Member Reviews

This was a weird book that I didn't quite understand, but I did like reading it. This book feels more cerebral rather than fun, but it was a nice read and easy to get through!

Was this review helpful?

I received a free copy of this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Rutherford's book does pretty much what you want a pop science book to do: it provides an accessible, often simplifying to the point of near-deception, walk-through of complicated scientific processes, the main one here being how homo sapiens became the dominant species on the planet. Of course, this isn't actually a "scientific" process at all, but too often we've left it to natural sciences to provide all the explanations, which tends to leave us with very little explanation at all. What I particularly like about Rutherford's approach is that he shows just how our dissimilarity to other species is a question of degrees, and whatever we like to pretend is uniquely human might not be so unique after all. Less successful - as almost always is the case - is his attempt at explaining the "human" drives to create art, invent, complete large-scale projects etc. But overall, apart from the awful title, this book is a fun and easy-going journey through the history of homo sapiens.

Was this review helpful?

Everyone knows that humans are animals and that we belong in the same family as chimpanzees and gorillas, but we are always quick to point out what makes us stand above the other animals. Rutherford points out that many of the things we thought made us unique are not quite as uncommon as we thought. Humans are the only ones who make and use tools. Well, not quite. Only humans use fire. Guess again. Humans are the only ones to create fashions and decorate ourselves. Wrong again (although I doubt the trend of wearing a blade of grass in our ears will catch on any time soon). Rutherford's surprisingly humorous and readable analysis shows that while we may share more than we thought with other animals, humans are still remarkable and unique.

Was this review helpful?

A very well-written book on an oft-pondered upon issue - What makes us human? Is it our culture, ability to transmit and write stories or ability to develop tools?

Rutherford makes a passionate case for us humans not being so different from the animals at all. We traditionally have been guilty of thinking us to be the pinnacle of an evolutionary ladder (nothing like that exists btw) and of late, anthropomorphising animals to such an extent that we start projecting human conditions/behaviour in them. Rutherford warns us about both, all the while reminding us that, we are in our own way unique, just like how thermophilic bacteria can survive in extreme environmental conditions or how meerkats live in social groups protecting each other. In the same manner, we are just humanimals, extraordinary, unique and fascinatingly quite similar in the same way as every other species is.

My Rating - 4/5

Was this review helpful?

Evolutionary history and evolutionary biology are fascinating subjects, and in his latest book, Humanimal, author Adam Rutherford takes a look at what sets humans apart from the rest of the animal kingdom, and asks if we are truly as unique as we have been led to believe. Broadly speaking he looks at a variety of behaviours that are often regarded as uniquely human , ranging from speech and communication , to art and the use of tools and even sex for pleasure rather than procreation and finds examples from around the globe that show similar behaviours in animal species that will surprise you. It is fascinating to read about species of birds in Australia who have learned to use fire as a tool to flush out prey, or dolphins who use sea sponges on their snouts as protection when hunting. Rutherford clearly and simply breaks down how the genetic similarities and differences between humans and other animals may be less than many would expect, but they are enough to make us vastly different.
Although the subject of the book is vast and complex, Rutherford does a wonderful job in breaking it down, and making it not just accessible but also fascinating to the lay reader with no background in the topic.
“We transmit information,” writes the author, “not just via DNA down the generations, but in every direction, to people with whom we have no immediate biological ties. We log our knowledge and experience, and share them. It is in the teaching of others, the shaping of culture, and the telling of stories, that we created ourselves.”
I read and reviewed an ARC courtesy of NetGalley and the publisher, all opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

Humanimal is an examination of what it means to be human from a genetic and biological standpoint, and how our definers mirror those of what we consider ‘animals.’ Rutherford presents a well-researched guide to humanity – from our bodies to our behaviors to our cultures. Human history is a long, drawn out story and Humanimal makes it fascinating.

You’ll learn a lot about the ways different animals match human behaviors and genetic makeup. How do animal brains compare to human brains? How does sexuality manifest in animals as compared to humans? Does the usage of tools actually work as an indicator of human intellect, given the fact that so many animals have created crude tools of their own? The similarities are surprising at times, showing how much we truly are a part of the world. It’s easy to imagine humanity as vastly different from the other living things around us but, behavior-wise, we’re quite similar.

Most interesting is the sub-section regarding human speech. This is a book that gives us the root information and continues with further details until you feel pretty knowledgable about most parts of the human condition. The author examines the parts of our DNA that make it possible for us to speak before diving into how language has evolved over time and, further, how the meaning of words have evolved. It’s a fascinating progression that says a lot about our history and its sheer length of time.

Above all, expect Humanimal to teach you a bevy of things you didn’t know about the world and its inhabitants. You’d be surprised at how entertaining genetics can be when illustrated by a talented author. This is an easy-to-read guide that entertains, surprises, and enlightens.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley, the Experiment, and Adam Rutherford for an ARC ebook copy to review. As always, an honest review from me.

Like:
- Opportunity to learn even more about evolution
- Shows the specific genetics and behaviors that contribute to evolutionary change
- Many visuals to help with understanding of the text


Love:
- Everyone can learn something from this book
- Complex information that’s written in an easy to understand way. You don’t need a college degree in science to understand the information

Dislike:
- Not so much a dislike, but more of a warning- there’s chapters on sexual activity ( because how else are new animals and humans created) It goes in depth into various sexual activities, mating practices, and genital touching. So heads up, if you end up listening as an audiobook without headphones.

Wish that: —


Overall, a well written, comprehensive book about the step by step process of evolution. Written in an interesting easily accessible manner. I definitely recommend if you’re interested in the topic!

Was this review helpful?

Another great book by Rutherford that will not disappoint

I loved this book. I wasn’t surprised, however, since I had read two other books by Adam Rutherford - “A Brief History of Everyone Who Ever Lived” and “Creation” and had loved those as well. In this book, Rutherford makes the case that humans are animals and that many of the ways we behave is also seen in the animal world. Rutherford writes with a conversational tone and he makes the science completely accessible. Humanimals is well written and with the same sense of humor that Rutherford displayed in his other books. And again, the footnotes are worth reading.

Was this review helpful?

What an intriguing look at the fine lines that separate humans from animals, and yet really, there is not a lot of distinction genetically. The descriptions of DNA and genetic codes were easy enough to follow, and yet at the end I found myself not really close to understanding the brilliance of science and nature. I believe the point of the book was to inform readers that despite the marvelous advances in scientific research, DNA coding, continual theory, speculation, and scientific experimentation, we are still a long way from discovering the "missing link" that made us evolve as we did, and continue to do so. It is as if the more we know, the less we know despite our best efforts to figure out the complete truth of why we are here and how we are as we are.

I found the sections on sexual habits and evolution a little disturbing, and yet I know that was not the intention. They were matter-of-fact observations told in clear words, and they were not offensive, and yet it brings home the point that, really, acceptable behavior boils down to our thinking and mental process. It ties into specific current society as to what is considered acceptable and what is not, and it is also varied from country to country. I loved reading about the mystery of the evolution of language, and although I have studied a little of the history of cave paintings and Venus sculptures, this was a fresh look and more in-depth with knowledge that dates back to far beyond what I have learned in the past. I particularly like the fact that at the end the author states that he did his own research based on the work of other scientists and their works. It's really a compilation of pared down research done by others,. He does give credit where credit is due.

This is a fascinating look at evolution. It is not a book that most people, in general, will pick up and read; it is not a light, easy, get-lost-in-the-story kind of book, and I am uncertain as to a true audience that will appreciate it. I did appreciate in the end, although I also found some of the science throughout a bit over my head. I am glad for a chance to read and review it. It is not a genre or a book I would generally pick up and read from cover-to-cover, but I did in this instance and I am glad that I did.

Was this review helpful?

The author provides a complete scientific reference about the link between humans' basic behaviors and natural animal instincts. A deep reflection and an interesting approach to describe the evolution of the ape into a complex biological and cultural unique being. Excellent book!

#TheBookOfHumans #NetGalley #TheExperiment

Was this review helpful?

Humanimal is the popular science book by Adam Rutherford, which discusses both the role of evolution and genetics in the story of humans, complete with beautiful illustrations by Alice Roberts.

Fascinating anecdotes run throughout the book; whether that be pyromaniac birds, homosexual giraffes or Obama-recognising sheep. However the book is much more than just animalistic anecdotes, but presents a well-balanced discussion of the biology that shapes us. Where Rutherford does particularly well is balancing the cognitive dissonance we can have when studying animals. We are guilty of both anthropomorphize animals, projecting the human condition onto animals, as well as the opposite—
considering ourselves superior, when in fact we may not be as distinct from the animal kingdom as we would like to believe. These issues can be interesting to consider when thinking about zoology—that it is one animal studying another.

The book is well written, and accessible—the level of scientific discussion is both sufficiently clear for beginners to the field but lively enough to interest those with a scientific background. In addition the focus is broad, combining archaeology, neurology, zoology, genetics and beyond.

Was this review helpful?

An interesting take on a well-chewed subject. What makes humans human - how do we differ from all our relatives, from the great apes to bacteria and viruses? It's mostly, though not entirely, about behavior - cultural transmission of information and habits, and how that is not _quite_ unique to humans. Use of tools, making of tools, even use of fire...fashion and pointless decoration, too. And considerable discussion of sex, how our behavior is similar to and different from that of various animals - with the repeated caveat that while you can ask a human why they're doing something (and sometimes get the answer "because it feels good"), you can't ask an animal why they're doing it, or how they feel about what they're doing (this applies to sex, but also to tool use, and many other behaviors). I also found the review of (relatively) recent archaeological discoveries interesting - a subject I enjoy, but my knowledge is rather behind. This is my first Rutherford, it won't be my last. I received this book through Netgalley in return for a review.

Was this review helpful?

The effort to distinguish humans from the rest of the animals has filled volumes since before Darwin took his fated voyage on the HMS Beagle: tools, war, sex habits, language. In his latest book, The Book of Humans: The Story of How We Became Us, geneticist Adam Rutherford looks at each of these things and how our behaviour is different to and often surprisingly similar to other animals. The use of tools eg. was once seen as the main distinguishing factor that made us unique but scientists have documented many cases of animals using tools, monkeys using twigs to get at hidden insects and, as recently as 2017, some birds of prey were seen picking up sticks from brush fires and dropping them in dry grass to drive small animals into the open for easy pickings. As to sex habits, it has been argued in the past that humans were the only animals that had sex for reasons other than procreation but that is no longer the case. As Rutherford points out, there are few sexual habits of humans that haven't been observed in other species - here, I will freely admit I now know more than I ever thought I needed or wanted to know about the sex habits of dolphins and otters - turns out they can be really big jerks in the sack.

In the end, Rutherford shows we really aren't that much different from other animals except in our ability, not only to learn but to teach and not just our closest kin but strangers. He also shows how we haven't really evolved genetically from our ancient Homo Sapiens ancestors or even likely Neanderthal or Denisovans - they had a capacity for language, for art, for symbolism just as we do now. He posits that it was increased population rather than genetics that is responsible for the rise of civilization, that as populations increase, so does our knowledge and skill-sharing.

Adam Rutherford has become one of my favourite science writers - he not only makes the science accessible to the scientifically illiterate like myself but, thanks to his use of humour, he makes it fun to read. The Book of Humans is no exception. It is well-written, well-documented, clearly explained and interesting. I would even call it entertaining, a word I'm sure most would agree is rarely used to describe a book of science.

<i>Thanks to Netgalley and The Experiment for the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review</i>

Was this review helpful?

Un viaggio appassionante nell'evoluzione non solo umana.
Una storia di creature, perse nei labirinti del tempo o ancora nostre compagne sul pianeta, che è la storia di tutti noi.

Was this review helpful?

On the whole, this book provides an easy to read, overly simplified introduction to human evolution and what makes humans different (or not) from other animals. Each section covers a different aspect of "humaness", such as tool use, sex, speech development and cultural dissemination. I found the book a bit bland and lacking in substance as it did not provide any information that I hadn't come across in other books, journal, magazine or internet articles.

Was this review helpful?

This book does difficult work of making complex topics simpler and interesting at the same time, so that non technical reader may enjoy and learn a lot of things about our past and how it unfolded. Book is engaging description of how humans used tools, language, teachings,fire and art to conquer the earth and how we became better than our cousin apes and all the mammals, who share many similar genetic features.
After a slow first chapter, book becomes rainbow of fabulous facts about us and animal kingdom. Chapters on sex life of man and animal kingdom is very good with details you will be surprised to know. Book dissects brains of man and other species in parallel. Illustrations that pop out at various points are pleasurable bonus.
Thing which one may dislike is complex discussion of genes and genetics and too much Darwin. Also, description of cannabalism, rape and abnormal sexual behaviour in animals may be distracting force for some readers.
Overall, a feast for science and non fiction lovers with a lot of new information but little complex nodes in between.

Was this review helpful?

I would love to read this, but I also had trouble with the download. I hope they fix the issue so we can read the book.

Was this review helpful?