Member Reviews
4 stars — Confession: I have never read Pride & Prejudice. *sigh* I know, throw stones, whatever… I don’t even have the desire to! *gasp* right? I have, however, watched and loved both the BBC 6-part mini series, and the more recent Keira Knightly edition. So I have a feel for the story and its characters.
I thought the author did a really interesting job of incorporating so many of the characters into this modern story! It really impressed me how they all made sense in this modern version, and what kinds of relationships they would have with Elisa and Darcy in a 2016 USA. I also really appreciated all the little nods to “world events” happening in 2016 that Ms. Garrett incorporated into the story (even the introduction of Pokemon Go!). Basically, while I am by no means a P&P expert, from my perspective she did a great job with this retelling.
The thing about retelling a story is that you want to remain faithful, but you also want to have a purpose for the retelling…something that makes it unique and necessary. And this story tackled so many interesting issues, most particularly the immigration/illegals/DACA situation in the US. Now, saying all that, I’m Canadian. I really don’t have a grasp of this issue other than what I see on the news, or from watching Colbert. So again, from my perspective I thought the way it was handled in the story, and the things I learned, and the very real fears that Elisa’s family felt were thoughtfully portrayed.
And while that was most certainly the biggest issue tackled, the author also touched on the harsh trials of celebrity, human trafficking, elitism (obviously), and how far apart we’ve become from those who have different beliefs from us, among others.
Now, obviously going in I knew this was going to be a slow-burner…and also, likely not a steamy read, given what it was retelling. And while I loved the general plot and character development, and general storytelling, the romance was a bit lacking. I did feel some butterflies over the DC “date”, but I guess I had hoped for a good kissing scene. I don’t mind reading clean reads, but I still want some swoony kissing you know? The kisses were essentially described as “they kissed”. So if you’re hoping for a bit more in that area, tamp those hopes down.
As an aside, is it weird that the author’s note at the end, with it’s strong Christian bent, made me uncomfortable? I know lots of authors who are Christians, and they thank God, and that makes sense. This felt more preachy somehow, like life is only good if you walk with God. Sucks for those of us that don’t. But I’m sensitive like that.
So yeah. Faithful retelling that was thought provoking and relevant, just slightly short of swooniness. Initially I felt like the ending was rather abrupt, but after some thought it felt right.
I always enjoy retellings of the classic Pride and Prejudice. This is a charming modern version. There are elements of the original as well as new ideas to keep the story fresh. The characters are likeable and engaging. It's well written and fun to read. I recommend for anyone who enjoys different spins of the timeless classic. Thanks to NetGalley for an arc in exchange for an honest review.
It is absolutely refreshing to read a modern retelling of such a beloved novel; Garrett definitely does "Pride and Prejudice" justice, offering a poignant twist and weaving modern day politics in the brand new albeit well-known love story.