Member Reviews

Thank you, NetGalley for the preview of this graphic novel.

What Makes Girls Tired and Sick was a quick read but it stays with you long after you've finished it. Would recommend it to all the girls out there.

Was this review helpful?

I don’t even know how to start talking about this book.

It’s excellent.

If you want to know what makes many women around the world <i>sick and tired</i>, take a look at this book.

This world is fucked up by the patriarchy and it’s going to take some heavy rebellion to fix it.

This book addresses the kind of stuff we need to be fighting.

When certain vocal majorities - who are, thank god, becoming minorities - hold sway over the rights of other groups, all over the world, we need to figure out what we can do to remedy these issues.

Of course, just writing about it isn’t a huge help.

I've got to do more.

Was this review helpful?

This was a quick little read, with a lot of impact. The authors draw attention to the issues of women (ALL women, incl. LGBTQ+/race/culture/disability etc.). I appreciated how inclusive it was, and that the author and illustrator acknowledged that as white women they can’t properly speak for everyone’s lived experiences. While reading through, I found myself saying “YEAH!!” in my head, because so many of the passages spoke to me.

This is a booked aimed at teens, and I really do think this is a great starting point for that age group! I’d like to see more from de Pesloiian and Darling!

Was this review helpful?

While a bit repetitive, this book does beautifully illustrate the struggles heaped upon women by society. There are many great books that delve into more detail but for a short primer on the challenges faced by women this is a solid choice.

Was this review helpful?

I don't know how to rate this one fairly. I love the concept, and I think that there are some points made in the book that could launch some powerful discussions. There are some great stats included, and the material covers a lot of bases.

But I struggle to understand who the appropriate target audience is. For the most part, this really just reads like someone preaching to the choir; those who would pick up this book are likely already well-versed in the material within.

I'd be tempted to want to give this to a girl at about 12 to introduce her to what it means to be female in this world, but I think some of the information might be too mature for many at that age. I'd love to see men and boys reading this, but I think many of them (especially those who need the info the most) might be put off by the tone. This book is unapologetically for girls, and I think that's actually a limitation.

So down the middle I go for this at 3 stars.

Thank you to NetGalley and Second Story Press for providing me with a DRC of this book that will be available in March of 2019.

Was this review helpful?

The only flaw I can find with this book is that it was way too short. The idea behind it is great, the wording of the list the author presents is great, and the minimalist artwork perfectly accents the statements it's accompanying.
I enjoyed it a lot. This book is a must-read for many people.

Was this review helpful?

Almost what is written is true. It's the social perspective of society towards women in general. Had expected great colour schemes but it seems dull to me. But the content is mature and informative.

Was this review helpful?

A quick little read. While I was hoping for something a little more poetic in nature, I enjoyed the illustrations and comprehensive list of girls issues. I could see this being used in schools as a jumping off point for women & gender studies class.

Was this review helpful?

What Makes Girls Sick and Tired is a wonderfully illustrated depiction of the issues and struggles that effect women daily. De Peslouan highlights a plethora of issues but only gives the slimmest of details. I do wish this book had been longer and delved in a bit more into each of these important topics. What we do get however may encourage its readers to explore these topics further. If a sequel were made that explored these topics further I would be incredibly excited to read that.

Was this review helpful?

Yes, girls are sick and tired of being grouped into one category, and defined by everything in the world but ourselves.
I love this spirited roar of individuality but also inclusion. Yay.
Loved the artwork. REAL FEMALES.
An excellent book to put into my students' hands. Girls are way more than sugar and spice~

Was this review helpful?

Cute art and aesthetic. Talking points are important but the formats are pretty basic and might really only appeal to the younger end of the young adult age bracket.

Was this review helpful?

A simple, yet great way to start a conversation on the problems that women face on a daily basis. I liked that the author included a myriad of different issues, but I wish there was a little more depth to it. This book seems like a stepping stone to a longer, more detailed conversation.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Second Story Press for this DRC.

"Girls are less sick and tired when they are encouraging, supportive, and united in solidarity with one another. It's the best part of feminism."

I think everyone can be included and encouraged to read this book, not just girls.
How wonderful that books like this are being released to create questions, discussions and movements in a forward direction. I think this is a fantastic read for all teens and adults alike!
There is of course more that could be addressed in here, but I;m hoping this will open the door for more...maybe a series?

Was this review helpful?

I loved this. It’s short, illustrated, and doesn’t take its sweet time to get the point across. Instead, it plasters the point across every page with demand. I loved that this was so inclusive to all women, because we really don’t need anymore exclusion in this movement. I think that there were of course some missed opportunities in here (which accounts for why I didn’t give this a perfect 5 stars), but I think that with a short graphic novel, it would be practically impossible to please everyone. I personally felt like the book covered a lot of ground and I felt the “sick and tired” in every single page. The illustrations were cute (to me) and I’m happy that I got a chance to check this out. I will 100% recommend this to others looking for reads on feminism.

Was this review helpful?

An ARC was provided to me via NetGalley in exchange for an open and honest review.

What Makes Girls Sick and Tired is a short collection of reasons why all women are "sick and tired" of the way they are treated. I completely understand what the author and illustrator of this short were attempting to accomplish, but it all fell flat for me. I honestly think the illustrations in this are to die for and they were really inclusive in my opinion, but I understand that an extremely simplistic style may not be for everyone. I gave this three stars because I enjoy the subject matter, but the writing style was sooo elementary to me. If the subject wasn't as intense I would have taken this for a children's book. Honestly, I actually think it would be better as such. Anyone above the age of a preteen completely understands why women are tired. I think this would carry out better a middle grade-preteen short to teach those younger about the fight for feminism among all different types of women.

Overall, as a woman myself, I just felt like this was sooo bland and obvious. Either make it a bit less intense, offer solutions, and then publish it as a middle grade book or bring some new insight to the table and make it even more YA-adult. I thought it was beautiful and the point was well received, but I didn't learn or gain anything. It was just a reminder of all the shit women go through, which I don't particularly think we needed. WE BEEN KNOWN.

Was this review helpful?

Though a very quick read, this book covered quite a few of the injustices of being a woman. It was very powerful and inspiring. I’m sick of the same things and it feels so refreshing to share that with the author.

Was this review helpful?

What Makes Girls Sick and Tired by Lucile De Pesloüan is a short an minimalist styled graphic novel about all the issues girls of all walks of life are sick.

It simplifies issues such as body autonomy, rape, wage gap, and the "pink tax," which is the extra price we pay for the same things men use.

I think that this book would be great as a conversation starter because it does not go into any great details on any of the subjects it brings up. Each page opens the floor for an expression of feelings and questions. If a topic hits a nerve they would have to do further research because you will not find anything of depth in this book about the patriarchy or misogyny.

Thank you Netgalley for allowing me access. I would recommend this to anyone that whats to have these hard conversations with not only girls but boys as well.

Was this review helpful?

I gave it a 3 because i loved the message but not so much the flat illustrations.
Easy to read.
I received an ARC copy from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

A short, illustrated book that highlights some of the issues that girls and women are sick of.

The problems are familiar. I did have an instinctual response to a few of the problems that caused emotional reactions. One page might make me snicker from relatability, another would make me want to cry. It isn’t an uplifting read.

My biggest complaint is how short this was. The illustrations are cute, but not so complex that it couldn’t have been expanded to include an even broader range of things girls are sick and tired of.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free copy of this ebook in exchange for an unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

"What make girls sick and tired" is a ñittle resume abut why feminist is important for women. Try to point in the most concise way the main points of feminist today. This book have a few mistakes, not exactly in th info but how this is interpreted (the wage gap has many more edges than those presented here, and their calculation considers them) but overall is a good start about wonen issue.

<i>A digital copy of this book was provided by NetGalley</i>

Was this review helpful?