Member Reviews
Much Ado about Mean Girls is just about what you'd expect it to be. It's a retelling of the movie Mean Girls written in a Shakespeare-like play format. I didn't study too much Shakespeare, so I can't really measure the writing to his typical writing style. This is a fun little script. I think it'd be great to see performed rather than just reading.
Thanks to NetGalley and Quirk Books for the eARC.
I've been a fan of both Shakespeare and mean girls so I assumed I would like this. It was slightly disappointing to be honest.
Many lines were ripped straight from other plays which jolted you out of the storytelling. It was cleverly written and did have the Shakespearean feel but it did feel a little flat.
This book is hysterically funny. If you love Mean Girls and Shakespeare, this is a perfect union of the two. I laughed until I cried. There were no parts of the original missing. While reading, I was able to visualize the story the way it would have been in the 16th century; on stage. Seeing it in your mind's eye makes the tale that much better. The way Doescher blends the world of The Plastics with Shakespearean flair is flawless.
As a superfan of Shakespeare and Mean Girls, this book was very enjoyable! Ian Doescher writes the script of Mean Girls by Tina Fey as if the Bard himself may have written it. The language is very well done and fun to read, adding the Shakespearean style of sharp wit to the snarky vibes of the Plastics. I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a fun read.
I knew what to expect, and got what I expected. It’s funny in parts, is a nice reimagining of Mean Girls as a Shakespeare play, and would make a great gift for a fan of the two. The ARC was unreadable in part due to the formatting, meaning the speech didn’t marry up with the speaker, but luckily I’ve watched Mean Girls enough to figure it out.
I loved this book! What a way to marry a familiar, modern day story and Shakespeare's knack for description. Students will love reading something familiar in a new way. And those students who are already familiar with Shakespeare will get a kick out of this retelling. I can't wait to purchase a copy to share with my classes.
Thank you for the opportunity to have an early look.
Unfortunately my arc copy was unreadable as the different parts of the play were unattributed and all the attributions were above each act. If I were more familiar with Mean Girls, I might be able to make it work, but alas I have only a passing familiarity. I will try to read it when it's published. Note: Star rating is meaningless as a result.
WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE'S MUCH ADO ABOUT MEAN GIRLS is pretty much what is says on the tin. Don't expect anything new or revolutionary. If you've read WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE'S STAR WARS, you pretty much know what to expect: a remix of iambic pentameter and snippets of famous monologues. Don't get me wrong. The novelty of reading all of our favorite lines reimagined in Early Modern English is delightful. It could be a useful tool for engagement in a Shakespeare unit. But don't expect it to stand up to the beauty of the bard himself.
This book was received as an ARC from Quirk Books in exchange for an honest review. Opinions and Thoughts expressed in this review are completely my own.
Mean Girls is a movie that is a classic among women my age that really impacted their adolescent lives. Reading the story in the times of William Shakespeare was very entertaining. There were alot of familiar scenes transformed into Shakespearian times and a lot of our readers will find this very amusing and interesting that they will not want to stop reading it. This is a wonderful adaptation of a classic Shakespeare tale and a modern movie celebrating their 15th anniversary of its release. An interesting and entertaining adaptation.
We will definitely consider this title for our YFiction collection at our library. That is why we give this book 5 stars.
Amusing and witty but occasionally a little tedious. Not sure itXs the best in this series of Shakespeare/ modern story mash ups. There were several real pearler lines though that had me laughing out loud. Recommend for Shakespeare nerds and those who like their humour intelligent.