Member Reviews

Harry Bordeaux installs his wife in Montauk for the summer, while he spends his weeks working in the city, and vacationing at the beach on the weekends. The only problem is that he is spending his weeknights sleeping with other women, and his wife is not being a social success in Montauk. She is making the wrong friends, and making enemies of the wrong people. While her new friend Dolly is overtly “bad”, Beatrice is subversive. She doesn’t belong in her husband’s society crowd, and every choice she makes takes her further and further from being able to “fit in”.

Set in the seaside village in the run-up to World War II, this novel delivers a period atmosphere, and had enough plotting to keep me involved.

Was this review helpful?

Montauk is a small fishing town recently discovered by the elite from New York City. The wealthy flock to this seaside town for an extravagant summer of excess. Among them is Beatrice Bordeaux and her husband Harry, a young married couple. What follows is a summer of leisure that leaves Beatrice going some major soul searching.⁣

I initially thought this was a historical fiction book about the beginning of Montauk. This is actually a coming of age story with an unlikely love story. I enjoyed learning more about Montauk in 1938 and how this town came to be. I was pleasantly surprised when the story took a turn, as I thought I had it mapped out. The ending was completely unexpected. I’m impressed with this debut author and look forward to more from her in the future. For me, Montauk was ⭐️⭐️⭐️/5 stars. Thank you @stmartinspress for this advance reader in exchange for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

It is hard to believe that this is a debut novel, it is so engaging and beautifully written!

Montauk by Nicola Harrison takes place in 1938 when America is fighting to come back from the depression and World War II is yet a rumble on the horizon. New York City’s elite summer at Montauk, Long Island, the new “in” summer resort for the wealthy. The wives and children spend the summer, while the men work in the city during the week and come to the island for weekends. In contrast, the year-round locals live in a fishing village, full of shanty-like homes, doing whatever they can to get by.

Beatrice, the main character, grew up in a small town in Pennsylvania. Her beginnings were quite humble. Following the death of her brother, she moves to NYC, and meets Harry, a man of privilege. They marry and Bea is thrown into a social scene that she is ill-prepared for. She has a hard time fitting in with the socialites at Montauk and doesn’t understand (or agree with) their vacuous interests and values. Nor does she understand why Harry seems to find reasons not to come on the weekends and avoids spending time with her when he does. She expects more from marriage and is at a loss as to how to make things better, when Harry seems so uninterested in their relationship. More and more uncomfortable at Montauk Manor, Bea befriends Elizabeth, the local laundress. This is somewhat scandalous for the time and Bea doesn’t realize that her need for a friend could cause problems for Elizabeth. The more Bea explores the island, the more she falls in love with its natural beauty. She walks many fine lines all summer, trying to meet her “obligation” to curry the favor of the wealthy, pretending that all is well in her train-wreck of a marriage, and keeping her growing involvement with the townspeople a secret. It is a summer of great inner conflict and growth for Bea.

The author stays true to the social mores of the day when the roles and expectations of men and women are strictly defined and the differences between the social and economic classes are great and not meant to be breached. Her characters are fully complex and relatable (even the irritating ones!), and she is skilled at setting the scene with her descriptions.

An entertaining read from an author I look forward to reading again. This gets a 4-star rating from me.

Many thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin’s Press for allowing me to read an ARC of this novel in exchange for an unbiased review. All opinions expressed here are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I cannot believe this is Nicola Harrison’s debut book! The writing flowed beautifully and every word just drew me and I felt I was right there breathing in the ocean air. This book takes place in 1938 in Montauk which is at the tip of Long Island. Beatrice Bordeaux who was born into the lower/ middle class went to college but did not finish when her brother died unexpectedly in an accident. She married Harry Bordeaux a wealthy businessman after meeting him while she worked as a secretary. Beau and Henry are spending the summer in Montauk a hotspot for the wealthy. Beatrice and Henry’s marriage is failing after man failed pregnancy’s and she’s hoping this vacation will fix their marriage and possibly lead to a pregnancy. She’s soon shocked when she finds that Henry plans on spending most of his time in the city drinking, working and carrying on with numerous affairs while Beatrice is left on her own acting like everything is fine in Montauk. Beatrice finds herself bored and unhappy and she doesn’t get along with the other wealthy wives at the resort in Montauk. She soon finds a friend with the laundry woman Elizabeth and finds a friend in the lighthouse keeper Thomas and finds herself falling for him. Beatrice soon discovers more about herself the more Henry is away, and she knows she needs to come to some conclusion as the end of summer draws near. Beatrice’s story pulled at my heart and I so wanted her to find happiness. I loved this book I found myself getting lost in her story and I was amazed with each character. I give this four stars I didn’t want this book to end! It’s a perfect summer read!

Was this review helpful?

Montauk is more historical romance than it is historical fiction and typically that's not what I'm looking for when I pick up a historical novel but lately, I can't seem to delve into anything deep, so I was very pleasantly surprised to be swept away by the utter beauty of Nicola Harrison's debut novel. 

Harrison impressed me from the start with her writing style. It is lyrical and flows so elegantly as she describes the beauty of Montauk, the charming village off the end of Long Island known still today for its gorgeous beaches, luxury resort, and historic lighthouse.

In 1938, Beatrice Bordeaux and husband Harry head to Montauk Manor, the luxury resort built by famous financier Carl Fisher (developer of Miami Beach), with plans that she will spend the summer there with other wealthy wives while he visits from the city on the weekends―although he rarely ever visits as promised. Beatrice loses all hope in reigniting their passion and trying for a child, especially once she discovers Harry has other interests. 

Beatrice, who is from a middle-class family, soon grows bored and annoyed with the gossipy, sniping, idle other wives and takes off exploring the seaside village of Montauk where she befriends Elizabeth, the laundress for the resort. Elizabeth and her family remind Beatrice of her own roots, and she begins to clearly see what she's missing in her own marriage and life.

Beatrice also becomes close to Thomas, the lighthouse keeper, and the relationship that develops between the two is quite lovely and gives Beatrice a chance to discover the woman she really wants to be. Yet, it's emotional and bittersweet, and I shed some tears―so maybe keep some tissues handy.

I really enjoyed this one and the issues it explored such as class privileges and societal norms of the time period and true love without money versus living in a loveless marriage. If you like your hist-fic to have a romantic side, then Montauk is perfect. It's also an ideal summer read since Harrison does such a wonderful job taking you right to the beach town of Montauk! 

**Thank you NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for an ARC to read in exchange for my fair and honest review.**

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for an eARC of this book.
What a disappointment. I counted on this book being more a romance than a mystery but was in the mood for a bit of fluff. It was very slow getting started and though it moved more quickly, I just couldn't relate to the characters and I really didn't much like them. It was a real struggle to get to the end.

Was this review helpful?

Montauk by Nicola Harrison certainly was a surprise! The setting is the summer of 1938 and the New York elite are vacationing on the resort beach of Montauk. Talk of war is just that, talk, and no one believes it could happen again especially not the rich and privileged. Beatrice Bordeaux is the main character. I loved her! She is from a blue collar background and has married into high society. The death of her brother has changed her life and a new life with Harry Boudreaux seems to be just the ticket. But when Beatrice spends the summer at Montauk with the other high society wives she realizes she isn’t as happy as she thought. And waiting every month to see if she is pregnant isn’t helping. While Harry is taking care of “.business” in the city Beatrice discovers what true happiness is. Thomas, the lighthouse keeper, changes her life in more than one unexpected way.
Montauk brings to life the last vestiges of the wide gap between the rich and the poor before World War II. I loved the descriptions of fashion and food as well as the carefree lifestyle of the rich. But the “locals” are probably the most realistic in the story. Living day to day, loving each other despite the lack of money and facing life head on. I can’t say the ending was my favorite but I still am certain this is a 5 star story!
I voluntarily received a copy of this book from Netgalley.

Was this review helpful?

If you love Beatriz Williams...Nicola Harrison will be your new favorite author! Historical fiction, a beach read & romance all wrapped up into one delicious summer novel! I held off reading this book, so I could read it closer to the summer season! I knew from reading the description was absolutely going to adore it!

I loved the romance, the scandal, the island gossip - I loved it all!

I have already recommend this book to several friends!

4.5 out of 5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

What a great debut Nicola Harrison! This has all the high-drama and scandal of a soap opera. Set in 1938, Beatrice has married Harry, who is very wealthy. She, herself, came from a more humble backgroung. Spending the entire summer in Montauk, New York - a beach resort town, Beatrice tries to throw herself into the high-society curriculum and make friends. She longs for a child and wants to rekindle her marriage which has become stale. She is pretty sure Harry is cheating on her.

This is a fascinating, scandal-filled view of lives of the privileged in a country on the verge of war. I enjoyed the read and my daughter will love it as she always likes books filled with "cheating". The themes are romance, scandal, women's issues, class inequality, and political issues - quite a range. The characters come alive on the page and the book is well-written.

Thanks to Nicola Harrison and St. Martin's Press through Netgalley for an advance copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Nicola Harrison does an amazing job of bringing Montauk, Long Island in 1938 to life. Although I would have liked to see more descriptions of the beach and the view from the lighthouse, the setting and atmosphere of Montauk and the Montauk Manor are lush, elegant and glamourous and make it seem the perfect place to spend the summer. The looming development of Montauk and what it will do to the locals is a fascinating story. Harrison also captures the not-so-perfect restrictions, prejudices, class distinctions, anti-Semitism and male/female rules, restrictions and expectations and social mores of the time. Some of the behavior and attitudes of so-called professionals were eye-opening to say the least.

While I loved the historical aspect of Montauk, I was not as pleased with the character development and romance. Beatrice Bordeaux is naïve, immature, innocent, deeply hurt by Harry. She has never really fit in with the society life and its expectations she’s been thrust into, and now rather than the opportunity to rekindle the romance with her husband, she is faced with 12 weeks with women she doesn’t know or feel comfortable with. She may never have married Harry in the first place had she not withdrawn so much after her brother Charlie’s death.

But this is the life she chose, and she comes off as careless and irresponsible in her forced interaction with the locals. She may feel more naturally at home with them, but she is not of their world anymore and she puts their livelihood at risk. She insists on becoming a part of Elizabeth’s life, and she’s playing with fire with Thomas, putting not only her own reputation and way of life at risk but those of so many others, especially Elizabeth and her family and Thomas. Beatrice is also putting herself at risk with her newspaper articles, not just because she is doing something independent, anonymous and a little radical, keeping it secret, but because she continues to associate with a Jew after being told not to. It’s kind of hard to wrap your mind around how restrictive and confining by today’s standards the lives of these wealthy privileged pampered women were, and how narrow-minded and casually cruel everyone could be, and Beatrice seems justified in making her own choices, especially when she is welcomed into the local world. But actions have consequences and she is heedless of them.

I found the first half of the book excellent. Montauk was beautiful and the characters were turning out to be very, very interesting. But then the story began to lose momentum and feel rushed. In three short months Beatrice gets herself into a predicament from which there is no easy escape. Someone is going to be hurt, someone’s reputation is going to suffer, and there may be real physical danger. Again, I was pleased with her independence but couldn’t help feeling that even though this is not the life she imagined it is the life she chose and she needed a well-thought out way to extricate herself. At some point it started to feel like a thriller, as I was waiting for her to get caught. It was a bit unbelievable that she continued to sneak around without anyone seeing her and confronting her until nearly the end of the book. Even if Montauk Manor is large, she is part of a small group and it seems like someone would have been asking about or looking for her more often. Because of the secrets she kept and the corner she backed herself into, there were only so many ways the story could end.

Thanks to St. Martin’s Press and NetGalley for an advance copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. Montauk was an enjoyable read and a good beginning for a debut author.

Was this review helpful?

Beatrice is lucky to have married a very wealthy Harry and to be spending the summer vacation in Montauk. But is the social pressure and the rampant cheating really what she wants?

I really enjoyed this book. I love that Beatrice was different from the other “housewives” and that she truly stood up for her beliefs as the book went on. I loved her relationship with Elizabeth and Dolly and how both friendships grew over the course of the book.

Thank you netgalley and st martins press for allowing me to read and review this book in advance!

Was this review helpful?

At first glance Montauk screams of a historic beach read, but it is so much more than that. Montauk is a sweeping summer romance set in a time lost. This book at its core is a story about love and following your heart. I am confident this one will be a bestseller.

Was this review helpful?

Montauk, playground for the privileged was the perfect backdrop for this story. I enjoyed learning historical events going on in the world during that time and appreciated the author’s robust picture of class and privilege.

Beatrice realizes that her husband Harry has been unfaithful during his prolonged absences. She feels out of place, lonely and longing for something more than planning lavish parties and putting on airs.

She ultimately realizes she must build a life separate from her husband. I had high hopes for her journey to self actualization. Beatrice falls into a job as a journalist exposing Montauk’s wealthy. I enjoyed this vein of the story and wished the author dedicated more time to it. I could imagine the scrambling and chattering amongst the ultra rich. I also wished my favorite character Dolly was in the picture more. Loved her spunk and rebellious nature.

Beatrice is a middle class young woman who married into money but she craves ‘normal’ company. Unfortunately, she puts livelihoods at risk as she attaches herself to local ‘commoners’. I was not a fan of her persistently impulsive behavior and naïveté. I understand this character was not fully ‘cooked’ yet, young and bored, but the writing and Beatrice’s behavior were unrealistic at times.

Was this review helpful?

Took me a while to really get into this book but oh bog did I get invested . The author managed to recreate 1930s ny with great detail of its classism and racism. The characters truly came alive for me and I would love to read more from Ms Harrison. This book was graciously provided by the publisher via netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Montauk is the debut novel by Nicola Harrison. Through the eyes of Beatrice Bordeaux, we are taken to the shores of Montauk which was still a sleepy town in the late 1930s. Beatrice finds out that she will be spending the summer at the new luxury resort Montauk Manor which is nestled in a closely knit village.

Life for both Beatrice and the U.S. is a bit tumultuous at the time and we learn about her struggles in her own marriage and roles as a woman while also getting a wider view of life around her..specfically the small fishing town and the residents who many are barely making it by.

While being a character study, there are nods to anti-Semitism, sexism, privilege, loss, and fertility. Harrison's descriptions of the people, clothing, and environment drew me right into this storyline. Her writing is captivating and engrossing and the multifaceted characters and storylines added a lot of depth that made this so much more than just a beachy romance.

I rooted for Beatrice and loved seeing her find her courage and strength once again. I highly recommend this beautifully written story and if you have enjoyed books by Anita Shreeve or Beatrix Williams I think you will enjoy this one as well.

Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley for an arc in exchange for an honest review

I enjoyed reading Montauk. As someone who lived in Long Island for a while it was fun to read about the Hamptons when it was in its infancy.

I thought the descriptions of the hotel where the ladies summered while waiting for their husbands on weekends sounded very luxurious and the fishing village was not but showed the haves and have nots to the extreme during this time period.

Beatrice is a young married woman who is summering at the Hamptons and trying to make friends and find her way in the upper class and slightly uncomfortable as she grew up in the country in Pennsylvania.

I don't want to ruin the plot but I enjoyed that Beatrice found herself in the story and found love.

Was this review helpful?

I finished this book this morning and have been mulling over how to write this review all day. I am truly torn on my review. The story started out so good, it was covering the lives of the rich and famous in the newly developed summer escape in the resorts of Montauk Island, the descriptions of the ladies and the island were wonderful. We follow Beatrice and Harry, an affluent couple from Manhattan spending their first summer on the Island. Beatrice is a kind, sweet young woman that doesn’t quite fit in with the rich and famous wives and lifestyles, but she does blend in fine with the locals with their down-home attitudes. Harry, on the other hand, spends his weeks back in the city with work and many other activities to keep him entertained.
Somewhere about half way through, the story takes a downward turn and leans more toward Beatrice being narcissistic and only caring for herself. She tries to justify her actions by any means possible. The love story does have its moments and I did enjoy reading it, unfortunately I wish the entire book could have stayed at the same caliber it started out with.
This one gets 4****’s. I was given an advanced copy from St. Martin’s Press and Net Galley for my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I found this book interesting and well written, It was a little predictable but I appreciated the time period and description of the place.

Was this review helpful?

This was a great read. Beatrice a lonely rich housewife, sees her marriage is falling apart. Beatrice finds new meaning to her life, but the ending will blow you away. I highly recommend.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks for Netgalley for the proof to read.

Come back to the 1930's and meet Beatrice and Harry. He's a typical male of the times, but since she's our heroine, she isn't. They've been trying to have children, but it doesn't work the greatest when he only comes down to see her at Montauk on the weekends.
The story ended pretty much how I expected, but slightly different. I loved the descriptions of life back then. All in as ll, an enjoyable experience to read. 3.75 stars from me.

Was this review helpful?