Member Reviews

An ode to another time and a journey born of desperation, a prayer for the innocence of childhood shattered by evil intentions and cruel actions of adults entrusted with their care, a classic coming-of-age tale that includes an ambitious quest, and an entreaty for the inner peace found in offering forgiveness to others.

“Ask me, God’s right here. In the dirt, the rain, the sky, the trees, the apples, the stars in the cottonwoods. In you and me, too. It’s all connected and it’s all God. Sure this is hard work, but it’s good work because it’s a part of what connects us to this land. This beautiful, tender land.”

In 1932, as the Great Depression has begun to transform the country is when this story begins. The Lincoln School near the Gilead River in Minnesota was founded primarily as a home for Native American children who had been separated from their families, sometimes through death, and sometimes not. Those running this “home” were not known for their kindness, Mrs. Brickman seems to have particularly targeted two orphaned white brothers, Odie and Albert O’Banion. Albert is almost old enough to age out of Lincoln, whereas Odie is younger, and the primary target of Mrs. Brickman’s evil nature, she uses Odie’s misbehaviors – which tend to be fabricated more often than not - to keep Albert in line. Mose is a friend of the brothers, a mute Native American boy known for his physical strength, who communicates through sign language since he is unable to speak. The fourth member of this band of soon-to-be runaways is Emmy, a young girl who will lose her only parent through the wrath of Nature. These four Vagabonds escape these halls and set off to find a life that is far away from this hell, a life that contains hope and love.

I loved living in these pages, the prose flows like the rivers they are navigating, and the characters seemed so real that it is hard for me to think of them in any other way. I am so saddened by the thought that it is now time to leave these pages and these people behind, but I know this is a story that will long live in my heart.



Pub Date: 03 Sep 2019


Many thanks for the ARC provided by Atria Books!

Was this review helpful?

5 +++++ glorious stars

I have been waiting for a long time to say this about a book, and now I can: This novel is a masterpiece. It is William Kent Krueger at his very best - it is clear he threw his entire heart and soul into this book. I will buy a hardback copy (something I never do) and keep it forever.

Set during The Great Depression in 1932 in my home state of Minnesota we follow our protagonist, 12-year-old Odie, and his three fellow travelers (self-dubbed The Four Vagabonds) on their search for “belonging” and “home.” The story is told solely through the eyes of Odie, and the story line is linear. The Four Vagabonds’ journey is not easy; in fact, it is difficult, very difficult. Along the way they meet a variety of different people, many as bad off as they are, but others that are very kind and willing to help them. The Vagabonds endure much suffering, but also display considerable strength and engage in a great deal of soul-searching. Odie finds it difficult to believe in a God who would let these things happen to him and his companions, but he also can’t help but think many of the unfortunate events are unintentionally due to his own actions. He tries to do the right thing, but carries much guilt when things go wrong. This is a spiritual journey, one that I almost felt honored to be on with our characters.

The story is extremely well written. The prose is exquisite. Mr. Krueger has the ability to set a scene and a mood beautifully without excessive words. I have always been awed by his ability to create just the right atmosphere in his stories, and this one is no exception. Of interest, a chunk of the story takes place in the fictional town of New Bremen, Minnesota, the setting of Ordinary Grace, which takes place twenty-nine years later during the summer of 1961.

This Tender Land flows seamlessly and the chapter lengths are just right. As always, Mr. Krueger includes Native American characters in his book, not something I usually look for, but I always learn something by the inclusion of our Native Americans. I came to care deeply for Odie, but could not see a good end for him. This, along with being immersed in events of the odyssey, kept me fascinated and glued to the pages. Best of all, the author includes a wonderful epilogue that gives us the highlights of our characters’ lives over the next several decades. Some things intentionally remain a bit uncertain, but that was fine with me.


After publishing his brilliant Ordinary Grace in March 2013, Mr. Krueger embarked on the writing of a companion piece, also called This Tender Land. He finished the manuscript, but was not satisfied with the end result and did not feel it represented his best work. Much to the disappointment of his publisher, he asked to have the project abandoned so that he could start over with an entirely different concept. That was three years ago. The current version of This Tender Land is the result of the rewrite and is well worth the long six and a half year wait. Best of all, as you will see in the Author’s Note, Mr. Krueger is deeply fulfilled and content with the new version. I think it says a lot about the author that he is unwilling to put out something that was not perfect in his mind. I doubt we will ever see a “co-writer” on any of his books in the future.

Write what you know. I have the feeling that is what William Kent Krueger does here. This Tender Land gives us insight into this man that we saw a glimpse of in Ordinary Grace. I absolutely love his Cork O’Connor series, but I so hope we will see another stand alone novel in a similar vein to these last two. I will happily wait six and a half years to see that happen.

If you only read one book this year, make it be this one.

Many thanks to Net Galley, Atria Books, and William Kent Krueger for gifting me an advanced review copy of this book. Opinions are mine alone and are not biased in any way.

Was this review helpful?

Another beautifully written saga by William Kent Krueger. This book is a gem! Thank you for giving me the opportunity to read an advance copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

This Tender Land by William Kent Krueger is a big-hearted novel that doesn't disappoint.

Four orphans form an unlikely family in 1932 Minnesota: Motherless Odie O'Banion and his brother Albert, are the only Caucasians at the Lincoln Indian Training School, committed there after their father's death; their friend Mose, a Native American boy whose tongue was cut out in an attack that left his mother dead; and Emmy, orphaned at six after a crushing tornado kills her mother. The Lincoln School is a dark place -- DiMarco, a groundskeeper-cum-sadistic enforcer for the school superintendent, Thelma Brickman, also known as the Black Witch enjoys giving the children the belt for infractions large and small, but even more he enjoys isolating them in the "quiet room" where he can do with them as he wishes.

Odie, Albert, Mose, and Emmy eventually escape the Black Witch and her sadistic minions under the cover of darkness in a canoe, each of them searching for something; home, identity, and safety. They are running from the Black Witch, who claims that the older boys kidnapped Emmy. The police are after them, and they must hide their identities.

Krueger has a stethoscope to the heart of each of his characters -- he knows what makes each of them tick, the longings buried deep in their broken and empty chambers, he also knows what each of them needs to become whole. The orphans travel the Gilead to the Mississippi hoping to eventually reach St. Louis where Odie and Albert remember having an aunt -- their mother's sister, Julia.

The cast is filled with remarkable characters: One-Eyed Jack, a hard-drinking farmer who has lost his family and is about to lose his farm; Sister Eve, a kind-hearted faith healer who may or may not be running a scam; and Aunt Julia who harbors more than one dangerous secret.

The novel is framed by an aging Odie, looking back on his early years:
"Our former selves are never dead. We speak to them, arguing against decisions we know will bring only unhappiness, offering consolation and hope, even though they cannot hear. "Albert," I whisper, "stay clearheaded. Mose, stay strong. Emmy hold to the truth of your visions. And, Odie, Odie, do not be afraid."

William Kent Krueger's super power is creating characters with real depth and placing them in stories that reveal truths about what it is to be human in this world. This Tender Land is a novel in the tradition of the Great American Novel. Highly recommended for fans of Mark Twain and John Steinbeck, as well as contemporary author Leif Enger.

Special thanks to Atria Books and Netgalley for providing me with an digital advance review copy for review.

Lin Salisbury is host and producer of Superior Reads and Superior Reviews on WTIP 90.7 Grand Marais, Minnesota and on the web at www.wtip.org and www.superiorreads.blog. Listen to her author interviews and reviews on www.wtip.org and www.superiorreads.blog.

Was this review helpful?

A beautifully written historical fiction tale of 4 orphans in search of a place they want to call home. Odie, Albert, Emmy, and Mose are on the journey of a lifetime in hopes of finding a final place to rest their heads. This story takes place over the course of a summer while the orphans are traveling down the Mississippi River on their way to St. Louis. Along the way they meet people from all different walks of life, some who will help their journey, and some who will hinder it. Regardless of their role, each person met along the way will help shape each orphan into the person they will become.

This story touched on some parts of history that I wasn't aware of. The author's note scraped the surface explaining Native American Boarding Schools and should definitely not be skipped. This book shouldn't be skipped either! Add it to your list, it's long but well worth it.

Was this review helpful?

Hands down the best book I’ve read in 2019!! In This Tender Land, William Kent Krueger has written a novel for the ages!

Set in Minnesota in 1932, This Tender Land follows four orphans and their journey to flee the horrible grasp of a corruptive and abusive “school”. After their father died, Odie and Albert O’Banion find themselves at The Lincoln School, which is an orphanage of sorts for Native Americans (the brothers are the only caucasians in the school). Odie and Albert befriend Mose, who is unable to speak, but communicates with the boys via sign language. The three boys work out in the community to help local farmers and that’s where they meet Emmy. After many horrible and unthinkable situations at The Lincoln School, the foursome decide to run. From that point, I knew I should savor every page because I was in for some literary awesomeness!

I never wanted this book to end! This coming-of-age novel tells such a powerful and emotion tale. I was amazed how the novel played out like a movie in my mind! The characters burrowed their way into my heart—this group of “Vagabonds” will absolutely be staying with me! I haven’t read a Willian Kent Krueger novel before (I am kicking myself for not reading him sooner), but I am really looking forward to reading his prior novels! I wish I could give This Tender Land more than 5 stars because it was that fantastic! Everyone should read this book, I really think everyone will love it as much as I do!

Was this review helpful?

This is the best book I have read in 2019. It is good old-fashioned storytelling and is beautifully written. The characters are so well written and developed that I wish I had known them. The author did a magnificent job of describing the feel and realness of the Great Depression. My own parents lived through it, and I well recall their descriptions of the poverty and despair. Mr. Krueger's writing and storytelling is similar to one of my other favorite authors, Kent Haruf. I will certainly bee recommending this book to everyone.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you NetGalley and Atria Books for the eARC.
This book is wonderful, I didn't want it to end and it will probably stay with me for a long time.
During the Depression three young people escape from an Indian School where they lived in deplorable conditions. They call themselves The Vagabonds and they embark on an epic journey in a stolen canoe, meeting and interacting with many characters as they manage to slip unnoticed from town to town. Their many adventures and their sheer grit made my eyes well up; it's such an extraordinary, moving story that it was hard to get back to reality and do some housecleaning! Highly recommended!

Was this review helpful?

A tour de force novel deserving of a 5+ Star rating. A heart rendering odyssey of four orphans fleeing from the Lincoln School for Native Americans in Minnesota during the Summer of 1932 .... heralding the onset of the Great Depression. A beautiful novel that I wanted to never end!
It was a time when our government deemed in wise to forcibly separate Native American children from their parents and culture. Two caucasian brothers, Albert and Odie, find themselves mysteriously interned at the school. Odie, the younger, is six years old and full of "piss and vinegar" and frequently is at odds with the stern school superintendent ... who the children collectively term the "Black Witch"
The O'Banion boys flee the school in the company of their best friend, Mose. A mute Native American, whose parents were murdered and his tongue was cut out. They reluctantly included the recently orphaned six year old , Emmy. ... they couldn't possibly allow her confinement- imprisonment in the Black Witch's home. Emmy. "cute as a button" accompanies the trio in a canoe down the Gilead River ... ultimately hoping to connect and follow the Mississippi River down to St. Louis to search for the O'Banion's Aunt Julia.
This odyssey down the waterways leads to multiple encounters and confrontations with both good and bad people. "There's no end to the cruelty in this world, and no matter how far down you reach, there's never a bottom". The exploits of the four Vagabonds while traversing the river expose the tumultuous times facing the populace during the Great Depression.
Krueger proves to be a masterful storyteller ... he explores the multitude of differing ways to cope with extreme adversity during this trying time in our countries history. The story is both tender and sweet and at times brings tears to both women and men readers.
Thanks to NetGalley and Atria Books for supplying an Uncorrected Proof of this gem in exchange for an honest review. Excuse me ,while I immediately go download his previously highly touted novel - "Ordinary Grace"

Was this review helpful?

One of my all-time favorite books is Ordinary Grace, a book I gave 5 stars and have read twice, even though I rarely re-read books. I was highly anticipating the author’s new release and was thrilled when offered a review copy by the publisher.

Four orphans escape an abusive situation at a boarding school and set off on a river trip in a canoe bound for St Louis. The trip is not a leisurely one, as the authorities are hot on their trail. Along the way, they meet a variety of people, all trying to make their way in the world under trying circumstances. Some are good, some not so much, and some are somewhere in the middle. They all have lessons to teach as Odie, the main character, attempts to come to terms with his faith and God in a world he find unfair and where everything and everyone he loves is taken from him.

The author is a wonderful storyteller, the prose is beautiful, the characters well-developed and engaging, and the setting and time period of the Depression years were brought to life. But the story is a long one, my interest flagged and I found myself fighting the urge to skim. The book has gotten plenty of 5 stars reviews so take my review with a grain of salt. The two books mentioned in the blurb as comparisons were not books I enjoyed so it’s likely a case of being the right book, wrong reader. Many thanks to the author and Atria books for the opportunity to read this book for review.

Was this review helpful?

What a beautiful, enriching saga; I cannot say enough how fortunate I was to be selected to read this ARC. I. Loved. It—every word...every adventure...every impact it made on me. From the depths of my bounding heart: I loved it, for it was absolutely magnificent!! It will feed your soul, as you confirm in your mind that a family is not defined by blood, but rather who you choose to protect, love and to whom you pledge yourself. This family you create ensures you’re “never alone”.

In William Kent Krueger’s, “This Tender Land”, you will meet characters that will stay with you long after you’ve reached the last sentence of the epilogue. We begin by meeting orphan brothers Odie and Albert who are sent to The Lincoln Indian Training School in Minnesota in 1932 after the death of their father. The horrors that await them there are the reason why the central family comes to being. Odie and Albert soon build a family with Moses and Emmy and they all embark on this adventure, deciding to run away from the atrocities that are at the school. They leave via the Gilead River with the hopes of traveling to St Louis to begin a new life; their journey is nothing short of awe-inspiring.

I loved the language of this drama. The characters were richly developed and the pace was perfect. Filled with as much hope as sadness, it’s a lesson of kindness and love and family in which we all need reminders: We need each other and we need to be responsible for others.

Thank you to Netgalley, Atria Books, and William Kent Krueger for enriching my life and allowing me the opportunity to read this book in exchange for an honest review. On sale September 3, 2019.

Was this review helpful?

3.5 stars

There's a lot to like about "This Tender Land" --the writing is lovely and stories of children on the move during the Depression is always moving and brings Tom and Huck to mind. Author Krueger throws in a brutal Indian school in Minnesota, a traveling revival show and even a wicked witch.

Several things bothered me. The six-year-old girl is able do things that such a small child would not be able to do--she could help make a complete chicken dinner (with pie) but I doubt she could do so herself. Most of the other kids are skilled beyond their years and circumstances. If the children were a few years older, the story would feel more authentic, less simplistic.

This felt like a middle school novel, which is not necessarily a bad thing--there's a lot of quality stuff on those shelves. It would be interesting to hear the takes of children the same age in current time. on the journey of Odie and his friends. A history lesson, an engaging struggle in a difficult time, and characters who work to be true to themselves would be a strong addition to those reading lists.

Was this review helpful?

I’d give this one more than five stars if I could. I am a huge fan of Willian Kent Krueger and absolutely loved Ordinary Grace. I wasn’t sure anything could top it. Well, hard to say if this is better, but it’s equally as good. WKK is just such an amazing writer. He’s got it all, well turned phrases, engaging plot, characters that draw you in immediately and feel so real you’re convinced you’ve met them.

“Home is where the heart is.” And Odie, Albert, Moses and Emmy are all looking for their own versions of home. Odie, Albert and Moses are all orphans at the start of the book and never really had homes. Emmy loses her mother in a freak accident. When they’re all forced to flee, they take to the river. Told over the course of one summer, the book paints a perfect picture of the 1932 Midwest - farmers desperate to survive, faith healers, folks living in Hoovervilles.

This book tugs at your heart. I will admit to crying more than once. It deals with loss in so many forms, but also the faith to survive and move forward and the need to forgive. “Of all that we’re asked to give others in this life, the most difficult to offer may be forgiveness.”

This book seems destined to be a modern day classic. WKK cites Twain, Homer, Sinclair Lewis and Dickens as sources of inspiration. He has done an inordinate amount of research, which he outlines in his Author’s Note. But as he also states, “the river voyage upon which Odie O’Banion and his fellow Vagabonds embark in the summer of 1932 is a mythic journey.” Or as Odie says at the end of the book, “in every good tale there is a seed of truth, and from that seed a lovely story grows. Some of what I’ve told you is true and some...well, let’s just call it the bloom on the rose bush.” Run, don’t walk, to buy this one as soon as it becomes available. I truly can’t tout it enough.

A huge thank you to netgalley and Atria Books for an advance copy of this book.

Was this review helpful?

Another wonderful story from William Kent Krueger! This is a great adventure tale written about a time of many troubles in our past.

Was this review helpful?

This Tender Land invites obvious comparisons to Huckleberry Finn, with orphans piloting a canoe down the Mississippi while fleeing the law, but it really is more like Charles Dickens, if Dickens wrote in Depression era America. It contains all the hallmarks of a classic Dickens tale: An orphaned boy, living a tortured life in an orphanage with a cruel headmistress, prone to being locked in a basement with only a rat for company. Odie has only three friends in the world: his big brother Albert, a fellow orphan named Mose, an Indian boy found as an infant with his tongue ripped out and now forever mute, and Cora Frost, a sweet widowed teacher who is the sole example of goodness in a twisted adult world.

Odie’s terrible life takes an even darker turn; after a tornado literally turns the one good thing in his life upside down, and a dark night leads to a shocking act of violence, Odie is forced to flee the orphanage, along with Albert, Mose and Cora’s young daughter Emmy.

Accused of vicious crimes and hunted as kidnappers, the four kids make their way down the Mississippi through the heart of the country in the heart of the Depression. Along the way, they encounter criminals, Hooverville families, and, most memorably, a traveling faith caravan that may or may not be a huge sham.

There is much to like about this novel. The plot elements as I laid out above are strong and compelling, and Mr. Krueger is a thoughtful, precise writer, with a real sense of place. The river itself, and the plight of the kids making their way down it, is well crafted. Each orphan, of course, is searching for something: for a sense of identity, for home, for a place to belong. And the novel unfolds in a series of set pieces in their stops along the way.

Some of the set pieces work better than others; a supposed romantic interlude for Odie fell flat for me. And there were times in which the story, like the Mississippi itself, seemed to be drifting slowly, with no real purpose. There is not too much of a sense of escalation — instead it’s like a series of short stories, involving these characters. But some of the stories — especially the extended interlude with the faith caravan, and the tribe of believers (or scammers) who live in or follow that world — are really quite powerful.

The novel opens and closes with Odie, now a very old man, talking about the power of stories, including the story he is telling in the pages between. There is a late-breaking mystical element to the story, which didn’t work as well for me, but some might disagree. And when Odie talks about how you can tell a story in any way that you want, to create the ending you seek, it has a sweet kind of resonance.

Was this review helpful?

God Is A Tornado!
JUNE 26, 2019KERRINHP EDIT

This is my favorite book of 2019 (I know it’s only June, but this book will be hard to top as my favorite)
How special it is to find one of those rare and beautiful books that etches a place in your heart. This Tender Land is certainly one of those books for me. I have a feeling once released, it will be on the best seller list for quite a while. Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books, for my advanced reader copy. And thank you to the author, William Kent Krueger, for sharing your heart with this book.

The book starts with the narrator, Odie O’Bannion, looking back upon events from the great depression. He tells the reader to open themselves to every possibility, for there is nothing your heart can imagine that is not so. Then he promises a tale of killing, kidnapping, children pursued by demons (and a very persistent Black Witch), courage, cowardice, love, betrayal, and of course hope. And boy does he deliver a magical story!

It is an odyssey of four orphaned children who escape a horrible existence at an Indian School in Minnesota and try to travel via canoe to St. Louis, Missouri in 1932. Odie, along with his brother, their best friend Mose, rescue a young girl, Emmy, and take off with some stolen cash and a gun, knowing they will be chased by the law. As they follow the twists and turns of the great rivers they paddle, the four learn more and more about themselves. There are many well wishers, who always say to them “God be with you”. There are also several evil people, who shake their belief system entirely.

Odie O’Bannon, who was only 12 years old, tries to understand God, who had taken away his last hope of happiness with a tornado that killed Emmy’s mother who was his favorite teacher. He felt like at every corner of the journey the Tornado God had its ultimate purpose to deny the boy a happy ending. But as the journey continues, he realizes he can’t pin down God. The most important truth he learns is that when he yields to the river and embraces the journey that he finds peace. The other 3 children are also able to come to peace with their purpose, and to find a place they could call home.

On a scale of 1 to 5, I give this 10 stars. I really loved this book. It will be published on September 3, 2019. Be sure to add it to your “To Read List”!

Was this review helpful?

This is a book that is destined to be placed on a "keeper" shelf. I couldn't help feeling like I was slipping on a old sweater that was warm, comforting and enveloping. Krueger has written a coming of age tale of 4 Vagabond orphan children who make their escape from a horrible orphanage for Indian children though only one of them is Indian. They travel by canoe trying to escape the authorities, while meeting a cast of characters along the way. It is hard to put into words how special this book is. The characters are so well drawn, the grappling with G-d,family,injustice,forgiveness and discrimination permeate throughout the book and color the landscape. You want to hug these kids ,hold them tight, and never let them go. Thank goodness that we can revisit them again and again.

Was this review helpful?

Set during the summer of 1932, This Tender Land is a story that embraces tragedy and cruelty, kindness and love, murder and salvation. Most of all, it is about hope. Hope that we can find home, hope that we will find love, hope that life offers more than terror and injustice and cruelty. Hope that we can forgive and be forgiven.

This mythic story is a combination of Huckleberry Finn for its river journey and episodic adventures, with characters and events encountered from The Odyssey, and the darkness of The Night of the Hunter with children under threat fleeing downriver. And it recalls to mind the Book of Job as Odie grapples with the nature of God.

In 1932 Minnesota, orphaned brothers Albert and Odie are sent by their aunt to a Native American school, where she believes they are being well taken care of. The Brickmans run the school, siphoning off funds for themselves and allowing cruelty and abuse to reign. The boys befriend the mute Native American boy Mose. Albert and Mose are hard workers, but Odie rebels and is often punished. They have a friend in the teacher Voght, and the kind, widowed music teacher who offers to take the boys into her home to help run her farm. But a tornado takes her life, leaving her daughter Emmy in the hands of the cruel school headmistress.

The 'tornado god' wrecks more disaster in Odie's life, leading to an accidental death. The children together flee down the Mississippi River in a canoe, pursued by the headmistress of the school and the police who believes the girl Emmy was kidnapped.

William Kent Krueger writes, "I love this book every bit as much as I loved Ordinary Grace," and that offering this book he is "offering his heart." I, too, loved it every bit as Ordinary Grace, if not more.

It's a big 400-page book, engrossing and beautiful and heartbreaking. There is a lot of 'God talk' between Odie and the people he met who help him understand the timeless problem of why God allows evil in this world.

I was given access to a free egalley by the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for a fair and unbiased review.

Was this review helpful?

William Kent Krueger's follow up story to Ordinary Grace is outstanding and a true masterpiece of literary fiction.
I highly recommend this book..

Was this review helpful?

NO SPOILERS...

“This Tender Land”, is a mesmerizing tale with wonderful characters, rich themes, extraordinary storytelling, delicious writing....with dialogue that sprinkles gold nuggets in our hearts, gut, and mind.
A couple of times I thought: “Stand By Me” - meets “Deliverance”....meets Huckleberry Finn. It has those ‘type’ of a ‘feelings’.
I’m pleased as a pickle—to say this novel is every bit as good as “Ordinary Grace”...( another book by Krueger that’s one of my favorites).....
starting with a wonderful note to the readers by the author...to the very end....and the wonderful Epilogue.

The experience of having read this novel is pretty special. Its definitely one of the best books this year.,

Twelve year old Odie Banion, narrates the story. Albert, his brother, is four years older than Odie. We get to know these brothers well, as well as many other characters.
The heart of this story focuses on four children - [the Vegabonds]...
Mose and Emmy are the other children that are part of the gang.

There are so many great things to say about this book - the charm of the kids -
Odis’s gift for storytelling himself - his harmonica playing - (music gives him and others solace)....his grappling with God and religion. ( there are many scenes about God: believing or not)...
Themes of grief....loss of parents...coming of age...injustice/ abuse/ and cruelty....family, love, faith... hope....forgiveness...... sacrifice....racial inequality, economic hardships...self-identity...the basic understanding of human nature....
and kinship of protecting those we love.

I discovered symbolism & wisdom.....even from a little rat named “Faria”.....

So much to enjoy about the characters:
Alberta’s intelligence - and awareness-
Emmy’s sweetness and incredible wisdom for such a little girl - all of age six -
Mose who can’t verbally speak - rather speaks sign language ( the other children are also fluent in sign language)....

A rich mixture of adventure - tragedy- and healing......infused with transformative verities.

William Kent Krueger’s novel moves in a current - slow or as tumultuous as whitewater rapids.

ONCE IN A GREAT WHILE, A BOOK COMES ALONG THAT HAS SUCH WONDERFUL CHARACTERS AND MARVELOUS PROSE..... that we read it as much for the pure joy it offers on every page as to find out how it ends. THIS IS THAT BOOK!!!

Odie ...LOOKING BACK:
“From the height of a certain wisdom acquired across many decades, I looked down now on those four children traveling a meandering river whose end was unknown to them.
Even across the distance of time, I hurt for them and pray for them still. Our former selves are never dead”.


Thank You Netgalley, Atria Books, and William Kent Krueger

Was this review helpful?