Member Reviews

Erin’s writing in her debut novel was captivating. It was phenomenal. I quickly became entangled in Annaleigh’s emotions and thoughts from the beginning, and throughout the book, I couldn’t help but root for this character who felt so alive.

When it comes to retellings, I think sometimes the world building can be melodramatic or barely a part of the story. To me, I love the fantasy of a fictional world! I want to see, hear, and feel what the character does and to do that I need a well-developed world. That was all done perfectly here and was artful and enchanting. If I’m to be honest, reading about Highmoor and the islands was my favorite part.

I felt sorry for Annaleigh. She had suffered so much grief in her life, and now facing the death of her older sister Eulalie, it seemed that she’d always be in a state of loss. After losing so many, the people of the islands started to say the Thaumus family was cursed.

From the start, Annaleigh assumed there was foul play involved in her sister’s death and in the opening scene you can tell that it will play a big part in the remainder of the book. The first chapter set the stage for the atmosphere of the book, and I got to enjoy a gothic romance with mystery. The story unfolded nicely if albeit a bit slow at time, but I think that may have been an aspect of the book.

Even though Annaleigh was the main character, all of her sisters played a key part in the development of the plot. I really liked how the author included Verity in the story and the tragedies. She didn’t shy away from exposing such a young character to the morbidity of life, and I loved it.

Overall, it was a fantastic book, and I loved reading it! I’m definitely going to reading any future books by this author, and I can’t wait to see what she writes next.

Was this review helpful?

I absolutely love fairy tale retellings and when I saw this was a retelling of The Twelve Dancing Princesses, which is one of my favorites, I jumped at the chance to read it. This retelling was very well done and did not disappoint. The writing was captivating, the characters well developed, and the setting perfection. I will be passing this one on for my teen to read for sure!

Was this review helpful?

*I was given an ARC from NetGalley for an honest review.*
House of Salt and Sorrows by Erin A. Craig, is full of chills and thrills sure to keep you reading well into the night.
The story focuses on Annaleigh Thaumas and her journey to figure out the curse on her family. Once there were twelve Thaumas girls, but after the four eldest die in turn, people start to fear her family. Annaleigh never believed in the curse, but when she starts seeing ghostly visions she begins to think otherwise.
With the help of a handsome stranger, Cassius, she begins to uncover the mystery surrounding her family. As more deaths occur, she tries to to save her sisters before it's too late.
House of Salt and Sorrows is a great atmospheric read that will keep you guessing until the end.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you for publisher and Netgalley for approving me an e-arc of this title.


Annaleigh thinks her family is cursed until some instances begin to change her mind. She believes that her sister's deaths are not a mere coincidence and seeks to find out the truth.


This is a retelling of the Twelve Dancing Princesses fairytale and very well done. Though the story was intriguing I did feel that the story was predictable. This did not take away from the entertainment factor. Though I have to disagree with others who said the story was creepy. I did not feel the creep factor, but as I said earlier, I still liked it nonetheless. I absolutely loved the mythology aspects and the romance was sweet.

If you enjoy fairy tale retellings, with some cool twists be sure to add this one to your TBR.

Was this review helpful?

House of Salt and Sorrows is a gothic retelling of Grimm's The Twelve Dancing Princesses and while the original was creepy enough, Craig brings a thrill to this story.

Annaleigh is one of twelve sisters of the house of Thaumus. Four of her older siblings have perished in the last 5 years and the story opens with the funeral and eulogy of Eulalie. While three of her siblings have died of natural or "plausible" causes, Annaleigh suspects foul play with this recent death. She begins to investigate despite her sisters wishes and meets the hero, Cassius. Alongside this murder-mystery, the remaining sisters find a door that transports them to a mythical kingdom where there is no Thaumus curse.

Annaleigh and her sisters are each flawed, exhibiting traits common to young teenage girls - greed, lust, and hubris. Annaleigh, however, grows as a character and really shows a maturity when she sets aside her quest and her nightly balls to help her pregnant stepmother plan the annual Churning (a solstice of sorts). In the meantime, her feelings for Cassius continue to grow and merge with fears that he may have had something to do with Eulalie's murder.

This all comes to a spectacular conclusion that reminds me of Crimson Peak in some way. While I love the romance between Cassius and Annaleigh, I can't help but wonder if the author tried a little too hard to give them a happy ending. Then again this is a YA novel and perhaps we can all use a happy ending.

One thing that I personally appreciate is that unlike many YA novels, House of Salt and Sorrows is a standalone. You heard me right, folks. This will not have two more books stuffed with filler plot and never-ending tropes. Craig was able to describe the world in great detail while juggling the mystery of the deaths along with the romance and the eight dancing princesses.

4 stars for House of Salt and Sorrows

Was this review helpful?

To say I was swept away by this novel would be an understatement! From the opening pages, I was immediately sucked in, transfixed, and never turned loose. Annaleigh's character is what held me in not only her words and actions, but overall demeanor, mysterious air, and sense of wonder. Through glorious, decadent descriptions of events and settings, fabulous plot involvement and a beautifully told story, this is sure to be an instant hit for many. Highly recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Folktales have been told and retold for centuries, and I am always up for reading something new. Often, the retellings are interesting but not very original. Erin Craig, though, has produced an imaginative, lovely, wholly orignal retelling of the Twelve Dancing Princesses which takes the kernel of the old story and builds a whole new world peopled by fascinating characters and customs.

The Thaumas Dozen is as interesting a group as I can remember from my reading. Twelve sisters, all different in their own ways with very different wishes for their futures. Tragedy strikes the family again and again as first their mother then sisters begin to die tragically. The family, it is whispered, is cursed, with the girls being described by hoped for suitors as “lovely as a bouquet of belladonna.”

Two sisters, Annaleigh and Verity, know something is very wrong and each works towards solving the riddle of their “curse.” Throw in the wicked (is she or isn’t she?) stepmother, an enchanted father, and all the glorious wickedness of Faeryland and you have a tale that will delight and capture your senses.

This will appeal to teens and adults alike, and Erin Craig is on track to take a place next to Marissa Meyer, Naomi Novik, and Sarah Maas.

Was this review helpful?

I'm completely enamored of fairy tale retellings, especially when they are done with a sinister twist. After all, original fairy tales tend to be darker and deeper than the Disney-fied versions that they have become. If you don't know the story of The Twelve Dancing Princesses, essentially a King had 12 daughters. Each night, they were locked into their bedroom. Yet, in the morning, their shoes were completely worn out. The King promised the choice of his daughter's hand in marriage to the man who could figure out the mystery. The House of Salt and Sorrows takes this and gives it a wonderfully creepy gothic flourish.

For a debut novel, this is an incredible offering. It's a dark fantasy threaded with almost whimsical mystery and peeks of horror elements. Erin A. Craig weaves this eerie world with its own set of mythologies so perfectly, that you even begin to question whether what's happening is real. The horror components were the best part for me. Unexpected and gruesome, with a gratifying nightmarish quality, those little moments of disturbing terror play out in a way that any horror fan will adore. Yet, her overall storytelling vibe is hauntingly beautiful and almost poetic.

The characters were so well done. Even though there are only eight sisters living, the reader is introduced to each in turn. Each sister presents her own distinct personality and traits, even those that are now among the dead. You are drawn to have strong feelings about each character, which shows how well written they are. Annaleigh's father as the inattentive, almost neglectful father and of course, with all fairy tales, there's an evil stepmother...or is she? There are the handsome love interest and the best friend pining for the MC. All written in such a way that your estimation wavers throughout until you don't know who is being truthful. When you think you have it mastered, something else occurs and confounds you again. The ending was like being hit by a sledgehammer.

House of Salt and Sorrows is my #1 read this year, paws down! I'll be saving this one to reread again later. In fact, I kinda want to read it again right now. I can't wait to see what the author has in store for us next!

Was this review helpful?

This book!! It was so beautiful yet dark. A story about sisters and the absolute heart break that they have to endure. The writing completely blew me away!

Was this review helpful?

I read another reimagining of the 12 Dancing Princesses not that long ago, set in the Jazz era, and it was a very good and very entertaining. As good as that one was, this was better... It was dark and Gothic and weighty and extremely well-written, with horribly creepy details and marvelous characterization. The World created was wholly fresh and the way the plot and reveals played out was masterful. I will definitely be on the lookout for more from Erin Craig!

Was this review helpful?

This is a beautifully written book. The author has an amazing way with words! It's so hard to put down, especially after things really start rolling. A really incredible read. The cover is also really awesome! We have some teens that will check out based on the cover and I think this one will draw attention.

Was this review helpful?

One of my favorite things in a book is the setting, where the atmosphere has a personality all its own. In HOUSE OF SALT AND SORROWS, Highmoor manor breathed and the sea called. Craig's descriptions were beautiful and eerie and set such a mood! Simply gorgeous writing.

There were threads of darkness and light throughout the story, tragic deaths brushing against the finery of life. The mystery surrounding the untimely deaths of Annaleigh's older sisters pulled me into the story and the creepiness (such as her younger sister Verity's strange drawings and talk of ghosts!) gave me chills. Loved this book!

Was this review helpful?

This book was simply amazing...I loved the new world and all the characters, everything was so much more complex than it seemed at first! This is a fantastic story of the bond between sisters, the love of family, the ability to see beyond what is in front of your face and the magic of storytelling. I loved this book!!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to the publishers and NetGalley for allowing me to review this book!

Holy page turner, Batman! This book held me captive until the very last words. There are so many twists and turns! Annaleigh's family is shrinking, daughter by daughter, and it seems as though they are all cursed. Are they really? And if so, what lengths will they take to break the curse?

This book is ghost story, murder mystery, thriller, and so much more. I found Annaleigh to be a great narrator, even with all the craziness around her. I loved how not everything is how it seems, even in the narrator's own mind, and that alone made me keep turning the pages, just to see what was real and was wasn't.

Masterfully written!

Was this review helpful?

House of Salt and Sorrows is a clever and dark retelling of The Twelve Dancing Princesses, which on more than one occasion, reminded me of the Netflix version of The Haunting of Hill House. It’s well-written and I didn’t see all of the twists coming. For the most part, I enjoyed this story and am very grateful to NetGalley and Delacorte Press for the advanced copy. Thank you!

Was this review helpful?

I received a copy of this book from Netgalley and the publisher in exchange for an honest review.

Wow, this book was amazing! The writing is beautiful and atmospheric, and do delightfully creepy.

This is based off of the 12 dancing princess story and then barrels it's way in an incredible but completely unexpected direction.

I loved Annaleigh and her sisters. There voices were authentic and tragic. The pervasive loneliness and isolation of the Thaumus sisters was portrayed so we'll!

Was this review helpful?

When I was first saw this book all I hoped was for it to meet my expectations; but it ended up exceeding them. It was beautiful and dark, a lovely story about sisters and the tragedy they go through.

If you like Gothic/Gothic Romance and Mystery, you definitely don't want to miss this!! I really really hope a lot of people read this book come August. I can also see this as a Netflix show :)

Was this review helpful?

I think it's safe to say this is probably going to be in my Top 10 Books of 2019. This was everything I ever could have wanted. I remember adding this to my goodreads last April and I was so excited to read Erin's debut story. House of Salt and Sorrows was hauntingly beautiful, creepy, and a page turner. Annaleigh was a great MC. Currently writing up my full review for my blog now!

Was this review helpful?

*I received an eARC of this curtesy of the author and publisher from NetGalley, all thoughts are my own*

can I properly describe into words how EPIC this book was? I’m not sure but let’s find out.

house of salt and sorrow is a retelling of the twelve dancing princesses, my personal favorite fairytale. it is tragic, haunting, and absolutely stunning.

I have been personally victimized by craig’s writing and I demand a trip to highmoor and ALL the thaumus’s children’s wardrobes because when I tell you the descriptions of this world were breathtaking, I mean it. I feel as though I found pontus’s doorway myself and was transported to astrea.

you are hooked instantly into this story and feel apart of the family as you experience their trials and tribulations. you would expect for personalities to get lost in such a seemingly chaotic family however each of the sisters have their own personalities that shine through, right down to the youngest, verity (who was my personal favorite).

not only do these characters shine and add deep complexities to the story, but the world building is absolutely phenomenal. craig is able to give you a sense of the world around the islands through legends and lore that is just as fascinating as the major plot. if the amount of world-building in this STAND ALONE novel can succeed, I no longer want to settle for less in series with multiple meandering books.

AND THE ROMANCE. I cannot remember the last time I genuinely loved the romance in a book as much as I do here. I don’t know what it is about these two but the chemistry made me want to go through the trials of AP testing all over again.

this book had me LITERALLY at the edge of my seat in class while I finished the last scene of the book. though the ending was a bit predictable, the way it played out was not AT ALL.

if you are a fan of thrillers and fantasy you NEED to read this. it has the absolute perfect balance of magic, mystery, and down right scary shit that sent shivers up my spine in a crowded university hallway.

I cannot recommend this book enough. this is my favorite read of the year and I can’t imagine anything beating it anytime soon.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to NetGalley and Random House for this ARC! What a whirlwind of a book! It starts off with a bang, throwing us into this mystical and fantastical world with tragedy, family, and power, and what a striking world it was! The world building in this novel was awe-inspiring. I would love another novel on just the different gods and goddesses! For this narrative though, we start out by being given a mystery, and I was very literally kept guessing until the end! There a small clues dropped, red herrings delicately placed, and enough twists and turns to make your stomach roll like you’re on a rollercoaster. I enjoyed the journey from start to finish; it was a delectable spin on an old tale -Twelve Dancing Princesses- but you can tell from the very first chapter that the author made it her own in a variety of ways. My absolute favorite of those is how absolutely dark the story is. Murder, ghosts, madness, and tension that is so tangible you can almost choke on it all make this story wholly original and a delight to have had the pleasure of reading. I had chills the majority of the book, and it was extremely hard to put down. I didn’t want to miss a second of the Thaumas saga! I love retellings, but this book exceeded all of my wildest dreams. It’s a perfect read for a dark and stormy night!

Was this review helpful?