Member Reviews

OMG, this book is soo freakin good. I've been anticipating this ever since I heard about it and knowing the author, I knew it was going to be a good read. It did not disappoint at all. I could not put this book down at all and the romance was just so swoon-worthy, I loved it!

Was this review helpful?

This was all sorts of geeky fluffy cuteness...which is just what I was hoping for! I loved Geekerella and this one fits in as a companion novel: same world and reoccurring characters, but different protagonists from Geekerella. You probably could read it as a solo? But there'd be a lot of confusing references. Also *raises hand* I was still, um,,,,confused I confess because I read Geekerella so long ago (and don't own it to reread sob). And I know you shouldn't compare books to their older sisters but...yeT. I didn't connect to this one as much as I'd hoped.

It's set at a con! So the nERD IS STRONG WITH THIS ONE. Like literally, the love (and wariness) of nerdom culture is just everywhere here. The slang is so Gen Z it's just amazing lmao, and they quote movies and are in fandoms and the term "he's a burnt Hufflepuff" is in here so like what more can I say. This book LOVES fandoms. But....it still pays attention to the toxic side. Which, like holy heck, it gets worse every year. Since our two protagonists (Jess the movie star and Imogen the fangirl) are on opposite sides of whether they love/hate this life -- we get to see BOTH sides. Also at one stage the book says "it's impossible to have a nuanced conversation on twitter" and like...LMAO SOMEONE SAID IT.

Yes to the genderbent Prince and Pauper vibe! Imogen and Jess swap places and it is FUN. I'm always dubious about this trope being pulled off, but it worked well here. Anyway, I very much enjoyed reading the girls! Imogen is all squishy and heartfelt and brash. Jess is very closed off and guarded and snipey but so so desperate to be soft but scared to be?! (Ya I have a favourite haha.)

And there is romance of course! There's an f/f romance, but it's not between the two protagonists...and it's very small and slow because like the book takes place over 4 days so ya. I did think both romances were cute! Although they didn't have enough time for me to get very invested.

Ok so quick confession...I didn't connect to the book like I'd hoped so it was fun but the stakes weren't so high and I am not super into any fandoms myself rn. And people who absolutely pledge their entire lives/thoughts to stanning fictional characters...like I don't get it. lmao. I also found the girls' voices so so similar, and both in 1st, so it was a bit hard to remember whose chapter I was in.


So this is definitely for the passionate fangirls and nerds out there! It's fun and squishy and there are lots of adorkable moments too!

Was this review helpful?

Even though the story was very predictable it was a fun enjoyable read. I haven't found a retelling I didn't enjoy yet. Being predictable is part of what makes it a retelling the setting and characters are what sets it apart from the original. The nerdy setting and issues made the book original in its own ways and sets it apart from other fan-fiction type novels. The author has found a way to engage the reader to a classic story by making it relevant to today's culture. We have all seen or read similar plots but this story was different and the same but above all fun. It was a fun read that kept me wanting to read more and anticipating the next in this collection of retellings by the author.
This book continues a popular trend in YA with retellings of classic story. This storied is a fresh contemporary version of the Prince and the Pauper by Mark Twain. It is relevant to today's young adults and clever for adults as well. The story takes place at the same ExcelsiCon as the author's first Geekerella, but different characters. Of course Darian and Elle are characters in this story but the story is centered around the famous Jessica Stone who plays Princess Amara and Imogen Lovelace a fangirl of the movie series. Jessica is desperately wanting to break away from this popular sci-fi movie serious to land roles in Oscer worthy roles. The in the latest movie Princess Amara dies and she is hoping the next film will keep her dead so she can move on with her career. However some of her fans, including Imogen, want to bring back her character. Imogen has started the #saveamara petition for the writers to bring her back. Imogen has a booth at this year's con with her online friend Harper passing out #saveamara pins and promoting her initiative. Jessica is booked with photo ops and interviews thorughout the convention but learns someone has leaked the script to the next film through Twitter. Some think that she is leaking the script to write herself off because she has been outspoken about wanting to move on from the franchise, which has caused serious issues with trolls on social media. Imogen unexpectedly finds herself on a question panel with all of the famous actors of the series because she is mistaken for Jessica when she isn't on time. Imogen plays her part well in answering the questions and avoids almost certian disaster for Jessica. However this comes in handy when Jessica needs to find the script she lost before she is accuse of being the leak of the script and never gets another acting job in her life. The two switch places for the remainder of the convention and it all seems to good to be true. Imogen gets the attention and admiration she has always wanted and Jessica gets away from the paparazzi and glamour of her life. The two unexpectedly fall in love under false impressions but works out as expected.This book is expected to be released in April 2019. I look forward to adding to our collection in the library. 

All of the opinions expressed are my own and not affiliated with anyone else. Thank you to Netgalley for the advanced copy.

Was this review helpful?

Geekerella was one of my absolute favorite books from last year. I live for fandom based books. They are my lifeblood. So when this book was announced, and it sounded super gay, I was sooo excited! This book follows Jess, Darian's costar from the first book. And Imogen, a new character who has grown up around Excelsicon. They switch places and chaos ensues.

Jess is a lesbian, which was well hinted at in the first book. Her romance is with a black fan artist. Jess is hard to like at times, but she has a lot of growth throughout the book. She's only ever seen the bad side of fandoms. Think Daisy Ridley and Kelly Marie Tran.

Imogen's romance is hate to love which is my shizzzz, okay? I just loved everything about this.

I love how the toxicity of fanboy culture is called out in this. And I love happy endings. We also got to see all our faves from the first book! I can't wait until this is out in the world so I can squee with everyone about it.

Also, Imogen's brother is adorable and I loved their relationship a lot. And his relationship with his boyfriend was too friggin cute. Wouldn't mind following them in a book next. :D

Was this review helpful?

This was a fun book that all geeks and comic con goers will love. Smattered with pop culture references, readers will feel a real connection to the characters and setting. I enjoyed it even more than the first book!

Was this review helpful?

After finishing Geekerella earlier this year, I was completely satisfied and in love with the book... except I wanted more Jessica Stone! Jess' story was left hanging, in my opinion, and now I see why. The Princess and the Fangirl is a combination of geeky goodness and The Parent Trap if Emma Roberts played the main role(s). This book was so fun, and both lead characters, Jess and Imogen, are so lovable. I also think it's an extremely relevent read, as Jessica Stone's situation in this novel is very similar to ones like Kelly Marie Tran's. I can't recommend this book enough, especially if you enjoyed Geekerella, as there are many "ah-ha!" references to the original novel in this. My only "complaints" are that Imogen did annoy me a handful of times, and I wish the plot twist near the end had some more clarification behind it. But those are such small things to point out! Go read this one, guys! 5/5 stars!

Was this review helpful?

Having read Geekerella I was really excited to read this companion novel. It was everything I loved about geekerella; quirky, relatable, funny and heartwarming. I would implore anyone to read it if they loved geekerella.

Is it the most profound book? No. But it doesn't need to be. It's fun and lighthearted. I just wish there was a bit more time spent with the characters, and less running around convention centres.

Was this review helpful?

Goodreads - I appreciate all of the details in the Once Upon A Con series...like correct me if I am wrong but Starfield is an amazing universe backstory that Ashley has made. Which is insane. Insanely cool. Not to mention the nerdy, girly, friendship, fairytale, shoe themes that follow through. Sometimes you have to live in someone else's shoes to understand yourself. To see how great your life is. To see what you can do, and do it. I’m not going to say more than that because I don’t want to ruin a book for anyone ever. But if you haven’t already figured it out I loved this book, and am waiting for someone to tell me that Starfield exists so I can watch every episode (in the correct order of course).

Facebook - Sometimes you have to live in someone else's shoes to understand yourself. To see yourself as others do, maybe like what you’ll see, maybe you’ll want to change their minds. This book is very Parent Trap meets Geekerella, a nerdy friendship fairytale. I think the Once Upon A Con series is great and am waiting for someone to tell me that Starfield exists so I can watch every episode (in the correct order of course). The Princess and the Fangirl is set to publish in April 2019, in the meantime you can catch up with Geekerella.

Was this review helpful?

Jessica Stone is not having a good day. She took the role of Princess Amara in order to further her movie career, not to become the queen of the Cons. And yet, here she is. Well, sort of. Because the girl answering questions about being Princess Amara on the Starfield panel is decidedly Not Her.
Imogen Lovelace did not mean to step into Jess Stone's shoes. She just wants to #SavePrincessAmara from death. So when gets the chance to step into the role of Jess Stone, Imogen does the opposite of what the star desires. And that first deception leads to further plans when a script given to Jess is leaked online. Just because she doesn't want to play Amara anymore doesn't mean she wants to commit career suicide.
Told concurrently with Geekerella this is going to delight fans and new readers alike.

Four stars
This book comes out April 2
ARC kindly provided by the publisher and NetGalley

Was this review helpful?

Welcome back to the Geekerella universe where fandom reigns supreme. The best of this book isn't the role-swapping story, but the argument for the power of stories and how they inspire people. That is the basis of fandom - what an alternative plotline can do for the person who needs to escape the day to day and be someone else for a while. And so the remake of the Prince and the Pauper is a strong metaphor for Con and all that fandom means to those who embrace the infinite alternate realms that exist alongside reality. A great story to explain fandom to those who just don't get it.

Was this review helpful?

"The Princess and the Fangirl" isn't the first Ashley Poston book I've read in a day, and probably won't be the last either. She captures fandom culture so well, and I loved seeing her take on conventions. It was lovely seeing glimpses of Elle and Darien again. Imogen and Jessica were great characters too and I coudn't help falling in love with them. Jessica's story especially was very poignant, the way in which it touched on the pressures for women in big budget science fiction films. Both love stories took me a little longer to become invested in since we were focused on two different tales instead of just the one, but were still absolutely amazing. I also love the glimpses we get of "Starfield". Amara and Carmindor are fantastic characters and I want to hear more about them. Really hope we get more in this series!

Was this review helpful?

This is my third time reading Ashely Poston (I’ve previously read Geekerella and Heart of Iron), and I have to say that I think this might be my new favourite book of hers.

I was so excited when it was announced that she was going to continue telling modern fairytale retellings within the Geekerella world, and I’m crossing my fingers that Poston continues this series (perhaps a Calvin story arc?).

The Princess and the Fangirl ended up being far more hysterical than I was expecting. It has a slightly lighter plot line than Geekerella did.

So much of Imogen’s narrative had me cackling and barking out loud with laughter. Poston has a gift at writing beautifully sassy nerd girls that are crazy relatable.

What I loved most about this book is how inclusive Poston was at talking about both the positive and the negative side of fandom life. She did a great job at showing how we can come together, but she also showed how toxic it can be, especially on the internet.

I really adored this book.

Was this review helpful?

I thought the first book in this series, Geekerella, was fantastic. This book in comparison seemed disjointed, and the vocabulary assumes a lot about the reader's knowledge of current popular anime, cartoons, and fandoms. Outside of this, I think the book is an adorable meet cute story that features an LGBT protagonist and was very enjoyable.

Was this review helpful?

Although a weaker story than Geekerella, I still enjoyed this sequel, which retells the Prince and the Pauper using a con-loving geek girl and the mean actress from the Starfield movie series introduced in the book prior. One nagging issue I had is although the Starfield universe is entirely fictional, the other pop culture geekiness is real in this book and I started rolling my eyes from overkill.

Was this review helpful?

**3.5 Stars**I believe that there are books that come to you at exactly the right time in your life and that you connect with in a special way, that was Geekerella for me. As a result, I went into this book with very high expectations. I would not call this a disappointment, but it wasn't quite as good as Geekerella. The character development was really well done for both characters. I started out not liking Jess at all, but the changes she goes through during the book are well earned and make sense. I liked Imogen from the beginning and thought her story was very relatable. My only complaint is that there wasn't enough between Imogen and Ethan to explain how their relationship evolved throughout the story. In addition, I think the author's message about how what you post on social media can hurt those you write about is an important one for young people. It was also nice to get little glimpses into what Elle and Darien are up to. I highly recommend this book to middle schoolers and those who enjoy cons and twists on old fairy tales!

Was this review helpful?

I loved this book! The full review will be posted soon at kaitgoodwin.com/books! Thank you very much for this wonderful opportunity to connect books to their readers!

Was this review helpful?

I was a massive fan of Geekerella when I read it last year so I was so excited to hear a new book was coming out. Wow was I not disappointed!

Possible spoilers.





It was a quick paced book with a queer romance which was beautifully told. The new characters were brilliant and some characters from Geekerella also made an appearance which I loved. It gave a great insight into fame and how it isn’t always sunshine and rainbows. I will be recommending this to everyone!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to netgalley & the publisher for the ARC
**

I enjoyed the heck out of this book. It was fun to see what happened with the characters in Geekerella through their cameos and the new characters were equally enjoyable. The structure and plot feels familiar both as the summary-referenced retelling AND as the sort of trope-y fun found in a lot of fanfiction. The various romances (both shown and/or developed) include m/f, f/f, and m/m and my main sadness about most of them is that I don't get to see how they continue (unless there's another book, I suppose).

Outside of the characters, the biggest joy I found in Geekerella was in the description of fandom culture and the experience of being at a convention and it was what I hoped for the most in The Princess and the Fangirl. And personally, this more that delivered. With these particular set of main perspectives, I'm glad that it didn't shy away from how toxic fandom/internet culture can be, especially when it comes to women. But most importantly, it was once again full of the positive emotions that fandom brings to people, no matter what you like. I was once again wishing that there were a way to bottle up the feeling of being at a convention, surrounded by people who might not love the same things you do, but at least you all love SOMETHING fiercely.

Was this review helpful?

Thanks to Netgalley for providing me with an ARC of this.

Having enjoyed Geekarella, I had high hopes for this and Ashley Poston didn't disappoint. The characters are easy to engage with, even when they are not entirely likeable. There are plenty of fun moments and the fandom/convention references are relatable and honest. Fandom isn't portrayed as a permanently perfect, friendly environment and I'm so glad that Poston chose to make reference to the darker, less pleasant aspects of fandom.

The story is engaging and I found myself reluctant to put it down. None of the romantic element felt forced or like a plot device. I was really rooting for the f/f couple and hope to see that particular pairing revisited sometime in the future.

Was this review helpful?

This book was hilarious, sweet, and so much fun! I really enjoyed all the geeky references, the characters, and the inclusion of f/f for one of the two main romances.

Was this review helpful?