Member Reviews

I came across this book in ARC form to read and give my honest opinion. I give this book a 3.5/5 stars. I loved the graphics of this book. It’s really beautifully put together. The storyline I also enjoyed.
Mera:Tidebreaker is an origin story of Mera. We learn that she dislikes the Atlantans and is part of an arranged marriage. Mera doesn’t want to be married instead she wants to rule by herself and wish her father could see that. Mera over hears her father talking about killing Arthur/future Aquaman. The teenage rebel that Mera is she wants to prove to her father that she doesn’t need a husband to be a great ruler and decides to leave home and kill Arthur herself.
Although the graphics are AMAZINGLY done I couldn’t get past the insta-love. She started out her story hating the man but then after showing some kindness she is in love? I feel like this just seems a little off for Mera’s character. Especially since she was passionate about being taken seriously as an independent warrior and future ruler.

Was this review helpful?

Strong female characters are always a favorite of mine so I definitely enjoyed diving into Mera's world!

Was this review helpful?

A great look into a character gaining popularity due to the new movie. An interesting reimagining of the starts of Arthur and his future queen.

Was this review helpful?

Mera: Tidebreaker is the prequel-ish graphic novel to how Mera and Arthur meet. This was a fun read, but not MCU friendly. Arthur has no idea who he is and Mera is more of a warrior than the princess we met in the movie.

When Mera hears about a chance to earn her right to the throne, she decides to take it. But, what happens when she meets too good to be true Arthur? This was a fun and fast read. I do wish the font was a bit different, it made the digital version kind of hard to read, almost like it was out of focus.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great start to DC's new YA line -- DC Ink, and a great way to get introduced to unfamiliar characters. I loved the art too!

Was this review helpful?

I don't read graphic novels or comics as often, but with all the movies, I've started to find that I do enjoy the stories. This is one of those. While it's definitely YA and for the teen crowd, I enjoyed reading Mera's story, and seeing this adaptation. I enjoyed the artwork, and the story is easily one that YA readers would enjoy. I know there seems to be a push for 'older' characters and situations in YA lately, but this one tends to fall back more to the YA when it started to really get noticed, and I loved the somewhat simpler style that tells the story that teens can read and enjoy without being asked to grow-up too fast.

This story wasn't ground-breaking or overly complex, but was still enjoyable and one I can recommend to readers from ages 9-19 without worry, and can also seeing adults enjoying it as long as they don't try to compare it, and instead are willing to accept it for what it is, a YA teen story about a girl trying to find her place.

Was this review helpful?

Mera is a mermaid princess who is overlooked as just a pretty face who can only talk about dresses. But what she really wants to be is a warrior and what she really wants to talk about is her kingdom’s future. So in order to get respect, after overhearing her father and his general talk, she decides to go on a mission to kill the prince of a rival kingdom.

I really enjoyed the pacing of the book and the plot. It was fast, but almost a little too fast. I felt as though the author jumped around a little too much from conversation to conversation and same with the action. A little of the dialogue was cheesy, but not too bad.

The art was gorgeous and I loved the blue-toned of it and how Mera and her father’s hair really popped orange.

Although it wasn’t a main focus, I also really enjoyed the bit of romance we got. I also think she did a good job of setting up future conflicts and fun bits for a future novel.

Was this review helpful?

I read this comic in one sitting. I liked it, but I didn't loved it. It's fast paced, and I loved fantasy part of it, but contemporary thing was totally dumb for me. I hate insta love, and this one has that. I hoped there will be more action. But, I loved tge universe and Mera is such a badass. Artwork was good, but I hated that everything was green. All in all, a good comic, but it's not what I thought it will be. At the end it was teased there will be more comics about Mera and I still want to find out what happened next. I would recommend this to young adults who just watched the Aquaman and want more of that world.

Was this review helpful?

Given the popularity of the Aquaman movie, most readers will be aware of Mera as an undersea princess, but it’s refreshing to see that here, she’s also a warrior, willing to fight for her people. While navigating history, birthright, and expectations, Mera learns to decide her own fate in this rewarding read.

Xebel, her father’s kingdom, is ruled by Atlantis. Mera’s father has two plans: to marry her off to his chosen successor, and to choose the winner by seeing who can assassinate the missing heir to the Atlantean throne, Arthur. Mera, meanwhile, is worried about living up to her mother’s legacy as warrior queen and steamed that her father doesn’t even consider her to take the throne as his heir.

Mera sets off to the oversea world to complete the mission herself, but once she meets Arthur, things don’t go as planned. Arthur, not yet Aquaman, here has the amazing-nice-guy demeanor of Superman or Shazam, which gets him further than the ability to talk to fish. Similarly, the emphasis is on Mera’s abilities and training, not any kind of superpowers (although she can make water blasts).

Events move briskly, keeping the reader interested in an epic story. Although a lot happens, the story has room to breathe, with large-sized panels to punctuate key moments. The faded color scheme, grey with hints of light green, makes the book almost resemble a black-and-white independently published comic. The tones evoke both filtered undersea light and the haze of memory. It also allows Mera’s red hair to pop, drawing the reader’s eye to her as lead on whatever page she’s on.

It’s convenient that the framework is familiar to many fantasy stories, allowing the reader to focus on Mera’s motivations. There’s a solid amount of action, but more importantly, there’s a realistic depth of characterization that establishes Mera as someone worth spending time with, someone more than Aquaman’s girlfriend. Although classically formulaic, evoking star-crossed lovers and those buffeted by fate and constrained by royalty, the journey here is deep and satisfying.

Was this review helpful?

This review will be rather short, as the GN was a quick read. I have never read any of the original comics, so I was going in with only the movie, mythology love and mild general knowledge of who Mera is, and the "story" of Aquaman.

I instantly loved the idea of a bad ass underwater princess/queen. I am a sucker for the Princess saves the day trope, and adding any kind of water to that - I'm sold. Mera was an interesting character. She was immature to be sure, but that was true to her age. She was also brave, headstrong and full of kindness, potential and heart.

I don't feel like that the story lines are as in depth and complicated in this tale as it is in a typical novel. The story revolves around Mera, who is now in the Queen in Exile, and her

journey from under the sea, to the land, and back. There is a constant feud between her people of Xebel and Atlantis, so of course we have a star crossed lovers trope in there, for good measure. If I'm honest - I really didn't care. Arthur and Mera are a favorite of just about everyone, so the over used trope is easily overlooked and forgiven.

The main characters are likeable, but Arthur can be very over the top at times - Mera puts him in his place a few times during the story. This made them more relatable for me. Boys can be dumb, and girls can be leaders. It was refreshing to see this antic play out between the two chracters.

The writing was what I expect of Paige, though it did feel a bit more middle grade dialogue at times, instead of the YA we are used to. I actually enjoyed this aspect - as comics and GN should be accessible and easily understood for the younger age range.

The art was beautiful, and by far my favorite part of the book. The characters were drawn well, without the over sexualization. Bryne did a wonderful job bringing them to life for a younger audience, and I will absolutely be adding this to my classroom reading list!

Was this review helpful?

This is part of DC's initiative to have YA authors write graphic novels aspart of the DC Ink imprint. This is very much a YA approach to Mera's origin. The basics are all there. Mera is still from Xebel and can control water. She's been sent to kill Arthur. Now there's something of a love triangle and some angst with her father built in. But in a very YA way, she falls in love with Arthur over the course of 2 days. Personally I think they could have just left that part out and just have her realize he's a good person and decide not to murder him without bringing in the romantic angle, saving that for a future book.

The star here is really the art. I love Stephen Byrne's crisp clean lines and muted sea foam coloring. It's absolutely gorgeous with the only pop of color being Mera's hair. My only complaint would be why did they change Arthur's hair color. Aquaman has always been blond except for Jason Mamoa and the Arthur depicted here looks nothing like Mamoa. If the whole goal is to get new generations interested in comics, wouldn't you want to make your characters as familiar as possible?

Was this review helpful?

I love this book and have had a few conversations with savvy teens and their parents about how they should read it!

Was this review helpful?

DC Ink continues to introduce younger readers to comic book characters. Danielle Paige does a satisfying job of introducing Mera and her role in the larger Aquaman story. While the plot has enough action and quippy fun for even casual fans, there is a lack of depth to Mera and Arthur's relationship and characterization that might leave some readers wanting more. Overall I enjoyed the art style and think many teens will as well.

Was this review helpful?

I loved getting the back story of mera. The art style and writing were phenomenal. This is a must read if your a fan of aquaman.

Was this review helpful?

It had good potential, but fell victim to some bad cliches. If you can look past them, it's enjoyable, but if not?

Was this review helpful?

This graphic novel bridges the gap between the adult Mera we see in the Aquaman movie, and a teenage Mera. It isn't a direct link to the movie because in this story Mera meets Arthur as a young teen. Mera is trapped in several gilded cages in her life. She is the princess of a community under the heel of Atlantis.
Mera hears of a plot against Arthur being planned by her father and her potential betrothed. She devises a plan to kill Arthur herself and possibly carving out some freedom for herself.

Things don't go the way Mera wants. She is injured and ends up being rescued by Arthur. As she gets to know him she doubts her mission and only together can they possibly create a future that leaves them both free. I loved the art on this book but the story lagged in a few places. It truly is a teen story and I think I'm a little to connected to the adult Mera because I found some of her choices in this story challenging. A great read for first time readers stepping into the Aquaman universe.

Was this review helpful?

I thought this was very interesting. The art was beautiful and the story was easy to follow. Mild language.

Was this review helpful?

Loved this story of Mera. The drawings are intricate and easy to follow. If you've seen the new movie, it doesn't match up to that, but was fine. I enjoyed the girl power aspect of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Mera: Tidebreaker is a basic origin story of Mera and Aquaman. The story and illustrations were fine. I hope the actions picks up in the next installment. Thanks DC Entertainment and NetGalley for the ARC of this title.

Was this review helpful?

I was hoping to enjoy this one but I’ve tried multiple ways multiple times and I’m still unable to open it. For now it’s sitting here waiting to be enjoyed. Please help me get access so I can change my review.

Was this review helpful?