Member Reviews
This story started off very strong and I was very engaged in the story and how it was going to turn out, then in the middle of the story it for me felt like it went on for too long. However I learnt loads about the Jewish way of living which I found very interesting. The ending was lovely too.
Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for the opportunity to read this story in exchange for a honest review.
Firstly, thank you to Netgally for providing an advance copy in exchange for an honest review.
Eliza Bloom is a complex character. Born into an extremely religious family, she defies them all and runs away with the love of her life, thus beginning a whole new chapter.
I didn't love this book but I didn't hate it. It is extremely well written but slightly confusing with the jumping timelines and flashbacks. Also, I did have a problem with some of the characters.
Eliza - she is no saint but sometimes I felt that she tried to make herself out as the victim which I don't believe she was. She made her own choices then didn't seem to want to "put the work in" when things got tough.
Alex - whiny, overly-sensitive, jealous. None of these tropes are attractive in my book sorry.
Eliza's family - lets not go there. What I don't get is Eliza's father is overly abusive without any real reason apart from the fact that he seems to be on a permanent power trip. Yet this man is taken down in one instance.
Leah - the girl who caused all the trouble, the frankly horrible teenager who I just wanted to slap.
I am not jewish so I will fully hand on heart say that I don't know about arranged marriages, or the the customs but even to me some of it seemed extremely over the top.
Anyway, that being said, Beth Miller can write. The book is extremely descriptive and I give her much credit from not shying from some serious issues. That is the reason I gave this book three stars rather than two. The characters for me were the major sticking point. I just couldn't feel any empathy or emotions for them at all.
I will however, look forward to more of Beth Miller's work.
I really struggled with this book. Although I found parts of this novel interesting (mainly the transition from Orthodox Jew life to the Real World life), I just found the characters insufferable. Eliza/Aliza was whiny, insecure, and duplicitous. Alex was condescending and sneakily controlling. Leah was rude. Eliza's father was abusive. Nathan was bland. I just didn't connect with the characters at all, and as a result, most of the novel dragged on and on for me.
I guess this is a twist on Pygmalion with Eliza as Eliza Doolittle and Alex as Professor Higgins. It would have been an interesting remake, if it hadn't been for the unlikable characters. I will say I found the ending sweet and relatively satisfying. I think that many readers will like this as a romance, but I couldn't get past all the issues with the characters.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publishers for an e-ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.
What do you do when your religion says one thing and your heart says another? That's a key question in The Two Hearts of Eliza Bloom. Set in both 2000 and 2016, this story explores Aliza/Eliza following her heart to marry a Gentile. Having been raised in a. Orthodox Jewish faith, it's an interesting cultural background that Beth Miller explores.
Wow this was a mess. I thought about giving up 25% of the way through because the story and characters were just so bad but I stuck with it hoping it would get better. Spoiler: it only got worse.
Eliza/Aliza basically flees her family into the arms of a smarmy, negging, controlling asshole who she sees as some kind of knight in shining armor.
Alex tried to control Eliza from the start, whining and barking when he doesn’t get what he wants. Poor Eliza thinks it’s unclean to touch or sleep together during er “bleeding” (period) but Alex drones on and in about how period sex is fine. Meanwhile Eliza views Alex as unclean after he so much as demands to hold her hand during her period. He has no respect for her her religious beliefs and immediately tries to change her into whatever he wants at that moment. It’s clear to the reader that one of the only reasons he wants Eliza is because she’s “pure”. But does Alex really need to serve up the line “some of the best fucks I’ve ever had have been with gals on the rag” yes folks he actually says that. Then he adds “making love during Eliza’s period” to his tacky list of sexy things to try. If this doesn’t turn you off enough then do reading.
Later Eliza mentions that blow jobs were on Alex’s sexy things to try list but she tried once and was not a fan. However there is a scene where Eliza is trying to get out of the house quickly and Alex is whining he didn’t get laid and doesn’t she think he’s attractive anymore?? So to shut him up she makes a gesture with her tongue then gives him a blowie despite hating doing it, all so she can leave the house without his whining. Of course after he finds the time to make a joke when she spits instead of swallowing “must get some of that kosher spunk so you can swallow”
The characters in this were just so cringeworthy. The references to sex seemed to be written by a horny teen who has never even kissed someone. The whole book was just a big ball of uncomfortableness. There was nothing redeeming here.
In fact there is a paragraph where Eliza/Aliza gets nostalgic for a pile of pre torn toilet roll that her friend has prepared so people can wipe on the sabbath. Of all the things to write about...
I am not an Orthodox Jew but I can’t imagine how revolting this book would be to someone who was.
Thanks to NetGalley for the copy to review but I wouldn’t recommend this book to anyone.
What Eliza/Aliza has with Alex is not and never has been love. It’s Stockholm syndrome.
Synopsis: Eliza (or is it Aliza?) Bloom’s runaway wedding has become the stuff of family legend, but legends have a habit of catching up with you in the most unexpected ways... as Eliza discovers when her daughter finds something buried in a shoe box that nobody was supposed to find.
I loved the way Beth Miller talks about ‘packing the suitcase’ when it comes to the way she writes her books. I checked goodreads and it looks like she’s been off radar for a couple of years, but boy is she back! With a well packed suitcase! This is a really nice read. It’s light, is heartfelt, it’s sensitive, it’s funny (at times laugh out loud)... I really enjoyed it. I got lost in their world and wanted to keep learning about their lives. I loved Eliza, though I admit I found some of her actions frustrating and hard to understand... but we all do confused things when life is a confusing mess.
This is the perfect read for when you’re chilling on the beach, preferably with a cocktail within arms reach 🏖🍹
Released 1st March 2019.
Thank you to netgalley and bookouture for this review copy in exchange for an honest review.
Aliza, within the confines of her orthodox religion, is going to marry Nathan, whom she does not love. But when she meets non-Jewish Alex, they secretly start to meet and fall ,in love, she knows she can’t go through with the wedding. On that day she leaves with a suitcase and meets Alex in front of all her relatives, causing them to shun her forever. Out in the “real” world with Alex she has so much to learn about current society, as well as to find out who she really is. A lovely story, showing us life is not lived on a straight line, and sometimes we have to go back in order to move forward.
A sweet & refreshing read. I flew through this book really enjoyed it! Would recommend this to anyone
The Two Hearts of Eliza Bloom by Beth Wood is a charming and, ultimately, uplifting novel about finding yourself against all odds. This is a thoroughly delightful read, and I would not hesitate to recommend it.
The novel is presented as a dual timeline, alternating between the years 2000 and 2016. In late 1999, we meet Aliza Bloom, the product of an extremely strict Orthodox Jewish household. Aliza is desperate to escape her sheltered and suffocating existence when she meets Alex, a gentile, at a training course. The two begin a tentative relationship, with Alex unintentionally altering her name to Eliza, the subtle change representing the woman she can see herself becoming in the Real World. The trouble is, Aliza has an agreement to marry Nathan, a man she does not love, but has agreed to marry in order to pacify her devoutly religious family. On the day of the wedding, Alex whisks Eliza away and quickly marries her, immersing her in his secular life. Eliza is forced to navigate her way through Christian customs, with the results being laugh out loud funny yet also, at times, heartbreaking.
When the couple's daughter, Leah, finds a wedding photo in 2016 of her mother standing beside a groom who is not her father, questions arise, and Eliza must come to terms with past decisions and mistakes.
Told in a breezy and conversational style, this is, ultimately, a feel good story about staying true to yourself.
Many thanks to NetGalley and Bookouture for this ARC.
A sweet read! Aliza/Eliza agrees to an arranged marriage (to Nathan). However, she runs away with her true love (Alex) on her suppossed wedding day. The story includes interesting details about the Orthodox Jewish religion and how Eliza adjusts to the "outside"'.
A stellar read with suspense and intrigue up until the very end. Delightful!
Many thanks to Bookouture and NetGalley for a wonderful story.
This was an insightful book regarding the Orthodox Jewish community and how their perspective on marriage and family shapes their lives. Re fact that Eliza rebelled against it showed who she was and how strong love is.