Member Reviews

Not much to say about this since it was a super teeny teaser arc, but thus far it pretty much just reads like the start of a normal teen romance. That said, I certainly expect Rowell will shake things up as it moves along.

Was this review helpful?

ARC provided by Netgalley and the Publisher.

Well ... it was an ARC of the first 18 pages. And I am invested now ... but I have no more pages to read. I just want this sweet, Halloween, pumpkin-spiced story in my hands right now. I guess this just really speaks to my basic fall obsessed New England heart. I WANT MORE!

Was this review helpful?

Well, that ARC was a tease! So far so good, though. I'm enjoying the M/F friendship between the leads and I'm digging the setting, but that's all I can say, having read such a small fraction of it. Looking forward to reading more!

Was this review helpful?

I didn't care for the book, it wasn't moving along at a steady pace. to predictable. cute boy, meets cute girl

Was this review helpful?

Very adorable. Wish is was Halloween time already so this graphic could go with the autumnal feel. Very short preview, but has lots of potential

Was this review helpful?

This teaser is too tiny! I need more of this pumpkin-patch romance. I am excited about the M/F best friendship, POC characters, and the charm of Halloween and pie. Can't wait to get my hands on this one.

Was this review helpful?

As always, Rowell's books are interesting and enjoyable---great beginning with detailed, inviting illustrations!
Looking forward to the whole story!

Was this review helpful?

Hard to say anything precise about the comic, since the teaser is too short to analyze anything. I did like the setting very much and there aren't that many farm comics and especially about pie making. I like Rowell's awesome friendly romantic approach and of course having POC characters is a plus too. The art looks cute and fun, but still serious in a sense. I surely want to keep reading this, since it's hard to say where this is going and that's interesting in its own right.

Was this review helpful?

Thank for the advance preview copy. I enjoyed the beginning of this story and I can't wait to read the rest!

Was this review helpful?

Sad this is only a teaser but I really love the art style. Our two MC's have a great relationship and I feel like I've known them forever. I'm very excited for the full book.

Was this review helpful?

Oooh, this was a great start! I'm loving the art style and the story. I can't wait to get my hands on the rest!

Was this review helpful?

I'm sad this was just a teaser. I love the illustrations and I'm really looking forward to reading the full book!

Was this review helpful?

So, this is unfortunately only a teaser but I’m hooked and can’t wait for this to be released. Deja seems like such an amazing friend to have and if I were her I’d give Josiah so many judgey looks too.
I was sold on this already because of the two names on the cover but the art is wonderful and the story is delightful. Will definitely recommend this.

Was this review helpful?

Ack like the first reviewer said, I'm also super bummed this is only a teaser! I wish the description had said so. But, these first 18 pages really hooked me in so I can't wait to read the whole thing some time! I was *totally* a Josiah at that age ;-)

Was this review helpful?

Bummed this was only a sampler! I look forward to reading the rest. The illustrations are gorgeous so far and I was enjoying the story.

Was this review helpful?