I really wanted to love 'The Grace Year,' but it fell short for me. The premise—a dystopian world where young women are sent away to rid themselves of their "magic"—was intriguing, but the execution felt uneven. The world-building left too many unanswered questions, making it hard to fully immerse myself in the story.

While Tierney, the protagonist, had moments of strength, her character often felt inconsistent. The pacing was also an issue; the first half dragged, while the ending seemed rushed and too neatly resolved. I also struggled with some of the darker themes, which felt gratuitous at times rather than serving the narrative.

There were glimpses of compelling ideas, but they didn’t come together in a satisfying way for me. Fans of 'The Handmaid’s Tale' or 'Lord of the Flies 'might still enjoy it, but this one just wasn’t for me.

The Grace Year by Kim Liggett is book that will stay with me for a long time. It was haunting, and though provoking. The Grace Year follows Tierney a young teen sent for her own Grace Year and her year turns into a fight for survival with threats around her and also nature. I loved Tierney's character. Shes smart but can be naive and also a strong character and it was nice to see her evolve throughout this book. I really enjoyed the tensed world building in this book. The Grace Year is about claiming your strength and human resilience. This book was thought provoking and thrilling and would recommend to my friends.

This one just wasn't for me - and it's definitely a case of "it's not you! it's me!" I love thrillers, but I'm not big on dystopian, ultimately this one was a struggle for me. I think if you enjoy dystopian novels this will be a great read!

Interesting story filled with action. I enjoyed the storyline and the characters. This is the first time I have read a book by this author, but I'm looking forward to reading more in the future.

Holy crap. This book is POWERFUL. It's perfectly described as The Handmaid's Tale meets Lord of the Flies.

It's about the lies that keep us pliant and docile - about facing the harsh truths full on in order to break free of them.

This is typically book I wouldn't enjoy reading: it's bleak and dark but there's so much hope infused throughout. The writing is crisp and vivid; the words in this book will stick with me for a long, long time.

A must read of the year. A feminist triumph.

The plot of lord of the flies but make it girls in a dystopia society is already great premise that doesn't require much to make it successful and yet....this book fell flat. The author had the chance to really do something amazing with this story. There were so many avenues to explore when it comes to teenage girls approaching adulthood in a society where they are nothing but property to the men in their lives and then finally getting the chance to experience a type of freedom. Female relationships and emotions are so complex and it could have been the great focus on how those relationships are what we can use to survive in a world made for men and yet....the storyline went the stereotypical route with a love interest that really didn't matter and that you never feel invested in the relationship building and now you have a character who only ever wanted to be free and be her own person focusing on leaving everything behind to be a wife to this guy. It was disappointing.

Unfortunately, I could not connect with this book at all and DNF'd pretty early on in reading it. This might have been the case of reading at the wrong time or it may just be me, because I know many readers who enjoyed this book. However, the unsettling nature of the book made me vacillate between wanting to push through and stop and I ultimately decided to. However, I revisited some early reviews from readers and since I loved Wilder Girls and this has been compared to it, I may have to continue eventually.

This book was one heck of a ride from start to finish. It’s basically a cross between The Hunger Games and The Handmaid’s Tale with a big splash of Lord of the Flies. In this dystopian society, girls are sent away at the age of 16 to live together in the woods for a year with only minimal contact from the main society. Many of the girls don’t return and even those who do are not necessarily guaranteed the “prize” of marriage.

Tierney is a formidable protagonist. She stands up to the mean girl of the group and she tries to encourage the girls to work together so that they all have a better chance of surviving their horrific ordeal.

I could have done without the love triangle, but the genre is contractually obligated to include one. To the book’s credit, Tierney doesn’t spend much time mooning over the two gentlemen because she’s much too busy trying to survive to mull her prospects.

I would absolutely recommend The Grace Year. This was a deeply moving book that really resonated with the current political climate. It was very easy to get invested in the outcome of the story and I found the book hard to put down.



I received a digital ARC of this book from St. Martin’s/NetGalley.

Just gripping enough to keep me committed to the end. However, from my perspective, the ultimate reliance on male saviourship just didn't align with the intended "feminist" themes. If you're a young reader looking for a somewhat less dark version of "The Handmaid's Tale," then this one's for you. Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC and to author Kim Liggett for having the courage to put share your creativity with the world.

I read this awhile ago but never reviewed. I did enjoy it, but it is more of a three star rating for me. The pace was a bit slow going into the story. While I usually like stories that are dystopian in nature and I see similars to the Handmaid's tale, there was just something I couldn't quite connect to. I feel like I didn't connect to the characters - they felt more unlikeable. Topics like these are hard to read and maybe a book like this takes time to process. But I think the author should keep writing books that do many people think and can be hard to read.

The Handmaid's Tale (dystopian speculative fiction addressing female repression and the male possessive thirst for power) meets Lord of the Flies (survival of the fittest but what is really going?) to form a page-turner.

I wasn't sure how to feel about this after finishing it. I liked it, but the ending was a little strange. I think I will read again, though! The "we're in love because we actually love each other, not because he's the only one who's been nice to me" was a little....bad.

The Grace Year by Kim Liggett captivated me from start to finish, earning a solid 5-star rating. Set in a dystopian world where young girls are banished to endure the ominous 'Grace Year,' Liggett weaves a gripping tale of survival, sisterhood, and rebellion. The protagonist's journey through this treacherous landscape is both haunting and empowering, as she navigates the complexities of societal expectations and the brutal realities of her environment. Liggett's writing is atmospheric and evocative, drawing readers into a world teeming with danger and intrigue. I found myself completely immersed in the story, unable to put it down until the final page. With its richly drawn characters and thought-provoking themes, **The Grace Year** is a must-read for fans of dystopian fiction. I wholeheartedly recommend it to anyone seeking a compelling and unforgettable read.

I really enjoyed the storyline in world building in the novel. I also really liked the characters. I thought this was a solid read, and I will definitely be reading more by this author.

4.5/5 stars

The open water, the breeze, the unobstructed sun glaring down on us - it feels like freedom, but we know it's a lie. This is how they break us. They take everything away, our very dignity, and anything we get in return feels like a gift.

A perfect mash-up of The Lord of the Flies and The Hunger Games during the Salem Witch Trials, Liggett's The Grace Year features a patriarchal society that fears the power of women, claiming a woman's luring gaze is downright witchcraft.

[Women are] told we have the power to lure grown men from their beds, make boys lose their minds, and drive the wives mad with jealousy. They believe our very skin emits a powerful aphrodisiac, the potent essence of youth, of a girl on the edge of womanhood. That's why we're banished for our sixteenth year, to release our magic into the wild before we're allowed to return to civilization.

Tierney, our female protagonist, is sixteen-years-old and is expected to marry and start a family, as is many of the other girls in her town. However, before she begins her role as a dutiful spouse and mother, she must embark on her Grace Year, during which all sixteen-year-old girls in the town will reside collectively in the wilderness until their "magic" dispels. Entirely alone and free to make their own decisions, these girls' choices will either strengthen or weaken their relationships, thus affecting their safety. Yet, when loner Tierney is unexpectedly courted by her best friend Michael, she is plunged into the female-female rivalries she spent years avoiding. Will Tierney be able to survive the year, or will her "magic" and the competition drive her to madness?

- - -

In the past year, the word "feminism" has been frequently raised on social media - to the point that I question whether I know what actual feminism is or if TikTok's toxic version has come to dominate my world. My initial thought of Liggett's feminist story was, "Like The Handmaid's Tale?" Although the story is placed in a dystopian era, the culture is more traditional and the practices can be compared to those done during the Salem Witch Trials, especially as the opinions of females are challenged with deathly punishments such as hangings. However, Liggett's take on a heavy subject and her storytelling easily made this an exciting and gripping novel.

Liggett's prose is executed wonderfully and places you exactly in Tierney's shoes. Although learning about the history of the town and its events from varying perspectives would have been interesting, the intimacy of following young Tierney makes the story do unputdownable. As Tierney readies to participate in the forty-seventh Grace Year, the reader is told that Tierney's mother previously underwent the ceremony as well and possibly her grandmother. Thus, since Tierney's knowledge of the the Grace Year is limited to what she has been told, there is so much mystery involved in the world itself. This quality not only lends to the reader's role as a detective aiming to understand the reasons behind the characters' actions but also unravels the town's repulsive and toxic nature. For example, women are plotted against each other from a very young age. In the town, men prey on and brainwash them; outside of town and during their Grace Year, this toxicity is fueled by their insecurities. Further, beyond the town's outskirts, ruthless poachers seek to kill these girls during their Grace Years and present their remains as trophies to be sold to the town's men and woman seeking to preserve their youth. However, as noted by the quotation marks surrounding the women's "magic," it's all false - a lie maintained to control these young girls as they develop into women.

There is no doubt that Liggett aims to reflect our society, particularly its cliques. The mean girls lead the young women during their Grace Year and inevitably punish anyone who disagrees with them. Tierney, with her set of survival skills, sets to improve the lives of the girls during their Grace Year. Rather than drink from an algae-infested well and rely solely on the rations they packed before their trip, she attempts to produce several solutions to help the overall experience of the Grace Year. Rather than the expected praise I would give Tierney for her creativity and resourcefulness, she is mocked and banished from the main pack. It's truly remarkable how Liggett skillfully portrays the influence of brainwashing over several decades and how much I literally want to hug each of these ladies.

However, Tierney's banishment leads to an unlikely romance with a poacher Ryker. Although I was at first flabbergasted with Tierney falling in love, Ryker fit the story extremely well. Tierney, at the beginning, is wanting her life to be entirely up to her. Since women are basically treated like property in her world, she despises courting, the Grace Year ritual, and anything to do with marriage. Tierney's initial wish is to not be chosen for marriage at the choosing ceremony and work in the fields where she can remain free. Although her plans are turned upside down after being courted by Michael, I enjoyed Tierney's love for Ryker was her choice, and I love that Liggett included this romance in this story, especially since it is not un-feminist to fall in love or do tasks that are stereotypically feminine. I love the maturity and bravery exhibited by Tierney during her time with and after Ryker, and these scenes definitely encompassed the strength and intelligence of Tierney wonderfully.

Lastly, the ending! Although I am somewhat confused by the ending, it was peaceful. There are spoilers ahead in this paragraph; therefore, I warn any socially awkward turtles to proceed with caution and read this masterpiece so we may discuss at our next meeting. Thank you!

So, the ending! Um...Liggett ended the story vaguely. Passing by Tierney's dismay of a betrothed, her subsequent send off into the scary wilderness, and her life's desire to give women the freedom to pursue their own passions, she gives birth to her daughter and experiences this:

As I close my eyes and let out my next endless breath, I find myself walking in the woods, weightless, free.

And, then Tierney is flashed to a scene of a very much alive Ryker walking around although the reader most definitely witnessed him die. So, it begs the question: is Tierney in too peaceful of a moment in which she dies during childbirth? With Tierney's mom freeing her hair and Ryker's dreamlike appearance, it's assumed that Tierney dies. Nonetheless, Book #2 will have to explain something about this ending scene and the legacy of Tierney's daughter.

Also available on https://newbookcatsreads.blogspot.com

Holy crap, this book was so much more terrifying than I ever expected. Just. Wow. I ended up listening to the final copy in audiobook, and dang what a ride. This was phenomenal in audiobook, I found myself making excuses to have my headphones on to listen. But just holy buckets wow.

Great story and theme. Likeable lead character (TierneyO wo discovers the secrets kept, the punishments to society, and the men who created it.

Same vein as Handmaid's Tale, Hunger Games (more adult). Would recommend to someone that is a fan of dystopian fantasy!

I really wanted to like this book. The synopsis held so much promise, but the book failed to deliver as much as I hoped for from it. I enjoyed it well enough, but with a few tweaks it could have been an even more enjoyable read.

The Grace Year is a quick read that builds on the dystopian novels that have come before. What I mean by that is that there seems to be a nod to female driven narratives that pit women against the oppressive societies that rule them, a nod that acknowledges that you know where we're coming from so let's just dive right into the action without a lot of the backstory of how they got there. In The Grace Year, that's not the point. I think the point is that Tierney and the other girls are in it now, so now what?!



In this novel, young women are sent away for a year to dispose of their 'magic' and when they return they'll return to assigned roles, like in a caste system. Some will marry and some will be laborers and some will be sex workers or outcasts. Tierney, our main character, assumes that she'll be a laborer because she's purposely led a life that would make that so. Her assumption is wrong and she starts her journey to their 'grace year' property in a state of shock and determination. Once all of the grace year girls arrive at their grace year destination, the immediate devolution of civility begins. There's peer pressure, bullying, and mob mentality at work ...among other things. Tierney tries to set up a society that would be equitable and helpful and within days, it's all destroyed. Within weeks she's an outcast and not long after that, she finds herself on death's doorstep. It's only when someone who should be her enemy nurses her back to health that she begins to really understand all of the elements working against the grace year girls, and begins to try to work against them to make things right, better for them all. Ultimately, when Tierney makes it back to her original home and has some time to reflect on it all, she gains some clarity and leaves us with a sense of hope for better days.



While I really enjoyed The Grace Year--it's definitely a 4.5-5 star read for me--I did want a little more backstory and information about how in the world they got to this point to begin with, where are they, and when is this all taking place. Other than those things, The Grace Year held my attention, was a quick read, and offered insights about being a woman in the world, insights that I wish we didn't have to learn because we lived in a truly equal and free society.

This is a fantastic sci-fi, dystopian YA novel. It is intense, and difficult to read at times, but it has a certain gripping quality that made it hard to put down, even when I didn't want to read anymore due to the subject matter. I thought it tackled themes of misogyny and the patriarchy very well, and it made no qualms about highlighting how dystopian those ideas are in general. I think this book is a solid choice to add to any YA collection in a library and might even make a good book club read, assuming you have older, more mature teens in attendance.