue on to another was the fact that the writing was all over the place. There were moments that lost me for when a certain sentence was happening because the next would contradict it. Time was also all over the place hopping from one moment to the future and then back to another moment in the past all in one kindle page.
Generally, I like to believe that I will come back to books I couldn't finish. This one is going to get deleted from my kindle eventually. I had such high hopes for this version of Beauty and the Beast and it let me down so, so hard.
Once I saw that this was essentially a retelling of Beauty and the Beast, but from the Beast's perspective, I knew I wanted to read it. However, I was incredibly disappointed. The Beast has been alone for centuries until one day a weary traveler stumbles upon his lands. He offers the stranger food and hospitality from the shadows, and once the man falls asleep, the Beast looks into his dreams and see a beautiful girl he wants for his own. The following day, as the man is leaving, the Beast manipulates him into plucking a rose from his garden. In exchange for this flower, the man must bring his daughter, Isabeau, to stay in his castle with him. The Beast knows the man will not grant his wish, but Isabeau goes despite her father's wishes. From there, the story just really goes downhill for me. I felt there was just no connection between the two, and what I did feel was obsessive and uncomfortable. I also didn't like Beast's actions throughout, such as spying on her family with his magic mirror and constantly proposing marriage despite Isabeau saying no every time. Aside from those issues, I also felt the writing itself was heavy and boring, and felt myself losing interest the longer the story went on. This whole thing was just really not my cup of tea.
The Beast’s Heart by Leife Shallcross is a standalone novel that is based on the classic novel Beauty and the Beast, but in the POV of the Beast. I wasn’t sure if I would enjoy this retelling of the original classic, but by a quarter of the book, I was hooked into reading about Beast’s inner feelings, struggles and loneliness. It was sad to see him in his hardened state, living in his dark world, and slowly changing as he meets Isabeau; developing a friendship and eventually falling in love.
I really loved Isabeau, who was a courageous and wonderful heroine. Especially that she willingly agrees to live at Beast’s mansion for a year, in order to help her father. She quickly got past her fear of Beast, and it was beautiful to see the changes between them both over time.
What makes this story compelling and mesmerizing , is not only Beast and Isabeau, but the magic within the mansion that slowly changes from the darkness within, to be a magical enlighten house, as the friendship and happiness begins to surround them; the unseen servants, the enchanted gardens, and the amazing magic mirror made this such charming and beautiful story
.
I loved when Beast used the magic mirror to check up on Isabeau’s family and we learn about her sisters, and how they were doing without her. It was very well done and added a wonderful element to the story.
Beast realized in time, especially as his feelings for Isabeau grew, that perhaps if he can convince her to stay with him, maybe he can break the curse. Of course, Isabeau, though caring for him, kept denying his request for love and marriage. Besides her friendship, she felt she needed to return home to her family after a year; but Beast continued his quest, even if slim.
The Beast’s Heart was a pleasant and enchanting read that Leife Shallcross wrote so beautifully. How she was able to give us a glimpse into Beast’s emotions, and bring them together was so well done. If you enjoy the classic Beauty and the Beast, I suggest you read this book, as it was a wonderful story.
It took me a couple tries to get past the first few chapters because I didn't care for the story. It did improve, but overall I found the story boring. It didn't add anything to the original tale, and there was a distance between me and the characters. I never really felt drawn into the story, or invested in their love.
It was interesting to see the Beauty and the beast story told through the Beast's perspective, but there wasn't really anything about this story that stood out. There were no dramatic plot twists, or changes to the story in any real way. It was simply the Beauty and the Beast story told through the Beast's perspective. And while that was interesting, it also wasn't? It was a story we've seen a thousand times over with no real changes to shake things up and draw you in? And it was a little bit strange how the Beast would spend all day watching Isabeau's family if I'm being honest.
This book was a delightful retelling of Beauty and the Beast from the Beast's point of view. The prose was lyrical without being gushy or un-beastly and fully captured the sensation of reading an old-fashioned fairy tale.
I love beauty and the beast retellings, but this one was not for me.
The writing was very flowery and overly descriptive and got kinda boring.
The story was in the POV of the beast, and the plot moves slowly. I didnt care for the roman e aspect either, the Beast simply loved Isabeau because she was there and he was monkey. There was no legetimate transformation or growth or development of feelings and at one point the beast askes Belle to marry him, she refuses but he continues to ask even after she said no. This kind of pestering isint romantic but manipulative and abusive.
I did like Belles family how and how their story devolved, her two sisters became independent and confident women. However I never cared for the Father he always just seemed so dysfunctional and unable to cope.
All in all I could not recommend this book at all.
I did not finish this book because I couldn't get into it. There was a lot of I walked here, I was angry, I was scared. I'm human. I wasn't remotely interested in the Beast's story because it came off as a lot of whining.
This book wasn't for me.
The Beasts Heart was good but in my opinion it would’ve worked so much better with a more modern voice.
This is a much more direct Beauty and the Beast retelling than I originally thought it would be but I really enjoyed that. When I first began this novel, I did not find the writing appealing. It felt as though the author was attempting to tribute an old timey vibe, while incorporating her own unique style. I found it to be choppy, and a tad confusing at times; however, as I continued to read, the simple charm of the melodic writing, started to rub off on me.
Isabeau as a main character was a treat to observe. We get a big chunk of the book about her sisters which I found to be enjoyable to read about. I think it contributed to the story very well.
I wouldn’t call it one of my favorite retelling but it has entertained me and the characters were memorable. I highly recommend this book to any readers who are looking for a great Beauty and the Beast adventure. The storyline may be super predictable but the characterizations were amazing.
The Beast’s Heart was a wonderful, descriptive retelling that had me engrossed in this well known fairy tale while giving it a fresh perspective. It took a deeper look at the Beast’s struggles, not only in regard to breaking the curse but also his feelings for Isabeau and how he came to be cursed in the first place. I really enjoyed this story as it felt true to the original with the setting and time period but had enough variation to keep it interesting. I’d recommend this book for fans of fairytale retellings but a must-read for those who love Beauty and the Beast.
2.5 out of 5 stars
***ARC received through NetGalley for review, much appreciated***
Another retelling of Beauty and the Beast, not a version of the Disney, its more true to the original story. Unfortunately this book commits a cardinal sin in the world of novels, its boring and I had no interest in the outcome of the main characters. A version of the story through the Beasts point of view should be interesting. He is written to have been past his anger and rage and just now a very lonely creature. I feel like we are supposed to be sorry for him, to cheer for him to get the girl but I just couldn't. Poor Isabeau doesn't fair any better. I never felt their romance grow. Which is interesting when you compare Isabeau to her sisters.
Both her sisters go through a strong well defined character arc. They start out struggling but grow into independent characters. Claude goes slow with her new relationship, which even though we never read about her previous relationship but it is clear how she has grown. While Marie learns a new trade, we follow her through it and her relationship with her guy. It feels like a natural development for the two women when compared to Isabeau and the Beasts relationship which feels forced. You can see the sisters character fall in love and become strong independent people, while there is nothing with the primary relationship.
Its her father that really bugged me. There is no other conflict so we are left with a father that is supposed to be heartbroken but just feels controlling. His daughters are flourishing and he seems incapable of accepting this or that they no longer are under his control. So he pulls the most abusive and manipulative action possible designed only to hurt Isabeau.
It is a disappointment that this book couldn't pull it out in the end.
I find myself torn, I always love the story of Beauty and the Beast in all of its' myriad incarnations, but with having read soo many versions it is hard not to compare them all. Having Beast's perspective was a treat, but much of his early years were so convoluted and confusing, it was hard at times to track what was real and what was nightmare. A chance to see Beast before his curse was totally missed, what I wanted and have been missing, was the REASON he was cursed. We've been told many a time, but usually only ever see but a one scene glimpse of bad behavior. This could have dove deep into what made him cold or cruel, but yet again, we get nothing. I wanted to be there, not be told after the fact. I feel like this is a huge opportunity lost.
Shedding my own wishes and biases I must admit that the story is enchanting. A magical world brought to life beautifully, if not originally.
This was a really interesting twist on a fairytale retelling. It was refreshing and also well written. I wasn’t 100% invested in the romance or I would have liked it much more. Still a very good read.
This was an interesting take on the Beauty and the Beast story. This version is from the Beast's point of view, which is rare (at least I haven't come across many like this). The author also added more to "Beauty's" family. In this version she has 2 sisters who's lives we get to see through the Beast's special mirror. There's no "bad" guy Gaston. And no magical furniture, though his castle does have magic and produces and does whatever they wish.
I give this book points for having a new vision of a classic story. It is slower in some parts and probably could have been shortened, but that doesn't mean it's bad. I'd say if you're a retelling fan or a Beauty and the Beast fan this book is a must read. If you're just a fantasy fan I'd say this book might be a hit or miss for you, but still give it a try.
There is always a special place in my heart for beauty and the beast. A childhood memory that always brings love, joy and danger to a wonderful story. This beast was a pure gentleman. A man... or beast of his word. He is only looking for someone who will love him for who he is, but aren't we all? There is something wonderful about a story like this. It really shows the good in people, something that is rare these days. This is what I loved about this book.
There were two things I didn't like, pretty big things. The beginning was a little flimsy. The beast let the father go and told him to bring his daughter back to live with him for a year. The father could have left and never returned since the beast had nothing that the father needed, but of course the father brought his daughter back to live with the beast.
The second thing that bothered me was the slow nature of the story. I was hoping something would happen, but it never did. Nothing really happened until the last 10% of the book and it made for a long read.
All together, this was still a good book. A wonderful twist on the childhood story that we all love. Read it and make up your own mind.
A very slow and lush retelling of Beauty and the Beast told from the Beast's perspective entirely. It follows the original version quite closely though it redeems the sisters and happily ever afters are had by all. As I mentioned though, this is a very long retelling. It rarely dragged surprisingly enough but if you aren't a fan of all the details of everything being shared, this version may be too slow for you. I liked the world building in such a small space and how it's as much a mystery to the person who was cursed (Beast) as the people who stumbled into the curse throughout the story. Also, Shallcross's language is gorgeous; the fairy tale tradition is leaned into hard and well. The Beast's voice is lyrical and yet authentic. He sounds exactly like a fairy tale hero should (with a hint of wokeness that was very much appreciated by this reader).
I love a good retelling! I saw this pop up on Netgalley and had to throw out a request for it. This was a fun re-imagined YA-ish settling of Beauty and The Beast. This one was a little slow rolling for me but the world crafting was excellent.
I am a big lover of the romance parts of a read, so the fact that that wasn’t the fore front for this read gave me a bit of pause, but at the end of the day it was a riveting read page after page. I loved the crafting of the world and the twists on the story that we all know. It kept me engaged and enchanted as I read.
Retellings have a special spot for me. I love the fact that loosely, we know where the story is going to go. We know the end game. But all of the parts in-between, all of those are up for grabs. This was one of the reads that plays very close to the known tale in some points, but browns and changes in a large way for others.
A solid 4 star read for me with a fantastic cast and beautiful world.
This is a retelling of Beauty and the Beast, told from the Beast’s perspective. To be frank, I found myself bored through the majority of the book. It wasn't until the 60% mark that things picked up and I couldn't put it down. I liked the side plots of Isabeau's sisters and father; they were interesting and lent some variety to the same old stuff that Beast & Isabeau were up to. I know some find it creepy that Beast spied on them but I didn't really mind getting this glimpse and it helped the Beast I think become more human with time because he got to know and care for people. The character of Isabeau seemed to be a little flat and not a lot of personality. I was a little confused, even at the end of this book, as to <i>why</i> exactly the Fairy cursed the Beast. Those flashback scenes with the fairy just served to confuse me and didn't really enlighten me further.
This was a decent debut and I would probably pick up further books by Leife Shallcross, as I liked her writing style.
The book was a binge worthy read over a weekend. I couldn’t put it down. It was a different take on Beauty and the Beast. Having the perspective of the Beast opens a whole new perspective on this old classic tale.
I really enjoyed this title. I'm a sucker for any "Beauty and the Beast" themed titles and this is the first I've read from the Beast's point of view. It kept me reading and it was nice to see things from his perspective. In fact, in reading I saw several parallels to another book series I'm reading, one that has nothing to do with this original tale. Recommending it to fantasy and fairy-tale fans will be easy!