Member Reviews

This is a really sweet story about first love. Jorge is dealing with typical middle school life, and then realizes he is falling for a girl. Jorge is an admirable character who sets a good example of how to act and how to treat people. The innocence of the romance is really sweet and feels realistic. This book has a richly varied cast of characters so that everyone who reads it should feel represented. It also addresses bullying, honesty, judgements based on appearance, and friendship without being preachy. This would be an excellent book for middle school students, as well as upper level elementary and high schoolers.

Was this review helpful?

I am in love with this book… probably more than Jorge loves Jazmine. But seriously, it’s so dang good! If you’ve never read anything by Svetlana Chmakova before you’re seriously missing out. Crush is fun, funny, and absolutely fabulous. It brings back the growing pains of being in middle school, navigating the complex world of social relationships, and the confusion of finding your place in the world. If you read only one graphic novel this year, this should be it.

I loved the diversity in the characters, and appreciated how the inclusive elements never felt token or forced. The representation of the school populous was anything by homogenous and presented an honest reflection of the average public school. There were cliques, distinct personality types, and it even played on the typical clubs and groups that can be found in almost any school. There’s the drama kids, the athletes, the cheer leaders, the nerds, and on and on. But what I loved most about these representations is that even though there are characters that play to stereotypes, that those characters that represent toxic masculinity and abusive behaviours are thoroughly condemned for their actions. So too are the bullies, the gossips, and the mean girls. No excuses are made, no free passes are given, and the real-word consequences for being horrible are detailed in full. Hello, cleverly disguised teaching moments!

And just as there are examples of poor behaviour and what not to do, there are some shining examples of how to be kind and conscientious human being. For this alone, I love Jorge! He’s a jock without being a jerk, doesn’t feel the need to participate in petty drama, and despite what his peers are doing he doesn’t cave to the pressure of commenting on or physically invading other’s bodily autonomy. He is supportive, respectful, and absolutely adorable. Svetlana Chmakova, thank you thank you thank you for putting forward an absolutely crush-worthy knight in shining armour. Thank you for setting the bar high when it comes to how people should be treated.

I appreciated that Jorge was painfully shy and unsure of how to navigate his first crush. He was human and relatable, yet at the same time Jorge is also confident in his individuality and unwavering in his treatment of others. I loved his patience, his willingness to forgive, and his refusal to stand idly by why others are bullied. That’s right my friends, while Crush might be about Jorge’s first love it also hands out some (not so) subtle tactics on how to stand up to d-bags of all ages.

With that being said though, the kids really taken centre stage in this book, as the few adult characters serve only to advance the plot rather than deliver lectures or provide guidance. The kids themselves navigate the grounds of what’s right and wrong, and that alone keeps it more relatable for to a middle grade audience.

As far as the artwork goes, I absolutely loved it. The line work is clean, the characters unique and easily distinguished – abstracted enough to be relatable yet detailed enough to convey meaning, and the panel arrangement easily readable. The facial expressions and body language effectively convey the differences in personalities and internal emotions, and speak volumes in a way that text never could. The panel arrangement is clean and not to cluttered, in fact it follows the left to right, top to bottom pattern of a standard books with only a few full page panels or exceptions to the rule. The result is that this text is an easy introduction to graphic novels for those new to the medium. The colours are used for maximum impact but aren’t overwhelming. They’re subtle, soft, and don’t detract from the visual language employed. Additionally, enough action takes place in the gutter to keep the imagination firing on all pistons, but not so much as to leave the reader to their own devices – especially when it comes to the emotional implications of decisions and behaviours.

Would I recommend this book? Let’s put it this way, I’ve already bought a copy and sent it to my old school! Great for parents, kids, and anyone in-between. This is a smash hit, home-run, middle grade must read.

Was this review helpful?

I loved Jorge and the way he moved throughout the story. I'm not sure I've read another character like him who uses his strength and size to protect others but we can also see his vulnerabilities. The topic of middle school crushes was handled perfectly - humorous and awkward and very real. Definitely give this (and the others in the series) a read.

Was this review helpful?

I loved the new protagonist in the latest Awkward book! It was great to be inside the mind of someone who has a difficult time articulating his feelings, but has a lot going on inside his head. This new book will definitely appeal to tweens, but also does a great job of looking at the complexities of cyber bullying and its impacts. Love!

Was this review helpful?

Crush tells the story that many middle school students will be familiar with - their first crush and subsequent interactions with that person that can be everything from mortifyingly embarrassing to something you want to replay in your head over and over again. With familiar characters from Svetlana Chmakova's previous titles in this series, kids will love this realistic look at middle school and first love.

Was this review helpful?

Crush is Svetlana Chmakova’s third graphic novel set at Berrybrook Middle School. I was very excited about the opportunity to read this book because my oldest daughter is in the sixth grade, and she loves graphic novels. For several years, she read graphic novels almost exclusively. She has always been a voracious reader, so this meant that we always had a lot of graphic novels in the house. She has recently branched out and found some novels that she really likes, but she still loves graphic novels.

Since she is an expert in the genre, I thought that it would be nice if she could share her thoughts on Crush:

So, I just want to say that I LOVE Svetlana Chmakova’s books, and that I was so exited when I heard there was a third book!

What I like about Svetlana’s books is that she takes a supporting character from a previous book and makes a book about them! This book is about a character from Brave, Jorge. He loves sports and will help anyone who is in trouble! At the beginning of the story, we get an intro to Jorge’s best friends, Liv and Garret and we are also introduced to the football team and this worsethanajerk quarterback who is a honor roll student, but he acts like a total worsethanajerk. But Jorge has a crush, Jazmine, who’s part of the drama club. (She has a boyfriend though. But he acts like a TOTAL jerk to Jorge.) Eventually, Jazmine and her boyfriend break up, which gives Jorge a chance to jump in and become Jazmine’s boyfriend. You’ll have to read the book to find out if it works out for them or not.

I really liked this book and was waiting for another graphic novel about the students of Berrybrook Middle School! If you haven’t read Awkward or Brave, you need to read them before reading!!! Svetlana draws and writes AMAZING YA graphic novels that I have become a big fan of! (Svetlana, if you’re reading this, congrats on the baby!)

Clearly, this is an enthusiastic recommendation for Crush. She is already looking forward to the next book the series, and I’m sure that she will be re-reading the other Berrybrook titles until then!

We voluntarily read and reviewed an advanced copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Crush is adorable!

Jorge is the strong, quiet type. He is also kind and good and always standing up for the little guy along with his hyper but trusty best friend, Liv. He is so big his classmates are afraid of him, which helps him keep order, and much more mature than them, which is why he has to keep order. At least, he’s mature in some ways. There is one way he’s still so young: he’s never liked a girl before. And he does not know what to do with it. The crush; not the girl, though he doesn’t really know what to do with her either. He forgets how to speak around her, gets frustrated when he realizes his feelings, and is constantly running off when his confusion becomes too much. His is not a giddy crush. Even when Jazmine agrees to go out with him, Jorge has to think hard about what to do next. Oh yeah! Maybe get her phone number!

Apart from Jorge’s delightful confusion and first love, Crush has great messages about consent, bullying, friendship, and even feminism mixed in to the overall story. When another girl realizes her boyfriend only liked her for her looks, she drops him like a hot potato. Jazmine breaks up with her previous boyfriend because he treats her badly. Liv is a constant advocate for respect among all her friends, though she doesn’t mind hurting people a little bit to get her point across. Chmakova’s beautiful art also shows an implicit acceptance of diversity in Jorge’s middle school.

Crush is the 3rd in the series Awkward, and as far as these three go, Chmakova always writes uplifting stories that encourage respect and kindness to everyone. She also looks at issues from a different angle from other books I’ve read. My students love the first two. I’m sure they’ll devour the third one as well.

Was this review helpful?

This GN has it all. A great guy, a lovely girl, feminist empowerment, Body anatomy, and even a little intrigue. Jorge is the nicest middle schooler I have ever met. He's a big boy, but he looks out for the little guy. He is the quiet type and believes in feminism, body anatomy, and that everyone should be excellent to each other. But middle school can be complicated. Some friends try to fit in with the wrong crowd, and how is a quiet guy supposed to talk to the girl he likes? It’s just all so hard and confusing. I am completely enthralled with this book and now must read all the others by this author immediately. She does a great job of talking about consent, and it's not just by the girl characters, but Jorge is totally on board as well. As well as body positivity, and that there are more to girls than being “beautiful”. I loved everything about this book, and see myself putting it in a lot of holiday stockings.

Was this review helpful?

I loved that this came from the male perspective. This will definitely be a relatable story for middle school and junior high students. There’s a nice mix of feelings and humor to make this feel realistic and relatable.

Was this review helpful?

Netgalley provided me a DRC of this book in exchange for an honest review.

I love, love, LOVE this middle grade graphic novel series. I was so excited to get a DRC, especially when I found out that Crush follows Jorge, one of my favorite side characters from Brave.

These books have SO many things going for them. The artwork is amazing (and adorable), the cast of characters are the most diverse I have seen in middle grade fiction, and the range of topics covered: crushes (and the drama that ensues), social media (and the drama that ensues), bullying, what it means to be a friend, judging others on their appearance, etc. I also love that this one includes a section regarding body autonomy. Everything is just so SPOT ON for middle school.

I recommend them to everyone--whether you're a fan of graphic novels or not.

Was this review helpful?

Having seen other books written by Svetlana Chmakova, I was very excited to read Crush. (After reading, I plan on backtracking to read the other books as well 👍). This graphic novel follows the school life of Jorge who is middle schooler known for his size, protective attitude, and quiet spirit. However, there is something about him no one knows - he has a secret crush!

This novel is the quintessential picture of middle school. Many relevant topics for tweens are brought forth, such as navigating relationships, cyberbullying, and standing for what's right.

I would highly recommend this graphic novel to anyone who's either already read other titles by Chmakova or is navigating the world of middle school.

Was this review helpful?

I'm familiar with Svetlana Chmakova</a> from her earlier work like Dramacon which was published by Tokyo Pop so many years ago. A friend of mine gave me a free comic book day issue featuring an excerpt from Crush. I read it and knew I wanted to read more. I haven't read the other entries in the Berrybrook Middle School series, <em>Awkward</em> or <em>Brave</em>, yet I read up on them enough to know that they are award winning graphic novels about middle school aged kiddos and that they are well loved.

I have twin god sisters who are finally in middle school and one of them--Rebekah--pops up with random questions and comments now, questions I've never heard before like: "Have you ever had a crush before?" (To which I say 'Yes, of course. It's perfectly normal to have crushes on people) and comments like, "I'm just so SINGLE." (To which I say 'Yo, there's nothing wrong with not having a boyfriend or girlfriend. There is NO rush. ) Hearing these types of things from her remind me that Rebekah and her twin sister are growing up and growing up means experiencing new things like having crushes, widening your social circles, and being on your own figuring out what life throws at you.



What I adore about this book is the creator, Chmakova, can craft a terrific story. A few of the overarching themes in this book that make it great are having your first crush, navigating newer spaces with new rules (elementary school is a whole new playground than middle school), and maintaining friendships—new and old. Seeing kids trying to learn to balance newer responsibilities (like getting the more challenging homework completed) while juggling extracurricular activities (like clubs), and hanging out with different social circles was something I remembered at that age. I was also pleasantly surprised to see kids verbally reinforcing the message of consent by way of body autonomy to their peers after certain kids think it’s a joke to just ignore.

I loved Jorge Ruiz, our main character who is a sort of gentle giant, who is shy and such a good-natured dude. He’s nicknamed ‘Sheriff’ for walking through the hallways and stopping those who horse around a little too much at the expense of others. He’s entered middle school with his best friends Olivia and Garrett, and they've been hit by wave after wave of change from trying to impress the wrong crowd to rotating boys that end up as boyfriends. Can’t say I’ve seen many boys of color as protagonists in graphic novels, and he’s a welcomed addition. His middle school experience becomes something new and unexpected when he starts developing a crush on Jazmine, the bubbly girl who is a friend of a friend who always greets him with a smile.

The art style is manga influenced and fun, especially when seeing the variety of the facial expressions in this book. I also felt that the coloring was a bit muted, yet I did like lettering effects. On my second read through, I noticed that there were more kids of color than I initially thought in the book. I see them in the backgrounds on almost every page, and I even see some hijab wearing students and having them in more featured roles or places in visibility would have serve this book better. I would have also liked more of them to have names. Yet, they are here in the book: on James', the jock’s, posse and in the drama club—two groups we see often. I absolutely adored the P.E. teacher/coach, Coach Rasad—who wears a hijab as well and is no nonsense having, authoritative figure and is well respected.


Jorge himself gets to shine, and the writing shows this in wrapping up loose ends and giving us closure which is a blessing to read after how disappointed I was remembering Bethany, the Black friend of the main character in Dramacon. Jorge gets centered, and the supporting cast is full of some swell kids which include girls who reject outdated beauty standards and serve up a big serving of sisterhood by looking after each other. This also includes boys who weren't being their best versions of themselves and see the errors of their ways, trying to impress in the name of also outdated shows of masculinity.

Jorge goes from being out of sorts by discovering he has a crush to staying steadfast in being true to who he is and trying his best to be a good friend. He is the glue to this tale being sucked into all the drama that happens yet learning much along the way about himself, those people who make your heart flutter, and learning what type of person he wants to be: thoughtful, considerate and decent, someone you don't doubt, and someone folks will always want to see coming. It can't be understated that having a boy protagonist respect his female peers and hold other boys to that standard is excellent to see and something that I want to see more of. Seeing a boy protagonist view and treat girls as whole persons and not just the sum of parts is super cool in my book.

The pacing of this book flows fine ,but I was surprised to see the book’s length of 240 pages which is more than I usually see for graphic novels for this age group. This book also ends on a good note: on choosing your tribe—the people who are your friends and being chosen by them. I also really dug the respecting others--regardless of gender, regardless of if they're your BFF or just a passing kid in the hallway. There is also something to be said about endearing friendships and how people, not just you but also your friends, change after time--some of the changing being good and bad.

Growing up will eventually happen, and there is no official manual-- yet such a fun read like <em>Brave</em> comes along and makes me wish I had it way back when I was a terribly awkward middle schooler. Chmakova's <em>Crush </em> is an adventure for the tween/preteen age group that carries all the feels and makes the ordinary seem extraordinary by how relatable it is.

When I think about on my little god sister Rebekah, a freshly minted sixth grader and her never-ending well of questions about what dating is and what's the correct way to wear this or that and what to do when the kid that sits next to her that doesn't know they stink to high heavens, I'm going to be make time for those questions. And I'm going to slide her over a copy of this book and heck, the other entries of the in the Berrybrook Middle School series, Awkward or Brave because Crush has made me a believer.

Was this review helpful?

Crush is a welcoming graphic novel experience with relatable characters and a fresh and colorful use of images. The story is enjoyable and the art is a lovely complement to the text. This is a book I would gladly share with readers, old and young alike.

A fine example of the graphic novel medium.

Was this review helpful?

I'm crushing on this book SO HARD!
The feeling of this book is spot on for the middle school crowd and definitely puts older audiences reading it right back into those awkward, crushy, stressful years.
Love love LOVED the message about consent added in there before a school dance.
Overall fantastic messages and great read.

Was this review helpful?

I received this book from publisher/Netgalley in exchange of an honest review.

As I said in my review for the previous book, I was hoping this one would be about Jorge, and look! Look! It is! Yay!!! *fangirls*

Jorge is so adorable, how he is trying to be all like: Oh nobody got time for all that dating stuff and blabla. We are on a mission to stop bullying and the like. Then he spots Jazmine and gets totally flustered! Adorable!!!!!! And that is how it goes every time he sees her, or if she talks to him. He just goes into the zone (which reminded me of scenes of manga/anime with swoony romance), and I just loved it. Of course, I was quickly (very quickly, like after one scene of that) rooting for Jorge and her to get together, or at least give Jorge the chance to confess. Go Jorge! Sadly, we find out that Jazmine has a boyfriend! SHOCK! Poor Jorge, he finally had worked up the courage to talk to Jazmine, and then finds out she is taken!

Haha: “Do I… like Jazmine?” Yes, sir, you do. And quite a lot given the way your acting. Face the music, and welcome to love!

And so, the story continues, we see Jorge navigate the treacherous ways of school, and still falling madly in love with Jazmine (he is noticing her everywhere).

Ahhhhhhh, adorable! He just asked her! YAYYYYYYY! Well, OK, to the ball, but it is a start! YAYYYYYY! Finally dating! I don’t consider that a spoiler, come on, it was obvious. Even with the whole boyfriend at first, I just knew that they would end up together. Eep! I just love how well they fitted together, and I was delighted to see the little things they did to spend time together.

Plus, good job Jorge, for acting normal when your girlfriend cuts her hair. Given how tons of other people reacted, which I found really stupid, but then again, I know from personal experience how people act when girls have short hair. 😐

Of course, he is not alone in this book. We also have Garrett and Liv. I do have to be honest and say that I didn’t like how they bickered quite a few times during the book. But thankfully they also show enough times that they are the best of friends. They were quite fun together, bantering.

Liv was a pretty OK character, she has her heart in the right place, though she should be a bit tactful about things (like eating lunch with your current boyfriend while your ex is at the same table… is not what you want to do).  But she does have an amazing superpower of getting people to join or do things, which is pretty nice!

We also see that she has some troubles with her current boyfriend. Of course, we only see her side of the story, so who knows what Marcus’ story is, but still I wanted, just like Jorge, to destroy Liv. Hello, a relationship works from two sides. You can’t just expect her to go with you to stuff, but then find her needy when she wants you and her to go the ball.

Garrett, a new addition to the school, in his previous school he was quarterback, but here? He can’t even play much as there is already a star player who gets all the play time. I didn’t get why he was so hot about James, I just thought that dude was a skeezeball. But I guess he wanted to be in the group, and people do silly things to be in a group.

Zeke? Jazmine’s boyfriend? Sorry, but what? I liked him at times, but it is true what Jorge said, he does seem to have 2 sides to himself. We see one of that in the corridor (when Jorge saves him), and then later at the party (what a crappy move, you don’t do that to your girlfriend). Thankfully, Jazmine isn’t happy either, and it seems that some stuff happened before. I was glad to see him out of the picture.

James? Please just fall off a cliff and disappear. What a disgusting piece of *insert lots of expletives* Especially nearing the ending when he did that to Jorge.

I hated that everyone just believed that Jorge would do those things. Really? Guys? Like, you know this dude, you know how hard he tries to make sure everyone is happy and not being bullied. You saw him with Jazmine, you saw him with other girls. And then you just believe that? Not thinking about how technology isn’t always to be trusted. Anyone can pretend to be someone. Anyone can hack if they really want it. But I guess, kids are just dumb in that way. :{

The whodunnit? Aka the one who was posting as Jorge, well, I was quite shocked. What a dick move.

The ending made me smile so so much! It was just the best way to end this book. A bit of drama, but also happiness and love.

I loved the extra info at the ending, especially how the cover was picked. I am happy that they picked the cover that is now in use. That one just fits the best with this story. How Jorge only sees her, even though his friends are there, even though there is chaos. So sweet!

All in all, I am hoping we get a new graphic novel, featuring another character. Maybe Brooke? Or Nic? And I would highly, very highly, recommend this one!

Was this review helpful?

Too cute and so relatable. As a middle school librarian, I can already forsee this being a big hit. There is something so genuine about the Berrybrook Middle School series. The voices are spot on for a middle school student and I think this one will help so many students gently navigate the awkward time of first crushes and friendships that fluctuate. The text is very accessible for all different reading levels so this is another multiple-copy must have for my library.

Was this review helpful?

Even though I haven’t read the author before, I liked it her style. It's a light reading, the illustrations are so cute and I loved Jorge.

The characters are diverse, and THE FEMALE CHARACTERS!!!, all the girls are strong and independent. I liked the messages that are given in the story. It’s a graphic novel that I would recommend to teenagers.

The only thing that I didn’t like was the issue with James at the end, that took away points from the story. Overall, an entertaining and recommended story.

Was this review helpful?

I SO needed this as a palate cleanse after the last two horrific 1 star graphic novels I just read.

This book is cute and sweet and everything I needed right now. I read the teaser handed out at ALA Annual 2018 and knew that I had to get my hands on the entire thing. I was right, it was so awesome! I didn't realize this was the third in a series, so now I have two other books to look forward to, yay!!

This is a contemporary story from the POV of Jorge, a large middle schooler with two BFFs, Olivia and Russell. It is their story of how they dealt with middle school, classes, teachers, fellow students, gossip, crushes, etc.

Jorge and Olivia were my favs, though the gym teacher was AWESOME. Russell was a bit of an idiot and I didn't like him, but he was true to a less self-assured pre-teen in middle school, so I can't hate on him. Just hate his initial behavior. He does grow and learn, so all is not lost.

This book would be great for the middle school years and maybe a younger, precocious reader and upwards. Highly recommended. 5, shiny, love Jorge and Olivia, stars!

My thanks to NetGalley and Yen Press/JY for an eARC copy of this book to read and review.

Was this review helpful?

A pleasantly lunky giant with a heart of gold finds himself with unexplainable passions for a drama student at his middle grade school. I'd guess the thinking of the modern schoolgoer is conveyed here. To the adult mind some of the late drama was forcibly put on the page just to give a shred of doubt where none was existing – it was fairly obvious they'd get over the hurdle and end up together, after all – and some of it was very much edutainment about respect and "don't touch, don't even look, don't judge people like that because people have done it for millennia but it's wrong now, OK?!" and all that malarkey. But on the whole it's a worthwhile, pleasant read.

Was this review helpful?

It is time to return to Berrybrook Middle School, where things are just as cute and complicated as always. Everyone around Jorge seems to be pairing off, but he isn’t about that romantic life. His two best friends are going through their own growing pains. Liv is having trouble with her new boyfriend and Garrett is desperate to infiltrate the popular guy’s sports clique. Jorge soon finds that he actually does like a girl at school, Jasmine, if only he could gain the confidence to talk to her. Serious tensions begin to evolve around these characters when Garrett’s new friends bully/torment their peers.

This graphic novel does not disappoint. The art and story are on point. The plot is realistic and relevant to today’s teens. I love the manga stylings of Chmakova. I love her diverse cast of characters and her socially conscious narratives, which support the growth of young girls. I know this one isn’t technically out yet, I know that the author just had a baby, but GAAHHH I want more!!

Was this review helpful?