Member Reviews

Perfect for fans of Bridget Jones’ Diary. She clearly shows the joys and challenges of being a first generation Indian in a tight-knit immigrant community where the pressure on the adult children to marry "right" is intense. A lovely romantic comedy about navigating the matchmaking world.

Was this review helpful?

Raina has grown up with her Nana and Nani, strict Indian grandparents, but she has always done what they wanted. As she approaches thirty, Nani is trying to arrange a match, which leads to a series of dates which are both funny and touching at times. Although on the lighter side, the book is based on themes of acceptance and friendship between cultures and within the Indian culture itself. I recommend as a peek into the customs and conflicts between generations

Was this review helpful?

Writing: 4/5 Plot: 3.5/5 Characters; 4/5

Women’s fiction pairing romcom humor with a smart, capable, protagonist. Complex themes with authentic resolutions. Multi-cultural and sexual diversity interest.

29 year-old Raina Anand is under constant pressure from her beloved Nani to get married. Her best friend is about the tie the knot and the close knit Indian community in her Toronto suburb is all geared up to help her follow suit. However, Raina is keeping a shameful secret — she is still in love with the man she left (in another country) 2 years ago. In order to protect this secret, she allows her Nani to believe she is gay — with broad and surprising consequences.

This is not your typical romcom. There are no firemen, no Fabios flexing muscles, and no ditzy but lovable blondes prepared to make some man very happy. The story continually veers off into unexpected territory and allows the main character to experience real emotional growth while trying to find her way in the world. Opening on Raina’s 29th birthday, the narrative carries through to her 30th, interspersed with reverse-order flashbacks to previous memorable birthdays. Her family is not typical (is anyone’s?). Half Indian, half caucasian, she was raised by her grandparents and only rarely saw her mother who bore her when only 16. But even this is not exactly as it seems — there is depth and nuance in this story.

There is a strong theme of sexual orientation diversity — portrayed in an interesting way because while our first person narrative protagonist is not gay herself, this “small” white lie highlights the clash of tradition and modernism simmering beneath the surface of her small, tight-knit, community.

Fun, witty, writing. Well structured with good messages about diversity, values, and the danger of letting shame drive you into making bad decisions.

Was this review helpful?

The Matchmaker's List is a delightful read! The flashbacks build suspense. And the main character is likable. I was rooting for her the whole time.

Was this review helpful?

Raina Anand turns twenty nine and contemplates her future. After her mother's wild youth leaving her to be raised by her mother Raina is the "good" granddaughter to her grandmother, she's got the good job and after a devastating heartbreak is willing to let her grandmother matchmake for her. I really enjoyed this book. It gave great insight into the Indian community , the tradition of the old mixed with the progress of the new. I loved Nani Raina's grandmother, she was so loving and open minded which if anyone knows anything about Indian grannies is in quite short supply not the loving part but the open minded bit. Raina's search for love is sometimes amusing, sometimes interesting, sometimes heartbreaking and through it all it's about a woman coming to terms with herself and her community.

Was this review helpful?

Raina Anand is your typical nearly 30 metropolitan business woman. She works too many hours, drinks too much, still has feelings for her toxic ex and all of her friends are starting to settle down. Add to all of her modern issues the fact that she comes from a traditional Indian home. Raina's grandmother raised her to respect her upbringing which means she wants her married in a traditional wedding to a doctor with two children before her eggs are hard-boiled. Let's just say time is running out.

While Raina works her way through the list of eligible Indian bachelor's her grandmother has made, she meets Asher, a former nomad/high school teacher. Through series of events they become frenemies and then friends and maybe something more if Raina doesn't ruin it all first. Believe me, she tries to ruin it.

I enjoyed this modern story of self-discovery, bridging the gap between cultures, and yes, even love.

Was this review helpful?

I told myself I was going to make myself finish this book tonight. I lost that battle.

This book had so much potential! It just ended up being soooo boring. The story was a almost 30 year old woman had promised her Nani that if she wasn't married by thirty that she would let her help her "find a mate"..and it could have worked. Nani's character sorta tried to bridge the gap of being a modern woman with her Indian heritage. Her- I tried to like. I just felt that enough time was not given to flesh out her character. Bummer

Then the main character Raina..she just got on my dang nerves. At the point where I gave up the ghost on the book she was back to mooning over the guy that dumped her years ago. He refused to meet her family and this girl was old school with her Nani and we were supposed to buy that? Not. Plus, he treated her like poo but of course that was the guy of her dreams. He lurrrrvvved her. *gag*

She reads as so immature for a almost thirty year old woman. I went into this book wanting a rom-com that touched on some subjects that haven't been done to death..such as arranged marriages. I didn't get that.

My head hurts.



Booksource: Netgalley in exchange for review

Was this review helpful?

A good book. I was rooting for Raina even when I felt she wasn’t rooting for herself. I’m really happy with the way things worked out!

Was this review helpful?

This book is amazing by making me not hate the main character no matter how stupid she becomes in the middle part. Altogether the book is about a second generation Indian-Canadian trying to reconcile who she is by the influences of her Indian grandma and her Indian-Canadian mother who rebelled heavily against the grandma. Very interesting and helped me continue reading when Raina decides to let her grandma think she's gay. That was painful but at least, as opposed to most woman's fiction, this was not portrayed as cute but heavily messed up and wrong of her.

Was this review helpful?

Sonya Lalli's The Matchmaker's List was a refreshing surprise. I read it on a whim, mostly because it was compared to The Wedding Date, which hit a tender part of my heart I didn't even know existed. The initial conceit is that the narrator, Raina, while still heartbroken over an ex, has to manage her grandmother's expectation that she settle down and marry a nice Indian boy sooner rather than later. I was expecting it to be a series of charmingly terrible bad dates that would end in a Happily Ever After with both Raina and her Nani perfectly content. What I got was so much more complicated. The Matchmaker's List takes on generational trauma, complicated female friendships, tradition, sexuality, cultural identity, and the murky line between what we want and what we have been told to want. But, there are still charmingly bad dates.

I recommend it for people who love a good breezy read about a woman looking for love, but want something a little more nuanced than your traditionally structured romance.

Was this review helpful?