Member Reviews

Thank you for the opportunity to preview this book! I know it will find its audience (much of it built-in), but it wasn't grabbing me. To be fair, I also couldn't get into the two other chick-lit books I was trying, so the problem could definitely be my mood. :)

Here are more characters and more characters to meet the minimum.

Was this review helpful?

A pity that this book is a retelling of such a legendary book because honestly it just does not cut it. I am an avid reader and hardly leave any book midway through but this one just could not hold me. The protagonist of this book, unlike the original, is full of fluff and nonsense who doesn’t even come across as an interesting fictional character. The portrayal lacked depth of perception or even language. It is very sad to have to write a review like this because books are my religion but I was given this as an ARC by #Netgalley (@netgalley) for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Emma wished she could freeze this moment. Her neighbor Adam came up to her - most of the time she sees him in sweaty running clothes or jeans and a tee shirt when he works at home. He does clean up nice. Then Adam said she did a wonderful job on the wedding but was it really Annalise? Annalise- the bride was her best friend and her partner in crime since forever. She had even talked to her father so they could have the wedding in her childhood home. Emma :had been the matchmaker, best friend, wedding planner, hostess, and maid of honor. Emma thought about Worth Papers and Stationary. She was never going to be good enough for the family business was she? Annalisa was moving across the country to be with her new husband. Her life would be different with Annalisa with her as a roommate and close by. At four years old Emma’s mother packed up all her gowns, furs and jewelry that was when Emma knew her mother wasn’t coming back leaving her husband and daughter. Emma was trying to do some work on her computer but the moving guys had started getting Annalisa’s stuff early in the am even though most of the furniture was Emma’s. Then Belinda came by - she was that neighbor - the one always poking her nose in everyone’s business. Emma has a blog called Worth it- an online guide to the best places in New York to eat, shop, see, and be seen. The Blog had started as something to keep Emma busy after she quit her job at the fashion e-commerce site- Luxe. After one year in her blog Emma had an ever-growing stream of readers Emma had experience conceptualizing, launching, and running, and running a blog. But now Emma was bored with the blog. She wanted to feel the thrill of a challenge and the satisfaction of a job well done again. ;As a favor to her old nanny Cynthia Emma had agreed to keep an eye on Cynthia’s niece Hailey who had just moved to NYC. Right now Hailey said she only wanted a server’s job to pay the bills until she figured out what she wants to do with her life. At Hailey’s age Emma thought she would go in the family business then her father rhden her father said he wouldn’t condone her working ai Worth Paper and Stationary . How that had killed Emma.
I really couldn’t get into this book. Emma got too into into Hailey’s life. Hailey should not have wanted Emma to make dating decisions for her . She isn't a little girl she is a college graduate and she should have had some idea what she wanted to do and it should have something to do with what she had majored in college. Also Emma should not have stretched the truth about Zac’s interest in Hailey just on what Emma thought Zac felt for Hailey. I was very disappointed in this. But I am sure there are others who will really like this but it’s not for me.

Was this review helpful?

I tried and tried, but I could never get behind Emma in this retelling of the classic Jane Austen novel. While the similarities between Hilliges' Emma and the original were certainly present, I found the modern-day heroine completely lacking in depth and likability. Stick with the original, or one of the many other renditions of this story that are so much better.

I received this book free from NetGalley in exchange for my honest and unbiased opinion.

Was this review helpful?

when i saw this on netgalley i was so excited! i love Austen retellings. sure, normally i read P&P or Persuasion retellings, simply because they are more common. i think the reason they are more common is that they translate so well to a modern time, whereas emma or S&S just... don't. northanger really doesn't. that's not the fault of the people writing the retellings, it's just how it is.

i love the original Emma, of course. so i was excited for this one. unfortunately it fell flat for me and i hate that. i wanted to like it. i feel like i give retellings a head start that i wouldn't give other books - i already love them for the story i know and love. i try not to compare every little thing, i love spotting the similarities and discovering what things the author changes. i could never be that imaginative. unfortunately, in this one, i liked some of the differences but the others rubbed me the wrong way. emma, in the original, is meddling, sure, but she means well. she's spoiled and a daddy's girl but she's not nasty or malicious. this emma just did not work for me.

i hate when i don't like books. i don't want to pick apart every single thing i didn't like. i am sorry i didn't like this. i hope other people do. the writing was good and i will pick up another book by this author. i just didn't like this particular spin on an old favourite.

i have no idea how much blood sweat and tears go into writing a book.. but the simple fact is there is no one book that will please everyone and conversely, we can't like every single book we read.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Red Envelope Press for the ARC.

DNF at 30%. I'm sorry, but it's too different from what I expected when I requested this title.

Was this review helpful?

This is another retelling in the year of retellings. Emma and the City is a retelling of Emma by Jane Austen. I liked reading it. I was disappointed not to see descriptions of New York or Hartfield through Emma's point-of-view. There is barely any romance in the book so I would caution readers to not pick up the book expecting so.

Overall, I did not love the book as I had presumed. however,I would encourage readers to pick it up as it has potential to be a good women's fiction.

Was this review helpful?