Member Reviews

This book was an intense read. Reminds me of a John Saul novel. Horror at its finest. It was hard to put down and when I did I found the characters remained in my mind till I could come back to the story. Very haunting

Was this review helpful?

Wow! I just finished reading "Imaginary Friend". This is one of the scariest books I have read in terms of nightmarish imagery. It involves a young boy named
Christopher who struggles in school. His Dad recently died and his mom is trying everything she can to make a better life for them. Christopher follows a voice out into the woods that sets a plan in motion that will affect everyone in the town. Hold on because you are in for a scary ride. The book has symbolism throughout and an ending that makes you go hmmmm. I enjoyed the book as fiction, not trying to line it up with Christian theology or my personal beliefs. It will be a great thriller to read and recommend for your Fall reading.

Was this review helpful?

Pub date October 1, 2019.
A very ambitious foray into horror from the author of THE PERKS OF BEING A WALLFLOWER. I was VERY into this in the first quarter of the book, I initially got Joe Hill vibes! The set up was suspenseful and exciting and the characters were rich and likeable. As the book moved forward, it completely unraveled for me. At 720 pages it's not an easy read, but there's a ton of potential here. I hope he writes more in this genre.
Thank you to NetGalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.

Was this review helpful?

Imaginary Friend by Stephen Chbosky was one of my most anticipated books of the year, as The Perks of Being a Wallflower is one of my all time favorite books. Unfortunately, this book really missed the mark for me.

What I liked:
The characters were well developed in the beginning of the story, prior to the horror aspect beginning, so I cared about Christopher and his struggles in school. I rooted for his mother to get back on her feet.

What I Didn't Like:
This book was extremely long and drawn out, with 720 pages. The story started out interesting, but it became so drawn out and repetitive that I frequently found myself bored. I can't even count the number of times I read about kids peeing their pants, getting bloody noses, or the descriptions of the steps into the treehouse "like baby teeth". This book also had a strong ties to religion, which I was not aware of going in to the book, and was not a fan of.

I previously loved Stephen Chbosky's style of writing, but this book read nothing like The Perks of Being a Wallflower and was overly drawn out. As a fan of thrillers, I may have enjoyed this book if it were half the length.

Was this review helpful?

When I first read the description for IMAGINARY FRIEND I became quite excited and developed high expectations. Initially I found the novel compelling, but the farther I read the more unsettling it became. Once I began the "final night" in the ongoing battle of Good vs. Evil, I thought that this section and time period endured too long; perhaps even the last quarter or so, if trimmed, would improve the quality of the novel. Also one particular secondary character's continuing plot thread ended with what I considered unrealistic and highly unlikely character evolution (three characters all unedergoing 180-degree reversals). However, the conclusion of that plot thread seems to dangle the potential of a sequel, starring that particular secondary character.


The two protagonists (five decades apart) are seven-year-olds. However, in no way is this a story for children. Sensitive readers: torture, gore, SERIOUS abuse issues (to adults and to children) are ongoing throughout, and some of the violence is extreme and stomach-churning.

Was this review helpful?

Overall, I enjoyed this book. I'm a fan of literary horror, and I loved Perks of Being a Wallflower, so why not try this book?? I really loved the beginning, but something about the way we got to the story was off for me. It was reminiscent of Stephen King, and not in a terribly good way. If you like horror, give it a try. Maybe you'll enjoy it more than I did!

Was this review helpful?

Thank you Netgalley and Grand Central Publishing for gifting me an E-ARC in exchange of an honest review.

I give this book a 2.5 out of 5 Stars.

First off, I appreciate the ending, I think it was a really great concept, and the way things unraveled, albeit very weird, it was very unique. As far as what I didn’t like, it was far too long, and far to slow paced for my liking. (In my opinion) I think this book could have been about 300 pages, and it would have been the perfect length. As my friend Savannah has said, “I can only read about peeing pants, and bloody noses so much” I’d have to say I agree. But everything else that I didn’t enjoy about this book, I cannot speak of, because it’s would ruin everything. I appreciate what the Author tried to accomplish with this book, and the message he is trying to convey. It’s just not for me.

I’ve read this will be a great book for fans of NOS4A2 Fans, and since I didn’t read that book, I cannot compare. I am so sad I didn’t love this book, as The Perks Of Being A Wallflower is one of my favorite books of all-time. But I do understand that this time Chbosky was targeting a different audience this time. I will say, Chbosky’s creative mind shows through in this book and his writing. This was an insanely WEIRD book, and it took someone very unique to put write it.

Was this review helpful?

Christopher Reese and his mom Kate haven't had an easy life since Christopher's father's suicide.  They're in debt and now Kate has gathered up her son and a few belongings to escape an abusive relationship.
They stop in a small town called Mill Grove, Pennsylvania and Kate feels she's found a safe place for her and her son where they won't be found.

Chistopher's never been a great student due to a reading disability, he worries about his mom a lot, and he's bullied regularly.  
Christopher vanishes for six days before emerging from the woods, seemingly unharmed.  Suddenly life takes an unexpected turn for Christopher and his mom.  They win the lottery and are able to purchase their own home and climb out of debt.  Christopher begins doing well in school and even has a small group of friends.
But then there's the nice man who wants to protect him from the hissing lady in his nightmares and the voice telling him he has to build a treehouse in the woods by Christmas.

As the holiday looms large, everyone in Mill Grove seems to be losing their minds.  Voices are telling everyone to prepare for a war and Christopher knows it's up to him to win the war and save the town from the nightmare.

My main issues with this book:  Christopher is seven-years-old.  This is a horror novel, obviously I'm going to suspend my disbelief for entertainment purposes, but I have a six-year-old of my own and couldn't wrap my mind around this kid and his friends being only seven.  His thoughts and actions (even before he vanished) made me imagine him to be older so that when childish thoughts or activities were mentioned, it felt awkward and out of place.
Then there's the repetition.  There are several descriptive phrases used multiple times, from the appearance of the treehouse steps being called baby teeth to the cloud that hangs around town being an all-seeing eye.  I mean, I get it, it's symbolic, let's keep this story moving forward.
I didn't feel like this book came together until the last quarter, which makes it a bit underwhelming.

What I liked about this book:  Chbosky carefully crafts his story by following several characters whose fates are all linked.  It's the tried and true formula for master of horror Stephen King and it was successful here, switching perspectives to advance the story.  
I loved the relationship between Christopher and Kate; it was so genuine and I certainly identified with Kate as a mother!
The creep-factor on this book was a slow burn.  There wasn't much in the beginning but by the end I had serious goosebumps.

Overall, I liked this story.  It tackles the heavy subject of good vs. evil with Biblical symbolism and looks at the way people deal with personal sin.  It's obvious Chbosky took great care in every detail of the plot and the relationships between characters with definite inspiration from Stephen King.

It was a loooong set up to get to the heart of the book.  Page count doesn't intimidate me and never factors in to my decision to read a book but in my opinion there were several scenes/chapters that could've been removed or edited down to the benefit the story.

If you love stories about kids fighting evil with sinister creepy old school Stephen King horror vibes, Imaginary Friend is worth checking out.

Huge thanks to Grand Central Publishing and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC in exchange for my honest review.  Imaginary Friend is scheduled for release on October 1, 2019.

Was this review helpful?

Wayyyyyy too long. It started out so strong too. So so creepy in the best way but then it began to drag. It needed to be about 300-400 pages shorter.

Was this review helpful?

I'll be first to admit that I never read horror, nor do I have the interest, but I wanted to give Stephen Chbosky a try just because he was an iconic author of my teenage years. But this..... wasn't it. Even from the objective perspective of someone not into horror, especially paranormal/fantastical horror, this was a longwinded mess.

This book started out strong to trick you to read on, but the ending was catastrophically terrible. The first 25% is basically what the synopsis describes, and then afterward, the story truly begins. Let me reiterate that this book is 700 pages long and the first quarter of the book is just exposition. From 25% to 75%, this book actually had a lot of good parts. It kept me guessing, it had twists and turns, it had a few creepy partys. But then the ending just became overwritten, incomprehensible plot divided between two worlds and between a cast of 10 characters. The writing was average at best throughout the book, but the end of the book just became totally ridiculous with all the characters screaming LIKE THIS!!!! at each other multiple times a page, aNd ThE viLLaiN oF thE boOk tAlkS liKe tHis. I skim read the last 10% just in search of answers, but this book provided none. I have no idea what the conflict of the book was and why any of the villains were wreaking havoc on the world. The main plot twist at the end just made the entire situation more confusing and everything got so muddled in the end that it's making me regret spending TWO WEEKS reading this massive book only for it to be so completely a let down because the plot doesn't actually get resolved in a way that makes sense. Chbosky just kept on dragging the conflict out even though he could have ended everything 500 pages earlier, with SO much unnecessary inner monologue that dragged out the pace even more.

Maybe if you like fantastical thrillers with religious/spiritual undertones you would enjoy this more, but in my opinion, just save your time and read Stephen King or something.

Was this review helpful?

"I can't tell...
I can't tell... you what is happening, Mom.
It would...
It would... terrify you."

This book is insane. It went in a direction towards that end that I would describe as [ pretty overtly religious / Christian but even as someone who doesn't really care for that stuff I was still entranced by this novel. It is about 700 pages and I raced through it in 4 days. Really amazing stuff. And it was truly scary, which I can't say for many books. That being said, does any book need to be 700+ pages? No. Could have lost about 150 pages and still been great. Either way, it was a fantastic ride from an author I've been obsessed with since Perks of Being a Wallflower. Highly recommend for horror fans looking for a character-focused story.

Was this review helpful?

Anyone who read Perks of Being A Wallflower and loved it as much as I did, be warned, this is full-tilt, no=apologies horror. If you're not prepared for that, you might have a tough journey ahead.
Chbosky takes the coming-of-age tale and injects it with some seriously dark proceedings and epic action whose pacing occasionally wears out its welcome due to the length and repetitive nature of what happens.
That said... anyone looking for a lengthy dive into some prime evil doings this Fall will most likely enjoy this well-written, sharply characterized, but an exhaustive yet exhausting, tale of a rather literal fight between good and evil waged within small-town dramas we know so well.

Was this review helpful?

Thank you to Hachette for providing me with an ARC of this book. Having twenty years between itself and Stephen Chbosky’s The Perks of Being a Wallflower, Imaginary Friend has been one of my most anticipated books since announced. Perks changed my life as a teenager, so I’m devoted to anything Chbosky goes on to write by default. That said, this book is very, VERY different from Chbosky’s teen classic. It’s a story about a mother, her son, and their town caught in the middle of an epic battle between good and evil.

Chbosky’s writing is reminiscent of Stephen King, both in themes and prose, in my opinion, so fans of King should definitely check this out. If you’re a fan of religious themes integrated into a plot, that’ll also be an added bonus for some, although it may get a little too on the nose near the end. Chbosky also uses a style of repetition throughout the novel that is very distracting, and it didn’t exactly work for me; it pulled me out of his writing, which is generally stellar here, and felt awkward. I’m not sure what he was trying to accomplish by using the metaphor of “baby teeth” dozens of times, for example. But who knows, maybe those will be trimmed down or out of the final version of the novel.

Those critiques aside, Imaginary Friend is one hell of a journey. It’s definitely a book to experience, and I recommend going in knowing as little about the plot as possible. Chbosky’s writing will suck you in instantly; just enjoy the crazy ride. 5/5 stars.

Was this review helpful?

This book gave me actual nightmares and has become one of my favorite books! You do not want to miss this. Go get this on October 1, do not wait a moment. Phenomenal!

Was this review helpful?

Yassss! So excited that Stephen Chobosky is back with another novel. But, unlike The Perks of Being A Wallflower, this is not an angsty Young Adult novel, this is full-on horror. Chobosky has said that he loves Stephen King and that influence is clear in both the style and length of this novel. The early part of this novel feel a lot like King's short story The Body (made into the movie Stand By Me) and Chobosky's familiarity with the visual mediums of television (Jericho) and movies is also evident. The Stranger Things vibe of the early novel changes into a more traditional horror which morphs into a classic 1980's horror movie bent (complete with biblical references) by the end. Everything you could want in a horror story with lots of twists and turns to boot. I'm looking forward to kicking off a month of book blogging about Halloween themed books on October 1st, the day of this novel's release.

Was this review helpful?

This book was like nothing I’ve ever read before. It felt like I was in a nightmare the whole way...which I think was kind of the point. It definitely wasn’t what I was expecting, and I am surprised that I actually enjoyed it. It was weird and creepy but in a good way. I will say it was LONG and maybe unnecessarily so. I think the same ideas and points could've been made in much less pages. It was good, and kept the mystery going and was intriguing enough that I wanted to finish it despite it's high page count. It was for sure intimidating when I saw how long it was though. Of course I loved Perks of Being a Wallflower so I was more inclined to want to read this even though I usually shy away from books so long. I definitely recommend this if you love horror and over the top weird books. I loved reading something so different from Stephen Chbosky, especially since I just recently read Perks. I knew it would be wildly different and I really enjoyed that! This was something out of my comfort zone, but I'm so glad that I got the chance to read it!

Was this review helpful?

The first half of Chbosky’s new novel reads like a throwback to Stand by Me or Stranger Things. Mysterious happenings with a group of young boys, which leads them to build a treehouse in the woods, unlocking something...
But man that second half kept going on and on, with the same repetitive themes. Hopefully an editor will grab this before the final printing. The last part was painful to read, if I saw “like baby teeth” one more time...
Some horror fans will enjoy this, it just wasn’t my thing.

Was this review helpful?

This book was really imaginative! I'll admit that I've never read, nor had the want to read, the author's other book The Perks of Being a Wallflower, but I have to say that I really do enjoy the writing style of this! The chapters were a manageable length, making it easy to stop when you need to, Like when you're reading at work, cough cough and cliffhangers at the end of some chapters, made them go quickly!
I really enjoyed the characters of this story and what I REALLY enjoyed was how un-annoying the cast of kids are in this book! I've read another book where some of the characters were these annoying brats that made it very hard to continue reading. Christopher was a fantastic MC and he had plenty of growth and heart that really made you root for this sweet angel.
Something else I really liked were the plot twists near the end of the story. I really could say that I never saw any of it coming! It really made me feel the betrayal and confusion that Christopher probably felt going through it all.

There were some small things that bothered me a wee bit. Every book has them, but this particular one got a little distracting at times. There are a few parts where you as the reader, and the characters are decoding some messages left behind by another character. Now, the way the author did this was instantly recognizable, which I enjoyed, but later on in the book, the villain of the story just talks like that normally which honestly drove me nuts after a while.
Another little annoyance that just might be a personal weird pet peeve is how weirdly... religious the book got? Like I said, it could just be me cuz I'm not religious, but it seems like it really hung on to the God VS The Devil type situation.

Was this review helpful?

I've read The Perks of Being a Wallflower more times than I can remember and adore Chbosky's writing style. Imaginary friend did not disappoint. Complex characters, compelling plot, and prose to die for. An absolute must read!

Was this review helpful?

Mill Grove Pennsylvania quickly becomes the battleground between good and evil with single mom Kate and her seven year old son Christopher arrive in town, on the run from an abusive relationship. Stephen Chbosky has written a scary story with engaging characters that immediately draws you into the insulated world of a small town in Pennsylvania. For me, it was very reminiscent of a Stephen King story with the scary monsters (most of them human), the dream world setting, and the small group of young (maybe a bit too young) but scrappy kids.

Was this review helpful?