Member Reviews

This is one of the most whimsically inventive middle grade fantasies I’ve ever had the pleasure of reading.

Changeling is infused with Ritter’s trademark clever humour and unique characters.

The subtle mention of an expert in New Fiddleham may have made me squee a little bit.

If you’re a middle grade reader or if you have littles who love quirky fantasy, I highly recommend this.

Was this review helpful?

Oh my goodness, this story! I didn't expect to like this as much as I did! I had to google what a changeling is to have a little bit of an idea about what this story is about, but that's on why end.

The main things I throughly enjoyed about this story:

> Tinn and Cole. I love how different they are. I also love the kind of relationship they have, especially on the scenes where we find out that they both feel like they could be the goblin, but that they would rather the other be the real boy. That was adorable.

> Annie Burton. That lady is a badass! I think that sums up Annie Burton nicely. Her dedication to her boys is admirable.

I really enjoyed the time I spent reading this book. I thought it did such a good job of setting everything up for future instalments of the series.

Was this review helpful?

A BIG Thank You to Netgalley and Algonquin Young Readers for providing me a copy of “Changeling” for my review.

What a fun read! The story-line is like reading a brand new Grimm’s fairy tale for the next generation! The concept is very unique and unlike anything I have read in a middle grade, fantasy novel. The story immediately hooked me and I wanted to find out what happened next. Also, the story is feels like a perfect blend of fantasy, humor, suspense, and feels wholesome.

The characters are wonderful! Cole and Tinn are adorable in their own way. They have contrasting personalities but go well together. Fable was the highlight of the story! I loved her personality and how she brought such an energy into the story. I also loved Annie Burton! Moreover, I thought it was great that the author made the mother such a prominent character. Usually, in such books, the parents don’t play an important role, and it is up to the kids to solve everything. However, Annie plays a pivotal role and does whatever she can to help her boys. Not only Annie, I also loved how the Witch of the Woods played an active part. She is such a complex character where you don’t know if she is good of evil.

The only reason I did not give it a full 5 star rating was because of the way it started. Honestly, when the tale opened, it was confusing for a bit. There are a lot of things that happen in the prologue and I couldn’t keep track of what was happening. However, as the twins grow up, this book is a roller-coaster ride. I loved reading it. On a side note, I also loved the illustrations on each chapter.

Overall, “Changeling” is a great start to “The Oddmire” series and I cannot wait to see how it progresses.

Was this review helpful?

It's That Good

I got this book a while ago. After the first few chapters I knew it was so good, so well written, so exciting and clever and amusing and touching and heartwarming and real, that I should put it aside as a special read. Well, with all of this coronavirus sheltering and whatnot I decided this was a fine time for a treat. I was right.

Our author is responsible for the Jackaby books, which are smart, and clever, and witty, and a wonderful balance of modern and old school entertainment. Often when you read a new series from a successful author you find you just have some old wine in new bottles, which isn't necessarily bad. Here, though, Ritter has taken off in a whole new direction. This is a fairy tale of sorts, and it features two kids instead of two young adults, and it's fantasy adventure instead of a revisionist Sherlock Holmes take. But while the series is a new direction for Ritter, and is aimed at younger readers, it is still very much in the style of a modern reinterpretation of a very old form.

Our two brothers, (one a human and one a changeling and they don't know which is which), are off on a hero's journey that involves adventure, magic, high stakes, and a search into who and what exactly they each are. For all the faeries and goblins and so on, we know for certain that they are in every important aspect - brothers. That brotherly bond, (and their mother's love), is the touchstone of the entire adventure, and the author's ability to cast that relationship in a practical, realistic, and yet also magical fashion transports this book into a fairy tale realm well above any simple adventure.

On top of the uplifting, heartwarming, oh so right feel of the book, it is ripping and very funny in Ritter's gentle well-timed deadpan way. Colorful and nicely imagined supporting characters get a lot of the best lines, but that's fine because with this book there's plenty of humor, action, and excitement to go around.

(Please note that I received a free advance ecopy of this book without a review requirement, or any influence regarding review content should I choose to post a review. Apart from that I have no connection at all to either the author or the publisher of this book.)

Was this review helpful?

Faeries. Dark forests. Magic. Goblins. Young characters. THE ODDMIRE is pretty much everything I LOVE about middle grade books, and I was not disappointed! I absolutely lived for the themes of family, adventure, and coming of age with an atmospheric fairytale twist. Such a refreshing, lovely story for children!

Was this review helpful?

I'll admit that at first this book wasn't grabbing my full attention. Neither was the cover.

However, as the story progressed, I was pulled in to this magical world of goblins and changellings and fairies. It was interesting to get to know these "twins" and finding out how they came to both be in the same realm.

I've never been much of a fan about Fae and Fae stories, but I guess I needed this middle-grade in order to ease me into this world.

I already had some knowledge of the changelling process thanks to Scottish Folk Tales, and this book took an interesting and fun approach to it.

Looking forward to reading the second book in the series, because there is another mystery to be solved that I'm really intrigued to find out.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an advance copy of this title in exchange for an honest review.

I loved the Jackaby series so when I saw the author was creating a MG series I immediately knew I had to read it. This book did not disappoint, Ritter was able to create a world that I was able to fall into, and I love the nod to Jackaby at the beginning of the book. I love how he is able to seamlessly create worlds where magic and humans coexist -- mostly because humans are blind to the magical world around them. This book immediately drew me in not just with the magical world building but also with the characters, just as with Jackaby he has created characters that you instantly feel invested in and need to make sure their story ends happily. This book did not disappoint and now I'm eagerly waiting for the second book to be released!

Was this review helpful?

A fun start to a new series. Ritter's writing is full of goblins, witches and other unique characters. I would recommend this book to fantasy lovers of all ages. Changeling follows twin brothers Tinn and Cole as they set out on a magical journey.

Was this review helpful?

I had no idea what this book was like, I didn't know the author, but the synopsis seemed really intriguing. This was an incredible intense MG book and it made me very happy. I absolutely loved the worldbuilding and the characters were really interesting aswell! Definitely looking forward to the next book.

Was this review helpful?

Yay Oddmire! I loved Ritter's Jackaby series and am thrilled to read this new series.

While Jackaby was more YA, this series is a bit more Middle Grade. No matter, it's very good. Great characters, plot and it flows nicely.

Can't wait for the next book!

Was this review helpful?

I received an eARC of this book through Netgalley.
This is a wonderful middle-grade read. I absolutely love how present parents are throughout the book. I loved how the relationships developed between all the characters and I loved how each character was distinct. The adventure was twisty enough to keep me engaged all the way to the end. I’ll certainly be reading the next installment of this series.

Was this review helpful?

I had high hopes for this story, having read William Ritter's Jackaby books, and while this was different in many ways it certainly met my expectations. Following two identical boys, one of whom is actually a changeling, the story was darker than many middle grade fantasies without verging into horror. The world building was compelling, the characters fully drawn and engaging, and the story contained Ritter's signature humor even with the creepy vibe. I'll be handing this to readers 10 and up who look at that cover twice.

Was this review helpful?

Well, Middle Grade has gotten intense! Ha! Goblins, Faeries, children who have to save the world. It's everything you could want in a fantasy book. I wasn't sure what to expect while going into the book, but it definitely exceeded my expectations.. From the first chapter to the last, I was engaged and hooked on the story line. Goblins that swap infants, magic that is fading and two boys that can save them all. This book gave me the feels of a 90s adventure movie mixed with high fantasy. I loved every minute of it. From the boys, to Annie, to all the side characters. I highly recommend this novel for all MG lovers of any age! 4/5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

I have yet to read a William Ritter book I didn’t love and The Changeling was no exception!

Ritter’s new series is filled with magical adventure, unique characters and a story that is as dark as it is heartwarming.

The Changeling is a must read that will appeal to the next generation of reader as well as those who are already fans. I’m already looking forward to the next installment!

Seriously, where were books like this when I was growing up?

Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for providing me with a digital copy of this book to read and give my honest opinion.

Was this review helpful?

To my mind, changelings are a vastly under-explored mythological creature so I'm thrilled to read any book that examines the life of a changeling. Especially when the resulting book is as charming as this one. Ritter shows us several perspectives and motivations: the changeling, the human raised alongside him, the mother that raised them, and the goblin that attempted the swap. We see a world that is in flux, magic perilously hanging on and a darkness that threatens everything. And each character has a motivation. Sometimes these motivations intertwine, sometimes they are at odds with one another. And perspectives that are at odds one chapter may align the next. That sounds messy and confusing but the flow is nearly seamless.The ideas are complex but accessible even for a young middle grade audience. I look forward to seeing the directions Ritter will take this series.

Was this review helpful?

A sweet fantasy story with plenty of adventure and light scares, and a lovely theme running through about mothers' love, and how family doesn't have to mean blood relations. Something about it didn't completely enthrall me - I think perhaps that the characters felt quite shallowly drawn, and I had a hard time imagining real people saying things the way that these characters did. I felt that Fable and the Witch of the Woods had the most spark of life in them, and I really liked them and their interactions! The twins who are the main characters, though, felt underdeveloped to me, and I would have been more invested in finding out which of them was the goblin if they had ever shown personalities through their actions and thoughts, rather than the narrator just telling us that they had personalities.
Still, I think this is a book that could capture the imagination, and it's great to show adoption treated so well in fantasy - this will warm many a heart. I think I would say for my personal enjoyment three stars, but for the quality and themes of the book, four is more appropriate.

Was this review helpful?

They say “parents know their child”, but is that really true? If your child was switched at birth with a child that looks exactly like the child you gave birth to, would you know? That is something that has been troubling Annie for 13 years. Kull, a goblin, did a botched job of switching the children. He was distracted and the changeling adapted to the baby before Kull had a chance to make the switch. Everyone has heard the stories, but what they haven’t heard… Tinn and Cole, the children have one day to figure out who is the real child. Magic is at stake… let the adventure begin!

Let me start by saying, I know I am way past the age for the targeted demographic, but I loved this book. It was funny, witty, intriguing, and full of mystery! Reading Jackaby first, I wasn’t sure what to expect of this series. When I was offered the opportunity to read and review this story, I jumped at the chance because of the author. I’m so glad I accepted the offer because I read this in one sitting and I’m eagerly awaiting the next book in the series. The characters and the world created was fascinating. I can’t wait for the next book!

Was this review helpful?

“Once upon a time, there was a child whom the goblins came to steal, and once upon a time, there was a child whom the goblins left behind…”

I don’t reach for middle grade fantasy terribly often because I tend to be picky, but when I do, I’m looking for specific things: a whimsical world I can escape in, a sense of humor that can make me smile (or better yet, laugh out loud), and characters I can genuinely love and care for. I cannot even begin to tell you how flawlessly William Ritter’s Changeling checks every last one of those boxes for me!

“We’re in the Wild Wood,” he whispered. “Uncharted territory.”
“It’s not uncharted. We’re twenty feet from where we hang out every day, and I am literally holding a chart.”
“Don’t ruin this.”
These characters are so precious and laugh-out-loud funny, but their quest is one wrought with endless suspense because you can’t help but love them and want them to succeed. It’s such a fascinating and pulling story from its barest bones, anyways, because from the very start, you know you’re rooting for them despite the fact that their intended quest doesn’t seem like it could possibly end in anything short of tears.

He could have been made of fire and she would not have let him go.
After all, this journey isn’t just about changelings and goblin-folk and magic; more than anything, Changeling is about family — blood-bound, or not — and the lengths we will go to when we want to keep our loved ones safe. The bond between Cole and Tinn is just as strong and sweet as any bond between human, blood-linked siblings, and even more so, Annie Burton’s motherly love for them both and the way she refuses to choose one over the other — it’s downright precious. Talk about the unsung hero of a story.

“Stories are important. They are born, they die, they’re born again.”
While the characters were my favorite part of the story, Changeling has more going for it than that: the writing is spare and lovely, crafting a three-dimensional, beautifully fleshed-out world — full of whimsical characters and creatures, good and bad! — in a very short span of time. This is undoubtedly going to be a hit with bookworms and reluctant readers alike, and I, for one, can’t wait to recommend it (and to eagerly pick up the second book when it releases!).

All quotes come from an advance copy and may not match the final release. Thank you so much to Algonquin Young Readers for providing me with this ARC in exchange for an honest review!

Was this review helpful?

I was so excited when I was asked to be a part of this blog tour.  I absolutely loved the Jackaby series, and I was hooked when I found out this book was set in the same world.  While it has been a while since I read Jackaby, diving into this book felt like coming home to a world I fell in love with.
I absolutely loved Tinn and Cole's mother!  She knew that one of her sons was a goblin, but she loved them both equally and exponentially!  It's a great message for kids that may be adopted or living with a foster family.  No matter what, they deserve to be loved!
Really all of the characters are amazing!  They are all well-developed which makes them that much more likeable, and you just want to root for them all.
I also felt that the pacing of this novel was excellent.  It wasn't too fast or too slow.  It left you hanging when it needed to and explained things when needed as well.  I always feel like Ritter's books have very good pacing, and they grip you enough that you find yourself still up at 4am and you're flipping the last page.  And I feel like pacing in a middle grade novel has to be just right to keep younger readers interested in what happens next.
If you know a young reader in your family, I would highly recommend you tell them about this book.  Or better yet, you get it for them as a gift!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publisher for giving me the opportunity to read this as an ARC and to also participate in the Blog Tour..


We've all heard of different stories based off of changelings left behind in place of a stolen human child, but never before have I read one where the goblin messes up so royally and leaves behind both the changeling and the human! This story was so unique and yet also felt like a tale of old that I've heard and find comfort in the familiar words. But then again it was like nothing I've read before in the characters were all so very original and the setting was pretty dark and eerie for a middle grade novel! I tend to really enjoy the dark and twisted tales though because through those you really can see the true grit of the characters as they discover who they are in the midst of the trials they are put through and what they can accomplish when faced with their biggest fears. I also loved the strong bond of family throughout this book. That no matter where you might come from, or who you were born to, you can still find family in different parts of your life. And that a mother's love can transcend all else, that nothing can come between a mother and her children whether she gave birth to you or not, there are so many other things that make a mom a true mother. This was such a heartwarming and heartpumping story that I literally read in one sitting because once you start, its nearly impossible to stop!

I think that my favorite part of this book would be the characters. I love that the boys even though they were never meant to be "brothers" have grown up inseperable as twins, but their mother didn't leave them in the dark about the truth of how they came to be. They have always known the stories that one of them is really a goblin, but never knowing which is which they have both been loved equally and treated equally if not cautiously by the townsfolk. Their mother sees them as both of her sons and even when they both doubt themselves from time to time, she clearly points out that they both have a goblin side, and both have a human side. So therefore she loves them both the same and wouldn't ever consider either of them not her own. Its a truly wonderful thing to read, especially when so many kids these days are going through such awkward changes in their lives and bodies, to know that your family is always there for you, and that you are loved no matter what is a big message to send across to the youth of today. I think that this part in particular in this book was fantastic and I wouldn't have thought this strong and heartwarming message could come from a fantasy tale about a changeling child and a goblin horde.

My next favorite character would be sweet Fable! I absolutely loved her naive and innocent view of everything about life. Her lack of tact and knowledge about how the world works was that comedic relief that really added a lighter side to the dark adventure in this book. She was so sweet and just wanted to be a part of something big. To make forever friends, and to travel across the Oddmire were things that she didn't think she could accomplish but in the course of the book you see her put herself out there whether she was really welcome or not, she made them see her for who she was and how she is also just as important of a person as the two boys. Living in the deep dark woods alone for so long probably takes its toll on a small girl, and I love that by the end, she has finally found her forever friends and the happiness she gets from this warmed my heart beyond belief. She was my favorite and I wanted to give her the world, and I'm happy that she gets a happily ever after.

All in all, this book was such a fun adventure and I think that it can be loved by middle grade readers as well as an older audience as well. There wasn't a slow moment throughout the entire book and yet, it felt complete from start to finish. There aren't many books that don't feel rushed but still keep a fast pace and I'm glad to say that Changeling surpassed my first impressions and was truly a wonderful book to read! It has so much more than you would think at first hidden in the words on the pages. The messages portrayed are so strong and perfect for younger readers to find that confidence in facing their fears and knowing they are loved regardless of where they are from and who they came from. I loved this book and cannot wait for the next in the series. Happy Reading!
1 like

Was this review helpful?