Member Reviews

Uma história sobre tristeza, descobertas, problemas familiares e um pouco de conto de fadas. Gostei da história até certo ponto, é envolvente, mas nada de tão incrível. Valeu a leitura, mas queria ter gostado mais

Was this review helpful?

Alex is 8 years old when her father dies. She becomes very superstitious. When her mother suddenly gets seriously ill she has to do something. The only way to save her mother is to go to the magical world of Haphaven.
I liked the story, but I didn't quite like the style of the illustrations. I especially didn't like the way Alex looked
You can read my review (in Dutch) on my website Ikvindlezenleuk: https://ikvindlezenleuk.nl/2019/03/harper-haphaven/

Was this review helpful?

This story was definitely interesting and unique. I really liked it. The adventure that the main character sets out is definitely thrilling and at times a little confusing for me. But overall it was something that I would purchase and read on my own.

I typically don’t like these types of books, because the whole world building and slow starts really turn me off. I’m glad I stuck with it and continued to read it because it was definitely a treat.

Was this review helpful?

I don't know what it is, but I have really been enjoying stories like this. It takes fairy tale elements and puts it into a modern setting. There is a mixture of the real world and a fantasy world that complement each other nicely. In this story, Alex is a young lady that is turning thirteen and her world revolves around superstitions. When one of them threatens her mother's life, she sets out on a journey to find a cure.

The fairy tale elements and the superstitions are great. The real winner for me is the characters. The book takes a decent amount of time establishing Alex's history and her motivation. That could give it a slow start for some, but it pays off. The supporting characters are wonderful too. I found them to be funny and they worked well within Alex's story. I loved the art. It is perfect for the story without being too cartoony.

Was this review helpful?

A harrowing story that deals with grief, self-discovery, and... leprechauns.

It had a bit of a slow start but it picked up by the time Alex was transported (Alice in Wonderland style) to Haphaven, a land of mystery and a place where superstitious Alex fits right in. The journey to help her mom was really fun, and I liked the twistiness that the author threw in there. I called one of the twists from the moment of introduction, but I still enjoyed watching it play out!

I did kind of expect Alex to have a little more respect or caution about this new world she's been thrown into - if only because she's introduced as a very superstitious character, and superstition usually goes hand in hand with caution. Plus, it never does you any good to be rude in a fairytale, which Alex should know.

The art style isn't my favorite, but that's totally subjective and the artist conveyed what was happening well, so no complaints there.


Thank you to NetGalley and Lion Forge for providing a digital ARC.

Was this review helpful?

This started off a bit slow but I was absolutely loving it by the end. Alex is a preteen who follows all the superstitions. One day she finally listens to her mother, steps on a crack and breaks her mother's back. Then she gets transported to Haphaven, the land of the Leprechauns where she goes on a quest to heal her mother. It's got a definite Alice in Wonderland or Wizard of Oz vibe to it in that we're in another world that definitely feels a little dangerous and off kilter. I like how the author played with some of those familiar fairy tale tropes. By the end I was completely all in and rooting all out for Alex.

Was this review helpful?

You know all those superstitions? Horseshoes can be good luck, as well as a rabbit’s foot? Or if you step on a crack, you’ll break your mother’s crack. All that is what this graphic novel is about. In a world where superstitions and luck rules, it can also effect Earth as well, especially to Alex and her family.

To have a world ruled by luck and superstitions is a really cool and original idea. I have never seen this before and I was immediately intrigued when I first saw this. I would have never even come up with this idea either. What I also liked in the story featured is how the two worlds are connection and the history that connects Alex to all of it as well.

Everything in Hapheaven really connects to the story and idea really well, which makes everything flow almost flawlessly. Mostly everything is just interesting and to see how everything works made this a good read.

Was this review helpful?

With a nice art style, and a very fun writing, Haphaven was a very nice and easy read!

I just love anything that will mix Superstitions with reality since there's something in me that actually belives it and at the same time don't!

Very fun, and totally a graphic novel I would give to my middle grade cousins!

Was this review helpful?

Most of my comics are digital, though a few deserve physical copies both to hold in hand and to have on a prominent shelf, and Haphaven is one of those.

The art and writing are in sync, with both hiding clever details. Characters are endearing, and the twists are surprising and natural. It's the kind of book an adult can love and a kid can fall into-- and for those who are both, it's perfect.

Was this review helpful?

'Haphaven' by Norm Harper with art by Louie Joyce is a story about luck and superstition and what one young woman will do to fix things.

Alex Mills was raised on superstitions by her father. It's been handed down in the family from her great great grandfather and Alex lives by the rules. When her father's luck runs out and her mother has an accident that could only have been caused by breaking a rule, Alex gets help to turn things around. She ends up in a strange place called Haphaven and makes a group of strange friends along the way.

I really liked this story. The worldbuilding was interesting and the characters weren't bad. The art wasn't my favorite, but it works for the story. This would be a decent young adult graphic novel to recommend.

I received a review copy of this graphic novel from Lion Forge, Diamond Book Distributors, and NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. Thank you for allowing me to review this graphic novel.

Was this review helpful?

The central conceit here is a unique one - that superstitions in this dimension directly correlate to realities of life in another, more magical dimension. The protagonist must adhere to superstition in order to travel through Haphaven and save her mother. As she learns more about the world, she realizes that she needs to truly understand how these things work together in order to fix everything, not just her mother but her whole world and Haphaven too. The stories she's heard aren't enough. And I liked the line between natural magic and real superstitions with interference from magical beings and simple misbeliefs. The first third was sort of shallow but if you power through, the level of engagement improves.

Was this review helpful?

Received via NetGalley for review.

With fun illustrations that service the plot well, this graphic novel would be a great addition to any middle-school library. The plot is original and well-developed, and the characters develop realistically. A fun read!

Was this review helpful?

This was an interesting story and had some great characters, it's just not really my cup of tea. I think people who are interested in the summary should definitely give this graphic novel a chance, I just didn't connect with it.

Was this review helpful?

I am not the sort of person who really believes that luck and superstition are real things that genuinely influence the world in ways that we cannot imagine. With that said, I absolutely <em>loved</em> graphic novel, <em>Haphaven </em>by Norm Harper and illustrated by Louie Joyce. Following the tale of a supposed lucky family whose luck has gone wrong, and a very superstitious young girl who took after her father, <i>Haphaven </i>details the journey of Alex Mills as she sets out to save her non-believing mother after having stepped on a crack she'd avoided her entire life when her mom attempts to instill upon Alex the ridiculousness of her superstitions. But finding a way to turn around the bad luck she incurred by stepping on the crack in the sidewalk and, resultingly, breaking her mother's back is not going to be easy in the slightest. When a leprechaun appears in her home shortly after the event to take her on an adventure to <i>Haphaven</i>, the world in which good and bad luck is determined, there is no hesitation for Alex. She knows she must go to save her mom.

I had an immense amount of fun reading this novel and I think one of the things that really made this book for me lay in the family story that Alex's father tells her at the very beginning of the novel, that of their ancestor whose luck ran out and who therefore set off to find Lady Luck and restore what he had lost. But things don't go according to plan. And luck changes for everyone.

Soon, Alex travels to the land of luck and superstitions, setting out to save her mother by getting the rabbits foot and fighting past a jinx to retrieve it. With the help of Penny--find a Penny, pick it up!--a lucky leprechaun, she soon learns that not everything in Haphaven is what it seems and knowing who to trust can be harder than anyone could imagine.

From the hero to the villain, I adored <i>Haphaven</i>. I don't want to get into too many details as it would certainly spoil the story, but suffice to say that there is so much to this graphic novel worth loving. Alex's journey is oodles of fun and while I don't believe in the specific superstitions that Alex does, I did find it to be a wonderfully told story with so many fun and amazing elements. <i>Haphaven</i> is at the end of the rainbow, everyone, and I would highly encourage journeying there.

<i>I was provided a free copy of this book via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.</i>

Was this review helpful?

The main character is a girl who believes in superstitions. She doesn't want to celebrate her 13th birthday because the number 13 is unlucky. I love the illustrations. Kids in middle school and high school will love the illustrations and how the girl overcomes the obstacles that she is forced to deal with. This was a great graphic novel!

Was this review helpful?

4*
Pros: Magical world-building. Refreshing premiss and plot. Interesting twists and turns. Beautiful colors and composition. PoC leading character. Interracial love story included. Witty and fun banter. Interesting take on luck and superstitions.
Cons: Too fast-paced.

Was this review helpful?

Definitely a unique fantasy read, despite some familiar tropes. How it plays with the tropes (chosen one, family legacy, twists/reveals) makes it worth a read.

Was this review helpful?

This is an okay graphic novel. I'm all for fantasy, but this one really requires the reader to suspend disbelief.

Alex Mills is extremely superstitious. She won't even celebrate her thirteenth birthday because she's worried about bad luck. After she steps on a crack and somehow gives her mother psychosomatic paralysis, she's thrust into the world of Haphaven, where all superstitions come from.

I think part of the problem I had with this one is that it looks like a young adult title. Alex is not drawn as a girl who's just turned thirteen. She looks far older. And so, as I was reading, I kept forgetting her age and then getting slammed out of the flow of the narrative by the juvenile plot elements: the talking cat and rabbit, the jinxed gun that shoots ice cream cones (among other things), Alex eating the equivalent of a Happy Meal (toy included!). The subject matter and age of the main character suggest that it's a middle grade title... but the illustrations just don't fit.

I also didn't particularly like Alex. She goes to a new world, and the first thing she does is kidnap a leprechaun. Then she snatches a rabbit. It's like she has no respect for this world at all. She thinks she knows everything, and yet, she's one of the most ignorant characters in the whole story.

The cat villain is just plain ridiculous. He might as well have been twirling his whiskers like a mustache. There's no nuance to the storyline about his takeover. Once another character contradicts his version of events, they're believed without question and the rest of the story goes from there. I would've liked to see a little more doubt. We've got two versions of events, and the one that Alex and her friends choose to believe is the one that fits with their biases. It could've been more interesting had the conflict not been so black-and-white.

I'm not having great luck with graphic novels this year. This one isn't terrible, but it wasn't what I was expecting. Younger audiences might get more out of it than I did... but only if they like the style of illustration. I think it might be hard for thirteen-year-old readers to relate to a supposed thirteen-year-old who looks like she's at least twenty.

Was this review helpful?

When I initially read the description of Haphaven I was intrigued. A girl journeying to a world where she has to work around and remember all the superstitions she has been taught throughout her life in order to save her mother.

I really enjoyed the story in this graphic novel and was surprised by it. It had depth to it that was well developed. The layers to the story lined up beautifully and you find yourself going on this journey with Alex, understanding her hurts and her thoughts. The backstory that was created explained her motivation as well as her character and why she believes the things she does.

Overall this was a really fun story that was full of laughs as well as a daring adventure. I thoroughly enjoyed it and think anyone who likes stories with fantastical elements would also enjoy it.

Was this review helpful?

Haphaven is an emotional trek through a brilliantly rendered fantasy world, filled with life lessons and battles against strange foes. The novel is a unique take on the grief of losing a loved one and the fight to overcome that grief to continue living your best life. Luck isn’t enough to live on, and through the many trials and tribulations of our heroine, we discover what it takes to keep the enemies at bay.

This is a deeply emotional journey, following a girl forced to come to terms with the loss of her father and the impending loss of her mother. She clings to superstitions because she doesn’t believe in herself, putting her fate in the hands of rituals that can’t save her. Her journey becomes more complicated as she tries to follow the rules of superstitions and instead discovers a more sinister plot. The author has done a great job showing this battle between luck and life, and the importance of believing in yourself when the going gets rough. The world itself is filled with magical wonders, including leprechauns in full fantasy battle gear, airships straight out of a steampunk novel, and anthropomorphic who rule the land.

The highlight of the novel is the intricate portrayal of the fantasy world, filled as it is with creatures and wonders aplenty. We see what’s on the other side of the rainbow, and it’s as bright and whimsical as it is dark and dreary. There’s a light and dark side to everything, and that’s an important aspect throughout. The artist balances between the deep story and the fun of a magical land.

Haphaven is sure to be a great read for kids and adults alike. You’ll find a story that’s thoughtful and well written, paired with artwork that perfectly portrays this magical land and its many mysteries.

Was this review helpful?