Member Reviews

Starting from African elephants to underground ecosystems that support giant pando aspens of Utah to single-celled organisms like amoeba, Matthew D. LaPlante's Superlative takes the reader on a fascinating journey through mankind's ambition that is fueling research to understand and leverage the unexplored power of plant and animal kingdoms. Do elephants really have sharp memory and recall things from a quarter century ago? Can venom from snakes and other poisonous organisms like frogs and even plants be used to treat other diseases that affect humans (over and above being antidotes)? Could it be that octopuses are cleverer than humans? Is it a good idea to use genetically modified sterile mosquitoes to eradicate malaria-causing mosquitoes? Superlative is awfully informative about how far human beings have come to understand animals and plants around them by rounding up all the scientific advances in one neat immersive book (news flash: we have not come far enough to understand either plants or animals well enough.) Equally delightful are the footnotes in each chapter that reference to anything from scientific papers to magazine articles to episodes of NPR's all things considered and Radiolab.

Was this review helpful?

Well written and so interesting! I love some good science writing. Even us scientists like it when scientific information is clearly and interestingly expressed. This book brings back that sense of wonder of the world that you have as a little kid when everything is amazing. Tiny bats, intelligent slime mold, blue whales... it's all even more amazing than you know. The author also discusses how this knowledge gives us insights into our own abilities and natures, and how we can develop beneficial medicines or behaviors. I learned so many truly fascinating and funny things about the world, and about humans as well. I can't recommend it more.

Was this review helpful?

Fascinating book! I'm a big biology nerd so this was very interesting to me. The book describes extremes in the natural world, sort of like a Guiness Book of Records. Some topics could use a little more explanation. I study Biology so for me it was not too hard but for non-science educated people it can lack a little in information. The writing style was easy and entertaining.

Thank you publisher and NetGalley for the eARC.

Was this review helpful?

Sorry I did not get to read this one before it was archived. I will look out for it elsewhere.
Has to be over 100 characters long, I don't know how to rate it since I did not get to rad it.

Was this review helpful?

I really enjoyed this! It was a great primer on so much of what I love about the natural world. I work in conservation, and this does a good job at capturing how much conservation science and learning from other species really matters and why. I personally find the natural world inherently interesting, but I thought this book did a particularly good job of telling interesting stories and moving fluidly from topic to topic to keep it engaging. It’s about so much more than just superlative species and really about what we can learn from nature. Just because something doesn’t think or remember the way we do doesn’t mean it’s not intelligent, and there are still entire universes to be discovered in our own backyards. This book is a love letter to nature. Recommend!

Was this review helpful?

Superlative by Matthew D. LaPlante is a wonderful book about some of Mother Nature's extremes - about the biggest, fastest, smartest, smallest, deadliest beings. But it's a lot more than just a version of the Guinness Book of Records. The author explores the different definitions of said superlatives - after all, everything is relative, recent discoveries surrounding the species, and possible benefits for medicine and technology through further research.
The scientific explanations are easily understandable and the interspersed stories about LaPlante's life and travels make this book a highly enjoyable read.

Was this review helpful?

As a kid I loved browsing through Guinness Book of World Records, I could sit for hours at an end, just reading about the biggest bird, the toothiest animal and so on. Superlative brings back much of that same fascination, albeit for an older audience (obviously!). Matthew D. LaPlante writes in a humouristic and engaging manner, making me eager to read more. I am still as fascinated by the extremes in nature as I was as a kid and this book is all about that, but also what lessons we can learn from other animals, even how animal poison is directing us to cancer cures. The natural world is truly amazing and I hope one day we humans will truly learn to appreciate the diversity of the world we live in! All in all I absolutely loved this book and I´d recommend it to anyone who likes to read about natural history and evolution, it´s a thoroughly entertaining and thought provoking book.

I got an e-ARC of #superlative from the good people at #netgalley and the publisher in return for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Since childhood I was fascinated by science books that detailed animals especially weired ones deep inside sea and deep inside rainforest. This book encyclopaedia of such outliers- animals with something special Which no one can match in entire world.
.

As you start the book you get caught in interesting prose and narrative of the author; who makes you familiar with fastest, largest, smartest, most dangerous, oldest, strongest and most adaptable animals and plants.
.
.
Their are so many peculiar animals you will forget counting after few chapters and admire how much science gains from these outliers and how our future advances depend on many of rare capabilities of these animals.
.

I found chapter describing single cell intelligence which is helping us in development of AI and largest organism of world which is not animal as we assume it.
Also chapter on Tardigrades is so fascinating and these water bears are so resilient.
.
.
Writing is simple, storytelling style with very less jargon. Every chapter is a highlight and there is lot to learn from these discoveries and furthur discoveries that these organisms inspire.
.
Essential book for any curious teenager or adult who love to explore things around them with clearer vision and informed brain.
.
.
Next time when you are choosing a gift for bright cousin or son it will be a perfect gift.
.
Thanks netgalley and publisher for review copy.

Was this review helpful?

Definitely a good introduction, but maybe most enjoyable for readers who are kind of new to science nonfiction. Each of the sections was interesting and I can't think of any that I would want to cut, but I often wished for more information on the history or current status of research in a particular area, something more than just "___ may help scientists find a cure for ___." Appropriate for all public libraries.

Was this review helpful?

A fascinating book which examines biological superlatives such as the tallest, the smallest, the loudest, and many more. I learned a great deal from reading this book. The author presented the information in a way that was very accessible. I think of the extremes in biology differently since reading this book and appreciate them much more. I look forward to reading more books by this author!

Was this review helpful?

3,5* fascinated stars

This is definitely a book for all the people that like to marvel about newly acquired knowledge. I feel like I know am the master of many little "fun facts" and am more aware of the insights into our own biology nature's extremes offer us. It certainly enlarged my already pretty big regard for the wonders of this planet. I would not recommend reading this book in one sitting but rather enjoying it a chapter at a time.

To give a summary of what expects you, I will shortly name all the superlative elements of the book. No summary would do this book justice and also undermine the author's expertise. Extremes being the topic of this book, Author Matthew LaPlante moves from the enormously big to the teeny tiny things on this planet. I was very interested to learn more about cancer treatment/science in general, especially. After that, the ancient livings, as well as the fastest ones, are coming into focus. We also learn about the importance of accurate reading and strength. The ending is formed by the deadliest and the smartest to illustrate how much knowledge these superlatives have to offer and what we can learn from them.

Personally, I favour the chapter on deadly stuff, especially since most people would never think of a mosquito at first but rather some kind of mammal predators (or humans, if they're being very smart). Nobody realizes that it can be tiny organisms that infiltrate your system and kill you much quicker than you'd think possible. Matthew finishes with an encouraging conclusion that wants each and every one of us to go through the world with a more open eye to discover what new extreme might lie around the corner. The author certainly sparked a lot of fascination and interest within me but I also had some issues.

Two things I want to caution the reader about is:
A. I feel like my education as geographer has certainly helped with understanding and following most of the contents and argumentation lines but I felt left behind at some points. Especially books like this which have the potential to ignite a passion for protecting this planet in a less aggressive way need to be down to earth.

B. There were an awful lot of questions Matthew brought my attention to, but I was missing answers almost just as many times. Obviously, this is no dissertation that gives the newest research results but the lack of answers made reading this book feel like a labyrinth with an awful lot of dead ends. Every time you think the way leads somewhere, the case is dropped.

Still, it is a very good reading to spark interest in certain topics and maybe find out more about them on your own. So, if you excuse me, I have to read more about how plants affect different organisms (human, mammal, etc.) differently.

Was this review helpful?

I thoroughly enjoyed this book by Matthew D LaPlante, kindly provided to me by the publisher via NetGalley. As a work of popular science I found it to be well researched and clearly written in a way that is easily understandable to the layperson. The world of nature is truly a fascinating one, and by focusing on its extremes LaPlante is able to both educate and entertain the reader. I loved how he was able to relate seemingly diverse topics, for example how understanding the biology and ecology of the worlds oldest tree may provide valuable information about climate change, or how studying the biology of long living animals may lead to breakthroughs in cancer research. Throughout the book, the author clearly demonstrates how all the parts of the natural world, from the smallest to the largest, are interlinked and all are valuable and worthy of our respect and study.. I loved the conversational tone, and the fact that the subject was clearly personal to the author. His genuine interest in the topic shines through in each anecdote and brings the subject to life.

Was this review helpful?

If I am being perfectly honest, I requested a copy of this book to fulfil the self imposed criteria of reading something in the Non-fiction genre and not get stuck in any specific sub-genre of fiction. I was rewarded for doing so. 

I did not realise how refreshing it would be read and/or discuss the topics in this book. It contains a lot of facts, this may seem to be a form of overload so I suggest taking it in, in chunks, one section or superlative quality at a time. The best part of all the facts in this pages is that they are new, the latest updates to them are as late as 2018. This is something unique for someone (me) who does not actually go out of the way to keep up with general discoveries or discussions in the natural or scientific world. The author clearly shows us how fascinated he is by the concepts that he shares with us and the immense, under-researched potential that is hidden within it and why. It is not meant for one sitting but it is meant for someone with a semblance of interest in the world around us and the power of genetic study and what research in it can throw our way. The Latin names of the species threw me off my pace but after a while I stopped trying to spell it right in my head and kept going. There is nothing conclusive in the chapters, as my usage of under-researched would indicate but there is still time.

Every section of superlative quality tackled here from largest, smallest to oldest etc and how each quality is defined (with some debates on the part of 'proper' definitions) can spike many conversations. I might even hope that for someone who is in the field or heading that way , this collection might spark something. I cannot speak for them since I neither work nor have studied anything biology related after high school level, but I can speak for someone with a healthy dose of appreciation for life in itself. I think when I go on my next buying spree, this book will be on my list.

Was this review helpful?

Great look at extremes in biology

I loved this book - it is science writing done well. Matthew D. LaPlante writes with a conversational tone and a good sense of humor. There is a lot of science in the book, but LaPlante makes it all easily accessible. If the reader is familiar with biology, as I am, the way the story is crafted makes this book well worth reading. If the reader is not familiar with biology, it won’t matter because everything is well explained. I recommend this book for anyone interested in biology.

Was this review helpful?

Superlative is really just a book with a bunch of nature facts. I found some of the featured animals/plants more interesting than others, but it was thoroughly researched and well written. I enjoyed LaPlante's humour and his personal involvement with the species he looks into. One thing that I was a bit disappointed in was that a lot of superlative traits mentioned in the book haven't actually been used for further research, so a lot of times the section ends with something like "this trait is superlative and maybe if we research more into it, we can learn something or do something". I guess I was hoping for more examples of how superlative traits have been used for human applications or what current applications are in the works because of superlative discoveries and not just the possibility. The number of species and the diversity of traits covered is quite extensive, so I do appreciate how there is a lot of potential in these animals and plants.

Was this review helpful?

Superlative is a nicely written book about animal extremes and what studying these animals can offer us in terms of knowledge, technological innovations and medical advances. LaPlante takes a look at a variaty of organisms - the fastest, tallest, largest, loudest, smallest, oldest, toughest, slowest, most venomous, most poisonous, and the smartest etc. While the author's fascination with superlative animals and plants is clearly evident, so is his (and this readers) frustration with the lack of interest science shows in these organisms. While this book isn't terribly indepth, it does provide a delightful survey of a variety of creatures, some well-known and some more obscure, as well as how the study of these superlative organisms can benefit humans in a variety of ways - everything from climate change research and indicators (frogs and clams), to genetics and cancer treatments (elephants), new drugs (spiders, snakes, jellyfish), technological advances (moths, bats, mites and whales), bioindicators (frogs), regeneration of lost limbs (Axolotl), aging, etc. The conversational style of the book makes it easy to understand. The occassional humour is amusing and not at all cringe-worthy. The extensive reference section provides a list of sources if the reader would like additional information about a particular study or topic.

Was this review helpful?

Superlative follows its title expertly, detailing the many species and biological marvels that fall within the extremes of their respective genera. It’s a fascinating book written in a down-to-earth style that’s filled with the excitement and wonder of a scientist’s inner child. At the end, you’ll understand how amazing the world truly is and how much these extreme creatures can help us understand about the world.

LaPlante takes us all over the globe, detailing his many strange journeys to collect information on these extreme creatures. We see him attempting to shovel poop in the wake of a giant whale. We see him searching for elephants deep in Africa. The most interesting aspect is the many conversations he has with experts of every scientific branch. Frog experts, microbiologists, tree scientists. Anything you could want to know about the extremes of the world is collected here.

These are the animals that so fascinated us as kids. Elephants, giraffes, blue whales. Their size alone makes them fascinating to the world at large. LaPlante digs deeper, looking at the many marvelous discoveries made possible by studying them closely. You’d be amazed at what you could learn from the poop and snot of a whale, or from the cutest animal you’ve never seen, the Etruscan shrew. You’ll discover many species you weren’t aware of as you get deeper in the book, looking at land speed, loud noises, age, strength and intelligence. Think of this as a Guinness World Record book of sorts. The difference lies in the fact that these creatures were already record-breaking without knowing it.

Overall, Superlative is an exceptional book that’s easy-to-read and easy to obsess over. You’ll learn so much about things you’ve never thought of and it just might spark a deeper interest in the planet.

Review will be published on April 30: https://reviewsandrobots.com/2019/04/30/superlative-book-review

Was this review helpful?

This amazing book is a love letter to the fabulous diversity of nature, and to hardiness of living organisms in general. Life really does find a way. From the three toed sloth to the cheetah, from the African elephant to the hummingbird, the author shares his wonder and passion for nature, natural selection strategies and genetics, as well as his frustration that we are losing so many amazing creatures and plants a year without even noticing or realising how they are so good at what they do. This book is beautiful and intelligent, sufficiently scientific for an ex geneticist like me but still accessible to anyone with an interest. This book truly is superlative.

Was this review helpful?

Matthew LaPlante’s Superlative is an homage to the Guinness Book of Records, natural edition. He admits everyone loves record setters, including if not especially him. And he is a lover of things natural. As a journalist, he says he pestered his editor until he was allowed to cover the zoo. The book is a best of, featuring what animals and plants do that Man can only drool over.

LaPlante has put a lot of passion into the book. He seems to have met pretty much every animal and plant he describes, from his visits with scientists and their labs, to field trips all over the planet. It is a labor of love as much as appreciation and awe. The most interesting aspects are the whys. Why is this the loudest, the biggest, the tallest, the smallest, the fastest runner/swimmer/flier? What is its advantage? Why does this being have this ability at all?

Elephants rank very highly in his schema. Elephants and Man share a cancer-fighting gene called p53. In Man it surrounds the mutated and mutating cancer cells, and fails to stop them. In elephants, which have 20 copies of p53, it tells the cells to die. So elephants are not cancer-prone. This commanded cell death is called apoptosis, and we see it in Man when the brain tells mitochondria to die when the energy they produce is no longer needed by aging bodies. Not a helpful option. Elephants are also emotional animals, traumatized for life by Man’s killing of their mothers in order to capture them for zoos. And true to the myth, they have phenomenal memories, which LaPlante proves.

The world’s largest tree is also its largest living thing. It’s a 107-acre Quaking Aspen in Utah. Quaking aspens spread underground, and all the shoots – what look to be a simple forest – are all attached to the same root, and are of course genetically identical. Now called Pando, the tree has 47,000 shoots. And it might be 800,000 years old (though some say “only” 80,000), making it by far the oldest living being as well. It’s a very interesting survival strategy: no flowers, no seeds, no fruit. Just root expansion. Very risky, but on planet Earth, there is no end to lifeforms and strategies.

Possibly the toughest beast on Earth is the tardigrade, aka water bear. It is a millimeter and a half sort of caterpillar with eight feet. It can be frozen, boiled, dehydrated and irradiated and still come back for more. We have only begun to classify the varieties of tardigrade we see worldwide. He says they are found from the highest mountains to the deepest ocean trenches. They’re the toughest, most resilient life we know of. They not only have impressive genes, they lack the genes that cause inflammation and pain. Their genes have the potential to change our lives forever.

Appropriating genes might mean Man could travel between planets without suffering the effects of unfiltered radiation bombardment. Or even just surviving the expected new temperature ranges up to 200 degrees Fahrenheit on Earth. LaPlante teases us with the genetic uniqueness of numerous superlative performers throughout the book and what it could mean for Man.

The octopus is the first/oldest intelligent being. Able to analyze its environment, measure up other beings in the area, strategize, escape, learn and make intelligent decisions, it has just two years of life to maximize its abilities. This once shell-protected smart snail is totally unprotected and vulnerable, and must live by its wits alone. The central brain acts as a quarterback, LaPlante says, and the remote brains controlling each of the eight arms do whatever they need to do to execute, which is why they seem to be all over the place, never moving in co-ordination. This distributed hierarchy system is now being applied to co-coordinating thousands of drones at a time.

The slowest animal in the world is the three toed sloth, which burns all of a hundred calories a day – a teaspoon of peanut butter would sustain it.

There are moths that can hear up to 300khz (humans stop at about 20, dogs at 40), far above the echolocation of today’s bats that seek them out.

Of interest is LaPlante’s frustration in doing research for this book. There is hardly any. Many of the animals he profiles were the subject of no scientific studies whatsoever. On others, the research is, to be polite, thin. In the meantime, they are disappearing, and we haven’t even figured out why they are so good at what they do, or how we could benefit from them. Doesn’t seem to stop anyone.

David Wineberg

Was this review helpful?