Member Reviews

Prunella wakes up on her birthday and decides that she's a big kid now and that all of the old things that she loved to do are "for babies" but when she gets scared that night she realizes that maybe it's ok to not try to grow up too fast. I enjoyed this story and the adorable illustrations. Great for kids that are struggling with wanting to be able to do everything the big kids do.

Was this review helpful?

This is a sweet book that covers a stage in life that all "big kids" go through, making it very relatable to almost any young reader. Pro, the main character, announces that all the things she used to like to do is for babies, until she realizes that having fun is for everyone, including big kids. This book may be a helpful tool for preschoolers straddling the divide between being a baby and independence.

I was given an ARC of this book by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

I liked this little tale of a little girl who thinks she's too old for her favorite things just because she's a year older. I think littles will relate to it Illustrations were adorable!

Was this review helpful?

The cover let’s us know Prunella has a little sass about her. She is wearing a hat and a big smile. Her shoe laces are dragging and she has her right hand propped out on her hip. Great cover and fits this sweet story all parents have been witness to.

Prunella wakes up on the morning of her birthday and announces, “I’m a big kid now.” She doesn’t want to do any of the things she usually loves. “That’s for babies!” she announces over and over again. Her doll, Talking Sally, is buried away, no more bubble baths, animal crackers or even heart shaped pancakes! Those are for babies and Prunella is a big kid now.

But what what do you do with that when a big scary thunderstorm happens at night? Do big kids get scared?

An endearing story about growing up, for little kids and big kids ages 4 and up.

Was this review helpful?

Prunella wakes up on her third birthday determined to be a "big girl." Her common refrain becomes "That's for babies." While stating this, Prunella denies herself old pleasures like special breakfasts, playing with a favorite doll, going to the playground and having playdates. Nonetheless, she remains determined until a storm awakens her at night. Prunella then tucks herself into bed with her parents. The next day she again participates in some of her favorite activities.

Children of toddler through preschool age often state that they want to be "big kids." Of course, they feel ambivalence at times. If you know a child for whom this is true, they may enjoy this picture book.

Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher. The opinions are my own.

Was this review helpful?

I read this book to my 2.5 year old son, and he seemed to enjoy it and asked to hear it again. Its recommend for 5ans up but I would say more 2-5 age range. I found the flow a little confusing but otherwise was a cute book.

Was this review helpful?

I received a complimentary copy of this book through NetGalley. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own - and well - my four year old daughters.

That's for Babies is a story about a young girl, Prunella, who wakes up one day on her birthday and decides that she is no longer a baby who plays with dolls, eats ice-cream or plays with toys. She decides to pack all her toys away. One night when the thunder rumbled, she bravely comforts her doll, Stella. And with the thunder, she realises even grown children can get scared.

This is a sweet story with a happy ending - teaching us not to be older before our time. It is okay to be scared of thunder. The pictures are colourful and the story is easy to follow. The author, Jackie Azúa Kramer, was able to keep my four year old daughter interested.

Was this review helpful?

That's for Babies is a book about an ugly little girl with an ugly name and an ugly attitude. I really didn't enjoy this one, and though the eventual message was okay, I'm confused and unsatisfied with the way the book came around to that conclusion.

Prunella (yes, the parents named their kid after the wrinkly fruit you eat when you're constipated) wakes up on the morning of her birthday and suddenly thinks everything is for babies. I'm not kidding. Everything. Her toys (even her favourites) are for babies. Heart-shaped pancakes are for babies. Educational songs are for babies. Animal crackers, bubble baths, and getting tucked in? All for babies. So are playground equipment, imagination, and ice cream. Seriously, I don't know where this kid got her warped ideas, but I suspect they're from her parents, since the illustrations show plenty of other children engaging in these activities. So that's a bit disturbing to me. Someone in this child's life has been telling her what they think age-appropriate activities are, but it's a really small list. Eating ice cream is for babies? Really?!

Pru (if the author really wanted to use that nickname, she should've just gone with "Prudence"; I just can't get past the laxative fruit name) gets scared one night during a thunderstorm and jumps into her parents' bed, after which her attitude magically changes. Now it's okay to engage in all those babyish activities. The book ends with Pru's parents telling her that if she's ever scared, she can sleep in their bed, and we have the following conclusion:

"I know," said Prunella.
"But that's for babies...
... and big kids like me!"

It's a weird, abrupt turnaround, and I don't really understand how being scared during a thunderstorm erases her weird, ageist attitude.

The illustrations are really not my thing. There are a few that are sort of cute, but they're kind of uneven, so some renderings of Prunella are rather unpleasant. Her parents are just creepy. I don't like the style of art in this book at all.

There have got to be better books about growing up and leaving childish things behind. Those books probably don't include ice cream and having fun as stuff that's only allowed for babies.

Was this review helpful?

Taking a cue from Toy Story, amongst others, a little girl thinks she’s all grown up and doesn’t need her toys anymore. Fortunately she wises up.
She’s really got the ego going when she says no to any kind of pancakes. And how can she think ice cream cones are for babies? Does that make me a baby? (Don’t answer that.)
The artwork is cute, but the story gets a bit silly.

Was this review helpful?

What a truly sweet book that teaches children what it means to be a big kid and grow up. The illustrations were adorable! Those early years seem to fly by, and our children quickly begin to test out their independence. The overall message was perfect-- that you can still do "big kid" things AND "baby things" even if you're older!

Was this review helpful?

That's for Babies is a picture book subject that parents of toddlers can be found looking for in a public library setting or for librarians to use in a story time setting. Littte Prunella wakes up one morning, which also happens to be her birthday and declares that she is a big kid now. Prunella is no longer in need of baby-like treatment throughout the day, like heart-shaped pancakes, animal cookies, and general pretend play. But that evening a big storm rolls in at bedtime and not-a-baby Prunella struggles with being scared and wanting to go to her parents bed for comfort. This book would be a great story to read to older toddlers in a story time setting, but I find the length of the book a little long for a young toddler, so the ages would be a mature child 3 and older. The repetition of "That's for babies" is a wonderful early literacy addition for the story. The illustrations are bright and colorful and follow the story well.

Was this review helpful?

A good story with an important message for young kids. But the Illustrations could have been better.

Was this review helpful?

When deciding to read this book to my 4 yr old grandson, it was due to him saying on a few occasions to his older brother, 'I am not a baby, i'm a big boy now. He loves being read to and enjoyed this book. Wonderful illustrations.

My thanks to Netgalley and the Publishers for my copy. This is my honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Great storybook for toddlers trying out their independence. Loved the illustrations and the story. The little girl discovers that you can do big kid things and baby things even if you're older. Loved it!

Was this review helpful?

This was a really sweet book teaching children what it means to be a big kid. It captured the very essence of childhood and the meaning don't be in a hurry to grow up.

Was this review helpful?

That's for Babies is such a wonderful book for young children who are trying to grow up too fast. My 3 year old and 5 year olds both enjoyed the story. The characters were very fun and likeable, and the colorful illustrations kept my children's attention throughout the book. I definitely recommend this book for young children to enjoy with their parents.

I received a complimentary copy of this book from Clavis Publishing through NetGalley and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are mine.

Was this review helpful?