Member Reviews
After reading the stellar reviews for this book - and it's comparison to Kristin Hannah's The Nightingale - I thought this was a sure win for me.
*Spoilers ahead!!!*
Sadly, it was not a win for me.
I *liked* this book. I thought the premise of the Women's Division of the SOE to be intriguing. That being said, I felt there lacked something in the execution of this book.
Why bring Grace into this story at all? The whole story could have been told from Eleanor's point of view, beginning with her landing in NYC to look for Marie (and not getting hit by a car), simply by starting from the beginning when Marie was recruited, to the end, where Eleanor sees Marie again and asks about the other girls. It would have been a much less confusing story in my opinion. All of Grace's story was unnecessary, and yet I know I am in the minority here.
Beautiful and haunting. I believe that through the space of time we forget about the hardships of war and those that are lost. Definitely younger generations (including my own) don't understand this fact because so few of us have gone through it. This book beautifully tells the story of the brave women who helped during WW2 as spies/saboteurs.
I received an ARC of this book. All opinions are my own.
I enjoyed reading this book. The characters were engaging and I became interested in their lives and their backgrounds. The book begins in New York City the Second World War has just ended. As the main character Grace is rushing to work and comes upon an accident. A woman has just been struck and killed by a car. As Grace takes a different route to work, she finds an abandoned suitcase, which belongs to the deceased woman. Inside the suitcase, she finds a packet containing pictures of young women in their twenties. The rest of the book is spent unraveling their identities and the roles they played during World War II.
Grace discovers the owners of the suitcase is named Eleanor and that she is a British citizen. With the help of a friend and love interest, she is able to discover the woman was the director of a group of female spies/radio operators that played important roles in defeating the Nazis.
The book jumps back and forth in time as we learn the backstory behind the photos of the girls and how each one lost their lives while serving behind enemy lines.
It’s is a book about friendships, loyalties, strong and brave women. It also shows us the horrors that people endure during war. This book is much more than just another historical fiction book about World War II. It is also a mystery, a book about betrayal, a bit of a love story and book about finding inner strength during impossibly dark times in life. I really enjoyed this book and had a hard time putting it down.
I love dual-time period stories! The Lost Girls of Paris portrays the lives of secret agents during WWII. Women secret agents! Their lives are intertwined and create a wonderful story. I was drawn in immediately, when Grace finds an abandoned suitcase and seeks the mysterious owner.
Each of the characters had their own place in my heart, but I mainly identified with Grace. I love how this story was told and that so much research went into this book. I had no idea how the secret operative was established or that women were even selected (at that time) as agents. I also love how heroic and brave these women were. I didn’t want the story to end!
I received a complimentary copy of this book.
A book about women and their roles during WWII - count me in! The Lost Girls of Paris was an engaging read that had me flipping through the pages late into the night to see what happened to the women.
Recruiting women to go into occupied France to be a W-T was no easy task, nor was overseeing the entire operation but Eleanor seemed more then up to the task. Clearly she is an intelligent, fiercely independent woman who was not afraid to stand up to the men who do not believe she nor her recruits were capable of the work. While those qualities made me admire her they weren’t what drew me to her character. It was her utter devotion to the cause and the women she sent over that did. Eleanor did not have an easy path in life, but she certainly made the very most of it.
I have to admit I struggled with Marie. She to had a difficult life and was trying to better her life for herself and her daughter - but she was just so naive. How do you go into Occupied France after rigorous training and make some of the choices that she did. I became frustrated with her and with Julian - as it just didn’t make sense to me.
Grace, oh Grace, she is the character I really enjoyed reading about. Yearning for something more then what was arranged for her she decided to do things differently. And by doing so created a whole new life for herself. I really admired her spirit and determination.
And the ending - it just felt like the right ending for this story and I am so glad that it wasn’t neat and tidy.
Overall, this was a four star read for me. If you enjoy historical fiction featuring strong capable women getting it done then this is the book for you.
Thank you Netgalley and Harlequin for the opportunity to read and review this book. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
I have read and loved all of Pam Jenoff’s books and this one is no exception. It is a WWII story of a female spy ring, their friendships and their courage..I thought it was well researched and beautifully written, as are all of her books. I thoroughly enjoyed the stories of Grace, Eleanor and Marie and highly recommend to fans of historical fiction, especially lovers of WWII books.
This book follows the narrative of three women.
Eleanor the commander of a covert mission during the war.
Marie, one of Eleanor's operatives
and Grace, a woman post war who stumbles across some information that leads to questions she wants answers to.
Inspired by true events, this was a fascinating book.
War time books are generally a hit or miss for me, as they can so easily go sideways. But the writing did this story justice.
We know that women were used as underground radio operators in Nazi occupied Europe, and this puts names and stories to these unknown women.
This was my first read from Mrs. Pam Jenoff and I look forward to more! An exciting read about the role of women spies working out of Britain. I enjoyed learning more about the role of the SOE and the on-the-ground work of these women. My chief complaint is that the end of the novel felt very rushed. Overall, it's a good work of historical fiction and an inspiring read about brave women. Fans of The Alice Network will want to grab a copy!
Thank you for an advance copy, NetGalley and Harlequin!
After reading and enjoying Pam Jenoff's previous two novels, I was excited to dig into this one. Pam has once again delivered a captivating story about World War II.
At the same time I was reading The Lost Girls of Paris, I also happened to be reading The Alice Network. While one was about spies and the other about saboteurs and they took place during two different wars (for the most part), they balanced each other out well. Funny enough, both novels mentioned Baudelaire's Fleurs du Mal. I learned some new things about World War II from this novel.
I liked the voices of the three women, but felt like Eleanor's narrative took a while to get into. Once the story took off, it was worthwhile. It was to get a grasp of her age though, but I guessed early forties. I also liked how Grace got caught up in the mystery of what happened to all the women.
The situation that Marie was in was scary and I couldn't even imagine taking such risks. Some things that happened throughout the story surprised me, as I didn't see them coming. I kept turning the pages, wanting to know what would happen next. While the ending felt a bit anticlimactic after everything that went on, I was also satisfied by how much information was given.
I recommend adding this novel to your TBR when it publishes in early 2019.
Movie casting suggestions:
Marie: Wallis Day
Grace: Allison Miller
Eleanor: Keeley Hawes
Mark: James Wolk
Vesper: Alex Pettyfer
This book was received as an ARC in exchange for an honest review from HARLEQUIN. Opinions and thoughts expressed in this review are completely my own.
We are always on the search for new historical fiction novels but this one in particular was historical mixed with action and I must say after reading I am a huge fan of this novel. The background of the suitcase leading Grace to meet Marie finding out she is an undercover agent was so intriguing to read that I could not stop and could not put this down. I really hope at some point this book will turn into a movie and it will definitely be one to re-read and watch.
This book will find a nice home in our Historical Fiction collection at our library and that is why we give this book 5 stars.
I was very excited to receive an advance readers copy of this book from Hanover Square Press and #NetGalley in exchange for an unbiased, honest review. I really, really, really loved this book. It is set in two different times - England and France towards the last few years of WWII and New York the year after. The separate stories tie in so beautifully together and everything flowed so well. I found it so hard to tear myself away from this story and couldn't wait to see how it all ended. I found myself as protective as Eleanor of her girls as I read the story. I am always fascinated and absorbed in WWII novels, but I found myself invested in this one so much, as it is always unique to see how hard women fought to make a difference and to bring justice during WWII. This is a must read!
Beautifully written historical fiction about a group of English women spies who put their lives on the line during WW II. Story is told in 2 time lines, only a few years apart. This story is about country, friendship and, most of all, the courage these women needed to go into enemy territory.
Ms. Jenoff’s writing so vividly describes the war, it’s horrors and the aftermath. The friendship, determination and relentlessness of the characters came shining thru. As does her descriptions of London, New York and DC. Book was well researched.
Highly recommend for fans of Historical Fiction. Fast read because you won’t be able to put it down!
Thanks to NetGalley and the Publisher for this ARC. Opinion is mine alone!
I enjoyed this book and read it quickly. The main story, about a British woman who served as a radio transmitter in WWII era France, interested me and kept me reading. However, the story had some loose ends at the conclusion of the book. The frame story, involving a woman who finds a suitcase in Grand Central Station in New York, didn't quite work for me. Nonetheless, I really enjoyed the book overall.
Having read and enjoyed previous novels from Pam Jenoff, I was excited to see she had a new book releasing. This is an engaging novel that takes place in two time periods, 1944 and 1946, with two intermingled plots. Both time periods focused on the role of women spies in the war effort, a topic I found fascinating simply because I knew nothing of the topic. This was a terrific novel that showed the enduring strength of women and just some of the hardships they faced during the War years. Fans of the Nightingale will enjoy this novel.
The Lost Girls of Paris by Pam Jenoff is a intriguing story of a courageous and brave ring of women spies in WWII Young English women are recruited to help the French resistance as wireless operators. Two time periods follow the stories of three women during and post-WWII. Highly Recommended Historical Fiction novel
Thank you to the publisher, author, and NetGalley for the opportunity to preview the book.
If you enjoy novels about WWII, this is a not to be missed treat. I really loved Grace and enjoyed reading about her. I was less fond of Marie but enjoyed the story overall.
Many thanks to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for my ARC. All opinions are my own.
When Grace finds an abandoned suitcase in Grand Central Terminal, she can't help but open the suitcase and rifle through its contents. She finds a handful of photographs, each with depicting a woman in uniform. Later on, she realizes that the suitcase belonged to Eleanor Trigg, a woman who was killed in a car accident outside of Grand Central. Determined to return the photographs, Grace begins investigating Eleanor. She discovers that Eleanor was the leader of a group of female secret agents deployed in France during WWII. The book also follows Eleanor and Marie, one of the secret agents, point of view.
I instantly found Eleanor and Marie's point of view fascinating, I was much less interested at Grace. However, by the end, the author brought everything full circle, showing why Grace was essential to the story. I enjoyed the interplay among the stories, and found Marie to be not only a believable character, but intriguing. Overall, highly recommended.
This was an enjoyable read, but not a perfect one. The first half was stronger than the second, and some characters were better written than others. I felt more drawn to Grace, and felt she was a more believable character, than Marie. For some reason Marie never seemed real to me.
This was well researched, but the plotting felt a bit off and the end somewhat anticlimactic. Overall, this was a solid read and I enjoyed it. But the negatives mentioned above kept it from being higher than 3 stars for me.
Thank you netgalley for a free copy in exchange for an honest review.
Thanks to NetGallery, the publisher and author for an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest opinion.
The Lost Girls of Paris follows in the footsteps of other recent novels presenting stories about women spies in WWII Europe, based on real events. There are two major threads to the story, separated by two years and an ocean. The first thread begins in New York in 1946, when Grace, a young war widow, literally stumbles on a suitcase whose belongings include a set of photographs of young women. The second begins in England, and winds its way to France, in 1944, with the story of the recruiting, training and deployment of female spies whose job it became to transmit information via wireless from enemy territory back to London. The two stories run parallel, mostly in alternating chapters, and eventually come together near the end of the book. The portion dealing with the actual spies was better written and more interesting to me than the post-war life Grace led.
I had not previously read any of Pam Jenoff’s books, though I’m aware she has written several that are set in WWII. Based on this, I would likely read another.
SPOILER ALERT.
Overall, I enjoyed this novel but I think The Nightingale and The Alice Network told similar stories much better. Two events in this book in particular let the story down. The first thing I struggled with was necessary for the plot line, but I still can’t figure out what on earth WHY Grace would open an abandoned suitcase, rifle through the contents and then take something out of it. As I said, necessary to the plot but REALLY? The second was when Marie is inserted into her post in France with no apparent cover story. Surely a single woman showing up in a town in occupied France at that stage of the war would need to have a reason to be there or stick out like a sore thumb. That her presence did not raise red flags immediately felt disingenuous.
3.25 stars rounded down to 3.*
I was so excited when I saw a Pam Jenoff book available for review on NetGalley. I really loved her book The Orphan's Tale and I was eagerly anticipating this story.
The Lost Girls of Paris is two stories wound into one-taking place simultaneously in Europe in 1944 and in New York in 1946- telling parallel stories of young female resistance operatives working to infiltrate German-occupied France at the end of WWII, and the story of Grace Healy, a young war widow who stumbles upon a suitcase in Grand Central Station and becomes embroiled in the mystery of what happened to these women.
I really like how Pam Jenoff weaves a tale- she grips you with enough facts and detail while making her characters believable, likable and completely fallible.
Historical fiction is one of my favorite genres, and I am coming to realize the dual timeline storyline is a common device, and I enjoy it. The only trouble is that sometimes I find myself feeling much more strongly about one of the storylines and the other falls flat in comparison. This book fell into that category for me. I really loved learning about the lives of the women who risked so much to become radio operators under deep cover with barely any training. I longed to know each of their stories. And while I enjoyed Grace's story...I just wasn't that interested in the storyline that detailed her romance nor her career trajectory. I did, however, really appreciate how Ms Jenoff revealed the big plot twist.
I'd definitely recommend this one to fellow historical fiction fans. Fans of Kristin Hannah, Michelle Gable, Ruta Sepetys, and Beatriz Williams will definitely enjoy this.
*with thanks to Netgalley for the digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.