Member Reviews
I adore Elizabeth Byler Younts (her THE SOLACE OF WATER was one of the best books I read last year), so it's no surprise that I loved her newest, THE BRIGHT UNKNOWN. With its grim asylum setting, the novel is heartbreaking at times. It's also surprisingly hopeful, although never in a cheesy way. Brighton and Angel are sympathetic, brave, and so vulnerable it's impossible not to root for them. The rest of Younts' story people are unique, intriguing, and (mostly) lovable. Despite some violence and disturbing subject matter, THE BRIGHT UNKNOWN remains a PG (maybe PG-13?) read. It's not always an easy book to read, but in the end, it's a satisfying, uplifting, even faith-promoting read that's engrossing, realistic, and not sappy in the least. Have I mentioned how much I loved it?
This book was hard to read. While I wanted to know what happened, the horror of it kept me from just devouring it. Elizabeth made a comment in the acknowledgements that made me think it is a book based on a true story perhaps.
Mental health was treated terribly in the early 1900s. Anything that made you different: blindness, deafness, depression, schizophrenia, etc. landed you in a mental hospital. The care you received was awful at best. A mental hospital like that is where this story takes place. Even though it is told in first person and that person is obviously out of the hospital now, the horrors she experienced as the daughter of an "insane" person were awful at best.
Brighton is the main character of the story and she is 65 now, but there are flashbacks of her life in the hospital. It is hard to imagine anything like that actually happening today with the advances in understanding of mental health issues, but back in the early 1900s very little was understood about mental health and you were just deemed weird and insane.
"All the darkness in the world cannot extinguish the light of a single candle. " St Francis
"There was so much pain then, but there was always a light in our path to keep us from giving up."
I received the book from Thomas Nelson via NetGalley and was not required to write a positive review. All opinions expressed are my own.
This was a sad but also hopeful story, I especially loved how things wrapped up in the end. Very enjoyable.
Haunting and unexpected plot with two characters that will stay with you long after you read this book. Writing is beautiful and invokes mental imagery that makes the story come to life.
I thought this was such a great and powerful story. I love how this is a duel timeline where we follow Brighton and Neil two of the same woman who has two different stories. Brighton was a child who was raised in an asylum along with her mother where she was cared for by a nurse up until she was 18. There she makes friends with Angel who was left there because he is different and later Grace a girl from the outside world who should not be there. And then we have Neil a woman who all grown and married with grown children when she received a package of negatives she had taken during the time at the asylum. Now Neil must make a decision to either forget her past. How she lived as a child and then escaped to a world she knew nothing about and trying to find her new home. I think this is a powerful about during a time where there is a lot of horror in asylums and people nurses, doctors, and the people who left their family members there.
I have to say that while this was a good and enjoyable read it was also a tear-jerker. So I do recommend you read it but I also suggest having tissues handy.
The Bright Unknown
By Elizabeth Byler Younts
Brighton Friedrich has only known the Riverside Home for the Insane, born in the asylum she can never leave - it's the law. She's not a patient but most definitely a prisoner and in someways a pet to a few of the nurses. Brighton knows all too well the pain and misery that lives in this place that offers to heal but in fact, does more harm than anything.
More than 50 years have passed and the girl she once was has been pushed into the hidden recesses of her mind until she receives a package from someone named Kelly Keene. The old memories come back and she is faced with a choice - allow Brighton to resurface or keep her forever locked away.
The Bright Unknown is a book well worth reading but at the same time it hurts the soul as one experiences what Brighton went through when she was in Riverside. The very means that were used to subdue and restrain are just so inhumane and when one thinks that this occurred in the 1930s and 1940s it is almost unbelievable that we claimed to be a civilized society and wanted to force our civilized ways on others.
This book is told in memories so it is not presented in a linear chronology so the reader will need to note at the beginning of each chapter the year. But this is more than a life imprisoned as Brighton manages to get the one thing she always wanted a life outside. But when you have never experienced what lies beyond freedom can be almost as frightening as the pain and grief that she had always seen. This is a story of perseverance and the strength that the right friend can give when you most need it. The Bright Unknown gave Brighton what she needed - a dream of the life she and her mother might have had, a dream of a future that was beyond the known. This is a story of the triumph and endurance of the human spirit. Would make an excellent book club selection.
I was provided a complimentary copy of this book with no expectations but that I provide honest opinion all thoughts expressed are my own.
Taking place in rural Pennsylvania , which is where I live this book caught my eye. I enjoy reading about the struggles people go through in asylums too so I knew this would be a perfect fit for me.
This was a quick read for me one I started it I could hardly put it down.
I went through a real mixed bag of emotions reading it anger,wonder,feeling pain for the characters,happiness,heartbreak and truly wondering how humans could treat each other in such a manner.
This book is bold,bright,beautiful,gritty and not afraid to explore past history in a way that makes this story stick with you. Unforgettable a true must read!
Thank you Elizabeth Byler Younts for a phenomenal story!
Published October 22nd 2019 by Thomas Nelson
I was given a complimentary copy of this book. Thank you.
All opinions expressed are my own.
Elizabeth Byler Younts is an author whose abilities to provide a strong sense of place along with well developed characters is unparalleled. This is a story whose theme should be noticed -- what has happened to you is an experience, not a life sentence. This is explored beautifully in this book. Wonderful!
The Bright Unknown by Elizabeth Byler Younts is a rare gem, a masterpiece of lyrical writing, rich characterization, sublime storytelling, emotion and hope. I was about to give up on ever finding a novel of this high quality in the Christian fiction genre. It’s not an easy read nor a fast one, but rather a compelling read that begs to be experienced. Kindness, caring, and innocence are contrasted with ignorance and greed. With a timeless relevancy, it forces us to examine the way we perceive those who are different, to see beyond the diagnosis. My mind, heart and emotions were captured with the first sentence and never wavered.
The Bright Unknown is Brighton’s story, a young girl born and raised at the Riverside Home for the Insane in the 1940s era. Life there was all she had known and was therefore normal, until suddenly it wasn’t – all because of a girl named Grace. Brighton’s friendship with another resident, who she named Angel, is priceless. The plight of the patients is hard to read, for in a time when ignorance abounded regarding mental illness, some were there simply because their families wanted them committed.
One strength of this story is the author’s exquisite prose and I savored every word and nuance of expression. This is just one example … “The flowering weeping willow’s boughs reached for me in the summery breath. It called out to me. Come to me. Let my delicate white tears fall over you. I extended my hand, even though I knew the branches were too far away to let their beauty cry over me.”
The Bright Unknown may seem like a dark story – and it is – but themes of hope, forgiveness and redemption are woven throughout. The conclusion is so very satisfying. The writing of Elizabeth Byler Younts is not to be missed, and The Bright Unknown goes on my “best of the best” list.
Very highly recommended.
I received a copy of this book through JustRead Tours and Thomas Nelson. The opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
The cover of this book drew me right away and than the back of the book told me I would need to read this. I wasn't prepared for the ride this book took me on.
Brighton was born into an insane asylum. She knows no other life. The story captures her life and shows us the inside workings of 1920's asylums. How people can do some of those things to others has always been beyond my imagination. Brighton drew me in and I wanted nothing more to hug her, rescue her and take her home. She was broken but never destroyed. It is so sad that people who didn't speak English, had anxiety or postpartum depression were sent to these places. They were not given care. This has always been something I have never understood.
Angel was left on the steps of the asylum because of the color of his skin. People assumed so much just because of the way he looked. I loved the friendship between Angel and Brighton. I could go on and on about these two. They cared for each other and in all honesty kept each other for going insane.
Though this book was difficult to read at times I couldn't put it down and I will always carry a piece of it in my heart forever. This is a book that will draw you in and won't let you go. When it is over you actually will be sad because you are so attached to the characters in this book.
If I could give 10 stars I would because it was simply incredible. I highly recommend everyone to read it.
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
A heartbreakingly poignant story of friendship, resilience, survival, courage and hope.
Brighton Friedrich has never known a life beyond the walls of the Riverside Home, an asylum for the insane and unwanted. She was born there, where her mother is a patient. She makes friends among the patients, bonding with a beautiful boy affected by albinism, whom she names Angel, and a girl abandoned by her parents named Grace.
She and her friends makes plans to escape the asylum, for a chance at life on the outside. But are she and Angel ready to face the challenges and dangers of a world they have never experienced?
Told through the eyes of Brighton, rolling forward and back in time through the years as she remembers the painful years in the asylum as well as the friends, betrayals and struggle for survival. Beautifully written this book took me captive, as I sympathized with Brighton's horrible plight, clinging to piece after piece of shattered hope.
Secrets are revealed as the time rolls forward and back, yet there are many surprises and twists along the way. I love how the author was able to write such complex and developed characters, no one was all good or all bad, and I loved the challenge of accepting each of them as they were.
Overall, a poignant and heartbreaking read that at times was hard to continue, yet the gimmers of hope kept me holding on along with Brighton. Filled with hope, in even the most stark of places, this is a heartfelt read that you won't soon forget, well worth the read!
I received a complimentary copy of this book. Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
What a fascinating novel! Elizabeth Byler Younts has written a powerfully moving story about a young girl raised as the only child in an adult insane asylum.
The story travels two timelines - 1937 and 1990 as the protagonist Brighton Friedrich comes to grips with the horrors of never really knowing who you are. Sharing a room with a mentally disabled mother and being raised for a caring nurse named Rose create a life that no one should be forced to endure.
Lies and secrets make escape even more treacherous for Brighton and her friend Angel, an albino boy with vague memories of a once loving family. Friendships made - and lost - leave lasting marks and the pair try to secure a future built on a crumbly foundation.
Grab a couple boxes of tissues because you will need them.
I received an ARC of this book through NetGalley in exchange for my unbiased opinion.
Brighton was raised in an asylum after her mother gave birth to her there. She knows her existence is different than most people's and wonders about life outside the asylum. Her only friend there is a boy she calls Angel; his parents left him in the children's side of the asylum because he is albino. The two plan an escape and then realize they have no idea what to do out in the real world. They hope to find a home of their own.
I felt horrible about the things the residents of the asylum had to endure, but I never fully connected with the characters of this book. There was a “surprise” twist at the end that I saw from almost the beginning. It's not a bad story, just not one of my favorites of the year.
Elizabeth Byler Younts captured my heart in the saddest way in her novel, The Bright Unknown. I was so moved by the painful childhoods of Brighton (aka Nell) and Angel. As we traveled through their life, I loved seeing the redemption that took place... but the unimaginable pain they experienced as a result of a childhood in an asylum was awful to read and consider. I will definitely read more by this author in the future! The ending was perfect.
A heartbreaking story of survival and friendship comes to life in author Elizabeth Byler Younts novel, The Bright Unknonw. Although Younts has written a fiction story, she brings to life the horrific circumstances of a variety of types of people, those who really need to be there and those that do not, living inside an insane asylum. It is a beautifully and powerfully written story that is both depressing and enlightening. Younts tackles a hard subject matter with beautiful efficiency. This novel is not for the faint of heart. It’s hard, and wonderful, and emotional, and a story that will leave readers thinking about it long after they turn the last page.
Genre: historical, Christian
Publisher: Thomas Nelson
Publication date: October 22, 2019
Number of pages: 368
Pennsylvania, 1937, and all fourteen-year-old Brighton Friedrich has ever known is life at the Riverside Home for the Insane. She was born there to a mother experiencing severe paranoia and psychosis, and knows nothing else. She has a best friend (a boy sent to the asylum because of his albinism) who she names Angel, and a handful of medical staff who treat her with kindness.
As Brighton grows and it becomes more and more apparent that she may never be allowed leave Riverside, she becomes determined to get out of there and take her friends with her. But even if she did leave, how could she survive in a world she knows nothing about? If she could run, who would she run to?
We've all seen those memes shared around social media with the reasons why women were institutionalised in the 18th & 19th (and more than likely the 20th) centuries. Reasons varying from "hysteria" to "imagined female trouble" and "immoral life". These were very, very real women, subjected to treatments like electro shock therapy, lobotomy, sterilization - all because they didn't fit in with society in some way. While this isn't a true story in that Brighton isn't a real life person, this DID happen to people. Regularly.
This isn't a pleasant read, but it's a part of history that we should be reminded of. And it's a reminder that no matter how bad things can be, hope is one thing that can never, ever be taken away from anyone.
A touching novel set on two timelines, one in 1990 and one back in 1937-1941. Brighton was born in an asylum because her mom was a patient there. She knew know other life and thought it was normal to live and grow up there. It was sad. She saw all the terrible treatment of people who were put there for medical reasons or other completely invalid reasons that made sense at all. Her best friend didn't even have a name so she gave him one. Her other friend was there for being in love with the wrong person and was sadly forced to undergo sterilization and a lobotomy. The terrors of the treatment and the ignorance of people with mental disorders in this time period is absolutely horrifying to read about. Well-written with hope and forgiveness weaved throughout this very difficult story. Amazing read!! Thanks to NG for the ARC!!!
Heart-wrenching. That is the best way I can think to describe this incredible tale. I am so glad that I decided to read this story. It's plot line is so engrossed in the asylum world, you'll feel you're watching it take place. Brighton and Angel are such fantastic lead characters, their stories will drag you into their reality. This haunting story will open your eyes to the harshness of insane asylum's of the past, but also fill you with the joy that there is hope even in the darkest of situations!
I received of complimentary copy of this story through NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
The Bright Unknown is one of the most thought-provoking novels I've read. Elizabeth Byler Younts draws the reader deeply into the unconventional (to say the least) life of Brighton, raised entirely behind the walls of an early 2oth-century mental institution. Through beautiful and reflective prose and a steady story progression, she builds empathy for not only Brighton and her albino friend Angel, but for the patients and the sometimes-villainous staff as well.
But things go from bad to worse when Brighton and Angel gain their freedom, embarking on a journey into an unknown that's more dimly lit than bright. But always, there is a spark of hope.
That's the hallmark of the novel - a glimmer of hope, a glimmer of the light of Christ, however small, however unevenly it shines. It's a glimmer here and there from a friend, an aide, a relative, or a stranger, that finally delivers Brighton to freedom.
The author also shines a light on real historical injustice that may be hard to reconcile, but which should nevertheless be faced.
A stellar read you should not miss.